EVE Search - Sion Kumitomo: CSM X

Check My IP Information

All Channels

CSM Campaigns

Sion Kumitomo: CSM X

» Click here to find additional results for this topic using Google

Monitor this thread via RSS [?]

Pages: 1 [2] 3 :: one page

Author	Thread Statistics \| Show CCP posts - 0 post(s)
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 261	Posted - 2014.12.24 15:16:45 - [31] - Quote Caleb Seremshur wrote: I'm curious to know why noone has addressed this yet. I read the CSM minutes every time they're released. I read them several times over. Specific people saying specific things gets lost in the details but what I've quoted above directly violates/contradicts the publicly disclosed stance of CCP (through the minutes) and while it's not a surprise I think it's worth more than just a footnote in your campaign. You're a volunteer peer reviewer, pretty much, from what I'm able to gather. To publicly state the things you have above is.. pretty damning really (of CCP). You're running for CSM 10, but I haven't seen Mynnnas declaration yet. Any other goon candidates this year? To be honest I haven't checked I'm mostly interested in recurring terms like yours. I appreciate that you've avoided using lofty rhetoric for the most part. Your honesty about CCPs position on their own institution is also appreciated. I just wonder why you're doing it, again I mean. It's pretty clear the CSM is being progressively marginalised and that last year especially was a pretty clear indicator of that. And then the sudden resignations of 2 CSM members this year as well. I would run for CSM too but not for the same reasons you do, I think. What the CSM "is" is difficult to define. The CSM isn't really a peer review process though. We're not peers and we rarely see things in time to review them in any meaningful capacity. Mynnna is not running this year, in his place Endie is running. The reason I'm honest both in public and in private about CSM matters is because I remember how the CSM came to be. The CSM exists not as a junior game developer consultancy, but as a means by which players can make sure we have a voice in legislating the rules of the game. According to one CCP employee, the CSM is a "PR tool." But that's a sword that cuts both ways as history has shown, and savvy CSM members recognize this. The reality is that CCP is in general in frequent contact with the playerbase, and they seek out and listen to many individuals and experts who don't have a CSM tag. On a superficial level, this makes the CSM redundant if the only purpose of the institution is to talk to CCP as player representatives. On the balance, this is a good thing. ThoughGÇösince individual players aren't under NDAGÇöit does sometimes result in some pretty hilarious NDA "breaches" for which the CSM sometimes gets wrongly blamed. As the other members of CSM 9 and CCP would no doubt tell you, I've been a firmGÇösome might say belligerentGÇöadvocate for the CSM as an institution. I've consistently went to the mats with CCP on being cut out of processes, our rights to engage as players, and the increasing marginalization of the institution. As for why, it's because I'm convinced that the CSM, when used properly and populated by capable members, is a huge asset to the community and the game as a whole. But regardless of what CCP does with the CSM, the ultimate responsibility is on us as players to make the CSM effective. And the reality is that we're not there yet. On twitter @siggonK
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 261	Posted - 2014.12.24 15:19:16 - [32] - Quote Solaris Vex wrote: [quote=Sion Kumitomo]Boo, awoxing was a unique eve tradition, that often lead to hilarious losses and memorable stories. A tradition that you will continue to be able to enjoy where it was originally developed and traditionally practicedGÇönullsec. On twitter @siggonK
Leyla Celeste GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 2	Posted - 2014.12.26 03:23:53 - [33] - Quote Sion's a good man, you should definitely have him on your list.
