| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Matalino
Gallente
Ki Tech Industries
   |
Posted - 2007.11.26 18:16:00 -
[1]
 Originally by: Kitex
- Continue trying to make Carrier/MS production work. 83.0097491876 % (83.0097491876/100.0)
- Switch to T2 Freighters, Rorquals, and new T2 ship production. 5.84117990167 % (5.84117990167/100.0)
- Liquidate and return as much isk as possible. 11.1490709108 % (11.1490709108/100.0)
Originally by: FastLearner
Looks to me like two things are rather obvious:
1. Wylker voted with his own shares,
2. Even discounting his own shares, option A. won the vote.
If those are the actual results (screenshot please) then everyone voted, including Wylker and any shares held by the corp.
As for an obvious victory for continued persuit of capital ship production, I am not so sure on that one.
In my opinion, as an disinterested third party, this vote should have been a two not three option vote. By providing three options Wylker effectively split the opposition to coninuing cap production.
If those who voted to Switch to T2 Freighters, Rorquals, and new T2 ship production would have voted to liquidate in a two option vote and Wylker kept to his original position of nuetrality, then the vote would have been close, but would have been in favor of liquidation.
While I don't care one way or the other what happens here, I do feel strongly about Wylker's change of position regarding voting with the corp held controling stake. That is wrong. The corp has no voice on its future. The future of the corp should be detirmined by those who paid for its existance. I see no problem with Wylker voting with the shares he had purchased. However, to publicly state that he did not intend to vote, then change to voting without a public statement is dishonest.
I think that Wylker has enough problems with running a business in a competitive market, he doesn't need to make things worse by calling into question his honesty.
**************************
Datacore Harvesting IPO |
Matalino
Gallente
Ki Tech Industries
|
Posted - 2007.11.27 01:10:00 -
[2]
Edited by: Matalino on 27/11/2007 01:11:05
Originally by: Wylker
Welp, I went to see how the vote went, and I just have the same information as everyone else, anyone know a top secret way to get the # of votes instead of the percentage?
The results are displayed as dual percentages, both percentage that voted and percentage of votes cast for that options.
So if you see 83.0097491876 % (83.0097491876/100.0) that means that 100% of shareholders voted, 83% of shares voted for that option.
Had there been share holders that did not vote, you would have seen a result such as 87.2027180068 % (8.02083333333/9.19791666667), thus indicating that 8% of shareholders voted for that option, but only 9.2% of shareholders voted at all, meaning that 87% of voters voted for that option.
**************************
Datacore Harvesting IPO |
Matalino
Gallente
Ki Tech Industries
|
Posted - 2007.11.27 14:45:00 -
[3]
Originally by: Shadarle
It is actually quite interesting that no one else thought this up previously. It's quite obvious and seems to make mathematical sense. Time to go back through some old threads to check some votes I think.
How do you think that I posted the number of shares that did not vote on the change to financing for DATAC?
I am suprised that more of you didn't already know this.
**************************
Datacore Harvesting IPO |
Matalino
Gallente
Ki Tech Industries
|
Posted - 2007.11.27 15:53:00 -
[4]
Originally by: Kitex
In fairness, it's an insignificant detail to 99.9% of the EVE populace.
True, I would not have expected many people in say General Discussion to know this, but I would think that this community with all the votes and polling that is done would have known that. In any case, everyone reading this thread knows: and knowing is half the battle. 
**************************
Datacore Harvesting IPO |
Matalino
Gallente
Ki Tech Industries
|
Posted - 2007.11.28 15:03:00 -
[5]
Edited by: Matalino on 28/11/2007 15:04:27
The example that I provided eariler was taken directly from the Financing vote for DATAC. Unless they have rewritten the voting system in the past couple of weeks then it would still be the same.
Originally by: Ricdic
http://users.tpg.com.au/ricdic/vote.jpg
An thus we see that 22.2% voted.
**************************
Datacore Harvesting IPO |
| |
|