| Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 |
1. Poll Results: Interest in Spaceship MMOs vs. EVE Subscription Trends - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
http://i.imgur.com/UmCvhW0.jpg
39 / 75-150 criticizing the progression system is an issue.
- by Dror - at 2017.06.17 07:35:46
|
2. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Jonah Gravenstein wrote: Glathull wrote: I want to give props to Dror for creating possibly the first thread in which I feel the need to agree with Jenshae. Congrats, Dror, that is some extremely advanced nutbag trolling to level 6 you have...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.28 12:55:42
|
3. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Jonah Gravenstein wrote: Dror wrote: Intrinsic reward, per a very standard definition, is mastering the game, succeeding, and the joy of experiencing the depth and variety. So how does your idea of removing SP help with mastering the game...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.28 08:00:44
|
4. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Scipio Artelius wrote: You are quoting CCP Rise there totally out of context. The context of what he was talking about was the older NPE which was based on setting tasks and then providing rewards for achieving those tasks. It set expectations...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.27 13:21:20
|
5. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Jonah Gravenstein wrote: Dror wrote: They have yet to be shown as uninformed. Nor have they been shown to be informed. Quote: "CCP even says that extrinsic motivation is poor for creativity. SP is an extrinsic reward." Link please, b...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.27 09:43:55
|
6. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Jenshae Chiroptera wrote: My little amusement is that he is holding up games with levelling systems. Systems in which there is severe level range restrictions with regards to who you can meaningfully play with. Mean while, we have this SP syst...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.27 09:03:44
|
7. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Emboldened replies : Jonah Gravenstein wrote: Odie McCracken wrote: Cidanel Afuran wrote: Your selective attention is acting up again. You should see a doctor about that. Have you been reading this thread? The reading definitely see...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.27 08:39:43
|
8. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Bobb Bobbington wrote: Exactly! While a character unlocks one thing, he has to wait to unlock another. That creates meaningful choices. It also incites excitement when you can "Finally fly a battleship!" etc etc. But at the same time it doesn't...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 18:31:19
|
9. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Bobb Bobbington wrote: Dror wrote: Bobb Bobbington wrote: Dror wrote: Bobb Bobbington wrote: *sigh* The 'arbitrary gate' aren't arbitrary. The 'gates' are the entire game. They're the whole point of the game. They're why we play th...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 18:13:31
|
10. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Jonah Gravenstein wrote: Dror wrote: Jonah Gravenstein wrote: Dror wrote: creativity Creativity is making the most of what you have. As for the SP system, it creates aspiration. A reward earned is worth far more than something handed...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 17:44:14
|
11. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Cidanel Afuran wrote: Dror wrote: Hmm? I just explained how SP limits creativity, and there's a list of creative-friendly constraints in this thread already.Enjoy. Dror, that just proves you aren't creative at all, and think the only co...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 17:08:36
|
12. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Bobb Bobbington wrote: Dror wrote: Bobb Bobbington wrote: *sigh* The 'arbitrary gate' aren't arbitrary. The 'gates' are the entire game. They're the whole point of the game. They're why we play the game. Want me to say this again for the...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 16:51:41
|
13. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Bobb Bobbington wrote: *sigh* The 'arbitrary gate' aren't arbitrary. The 'gates' are the entire game. They're the whole point of the game. They're why we play the game. Want me to say this again for the nth time in a row? "SP is the whole ga...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 16:39:10
|
14. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Cidanel Afuran wrote: Dror wrote: Every source on the topic lists themepark as a design that's unaffected by player input.. but if you can evidence that the game realm would just reset ever X because you can biomass a character, I'm sure tha...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 16:01:41
|
15. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Cidanel Afuran wrote: Dror wrote: Rep and sec status could be account-based (the same answer as about the original question.. Mind relaying how you imagine EVE to be more like a themepark game if subs can actually play the sandbox how th...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 15:32:46
|
16. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Odie McCracken wrote: Gotta hand it to him for keeping it on topic. Seems like these sort of threads usually devolve into a ganker vs carebear type of thing. This guy has kept the sights set on amusing nonsense and not deviated. Hats off on tha...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 12:15:21
|
17. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Thierry Orlenard wrote: Dror wrote: That's a deflection. Oh, you little scamp, you. I take this round. "I win because I refuse to address a topic." The questions are still relevant, btw.
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 11:29:29
|
18. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Thierry Orlenard wrote: Dror wrote: Thierry Orlenard wrote: There are a ton of examples in this game of alleged matched engagement tools that have been woefully unsuccessful. A carrier piloted by an inexperienced player can be in a lot ...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 11:20:10
|
19. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Scipio Artelius wrote: Dror wrote: 1/? Somehow the confusion shown by the question mark doesn't surprise me at this point. It fits well with this whole thread. It's less than obvious how reminiscing on punctuation, nor on showing a mult...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 11:07:13
|
20. Unbiased Criticisms for the Game - in EVE General Discussion [original thread]
Thierry Orlenard wrote: Dror wrote: Thierry Orlenard wrote: Dror wrote: That's quite the implication for something that's all being discussed pretty anecdotally. ...and your implication that if the SP system wasn't in place -- that...
- by Dror - at 2015.10.26 10:43:04
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 |
| First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |