|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 07:01:00 -
[1]
I don't know about the rest of the world but here in the United States if I wreck someone else' car I have to pay the full price of that car and own it in it's entirety. NOT just the CD changer(read as loot within the cargo). If someone goes to that car and takes the electrical system(read as equal to salvage.) I have legal avenues to follow for recourse. If someone goes to that car and takes the CD changer(read as loot in the cargo.) I have legal avenues to follow for recourse. The CD-changer and the wreck are considered to be all the same ownership. Nobody can run up and just load my wreck up on their rig and drive away with it. From a legal standpoint any item taken from that wreck(Including an Alloyed Tritanium Bar)would be an act of theft.(Is this different in the rest of the world? Comments?)
Wrecks are color coded. They are color coded to show ownership. This goes for wrecks that have things within the cargo and those that do not. If there was no ownership of a wreck then there would not be a need for color coding.(There is a warning message about theft of loot so the concept that it is a different color to protect people from accidently taking something is moot, bogus and weak at best.)
Why is it that in Eve I only own the CD changer? What if I own a salvaging company and what they are taking is how I make my living?(Read as I pay for an alt that does nothing BUT salvage behind me in missions that are done for my corp. My corp uses that salvage to make things and sell them thus thiefs are taking money from my corp. Maybe I shouldn't give CCP any money?)
Can someone from CCP actually vallidate this ignorace for me
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 07:08:00 -
[2]
Originally by: Signore Kaeota In real life, if you hit someone's car with a missile you're gunna be in jail for a long, long time - get over it.
As if mission farmers don't get enough isk.
So we should suply the entire underbelly of s****with money?
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 07:15:00 -
[3]
Originally by: Auroral Borealis Edited by: Auroral Borealis on 30/09/2009 07:05:46 for all the ppl who read this thread who are not trolls
SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION SALVAGE IS A MINI PROFESSION
budum ching
Theivery is a miniprofession too.....and they get killed for it in some countries.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 07:28:00 -
[4]
Originally by: Signore Kaeota
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny So we should suply the entire underbelly of s****with money?
No, you shouldn't draw a RL comparison with one half of an issue, then ignore the second half, aka, YOU JUST BLEW SOMETHING UP - last I checked, that's a hellova lot less legal than stealing a CD player or an engine.
And if your referring to my second comment, then I assume that's why your posting? As it's pretty much exclusively mission b*tches who have issues with ninja salvaging.
And who cares if you think their scum? It's a game, they play it the way they like - which just happens to make you cry, and us laugh. Does that make them scum? No, it makes you pathetic.
And if you blow something up you are reqponsible for everything that you blew up and are expected to replace it to the full monetary value. In the case of mission running you are attacking criminals. Criminals that won't pay for their past actions. You are basically a hired bounty hunter.(Dirka Dirka.....that is why you get bounties....)
Only little girls with no life look at the arguement of law as tears......Statements like your remind me that there are a ton of little boys that haven't dipped mr. winky yet. But thank you for your tears of lacking any real life skills young one. They make me laugh.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 07:34:00 -
[5]
Originally by: Draeca If I come and wreck your car, is the carwreck my property?
Yes and no. Your insurance company is more than likely, the one that will pay for and assume the ownership of the wrecked vehicle.
Although I have seen where a non-insured person was made responsible for their actions and paid for the wreck and was responsible for all aspects of its removal. Since they were at fault for the accident they did pay for the wreck and they did own the car.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 07:48:00 -
[6]
Originally by: Vyrk
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
Theivery is a miniprofession too.....and they get killed for it in some countries.
Yes and you are free to attack & kill anyone who has stolen from your wreck, to make them pay for what they have done.
Oh and you realize that this is game?
Yes I do realise this is a game. Do you realise that within this game there are several laws. And according to the current laws in the game you are wrong. If someone takes the electronics from the wreck they are perfectly allowed to do so with no recourse.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 07:55:00 -
[7]
Originally by: Signore Kaeota
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny And if you blow something up you are reqponsible for everything that you blew up and are expected to replace it to the full monetary value. In the case of mission running you are attacking criminals. Criminals that won't pay for their past actions. You are basically a hired bounty hunter.(Dirka Dirka.....that is why you get bounties....)
Only little girls with no life look at the arguement of law as tears......Statements like your remind me that there are a ton of little boys that haven't dipped mr. winky yet. But thank you for your tears of lacking any real life skills young one. They make me laugh.
Ahh, so your argument is that if you shoot a criminal, you only get his stuff not his corpse? Or that if you go blow up a pirate ship you get to loot the wreck but can't take the ships engines? Hate to break it to you, both cases are 100% illegal, as is the mentioned bounty hunting.
No, I look at your attempt to twist the law to apply to your liking as tears. Though I do find the 'mr. winky' comment most amusing, and must congratulate you on that one.
Speaking of twisting you are doing that quite well with my words. Your first statement has nothing to do with anything that I said.
The podding system has a different set of laws applied to it already. (Your above arguement on corpse) Personally I think they should include corpse in the wrecks as there are never any pods flying away from them and DNA could be anything.(Including someone loving spaceflight a little too much.)
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 08:01:00 -
[8]
Originally by: Future Mutant YAAAAAAA! Another thread on ninja salvaging! we dont get enough of these!
Its a good thing we have whining on the forums as an option i mean its tons easier then actually COMPETING for your salvage.
For you, see the section above about dipping Mr. Winky.
For any other little boys out there that have something actually relevant to the conversation please say so. Please remember though that we have Crank Yankers on TV if we want to hear from Special ED.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 08:45:00 -
[9]
Originally by: MIND SCR4MBLER Edited by: MIND SCR4MBLER on 30/09/2009 08:36:27 "blah blah blah sad look at legality".
Ok nubcakes, its like this. You dont go round "salvaging" cars.
heres a clue, when NASA decided they were going to go to space, they decided the most appropriate ppls was the navy aviators. as such "space" as always been regarding the preserve of the navy therefore the sea, "astro NAUT" as in NAUTICAL is the give away here. caldari navy, gallente navy, thats also a bit of a clue for you.
the fact that they are called "ships" and named after ship classes "frigate, destroyer, cruiser, battleship, battlecruiser etc" is more evidence of this sea-faring tradition of the space. You can also look at such references in star trek (they all carry naval ranks, captain, admirail etc) and there is a historical ships wheel in the state room of the enterprise. i digress.
Still with me? PAY ATTENTION NOW Y'HEAR!
CCP rule on salvage therefore follows the law on salvage at sea. if you find a wreck in the sea, ooh say the titanic or a spanish galleon full of treasure then under international maritime laws its yours to claim.
Now lets say said wreck is the bismarck. sunk by the british navy in 1943. carebear emowhiner would shout "no! you cannot salvage thee wreck, belongeth to me, the british navy!" when in reality salvaging is done by hardy folk on specialist salvage vessels with lots of expensive diving and recovery gear, principally on account of the fact the navyz of the world consider it their bizness to blow up teh ships and not recoverz the lootz which is left for seafaring salvage monkeys and treasure hunters. After all if the british navy was so bothered by salvage why did they leave so much gold at the bottom of the carribbean eh?
So before you come here spouting about "those darn CCP and there lack of legal morals", i suggest you avail yourself of free trip to library and look up the international maritime laws of salvage, on which all future laws of space will no doubt be based.
So what we have here is validation of your ignorance OP, and not CCP's.
official law on salvage therefore "finders keepers, losers emoragetearers, or quite simply first to the wreck wins"
You are so wise nubcakes pighumper.....The ENTIRE wreck....Including all the contents is the ownership of the salvager. It doesn't work half way with "Oh.....I still own what is inside of the ship" bs.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 08:59:00 -
[10]
Originally by: Signore Kaeota
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny You are so wise nubcakes pighumper.....The ENTIRE wreck....Including all the contents is the ownership of the salvager. It doesn't work half way with "Oh.....I still own what is inside of the ship" bs.
So... why aren't you asking for free loot rules, where it all belongs to the 'salvager', instead of the one who made the kill, if you're so determined that eve laws should reflect RL?
I am asking it to be put one way or the other.....I really don't care which way it goes. But they DO colorcode the wrecks to show ownership. There is no other reason for the color coding. Either it should be entirely owned by the person that shot it or there should be no ownership of anything in it.
|
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.09.30 09:11:00 -
[11]
Originally by: Too Dangerous OP, in my country it is illegal to own a weapon. Does that mean CCP should remove all wepaons from this game? That way we can all fly around peacefully and no one can shoot anyone! Now that would be a cool game bro!
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
I am asking it to be put one way or the other.....I really don't care which way it goes. But they DO colorcode the wrecks to show ownership. There is no other reason for the color coding. Either it should be entirely owned by the person that shot it or there should be no ownership of anything in it.
WHY ? As the previous posters have stated this is a game, so the rules can be whatever.
Read the top of the post and start from there.....
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.09 02:28:00 -
[12]
Originally by: Tom Peeping Edited by: Tom Peeping on 30/09/2009 14:09:13 Oh.... and if we really wanted to make salvage rules consistent with real world here's how to actually change it.
Your example of a car is not valid, because it pertains to something you had ownership of before it was wrecked and you have not "abandoned" it. In the real world, if you came across true abandoned salvage, then it belongs to the first salvager who lays claim to it. Even if the original owner came back and decided to claim it again, if a valid case was made that it met the criteria for being abandoned salvage, then the salvager would still have a good chance at being granted the salvage despite the original owners wish.(INCORRECT....I was referring to when YOU run into someone else' car. You have to pay for their car. please don't twist my words.)
To actually make salvage consistent with the real world, CCP should simply make it "belong" to the first person to go up to it and take it (i.e. exert a claim). Of course, if they in their turn abandon it, it becomes salvage again, not property. If CCP would only do this simple step, then we would have consistency with the real world for those who are begging for it... oh wait... that's what the rules we already have!!! OMGWTF!!!(Again.....the loot should follow the wreck....Both being salvage)
We could take the simple route, of acknowledging that the current rules are actually pretty close to real world rules, with a slight edge to the carebear/noob side (since the loot isn't treated as salvage, and the thief type characters can't tractor beam all wrecks). Isn't "close" to real world, with a slight edge to the noobish side, exactly what the game should be for the professions that noobs will be doing?(You can't tractor wrecks that don't belong to you.......Hmmmmm....Wreck ownership?)
I think what confuses people here, is that the rules which define "abandoning" in the real world, can't really be applied to the game. In the real world, there are specific criteria which constitute "abandonment" of salvage, which then makes it free to any salvager, regardless of the original owner. In game - Sure we could say "abandonment" would be leaving the mission... but don't forget that the same rules have to be applicable to player PVP wrecks, to plex wrecks, to belt wrecks... to all sorts of things. In the real world, there are a lot of specific rules which apply to different circumstances. In the game world however, a lot of specific rules for different circumstances equals increased complexity, increased chances of something going wrong, and in many circumstances, increased lag.... all things CCP considers MUCH more important to focus on. The current system of salvage, is actually an extrememly close approximation of the the real world rules, but with the benefit of simplicity.
Never said anything about abandonment....please learn to read. Thank you
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.09 02:48:00 -
[13]
Originally by: Sergiiy Kortos i WISH salvaging flagged me to the mission runner :(
Why? Are you too cowardly to take something out of the wreck?
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.09 02:53:00 -
[14]
Originally by: Terranid Meester What a stupid thread. OP should be locked up for forum crimes.
Just as you should be locked up for that FANTABULOUS haircut.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.09 09:23:00 -
[15]
Originally by: Varesk let me help you out with this.
its ccps game. they say i can salvage the wrecks you leave in space.
/thread.
w0w is that way =====>
Let me help you out with this. Its CCPS game. They say we can get changes through discussion.
Yo momma is that way =====>
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.09 09:35:00 -
[16]
Originally by: Multipurpose Cleaner Edited by: Multipurpose Cleaner on 09/10/2009 07:55:32
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
Originally by: Sergiiy Kortos i WISH salvaging flagged me to the mission runner :(
Why? Are you too cowardly to take something out of the wreck?
Quoting reading comprehension fail
No....I understood him to say that he wished salvaging would flag him....as if it would be so much more work to get flagged.....I guess it was truly a useless rattling of ignorance. Maybe a cry for help....You know..."Look at me Look at me Look at me.....See what I can do!"(Does stupid body spasm move from mad TV)
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.09 09:41:00 -
[17]
Originally by: Doktor Feeelgoood Edited by: Doktor Feeelgoood on 01/10/2009 21:26:01 it's funny how dumb americans can be sometimes. "in the u s of a the law is like this, why is it not like this anywhere else in the world (or vidja games)? we rule everything and everybody should be like us. now let's go raid the middle east yeehaw!"
Look at you...a ****** that does not understand that the american stated quite clearly that this may not be the case in your country. But most of the rest of the world hopes that your country will be able to catch up in the comprehension field soon. You need some help. (Why all the rage against Americans......Are you jealous? If so of what?)
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.10 04:17:00 -
[18]
Originally by: Tetrix Akuta
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
Let me help you out with this. Its CCPS game. They say we can get changes through discussion.
OP how would your suggested change improve the game? I am not seeing the benefit.
Being a ninja you never would. So wasting time trying to convince a ninja is just that.....a waste of time.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.10 08:02:00 -
[19]
Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 10/10/2009 08:03:38
Originally by: Sir Carnage Seriously, this isn't exactly the place to discuss the merits of the U.S. education system.
The entire reason for this topic is to cause just the sort of response it has generated. It does not belong in C&P. At best it could go into Features and Ideas. As it's explicitly addressed to the Devs and CCP, it should be removed from the forums all together. It does discuss crime so yes....it does belong here.
Also, go back to WoW. Maybe one day you'll graduate to Hello Kitty Online, but Eve is obviously beyond you
Never played WOW....Don't intend to. As the usual rifraf you add nothing. Go back to preschool.
The reason it was addressed to devs/CCP is because of simpletons like yourself that just feel the need to throw 2 cents in. Everyone knows(Even the lower end intelligence of the bottom of the barrel Americans.) that 2 cents isn't worth a crap. And that is all you have to offer.
As far as what this article is for is to build a respectably worded theory for myself and others that may or may not understand the idiocracy associated with salvage and looting and the difference of the two in CCP's eyes. If you had seen the first post you would know that the one that is up there now has evolved quite a bit.
Here is your 2 cents back....I hope you find someone that needs it.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.11 04:03:00 -
[20]
Seems like you have experience in that area. But real men don't need lube. That's for the ladies only.
You are correct sir.....Only a little girl would need "Carebear tears" for lube.(Read as self proclaimed high-sec "pirates".) "Good call" to you I say.
To those that think I created this topic to be a troll.....you are incorrect. This is my first post(And judging by the ignorance that is the majority of post to it(Majority....not the only kind)there probably won't be another. I need to find a forum with adults.) As I stated before, "The OP changes the more I learn here to reflect the true reasoning behind it all." Unfortunately most people don't offer anything but "Carebear tears" and "**** americans" or the famous "Post somewhere else....I don't want to read this"(Honestly the most ignorant of their own personal choices as they do continue to make them by reading things they don't want to read .)
Anyway....Continue to post if you have something worth reading and is logical to the way things are or should be.
|
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.11 04:08:00 -
[21]
Originally by: TokimoYsera What I don't get is why you didn't just say:
In EVE when someone steals loot from a ship wreck you've killed, you get to blast their face. Can we get face blasting rights when they steal the salvage?
