| Pages: [1] |
1. Over/Under on Null Sec Cartel CSM 9 members - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
So the input that shows the bug (Fred gets elected even though appears only on 2 ballots while Basil and Charlotte have 2 #1s the trickiness of exploitation is exemplified by the fact that a tie breaker win is needed for Fred's election): 4 2 3 1 ...
- by Megarom - at 2014.03.05 20:18:00
|
2. Over/Under on Null Sec Cartel CSM 9 members - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
Trebor Daehdoow wrote: It is extremely unlikely that it would affect a real election, but it's a trivial thing to fix; you simply check before the election starts for candidates with no first-place votes, and process them as you would a withdr...
- by Megarom - at 2014.03.05 07:07:00
|
3. Over/Under on Null Sec Cartel CSM 9 members - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
Malcanis wrote: Surely this flaw is trivially detectable by manual inspection? I only stumbled upon it while building pathological inputs to demonstrate the 'undesirable feature' mentioned in the post. I'll post the ballot exact ballot data ...
- by Megarom - at 2014.03.04 22:59:00
|
4. Over/Under on Null Sec Cartel CSM 9 members - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
Megarom wrote: The only weakness in the that I suspect the voting system has is that when people need to be eliminated for lack of anyone having enough votes to be selected it only counts the #1 positions at that time (if I've understood corre...
- by Megarom - at 2014.03.04 22:14:00
|
5. Over/Under on Null Sec Cartel CSM 9 members - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
Dinsdale Pirannha wrote: 3. The goons have a year of testing and analysis to figure best way to optimize their voting bloc's power. Everybody knows the optimal way to vote in STV. It's not really a secret, but if you don't know it let me s...
- by Megarom - at 2014.02.19 21:21:00
|
6. CSM7 Dec Summit Topic - Voting system changes - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
Snow Axe wrote: Oh it started that way. After being told twice that we were "invading" the thread with "tinfoil" by pointing out said problems by the 2nd page, it was pretty clear that they just wanted us to do exactly that - point it out once...
- by Megarom - at 2012.12.10 10:26:00
|
7. CSM7 Dec Summit Topic - Voting system changes - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
Reading the 2 earlier posts made me realize that there was underlying assumption in my thinking. What is the best voting system is relies greatly on what CSM is. Most of elections are into bodies that vote on stuff and make decisions that effect l...
- by Megarom - at 2012.12.08 22:19:00
|
8. CSM7 Dec Summit Topic - Voting system changes - in Jita Park Speakers Corner [original thread]
The current voting system is just crap. The fact that it has resulted in somewhat representative results is ultimately a stroke of luck. It's actually so bad that it's not listed in the wikipedia main article about voting systems. If you have som...
- by Megarom - at 2012.12.06 20:22:00
|
| Pages: [1] |
| First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |