Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 1 post(s) |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
0
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 22:11:00 -
[1] - Quote
Hey guys.
So, I've been running a rigged mission domi for some time now. After a good amount of missions and trading, I've got just enough so, if I sell my rigged domi at a little below real value with rigs, I'd be able to outfit a Navy Domi.
So, I go to Jita and offer a sale of my domi for 95mil, send out the message a few times. The rigs were 1x Sentry Drone Damage Aug, 1x Large Nanobot, 1x Large Aux Nano Pump
I get a trade offer, the window pops up. I throw my Domi in to see if that's what he's inquiring about, and I see 95mil in green show up, along with his accept checkmark. I accept as well, and it goes through.
But I never got the 95mil.
Character is Marhaba. He proceeds to say in Jita chat "Thanks for the free domi ;)."
Considering that that ship was my largest asset, I'm pretty infuriated. I don't know if this was some bug, scam, or what. Would CCP listen to a petition?
What do I do from here? |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
0
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 22:22:00 -
[2] - Quote
Seatox wrote:The trade window is terrible, and vulnerable to sleight of hand - and you shouldn't use it for commerce.
What probably happened was they put in 95 million, then zeroed it *and then hit accept*, and you didn't notice them zeroing the value before you hit accept.
Use the contract system instead.
Nope, I'm aware of that tactic. The 95mil was there. Not only was it there, but if it were modified within a short time frame within hitting accept, there would have been a notification (if I'm not mistaken, I've seen it before: ""Warning: your client has modified your order. Do you still want to accept?" Or something.).
Feligast wrote: and it's unlikely your petition would result in anything. Chalk it up as an eve lesson and get back at it.
Well this is unacceptable. That ship is worth 1/3 of my savings in the game, and I lost it due to poor game mechanics. I shouldn't be liable for unsatisfactory trade window code. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
0
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 22:31:00 -
[3] - Quote
Morganta wrote:Zarcan wrote:Seatox wrote:The trade window is terrible, and vulnerable to sleight of hand - and you shouldn't use it for commerce.
What probably happened was they put in 95 million, then zeroed it *and then hit accept*, and you didn't notice them zeroing the value before you hit accept.
Use the contract system instead. Nope, I'm aware of that tactic. The 95mil was there. Feligast wrote: and it's unlikely your petition would result in anything. Chalk it up as an eve lesson and get back at it. Well this is unacceptable. That ship is worth 1/3 of my savings in the game, and I lost it due to poor game mechanics. I shouldn't be liable for unsatisfactory trade window code. if you haven't been bankrupt by a scam or gank at least once, you haven't been playing EVE They wont admit it, but everyone here has had it happen in some form or another at least once
Well then, My 4 year old character shouldn't exist, eh?
I'm not gonna accept that, sorry. CCP is gonna have to get back to me on this one. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
0
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 22:34:00 -
[4] - Quote
Feligast wrote:Good luck with that  And I'm so glad you found the money to form your own corp a few minutes ago. Not so broke, huh?
... it costs a measly 1.5mil to make a corp, and I made it hours ago. The scam happened about 20 minutes ago.
Can you do basic math? Or do I have to spell out why your post is irrelevant on both accounts? |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
0
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 22:39:00 -
[5] - Quote
Montevius Williams wrote:Morganta wrote:Zarcan wrote:Seatox wrote:The trade window is terrible, and vulnerable to sleight of hand - and you shouldn't use it for commerce.
What probably happened was they put in 95 million, then zeroed it *and then hit accept*, and you didn't notice them zeroing the value before you hit accept.
Use the contract system instead. Nope, I'm aware of that tactic. The 95mil was there. Feligast wrote: and it's unlikely your petition would result in anything. Chalk it up as an eve lesson and get back at it. Well this is unacceptable. That ship is worth 1/3 of my savings in the game, and I lost it due to poor game mechanics. I shouldn't be liable for unsatisfactory trade window code. if you haven't been bankrupt by a scam or gank at least once, you haven't been playing EVE They wont admit it, but everyone here has had it happen in some form or another at least once Yea but the point still stands, CCP needs to fix dumb **** like this. You may not have the resources of Blizzard but damn, you cant make a properly working trade window? Really? C'mon CCP...
A petition has been filed.
I'll keep the thread updated on how CCP deals with it, so we can hold them accountable. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
1
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 22:50:00 -
[6] - Quote
Vincent Athena wrote:Hm, I wondered how that worked. I had someone offer me a ship for well below cost, a trade window popped up along with the ship. I could not figure out how such a scam would work, but this being eve I closed the trade window.
Lag scam? So they zeroed the amount and hit accept at just the right time so the OP never saw it happen due to lag?
Is there not supposed to be a notification window if the client modifies his order within like 3 seconds of pressing the accept button?
I could have sworn I've seen it before. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
1
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 22:55:00 -
[7] - Quote
ShahFluffers wrote:Are you sure you saw 95.000.000.00 and not 95.000.00?
Remember to ALWAYS count the digits and subtract by two (as those last two are "cents").
Yeah... dumb interface deatails thingy. But somehow... I have this nagging suspicion that CCP made it this way on purpose for this exact reason.
Yes, considering there was no exchange of money whatsoever according to my transactions journal.
Also, hooray for my first forum like recieved. \o/ |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
2
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 23:07:00 -
[8] - Quote
Rath Kelbore wrote:I understand that you're upset about losing your ship, but I suggest you just move on. You got scammed, it happens if you're not careful.
You can petition it but can you prove that the trade window said 95 million when you hit the accept button???? Probably not. It will just waste a gm's time to look at it.
It's just the way it is *shrug*. Eve isn't perfect but what else are you gonna play? World of Warcraft?
The fault of the decent into a state of tyranny rests on the shoulders of the apathetic. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
2
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 23:12:00 -
[9] - Quote
Marhaba > 0/ Zarcan > So I'm gonna go ahead and humbly request that you give me what's mine. Marhaba > what, like a wardec? Gladly Zarcan > How about that Dominix? You know, that one that represents 1/2 of my capital in EVE Marhaba > i've already sold it. [Contract for 65mil] Zarcan > Well then surely you've got the money to reinburse me.
... |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
2
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 23:18:00 -
[10] - Quote
Tippia wrote:Zarcan wrote:The fault of the decent into a state of tyranny rests on the shoulders of the apathetic. GǪexcept that scamming is explicitly and purposefully allowed by the game designers. Its existence has nothing to do with apathy.
... and why the hell would we as a playerbase tolerate that? |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 23:33:00 -
[11] - Quote
Mekki Muvila wrote:Your Domi fit sucks anyway
The Guristas disagree. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.13 23:56:00 -
[12] - Quote
I think that CCP just wants the extra $15 a month.
Oh, wait, scammers make so much ISK that they just plex.
Hmmmmm. Obviously a completely equitable situation here. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 00:05:00 -
[13] - Quote
Mekki Muvila wrote:Zarcan wrote:Mekki Muvila wrote:Your Domi fit sucks anyway The Guristas disagree. The Guristas are ********. You combine buffer and active tanks, you use a mag stab on a ship where your DPS comes from drones.... it doesn't take much to make a Domi invincible in L4s, but it takes some intelligence to fit it properly. No wonder you're so broke for such an old player, it takes you ages to do the simplest of L4s, and its mind numbingly boring to do it.
Oh save your crap. My dominix was a great combination of HP, repair quantity and resistances along with combined rail and drone damage.
If you think I give two craps about your opinion of my ship, consider; I had enough intelligence to not allow you to scam me out of 300mil, so, kindly go hide in your corner of your basement you sociopath. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 00:11:00 -
[14] - Quote
Hijeri wrote:Zarcan wrote:Mekki Muvila wrote:Your Domi fit sucks anyway The Guristas disagree. You think being able to kill rats enables you to judge whether a fit is good or not? That's freaking hilarious coming from someone like you, who's played this game for years. I can hop into an armor drake and do L4's. Just saying. I see ratters rat with the most stupid fits every day. You'll do good staying in high sec, running missions all day.
Teach me your ways, wise computer game master!
Montevius Williams wrote:Zleon Leigh wrote:Another example of how scammers get off without consequences... he'll never leave the station, never have sec status where you could even put a bounty on him (even though that is a totally f'd up mechanic as well) You know, you bring up a very good point People always talk about EVE in terms of "Risk vs Reward" Where is the risk for scammer? Can someone give a legimate reason as to why there is a risk for a scammer selling Carbon to someone who thinks its a Charon? Cause if there is no LEGITIMATE risk, this game activity needs to be put in line with all the other activities of EVE that require risk.
The risk, indeed, should be CCP catching them and banning them. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 00:14:00 -
[15] - Quote
Cryten Jones wrote:Sigh... There was some sympathy at the start of the thread. shame you went a ruined it really.... grow up mate, it's a game.
God forbid I'm a high-sec player.
Tippia wrote:Zarcan wrote:The risk, indeed, should be CCP catching them and banning them. For what? Do you also propose that CCP should start catching you and banning you for shooting those Guristas?
For what? Really? Do I have to spell out that scamming players out of ISK, which is transferable to game time, is the same thing as scamming people out of real money? A dishonest method of gameplay that CCP only endorses because it brings them more money? |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 00:20:00 -
[16] - Quote
Tippia wrote:Zarcan wrote:For what? Really? Do I have to spell out that scamming players out of ISK, which is transferable to game time, is the same thing as scamming people out of real money? Except that it's not. Well, unless you're an ISK sellerGǪ in which case they most certainly should ban you, not the scammer. Scamming is legitimate gameplay. Why would they ban people for playing the game?