That is something I discussed earlier...One type of salvage from the floating trash pile can be equipped to a ship....The other type of salvage can be used to make parts for a ship.....Why is salvaging a pile of junk any different than reclaiming the other section of that same pile of junk? Doesn't make any sense to me either.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.10.25 21:18:00 -
[22]
At least in Germany it doesnt work that way. If you wreck someones car, its still HIS car and you (or your insurance company, and I work for one) have to pay for the repair of said car or for replacement.
Ownership never changes...
Even if the car is totaled and you have to fully replace it the insurance company doesn't buy the car in in the proccess? The person that you ran into gets the car and a new one?
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 15:32:00 -
[23]
Originally by: Max Hatter
Originally by: edfhk'lkhff Edited by: edfhk''lkhff on 17/10/2009 14:52:11 It all boils down to greif. Get off the troll comments and get real answers. Ninja salvagers are just lazy and lack standing to get there own salvage to ninja. I blow up my wrecks. I like jelly beans.
Edit:WTH is TL;DR?
That's not the truth. I've done missions and I hated it. It's so god damn boring. You do the same thing over and over again and you have almost no social interaction. I think most ninjas have done missions but found it lacking. Hell I even found mining to be more fun then missioning.
Ninja salvaging is more varied you have the chance to get some PvP action. It even demands more skills (not skillpoints mind you) then mission running. I'm always looking to evolve my ninja salvaging skills. Not because I need more ISK (I could do missions or trading or something for that.) but because I find it challenging. But you who are against ninja salvaging probably won't care about what I'm saing anyway. You are dead sure we are just in this for the grief and as you say, we are to lazy.
So then.....what is the challenge in Ninja salvaging? You probe out a mission. You fly in and salvage. WOW....That was hard and SOOOoooo Challenging. What other reason could you possibly have other than greif or money?
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 15:49:00 -
[24]
Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 04/11/2009 15:50:20
Originally by: Tristan Acoma
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
So then.....what is the challenge in Ninja salvaging? You probe out a mission. You fly in and salvage. WOW....That was hard and SOOOoooo Challenging. What other reason could you possibly have other than grief or money?
Well..... then again, solo mining high sec veldspar isn't particularly profitable or technically challenging. Obviously the miners are griefing the asteroids, it couldn't possibly be for fun or ISK :)
Not true....know a lot of people that mine in large groups and they make decent money and have a good time. may not be technically challenging.....but t is enjoyable to them. I also know a couple people that enjoy mining on their own.....and they do make money at it and it is a mindless thing to do while they work at home.(Double the isk making....lol) I was questioning this guy as to what he does get out of ninja'ing since he says he doesn't do it for money or grief.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 16:09:00 -
[25]
Originally by: Maddock Krug Hey.
@SixToOne
You are right: Salvaging is not as profitable as very few MRwh***s claim it to be. Whilst you ask why Ninjas do it, you give some of more or less likely answers yourself. But there are many, many, many more more or less answers as well. Just start to use your brain and think in gameterms and gamemechanics and terms of EvE Experience. I cannot fully disagree with you, but I won't agree with you to any degree with anything you've spit into this thread.
Because all in all you are wrong.
First of: What you claim to be the intention of ninjas is, what may be right for some ninjas. But I have seen many ninjas just salvaging, and neither looting nor ganking the poor, poor, poor MR. So your statement on the griefdom by ninjas is incorrect, as it does not apply with all of 'em. Secondly: It is a legend, albeit a wrong legend, that ninjas are aught to be unseen while they do something. As many have told in this topic and in many other topics as well: comparisons with RL is - as always within any game - something to better leave aside, 'cause it is not comparable. That's why you are very wrong with your assumption on this. Thirdly: I am happy to figure that most MR really don't care (much) about ninjas; they run their missions and want ISK; that's why they don't waste time on salvaging and looting, as most missions (even L4s) don't really give so much valuable stuff (compared with bounties and rewards and also related with the missions sites); so focussing on bounties, rewards and time bonuses alone is what makes you really rich - all this with the assumption that you solo-run missions with mediochre skills, hoping that most eve player have them, realizing though they have not (seen to many people in lvl 4s just failing to do it right ...). Since I do ninja salvage (and sometimes loot as well), I more often get fleet invites to get along faster; and I get rambling fools ****ing their pants whilst emoraging on local or PM or private convo very seldomly.
That's why I conclude: The very few bickering about ninjas salvaging their missions behave like owning the truth, although they are -in fact- a poor and simple-minded minority claiming things which simply don't exist and which don't match with the EvE-wide common sense.
Fly reckless!