Crasniya Strange Energy The Bastion 556	Posted - 2015.01.05 18:03:44 - [34] - Quote Sion, you'll get a spot on my ballot. o7 Soraya Xel - Council of Planetary Management 1 - [email protected]
Schwa Nuts GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 82	Posted - 2015.01.07 14:05:28 - [35] - Quote Sion is a brilliant and dedicated advocate for the Eve players, a rational and thoughtful space diplomat/politician, and a generally good human being. And if I dare say so, someone I consider a friend. His addition to CSM9 was fantastic for us as regular Eve players, and he'll be a tremendous asset to CSM 10.
mynnna GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 3862	Posted - 2015.01.07 20:51:06 - [36] - Quote Caleb Seremshur wrote: You're running for CSM 10, but I haven't seen Mynnnas declaration yet. Any other goon candidates this year? As Sion noted, Endie is running in my place this year. I burned out pretty hard, largely courtesy of real life. Member of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal
Seraph IX Basarab Hades Effect 502	Posted - 2015.01.09 05:01:03 - [37] - Quote So what can you tell us about Kimsemus? Intriguing minds ponder. Hades Effect
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 268	Posted - 2015.01.09 20:01:19 - [38] - Quote Seraph IX Basarab wrote: So what can you tell us about Kimsemus? Intriguing minds ponder. I believe he's moved on to other MMO's, but I couldn't say for sure. On twitter @siggonK
Freelancer117 So you want to be a Hero 228	Posted - 2015.01.09 22:04:02 - [39] - Quote What is your opinion as a Goonswarm's CSM representative about Walking in Stations ? Should it be iterated on: to provide an immersive and superior New Player Experience to attract female players because of the immersion or emotional attachment to a character to ascend eve beyond the niche willing to suffer through its vertical learning curve source: http://www.themittani.com/content/soss-67-incarna-postmortem-6 The players will make a better version of the game, then CCP initially plans. http://eve-radio.com//images/photos/3419/223/34afa0d7998f0a9a86f737d6.jpg
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 268	Posted - 2015.01.10 06:24:01 - [40] - Quote Freelancer117 wrote: What is your opinion as a Goonswarm's CSM representative about Walking in Stations ? Should it be iterated on: to provide an immersive and superior New Player Experience to attract female players because of the immersion or emotional attachment to a character to ascend eve beyond the niche willing to suffer through its vertical learning curve source: http://www.themittani.com/content/soss-67-incarna-postmortem-6 Broadly speaking, I'm in favor of the idea of walking in stationsGÇöprovided there is compelling gameplay associated. I'd also quite like to see Dust boarding parties on titans, landing parties on sov infrastructure, and corridor firefights through outposts. Anything that makes New Eden a more immersive virtual world is a good goal. However, that must be balanced with the core of the game, which is the flying in space aspect that has propelled EVE along as long as it has. Dev time is zero sum, and I'm not convinced that FiS is at a point where it can be ignored long enough to properly implement WiS or that the resources are there to handle building both concurrently. I do, however, exception to your points. You'll have to convince me that WiS provides a superior NPE when compared with other potential NPE options that incorporate FiS. That premise is not a given. It offends my sensibilities that you appear to think females can only be attracted by first person avatars. Grow up. I have seen no evidence that WiS will flatten the FiS learning curve. The argument for WiS is there, certainly. I think you're doing yourself and all who share your goal of seeing a WiS reality a disservice by framing it in this manner though. On twitter @siggonK