CCP decides what is legitimate and what isn't. If you really want to put your energy into defending scammers, all the more power to you. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 00:31:00 -
[17] - Quote
I'm just really surprised that you all feel that way.
I guess this is another issue however, the trade window is the culprit.
If the right DEV happens to read this, the petition is filed, please get back to me. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
3
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 00:45:00 -
[18] - Quote
gfldex wrote:If believe you got hit by a bug file a bug report. If that bug is confirmed (that bug is very very old btw) you refere to it in your petition. Whining about a bug on the forum that was exploited will and always has spawn trolls. It never spawned devs.
Thank you for the reply. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
9
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 07:18:00 -
[19] - Quote
Okay all, I'd like to give a shout out to a few people right now.
I just got back from work and logged on to find 2 active contracts to me, one from a character by the name of 1-Up Mushroom, and the other from Captain Dunzel.
1-Up Mushroom's contract offered me 50,000,000 isk and a free Navy Dominix. Captain Dunzel offered me a free Navy Dominix as well.
I am astounded and reinvigorated. You both put huge smiles on my faces and restored some hope in humanity for myself.
I am reallocating the 50,000,000 isk to Captain Dunzel's wallet for his generosity, and declining his contract. While the ship is incredibly helpful, it's just the means to an end to making my own isk.
I think everyone should give a shout out to the altruism we've seen here today from these two players, and for stepping up when CCP did not.
Thanks again guys. I'd hug you if I knew you.
Zarc |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
9
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 07:34:00 -
[20] - Quote
Ursula LeGuinn wrote:I was considering offering you 100m myself (provided your petition went nowhere), but apparently I'm too selfish. Actually, it's more that I'm too generous and would be broke all the time if I gave in to every sad story. No joke, I'm the kind of person who gives $5 to every panhandler and beggar I encounter IRL.
What's important is that you learned a lesson. You were lucky enough that folks chose to help you out in your time of need. You need to get together with people who'll tell you about stuff like this, such as public chat channels for various corporations or alliances (E-UNI is one that's populous and accessible). There are also plenty of lists of EVE scams you can Google.
My God, you're arrogant. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
9
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 07:57:00 -
[21] - Quote
Ursula LeGuinn wrote:Zarcan wrote:My God, you're arrogant. Have you come to expect humility from anyone here on the EVE forums? Let's see, you're a mission runner flying a ship he can't afford to lose, you fell for an elementary scam (regardless of the functionality of the trade window), and you started a thread on the forums to complain about it. If that's not an old classic I've seen dozens of times before, I don't know what is. A few years ago, I swear people would've eaten you alive. I think this game is going soft. Even the smallest amount of research or discussion with seasoned pilots would have prevented you from embarking down that path of disaster. I may be arrogant, but hopefully my hurting of your feelings will help you to remember to do your damned research from now on.
I'm just absolutely astounded that you're really taking this much time and effort into deliberately being such a tool after this whole thing has already been taken care of.
You don't like that I do missions? Cry moar. I was around 4 years ago, tool. The playerbase was much more conducive to new players back then, not the opposite. Finally, pardon me for not googling "IS THE TRADE WINDOW FUNDAMENTALLY FLAWWED IN EVE ONLINE."
Go to bed, no one's listening to your pedantic rants about this video game. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
10
|
Posted - 2012.01.14 08:08:00 -
[22] - Quote
Ursula LeGuinn wrote:Zarcan wrote:I'm just absolutely astounded that you're really taking this much time and effort into deliberately being such a tool after this whole thing has already been taken care of. It hasn't been taken care of. You need to get a damned clue about how to survive in this game. The loss or reimbursement of assets is completely beside the point. Ursula LeGuinn wrote:I was around 4 years ago, tool. The playerbase was much more conducive to new players back then, not the opposite. Four years ago? Did you actually complete the tutorial? Stay mad. Get motivated. Then climb in a ship and come shoot me full of humility. I want you to keep playing and to learn the lessons you need to learn along the way.
You ever consider getting that perspective for real life? |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
13
|
Posted - 2012.01.15 19:43:00 -
[23] - Quote
Marhaba wrote:Miyamato wrote:What would make this trade window scamming impossible would be a final screen that shows the absolute end of the trade. Say I am buying a BC for 100 million. The battlecruiser enters the window, I put my money into the window and accept. Then the screen pops up with a final trade of Battlecruiser for 100,000,000. Do you Accept? YES. Then voila, the end result is controlled by the server and everything goes through smoothly.