Mad
OMG OMG OMG......That is the largest load of BS I have ever heard. I basically reads as"Yes...I agree with what you are saying but I can't bring my self up to an adult level to agree with you because that would make me something that I am not and I want to remain this annoying philosofical whimsy guy that truly doesn't want to agree with anything in life that another says because then I would be just like someone else and I can't be just like someone else because I have to keep my RL lameness seperate from my persona in the game as IRL I am just like everything and everyone around......blah....blah...blah...blah"
First OFF:You are right...some people do it for the money and not the grief because it is so profitable. Secondly:Then why compare it to something in Real life if not to make real life comparisons? Thirdly: How would you know seeing that you are not a mission runner(As niether is 95% of the people that have responded to this thread.) There is a good deal ammount of money to be made in salvaging/looting the missions if done right. I can honestly say that it damn near doubles the ammount of ISK made. Happy spoofing.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 17:06:00 -
[26]
Originally by: James Tritanius Edited by: James Tritanius on 04/11/2009 16:25:28
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
So then.....what is the challenge in Ninja salvaging? You probe out a mission. You fly in and salvage. WOW....That was hard and SOOOoooo Challenging.
What's the challenge in salvaging your own mission? You don't even have to probe it out and you can use tractor beams.
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny What other reason could you possibly have other than greif or money?
Wait... you mean there are other reasons to play EVE? 
According to Max Hatter there are....ask him.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 17:09:00 -
[27]
Originally by: B1FF I stopped reading at "In the USA if you. . ."
AFK parallels always fail. In AFK/RL we don't have space ships so we should remove them from EvE.
Also the premise in the subject is nonsensical. There is no legality. There are only the rules CCP states. CCP says they are junk owned by no one then they are junk owned by no one. If you don't like it leave.
CCP says that the rules can be changed then the rules can be changed. If you don't like it leave.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 18:59:00 -
[28]
Originally by: Phoben
Originally by: MIND SCR4MBLER
CCP rule on salvage therefore follows the law on salvage at sea. if you find a wreck in the sea, ooh say the titanic or a spanish galleon full of treasure then under international maritime laws its yours to claim.
Now lets say said wreck is the bismarck. sunk by the british navy in 1943. carebear emowhiner would shout "no! you cannot salvage thee wreck, belongeth to me, the british navy!" when in reality salvaging is done by hardy folk on specialist salvage vessels with lots of expensive diving and recovery gear, principally on account of the fact the navyz of the world consider it their bizness to blow up teh ships and not recoverz the lootz which is left for seafaring salvage monkeys and treasure hunters. After all if the british navy was so bothered by salvage why did they leave so much gold at the bottom of the carribbean eh?
So before you come here spouting about "those darn CCP and there lack of legal morals", i suggest you avail yourself of free trip to library and look up the international maritime laws of salvage, on which all future laws of space will no doubt be based.
So what we have here is validation of your ignorance OP, and not CCP's.
official law on salvage therefore "finders keepers, losers emoragetearers, or quite simply first to the wreck wins"
not really correct....
all wrecks are owned by someone, owner or insurance company, a salvager finding the wreck and taking from it must declare the salvage to the relevant authorities in the port they first come to ( or port of origin). Its then upto the authorities to find the legal owners of the ship, its then a deal between the legal owner and salvager for payment in lieu of salvage. It all gets pretty legal after that
for in game mechanics it would work that someone pilferring wrecks would have to declare the goods to the authorities and then a deal could be struck for cold hard cash to part with the loot. If so wished or the looter has to give up the salvage or faces prosecution from the authorities.
and Navys of the world take a real dim view of turning up on their sunken ships full of dead sailors and ripping salvage off them for profit.
Bravo sir.....Someone that actually knows what they are talking about and not a 13yo spewing crap from atop his head. I truly like it when someone claims to know the rules of something...spews their "Knowledge" all over the floor....then gets it mopped up by someone that actually knows. Then here comes the second problem....Idiots that will say"Well you shouldn't make IRL compparisons.", Although these idiots never say that when someone is trying to do an IRL comp. that discredits the OP......It is simply a biassed approach that leaves them looking like idiots. Anyway....good post Phoben...Bravo.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 19:06:00 -
[29]
Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 04/11/2009 19:09:33
Originally by: arbiter reformed IN 'UMERICA WE GOT MAD AND SHOOT STUFF WHEN PPL TAKE OUR ****!!! **** YEH
Blah blah blah.....Another loser from a third world country that is so ashamed to admit where he comes from but is none-the-less glad to attempt to mock a country that he has no true first hand knowledge of besides the media that his third world country blows up his a**.
First off....This isn't a place to vent your SPS or your dislike for a country(That probably kicked your pathetic ass some time in the past.) There are other forums for that in other web sites where people still could care less about your insesant whining. Second...AS I would figure from a back-woods idiot....nothing to say....just has to wave his flag for attention.....well....you should be happy now...you got some. CONGRATS. ( mumbles something about tardation and imbreeding results.)
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 19:40:00 -
[30]
Originally by: Jofridur It's game mechanics. Which means it is the way it is supposed to be and working correctly.
I find your game vs reality comparison hilarious because of just that, and the way you try to defend it too. 
If you don't like people salvaging your wrecks and want to do something about it why don't just wardec them or suicide gank them? Play the game everyone else is playing.
Duh....another brainchild adding nothing.....The game can be changed....said this a thousand times and keep saying it because there are so many simpletons that repeat the same spew you just did.
So what did you think of other peoples cap. to reality?.....or are you just biassed?
|
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 20:03:00 -
[31]
Originally by: Jessica Lorelei Its a fictional universe real world does not apply, nothing in this world applies.
your points about real laws, are null and void, much like you.