June Ting Valkyries of Night Of Sound Mind 124	Posted - 2015.01.10 06:30:42 - [41] - Quote Sion Kumitomo wrote: It offends my sensibilities that you appear to think females can only be attracted by first person avatars. Grow up. +one million. I fight for the freedom of my people.
Freelancer117 So you want to be a Hero 228	Posted - 2015.01.10 19:43:10 - [42] - Quote Sion Kumitomo wrote: It offends my sensibilities that you appear to think females can only be attracted by first person avatars. Grow up. You have to talk to your boss (lack of a better word) about that: Quote: My arguments in favor of Incarna remain sound. The core purpose of Incarna is to provide an immersive and superior New Player Experience, and if it ever gets implemented properly it should succeed. The development of the Carbon engine remains a business reality, though in hindsight licensing a tested 3D engine seems like a much wiser course. EVE still desperately needs immersion if it is to attract female players or ascend beyond the niche willing to suffer through its vertical learning curve Source: The Mittani (author) The players will make a better version of the game, then CCP initially plans. http://eve-radio.com//images/photos/3419/223/34afa0d7998f0a9a86f737d6.jpg
Dersen Lowery Drinking in Station 1422	Posted - 2015.01.10 21:48:40 - [43] - Quote Freelancer117 wrote: Sion Kumitomo wrote: It offends my sensibilities that you appear to think females can only be attracted by first person avatars. Grow up. You have to talk to your boss (lack of a better word) about that[.] That's not much of an argument. It just means that he's full of ****, too. I just watched Sion's presentation at EVE Down Under, and his particular area of expertise is exactly what's required to tackle the current shortage of women in EVE, should he choose to do so. It has very little to do with the gameplay, and very much to do with the existing player base. If he does, I'm guessing that he will find an immediate ally in CCP Seagull, who is also allergic to the idea that there has to be some sort of "pink" gameplay "for the ladies." Just make the game better. Proud founder and member of the Belligerent Desirables.
Lanctharus Onzo Alea Iacta Est Universal Brave Collective 80	Posted - 2015.01.12 08:53:17 - [44] - Quote Lanctharus Onzo wrote: Good to hear that you have decided to run again. As you are aware we at the Cap Stable Podcast interviewed you during your run for CSM9 and we wish to do the same this year for CSM10. Here is our announcement: http://capstable.net/2014/12/01/council-of-stellar-management-x-call-for-candidate-interviews/ As we stated in the announcement, you can contact us to schedule your one on one interview via any of the following methods: Email: [email protected] Twitter: @CapStable Or via our contact form We look forward to speaking to you about your particular skill set and expertise in EVE Online and we hope you success in your candidacy. Sincerely, Lanctharus Onzo Co-host & Writer of the Cap Stable Podcast Military Director, Alea Iacta Est Universal Hello Sion! Wanted to find out when did you want to schedule your CSMX interview? Writer, Co-host of the Cap Stable Podcast Twitter: @Lanctharus
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 272	Posted - 2015.01.12 13:44:30 - [45] - Quote Lanctharus Onzo wrote: Lanctharus Onzo wrote: Good to hear that you have decided to run again. As you are aware we at the Cap Stable Podcast interviewed you during your run for CSM9 and we wish to do the same this year for CSM10. Here is our announcement: http://capstable.net/2014/12/01/council-of-stellar-management-x-call-for-candidate-interviews/ As we stated in the announcement, you can contact us to schedule your one on one interview via any of the following methods: Email: [email protected] Twitter: @CapStable Or via our contact form We look forward to speaking to you about your particular skill set and expertise in EVE Online and we hope you success in your candidacy. Sincerely, Lanctharus Onzo Co-host & Writer of the Cap Stable Podcast Military Director, Alea Iacta Est Universal Hello Sion! Wanted to find out when did you want to schedule your CSMX interview? Hey Lanctharus, I'll drop you a line in private. On twitter @siggonK
Sven Viko VIkolander Friends and Feminists 320	Posted - 2015.01.14 22:19:08 - [46] - Quote Could you to give an example of a change to the game you have advocated for while on the CSM that would be good for the game in general, in your estimation, but potentially bad for your own corporation/alliance/coalition as an in-game entity?
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 274	Posted - 2015.01.15 03:51:58 - [47] - Quote Sven Viko VIkolander wrote: Could you to give an example of a change to the game you have advocated for while on the CSM that would be good for the game in general, in your estimation, but potentially bad for your own corporation/alliance/coalition as an in-game entity? I've advocated heavily for changes to the highsec corp aggression mechanics, which I suppose you might count. Though also, the conceptualization of what might be good or bad for a corporation, alliance, or coalition in terms of game mechanics depends largely on zoom level and time frame. A rising tide lifts all boats, and only the short-sighted or the narrow minded advocate for short term advantage at the expense of the game's ecosystem as a whole. On twitter @siggonK
Jenshae Chiroptera The Volition Cult 757	Posted - 2015.01.16 02:34:17 - [48] - Quote I like your blunt, shooting from the hip approach to the review. Edit: Oh. I suppose . That. I have to add the expected, "Grrr Goons" Otherwise. People will report this post. ... and claim my account was stolen. this was also written in their strata method so they can read it. CSM Ten movement for change. CCP - Building ant hills and magnifying glasses for fat kids. Status: Rabid carebear Blog
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 283	Posted - 2015.01.16 14:08:35 - [49] - Quote Jenshae Chiroptera wrote: I like your blunt, shooting from the hip approach to the review. Edit: Oh. I suppose . That. I have to add the expected, "Grrr Goons" Otherwise. People will report this post. ... and claim my account was stolen. this was also written in their strata method so they can read it. Grr, goons. On twitter @siggonK
StupidGenius Charante Alea Iacta Est Universal Brave Collective 5	Posted - 2015.02.01 07:36:37 - [50] - Quote I sat down with Sion Kumitomo for a CSM X Interview: http://capstable.net/2015/02/01/sion-kumitomo/