Pretty easy fix really. Fix? I'm not convinced anything's broken.
The 95mil was there when I pressed accept. It was lag. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
13
|
Posted - 2012.01.15 19:52:00 -
[24] - Quote
Brock Nelson wrote:Exactly, and how do you expect lag to be fixed? It's been a problem ever since Eve first came out and it's been a problem for every multiplayer game that ever exist.
In the sense that a game's efficiency is limited by connection speed, sure. I don't really believe that to be an sort of excuse for not correcting insecure trading windows, I haven't encountered this drastic of a trade window exploit problem in any other MMO.
If I'm not mistaken, even SOE (who was notorious for a poor connection with their playerbase, if anyone else was along with the NGE), SWG had an alert window whenever the client modified the order, precisely to prevent this problem. I don't see why this hasn't been implemented, especially in a game that has been around as long as EVE has. They don't like getting petitions any more than we like getting scammed. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
13
|
Posted - 2012.01.15 21:15:00 -
[25] - Quote
Miyamato wrote:Ai Shun wrote:Miyamato wrote:Lying and stealing someone elses property is not a legitimate mechanic. There is a different between a gullible person falling for a trap and an actual game-creating bug/mechanic that causes the ability to scam. If someone accepts a contracted mission and goes out to the spot to pick up the item and then gets killed, that is a legitimate game mechanic. That is someone setting a legitimate trap, someone falling into it, and getting killed in the process. Thats legitimate. What about the trade scams in Jita? They are lies that end up with somebody stealing anothers' property. Is that supposed to be a point? I'm baffled to be honest. Like I said I have played dozens of MMO's and never once seen a community that is so .... blah .... about scamming. Usually people complain about it, the devs fix the exploit or scamming method and everyone moves along. In this game, you actually have people saying people play EVE just to scam? You do know this is a game right? The money they make in game, from the scamming, has nothing to do with the real world? So why would someone actually start paying for a game just to scam people for no real reason? That, in essence, is insane. I dunno. I'm mind blown tbh. I think the people saying this stuff are the scammers themselves. Thats the only logical explanation.
Perhaps I shouldn't endorse you as I'm not too popular in this thread haha, but indeed, I'm really astounded at how many people actively defend it. I understand its a part of the game, I understand CCP endorses it, I'll never understand why the players fight for it so adamantly.
From my perspective, it doesn't *have* to be this way, and we wouldn't be having this 8 page discussion if it were a black and white issue, as some people would have you believe. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
21
|
Posted - 2012.01.27 19:32:00 -
[26] - Quote
Holy crap, 10 pages of people continuously ranting at me. Why is this thread still alive?
I don't have the time or patience to respond to all of these posts, the bottom line is that the trade window is broken and needs to be addressed. It's a pathetic cop out that CCP told me to "avoid the trade window" because if it's faulty mechanics.
If something doesn't work right in your game, fix it. Especially when it's as black and white as the trade window not having a 2nd stage confirmation window before the transaction goes through.
JC Anderson wrote:Zarcan wrote: But I never got the 95mil.
Zarcan wrote:Hey guys.
Considering that that ship was my largest asset, I'm pretty infuriated. I don't know if this was some bug, scam, or what. Would CCP listen to a petition?
What do I do from here? Zarcan wrote: Well then, My 4 year old character shouldn't exist, eh?
I'm not gonna accept that, sorry. CCP is gonna have to get back to me on this one.
I'm not trying to rag on you or anything but.... How did something worth 95 million ISK to you, end up being your largest asset after four years?
I've only been active for maybe a year and a half out of those four years. 13.7mil sp. College and work make it tough to manage a game like this sometimes. |

Zarcan
Liberate New Eden
23
|
Posted - 2012.02.01 07:02:00 -
[27] - Quote
Ehn Roh wrote:Zarcan wrote:I'm just really surprised that you all feel that way.
. No you're not, or else you wouldn't have spent all your time bumbling around hi-sec. People are piling on your for ranting that you expect that ripping people off would somehow be ban-able because it's a ridiculous statement from a "vet". Exploiting is obviously not cool and lag sucks. Not a fan of intentionally obtuse interfaces either. But scamming is a valid use of one's gameplay time, as is murdering, extorting, stealing, terrorizing, anchoring giant -secure-can dong statues, and just plain blowing crap up. Not everyone wants to do it, but when people do something constructive it is all the more impressive that they managed to get it done despite all that other nonsense going on.
I think we've seen pretty decent evidence that this is an exploit that needs to be fixed.
Riley Moore wrote:Check your wallet transactions. (from AGLAIA Thaleia, which is my trade alt). Everyone eventually gets burned on something. UI is ****. Live and learn. Live long and prosper
Wow. Thank you sir. o7 |
|
|