BTW I'm not in a 3rd world country before you start spouting your xenophobic bull**** again.
p.s. where do you mission?
First off.....Xenophobic?....had you actually read I only stated that in response to a xenophobe. Perhaps you should take a comprehension course so that you can understand what you read. Also on this subject.....To all idiots that think that ALL americans think that their country is the greatest.....Grow up. Stop taking what ever propaganda you take for your god. Open your eyes. Learn reality. There are a lot of people here that hate this country.
Secondly they try to apply real world in 90% of combat.....Trajectory....size relations....speed....So just stuff the "Don't compare with real life" BS....it gets old.
Third.....Just ask your mom.....I am sure she knows.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 20:08:00 -
[32]
Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 04/11/2009 20:09:14
Originally by: Jessica Lorelei well thanks for the hot headed patrotic bull****, and the ad hominem attack,
THIS IS GAME *******
LOL.....and non have proven them selves more ass than yourself.....For someone that thinks Eve is an OS you should really STFU. you prove your ignorance way too often....and not just on this thread.
Again....said again and again......CCP can also change those rules.....don't be a tard and think that they can't.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 20:14:00 -
[33]
Originally by: Benedict Carol
Originally by: Jessica Lorelei Its a fictional universe real world does not apply, nothing in this world applies.
your points about real laws, are null and void, much like you.
BTW I'm not in a 3rd world country before you start spouting your xenophobic bull**** again.
p.s. where do you mission?
Based on locater agents, I'm betting he doesn't move around much :)
Nope....he/she/it isn't smart enough to use a locater....That would take a little intel....and they are proving time and again that they don't have it.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 20:27:00 -
[34]
Originally by: Jessica Lorelei suprise suprise its a noob corp alt, how convienient.
suprise suprise...you actually were smart enough to attempt to look me up.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 20:43:00 -
[35]
Originally by: FireT
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
At least in Germany it doesnt work that way. If you wreck someones car, its still HIS car and you (or your insurance company, and I work for one) have to pay for the repair of said car or for replacement.
Ownership never changes...
Even if the car is totaled and you have to fully replace it the insurance company doesn't buy the car in in the proccess? The person that you ran into gets the car and a new one?
Holy crap man, you are the single most funny troll ever. I mean your pretension of stupidity is amazingly hilarious. Seriously man, nice job. I mean even in the US they do not give you the wreck. I would laugh my ass of it a neighbor of mine totaled someone's car and got the trash (totaled car) dumped in front of their lawn.
And if you are actually as stupid as this topic proved, please don't ever reproduce.
Sorry had to make that disclaimer, since in the US we cover both sides of an argument. 
You obviously have never seen the dealing of a totaled vehicle. The insurance DOES buy the wreck and usually sell it to a salvage company.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 21:00:00 -
[36]
Originally by: FireT
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
Originally by: FireT
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
At least in Germany it doesnt work that way. If you wreck someones car, its still HIS car and you (or your insurance company, and I work for one) have to pay for the repair of said car or for replacement.
Ownership never changes...
So by your own mentally ******ed logic and subsequent admission: CONCORD or whatever corporation does give you the mission should own the rights to the wrecks in Eve? And should they then come and pod you for stealing their stuff?
I mean the wreck is caused by you. But your insurance, in other words the NPC corp giving you the mission or whoever you insured with, should own wrecks.
So once again you fail to see the fault of actual real life logic in your statements. Thus making my previous request more urgent: don't reproduce.
Even if the car is totaled and you have to fully replace it the insurance company doesn't buy the car in in the proccess? The person that you ran into gets the car and a new one?
Holy crap man, you are the single most funny troll ever. I mean your pretension of stupidity is amazingly hilarious. Seriously man, nice job. I mean even in the US they do not give you the wreck. I would laugh my ass of it a neighbor of mine totaled someone's car and got the trash (totaled car) dumped in front of their lawn.
And if you are actually as stupid as this topic proved, please don't ever reproduce.
Sorry had to make that disclaimer, since in the US we cover both sides of an argument. 
You obviously have never seen the dealing of a totaled vehicle. The insurance DOES buy the wreck and usually sell it to a salvage company.
Atleast discolor your words so everything doesn't run together in a non-sensical waste of effort.
And BTW.....Do reproduce...You are making the U.S. what all the people that hate it see it as....loaded with idiots.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.04 22:56:00 -
[37]
Originally by: FireT
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
Atleast discolor your words so everything doesn't run together in a non-sensical waste of effort.
And BTW.....Do reproduce...You are making the U.S. what all the people that hate it see it as....loaded with idiots.
This is actually funny. Congrats. And yes I will reproduce, once I find the lady of my dreams. 
Till then I try to enjoy the topic, if you don't mind of course. Again, you claim that you should own a wreck, yet you admit that the insurance company technically paid for it. Thus you never had the right to grab the wreck in real life. And on the occasion that you ever do actually get to total someone's car (hopefully neither side will be injured, though unlikely) go ahead and try to take stuff out of the other person's car.
Slightly impossible since the person will be still alive. And if you killed them, even if they were a criminal in the US, you would get arrested.
Thus everything you spouted got nullified by actual logic. 
