
Pilk
Axiom Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.01 16:03:00 -
[1]
Originally by: Stitcher 1: The hit points. If a carrier's being used in much the same role as a battleship, then it shouldn't have that many more hit points than a battleship does. It should have more, certainly, but not as huge a margin as it presently does. I'd say about 150% of a typical tier 3 battleship's hitpoints would be sufficient
They used to have hitpoints like you suggest. The problem was, for armor-tankers, you could have a great armor tank up and running, tanking everyone shooting at you, but because there's no skills for "armor uniformity", you'd be taking structure damage whenever your armor dipped below 25%, and you'd eventually explode with armor still remaining. And let's face it, that sucks.
Originally by: Stitcher 2: the drone bay. These are, IMO, far too large, and this makes the job of engaging and neutralizing a carrier far too hard - no matter how many drones/fighters you kill, it always has more. I think it would be about appropriate for a carrier to have enough drone bay space to field one full-sized wing of fighters, and a full-sized wing of medium scout drones when filled to capacity.
Every carrier but the Thanatos has 80,000 m3 of drone space currently, and the Thanatos has 100k m3. A "full-sized wing" of fighters is 15 fighters (Carrier V + ADI V); that'd be 75,000 m3. 15 medium scout drones would be an additional 150 m3. So this isn't really that big of a change. Furthermore, that'd just mean that I'd have 14 fighters + several hundred smaller drones, instead of 15 + smaller. Thus, this proposed solution doesn't actually accomplish what you're trying to do.
Originally by: Stitcher Now, speaking as a wannabe carrier pilot myself, I accept that these suggestions are hardly fair on the people who fly them, which is why I suggest the following counter-balances:
1: Drop the build requirements by about a third. 2: Improve the warp speed to 3.0AU/s. 3: Spinners.
1: Can I get some warning so I can reprocess my carrier first, and build three new ones after? 2: tbh, this doesn't do a hell of a lot for me. Give me agility or give me death. (No, seriously, I die to lack of agility, not lack of warp speed.) 3: /signed, baby. If they can put spinny-thingies on a Harpy, then, by Jove, we need spinny-thingies on capitals!
--P
|