Hendrick Tallardar Habitual Euthanasia Pandemic Legion 373	Posted - 2015.02.01 12:03:31 - [51] - Quote Sion, In that interview you claim that Xander breached the CSM NDA on his podcast. You also assert that NDA'd information makes its way to people in a non-public fashion, which you discern through people's posts and so forth. That's a rather presumptuous claim to make given you lack anything really in the way of evidence. Do you feel that, given that CCP aren't keen on having people do that sort of thing, and the fact Xander is still a full member of the CSM without incident, your allegation is still true? CSM members have been ejected for far less than what you are accusing Xander of, and he remains on the CSM. Your thoughts on that? It certainly comes across as rumor mongering which is rather petty to do during a campaign, which is rather sad to see you resort to. Also pro-tip, you need a better mic. The one you used is pretty bad, and you should use the $30 it takes to get a better one. Unless, of course, you can't afford it. EVE Online Weekly & Monthly Nullsec Recaps \| EVE 101 Tutorial Series
Gossamer DT Wildly Inappropriate Goonswarm Federation 112	Posted - 2015.02.01 16:32:43 - [52] - Quote Hendrick Tallardar wrote: Sion, In that interview you claim that Xander breached the CSM NDA on his podcast. You also assert that NDA'd information makes its way to people in a non-public fashion, which you discern through people's posts and so forth. That's a rather presumptuous claim to make given you lack anything really in the way of evidence. Do you feel that, given that CCP aren't keen on having people do that sort of thing, and the fact Xander is still a full member of the CSM without incident, your allegation is still true? CSM members have been ejected for far less than what you are accusing Xander of, and he remains on the CSM. Your thoughts on that? It certainly comes across as rumor mongering which is rather petty to do during a campaign, which is rather sad to see you resort to. Also pro-tip, you need a better mic. The one you used is pretty bad, and you should use the $30 it takes to get a better one. Unless, of course, you can't afford it. Wow on one hand you are trying to discredit Sion by sighting that you have some kind of inside understanding of what makes CCP trigger on CSM ejection, and then on the other hand you are trying to push him down even more by attaching his mic and possible income level? Since when was space ships about your income level? who is your main, and what does he do?
Endie von Posts Bat Country Goonswarm Federation 129	Posted - 2015.02.01 16:41:57 - [53] - Quote Say what you like about that interview, it was the most controversially listenable one yet. And I include Xenuria's weirdfest in that.
Hendrick Tallardar Habitual Euthanasia Pandemic Legion 375	Posted - 2015.02.01 16:57:42 - [54] - Quote Gossamer DT wrote: Wow on one hand you are trying to discredit Sion by sighting that you have some kind of inside understanding of what makes CCP trigger on CSM ejection, and then on the other hand you are trying to push him down even more by attaching his mic and possible income level? Since when was space ships about your income level? If you mean referring to CCP's past treatment of "problem children" within the CSM is having "some kind of inside" then sure, I have intimate understanding of how the CSM is handled by CCP. Also, if you took the quip about his mic as an attack then you are very sensitive to internet forums. Endie is right, it was a controversially listenable interview even without the mic issues. Please don't feel the need to rush to your alliance mates defense when he is asked for further clarification. I'm sure he's fully capable and mature enough to respond on his own. EVE Online Weekly & Monthly Nullsec Recaps \| EVE 101 Tutorial Series