Take your half logic using tard self elsewhere. Ofcourse if you only use part of anything you can twist it around.....congrat idiot american.....you win in your little corner.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.05 01:00:00 -
[38]
Originally by: FireT
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
Originally by: FireT
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
Atleast discolor your words so everything doesn't run together in a non-sensical waste of effort.
And BTW.....Do reproduce...You are making the U.S. what all the people that hate it see it as....loaded with idiots.
This is actually funny. Congrats. And yes I will reproduce, once I find the lady of my dreams. 
Till then I try to enjoy the topic, if you don't mind of course. Again, you claim that you should own a wreck, yet you admit that the insurance company technically paid for it. Thus you never had the right to grab the wreck in real life. And on the occasion that you ever do actually get to total someone's car (hopefully neither side will be injured, though unlikely) go ahead and try to take stuff out of the other person's car.
Slightly impossible since the person will be still alive. And if you killed them, even if they were a criminal in the US, you would get arrested.
Thus everything you spouted got nullified by actual logic. 
Take your half logic using tard self elsewhere. Ofcourse if you only use part of anything you can twist it around.....congrat idiot american.....you win in your little corner.
Ah the American humor: waaaa waaaaa waaaaaaaaa And when someone comes along and points out how wrong you are: WAAAAAAAAAAA
Thank you man, you made me laugh all day. 
Noone has pointed out anything about me being wrong here yet.......Only spooged incomp. like yourself.....half-assing everything they do and say in twisted words to attempt to sound smart.....and failing.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.05 01:07:00 -
[39]
Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 05/11/2009 01:09:39 Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 05/11/2009 01:07:57
Originally by: FireT Well kid, if you can't read properly and only love your own ideas AND can't accept criticism and heavy sarcasm which is based upon your own drug induced version of humanity..... go ahead.
All I can say, if you ever get to shoot at people for salvaging your wrecks, and they retain kill rights.... I will personally become a griefer to annoy you. 
Again....tardation and inbreeding serve you well......there is nothing mentioned about shooting someone....only tards with nothing to bring to the table bring shooting someone to this conversation. and what is keeping you from doing it now by taking something from a wreck.....you want to go flashy red to me youcan....If you knew how.....keep it in the family.....you go...you go.....
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.08 09:00:00 -
[40]
Originally by: Asuri Kinnes Edited by: Asuri Kinnes on 05/11/2009 20:57:29
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 11/10/2009 04:59:14
Before you start to post here.... 1. This is not an issue about shooting someone. There are already laws about that in the game.
As there are laws about ninjasalvagin...
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny 2. Don't twist my words on the subject. It only makes you look like you just can't comprehend.
Troll - its been explained to you (and relevant CCP Dev answers have been linked). And still you troll... Like you can't comprehend.
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny 3. I don't have time to read every article that has been posted before me. (Think of it as the "Dipping Mr. Winky" principle of things.)
Let us know when Mr. Winky gets dipped, I'm sure we'd all like to be informed of when you hit puberty pubbie. You don't have to read all the other threads to find the relevant answers... 
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny 4. I am asking for someone from CCP to validate. If you aren't from CCP....I don't care what you have to say.
Sure, glad to help the less fortunate (i.e. - 'bred & 'tarded..):
GM Ytterbium on "ownership" of wrecks, and aggro mechanics... http://eve-search.com/thread/766902
CCP Prism X explains why it isnt a theft to salvage wrecks made by other people http://eve-search.com/thread/971872#30
CCP Mitnal locks thread cause CCP:s policy is clear. Salvaging others wrecks is NOT a crime (scroll down) http://eve-search.com/thread/1080709/page/2#47
GM Faolchu explains how CCP looks at salvaging http://www.eveonline.com/ingameboard.asp?a=topic&threadID=508034&page=9#262
I don't know about the rest of the world but here in the United States if I wreck someone else' car I have to pay the full price of that car and own it in it's entirety. Inappropriate language removed. Zymurgist
Just wanted to let you know, *you* do NOT own the vehicle in its entirety, nor do *you* have to "pay the full price of the vehicle".
If *you* have insurance, the Insurance Co. pays off the totaled vehicle, and the Insurance Co owns it - it has nothing to do with you... Only if *you* don't have insurance do you have to pay anything... And you *still* do not own anything in the other persons car, or the car itself. >TLOD!<
Sorry little kid....you are wrong on so many levels. 1. Yes there are laws governing shooting others and ninja salvaging.....this thread is about salvaging....not shooting....thanks for pointing that out brainchild. 2. Explaining something is not the same as twisting my words around.....thanks again for pointing that out brainchild..... 3. I am sure your mom can let you know.....but thanks for pointing that out to everyone brainchild. 4. These still don't validate why a wreck is different than the contents of the wreck as it is all one twisted pile of ****zle......thanks for pointing those out brainchild.
If you are paying the insurance company....you are pre-paying for that wreck. If you don't have insurance and the vehicle is totaled you will be responsible to replace it and or give enough money to cover a replacement and you will own the wreck.(Or the insurance Co. does if they pay for a totaled vehicle.)
And even if you DO have insurance...5-1 says you have a deductable.....and you still have to pay a substantual ammount.
