And i though that a good video had to have challenging fights that are exciting to watch. That was what i was criticized for not having in my 'Rebirth 4' and 'Clash of the Empires' videos by many 0.0 space players in my topic about those videos. So i'm gonna give the same criticizing back.

At least i was shooting other PVP players that did actually shoot back in my videos, so i can't really say i enjoyed this video. Because shooting / killing carebears with overwhelming force isn't what i call challenging and exciting.

So i'll give this a 4/10. And that's being nice. You get the 4/10 for having a good edited video and for having more instructions on how to scan for targets. That's the positive of the video.

Nobody gives a sh*** about you or your dumb highsec vids. Stop trying to make everythign about you you ugly troll with no talent.

So basicly, this video is fine just because it's from 0.0 space?

Here is a hint. It doesn't matter where the video is made.

No, this video is fine because it involves tactically catching one of the most risk-adverse aspects of the game, with null intel pretty much covering entire regions and keeping players aware of who's trying to kill them and where they are, Gulnar has managed to master dodging lock-down bubbles, intel and warp-to-pos safety to still make some significantly expensive kills.

He's doesn't roll with 30 logistics and have scouts on every gate...

The targets basicly had no chance what so ever because they were overwhelmed by a large margin in most of the fights.

Well, i actually gave Gulnar props for having a video where i gives him good words for showing how to scan and catch those targets in my first post. That was the best thing with the video. The editing was also fine. But the actual content where he just use a cyno to jump in more Black Ops on them was boring. The targets basicly had no chance what so ever because they were overwhelmed by a large margin in most of the fights.

So most of your PVP videos?

No, you gave him a thinly veiled complement followed by criticism because you were under the impression that his video closely resembled yours and you had got negative reviews before.

If you were paying any attention to the video you would have noticed that the majority of fights were just his cyno pilot (his alt?) and him, and that had there been anyone in local that was actually awake, could have posed as a threat.

There were a couple that contained a hotdrop and i felt those could have been left out because they were of low taste. However your videos and his are not alike, the fact that even the most blob-esque clips contained less than 10 players already differentiates between the two, if you want better reviews on your videos you're going to have to show something with a greater risk to you being blown up and that generally means less players involved on your side

...words

Some of the best PVPers in EvE commented in your 'Clash of the Empires' thread with a wide range of constructive criticism.

It's clear you haven't taken any of it onboard otherwise we would not be having this discussion, and the fact that you still think the content in your video was a beacon of light is evidence of that.

Considering Gulnar did not even comment in your thread is even more disgraceful, as here you are giving him bad feedback based on the feedback you were given by others on your own videos.

I'd like to receive constructive comments in this thread, comments from people that could help me to improve my future videos, After watching more or less all your releases I'd like you to cease posting in this thread as you are clearly not a part of the aforementioned group , thank you!

Also I never stated that this was a PVP video