Gossamer DT Wildly Inappropriate Goonswarm Federation 112	Posted - 2015.02.01 17:50:36 - [55] - Quote Hendrick Tallardar wrote: Gossamer DT wrote: Wow on one hand you are trying to discredit Sion by sighting that you have some kind of inside understanding of what makes CCP trigger on CSM ejection, and then on the other hand you are trying to push him down even more by attaching his mic and possible income level? Since when was space ships about your income level? If you mean referring to CCP's past treatment of "problem children" within the CSM is having "some kind of inside" then sure, I have intimate understanding of how the CSM is handled by CCP. Also, if you took the quip about his mic as an attack then you are very sensitive to internet forums. Endie is right, it was a controversially listenable interview even without the mic issues. Please don't feel the need to rush to your alliance mates defense when he is asked for further clarification. I'm sure he's fully capable and mature enough to respond on his own. yes I am RUSHING to the DEFENCE of my alliance MATE o7. who is your main, and what does he do?
Malcanis Vanishing Point. The Initiative. 16048	Posted - 2015.02.01 21:03:11 - [56] - Quote Anyone who's read my posts knows that I'm not exactly Sion's greatest fan as a person. He is, to be frank, and abrasive jerk. As one myself, I am qualified to say so, and he applies the term to himself. However he does have at least one of the two essential qualifiactions to be a good CSM: He cares about the game, and he cares about the CSM. It doesn't matter tuppence whether I'd want to go drinking with him; it matters if I think he will energetically and sincerely pursue CCP to address the issues that are important. I am confident that he would if re-elected. The other qualification is to be an effective team player, to avoid alienating people who are not required to use the CSM as a resource, and to demonstrate that the CSM can be a professional, cohesive team. My confidence here is not quite so emphatic. Sion has been pretty clear about what he wants from CCP; I hope that he will also realise that more will be required from him to earn that commitment from the devs and restore some of the bridges that have been - if not burned, then he will surely admit, pretty badly scorched. He's capable of it. If he can redefine his style in his second term in this way, I think he could be an extremely effective CSM member, and help turn CSM X into something more useful than the current team. "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his ISK/hr depends upon his not understanding it!"
DaveTheGreat Enlightened Industries Goonswarm Federation 9	Posted - 2015.02.02 09:18:34 - [57] - Quote Just listened to your capstable interview on the way to work. You come across as being very professional and well balanced, unlike some of the other candidates they have interviewed. I think Endie and yourself will be a great team, working for the good of the game.
Marlona Sky Burning Napalm Northern Coalition. 5947	Posted - 2015.02.02 10:20:12 - [58] - Quote In your interview on Cap Stable, you mentioned that you feel the CSM is a meta game entity. Can you elaborate on that more and without breaking NDA, give some examples? Vote for Marlona Sky in the CSM 10 election! Be sure to watch The Paradox, my PvP video.
Sion Kumitomo GoonWaffe Goonswarm Federation 297	Posted - 2015.02.02 15:34:34 - [59] - Quote Hendrick Tallardar wrote: In that interview you claim that Xander breached the CSM NDA on his podcast. You also assert that NDA'd information makes its way to people in a non-public fashion, which you discern through people's posts and so forth. That's a rather presumptuous claim to make given you lack anything really in the way of evidence. Do you feel that, given that CCP aren't keen on having people do that sort of thing, and the fact Xander is still a full member of the CSM without incident, your allegation is still true? CSM members have been ejected for far less than what you are accusing Xander of, and he remains on the CSM. Your thoughts on that? It certainly comes across as rumor mongering which is rather petty to do during a campaign, which is rather sad to see you resort to. Also pro-tip, you