Keep going troll.....and see if you can't come up with something realistic.
|
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.16 00:51:00 -
[41]
Originally by: Asuri Kinnes Edited by: Asuri Kinnes on 08/11/2009 14:27:48
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny
If you are paying the insurance company....you are pre-paying for that wreck. If you don't have insurance and the vehicle is totaled you will be responsible to replace it and or give enough money to cover a replacement and you will own the wreck.(Or the insurance Co. does if they pay for a totaled vehicle.)
And even if you DO have insurance...5-1 says you have a deductable.....and you still have to pay a substantual ammount.
Keep going troll.....and see if you can't come up with something realistic.
Trolling aside, CCP has said:
"This is our game, wrecks = aggression, salvage does not".
Thats what has been pointed out to you and you refuse to listen.
Last but not least:
One of the jobs I've had in the past was Insurance Agent. yes you pay all that money to the insurance company.
(Now I'll say this slow) No matter what, under NO circumstance will *YOU* *EVER* own any part of another persons wrecked vehicle. You are not "prepaying for that wreck" - your paying insurance so that you don't have to pay, OUT OF POCKET for the damages...
Title will not transfer to you, you won't have salvage rights, you won't be able to take anything from the wreck - nothing.
Originally by: BunnyBuzzBunny And even if you DO have insurance...5-1 says you have a deductable.....and you still have to pay a substantual ammount.
Which has nothing to do with salvage or ownership -
>DOLT<
"This thread is about trolling..."
I like pie.
From Page One:
Originally by: DoltBuzzBunnyDolt 5. The parts that you can take from of a wreck to make rigs for your ship are perfectly fine to take. The componets(Ninja edit: "COMPONENTS") that you could take from a wreck to attache (ATTACH) to your ship are NOT ok to take. This is perfectly logical to CCP but nobody else.
Its quite logical to most everyone except you. Its been explained to you (CCP sees it as a mini-profession) - your just being an idiotic troll.
Did you read where I said the insurance company will take the title? Do you even read there sparky....Bo....I guess not.....just feel the need to spew what ya spew.....its what you do.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.16 01:11:00 -
[42]
Edited by: BunnyBuzzBunny on 16/11/2009 01:11:30
Originally by: Tiberizzle Edited by: Tiberizzle on 12/11/2009 00:52:17
If some carebear who actually loots and salvages his missions would like to dig further along similar lines I'm pretty sure a strong case could be made either for or against the current policy on salvage. CCP will likely disregard any such analysis, though, as they are quite obviously intentionally griefing us all with some of these ****ty game mechanics 
Well Tiberizzle.....Atleast you seam to have your crap together. you are right.....and the cargo should follow the same rules as so money Troll mongers have pointed out. I love the fact that lots of people try to draw IRL comparisons when it makes th eOP look bad but when the OP fires back with IRL comp they say...."Its a game" Watch how many people will talk bad to you about using IRL in this instance....then go slam some someone using IRL.....The psycology of the turds that praise you when you slam and slam you when you praise is amazingly the same crowd(I see this on several diff. game forums.....Its what happens when they can't dip mr. winky and their agressions over-write their abillity to think logically.)(Well....not really amazing when you think about it is it?) Anyway....thanks for posting truth as opposed to feelings.....
Woodwraith====>Nice one toad....haven't heard this drivel before......Part of the wreck you say?....Like the contents?
Asuri Kinnes===> Just because I didn't sign on does not mean that you brought anything to the table.....as usual.....as with most of everything you have probably ever done.....like your short stint in insurance.
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.30 08:20:00 -
[43]
Originally by: Lian Xander tl;dr ....
YAY! Another ninja-whine thread. 
YAY! another idiot with nothing to add but just wants to see his name up on a board somewhere because he has no life and really needs the attention because of(Place random life altering cliche here). YAY!
Still.....nobody can make a logical statement about the wreck other than "Thats what CCP wants" ?
Nothing that gives a truly logical rational as to why 1/2 of the space pile belongs to you but the other doesn't?
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.30 08:39:00 -
[44]
Originally by: Gibbo5771 I don't see why ur ****ing idiots are still going on about this, do you walk down the street, throw a empty mars bar wrapper down and then shout at the guy who cleans it up?
If I'm walking down the street, there's a thrown out pc sitting on on the sidewalk...the noobie owner is probably too rich to get it fixed and just busy a one...oh not me I 'salvage' wats left, I've got a 320gb maxtor hardrive and a few gigs of ddr2 RAM doing this before. It's rubbish and it longer belongs to anyone besides the first hobo jakey bastard like me comes along.
Also posting in a whining carebear thread
Candy bar wrapper or PC....Make up your mind what you are trying to compare or go pick some flees off of your dad.
What if what you saw is replaced by someone that just sat it there till he gets out of the crapper? Maybe the guy had to go really bad and left it there till he can come back and SALVAGE IT HIMSELF?
|

BunnyBuzzBunny
|
Posted - 2009.11.30 10:07:00 -
[45]
Originally by: Ana'Lingus Please, just let this die. Take your rage out on people somewhere else, like, I dunno...ingame maybe? Learn to fly Recon cruisers and then go pop and pod some people if it makes your Irritable Male Syndrome go away.
Only thing I wish to die that is incomplete is yourself. Please feel free to make it so #2. there is no rage....just trying to understand why the game is screwed up in this concept.
|
|
|
|