need a better mic. The one you used is pretty bad, and you should use the $30 it takes to get a better one. Unless, of course, you can't afford it. Thanks for bringing up an excellent point on the need for greater transparency and visibility into the CSM. Protocols do not currently exist to allow CSM members to truly hold each other accountable, or for the voting public to hold their elected representatives accountable, so it can indeed come off as rumor mongering. This is something I'm going to attempt to tackle next term should I be elected again. As is, I entirely understand your reticence and am sympathetic as to how it could appear to be petty. With any luck, this will not be an issue next year pending some badly needed reform actions. The closed door nature of the CSM ill serves the purpose of the institution. Malcanis wrote: Anyone who's read my posts knows that I'm not exactly Sion's greatest fan as a person. He is, to be frank, an abrasive jerk. As one myself, I am qualified to say so, and he applies the term to himself. From one jerk to another, I consider it high praise. Where you see the most of me is in Alumni though, which I explicitly rope off for trolling. I couldn't run a team of diplomats, seventy directors, or any of the other people-centric organizations I run if that was my normal mode of interaction with people. Marlona Sky wrote: In your interview on Cap Stable, you mentioned that you feel the CSM is a meta game entity. Can you elaborate on that more and without breaking NDA, give some examples? It's a matter of definitions. Though metagame has evolved in EVE into a verb (I got metagamed, they metagamed me), it was originally used as noun used to refer to actions taken beyond the ruleset of a game that had potential impacts on said game. An elected space council meeting in real life and shelving their space persona to talk about business, game implications, rules, and other such is thus by definition a metagame entity. This is distinct from "The CSM is metagaming players," which is both a misunderstanding of term usage and patently false. On twitter @siggonK
Marlona Sky Burning Napalm Northern Coalition. 5948	Posted - 2015.02.02 17:23:09 - [60] - Quote Sion Kumitomo wrote: Marlona Sky wrote: In your interview on Cap Stable, you mentioned that you feel the CSM is a meta game entity. Can you elaborate on that more and without breaking NDA, give some examples? It's a matter of definitions. Though metagame has evolved in EVE into a verb (I got metagamed, they metagamed me), it was originally used as noun used to refer to actions taken beyond the ruleset of a game that had potential impacts on said game. An elected space council meeting in real life and shelving their space persona to talk about business, game implications, rules, and other such is thus by definition a metagame entity. This is distinct from "The CSM is metagaming players," which is both a misunderstanding of term usage and patently false. Solid response. Vote for Marlona Sky in the CSM 10 election! Be sure to watch The Paradox, my PvP video.



Pages: 1 [2] 3 :: one page
First page \| Previous page \| Next page \| Last page

COPYRIGHT NOTICE
EVE Online, the EVE logo, EVE and all associated logos and designs are the intellectual property of CCP hf. All artwork, screenshots, characters, vehicles, storylines, world facts or other recognizable features of the intellectual property relating to these trademarks are likewise the intellectual property of CCP hf. EVE Online and the EVE logo are the registered trademarks of CCP hf. All rights are reserved worldwide. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. CCP hf. has granted permission to EVE-Search.com to use EVE Online and all associated logos and designs for promotional and information purposes on its website but does not endorse, and is not in any way affiliated with, EVE-Search.com. CCP is in no way responsible for the content on or functioning of this website, nor can it be liable for any damage arising from the use of this website.