EVE Search - War... What Is It Good For?

All Channels

EVE General Discussion

War... What Is It Good For?

» Click here to find additional results for this topic using Google

Monitor this thread via RSS [?]

Pages: [1] 2 :: one page
Author	Thread Statistics \| Show CCP posts - 0 post(s)
JazWan Qoi	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:34:00 - [1] Edited by: JazWan Qoi on 17/05/2004 16:15:12 * FIRST OF ALL * too many people are reading just the title of this thread and not getting the real purpose. I WANT WAR!!! but... there needs to be standards! I don't know about you people, but I feel this war nonsense has got way out of hand. To the point where CCP has to look at it as being an expolit. War should not be about killing people, just so you can get free shots at players in Empire space. I get the feeling to many pks are tired of the low sec troubles and have now exploited war as an alternative. How can a 2 man corp star a war with a giant mega corp? This is stupid. All they want to accomplish is promote fear and perhaps wipe out a few indy ships. I now hear some corps hire these smaller corps to do their dirty business. I'm not talking about taking away war, and it's very hard to monitor and pull out the "legit" wars, but I feel there needs to be standards to start war. Why should any average Joe be able to declare war on anyone? Perhaps there should be a CEO skill? Or maybe a ratio of members to members that needs to be a certain percentage for war. Its stupid when about 99.9% of wars started in Eve have never been surrendered or ended. There should also be a peaceful end to war when the two sides never bother to attack eachother in a month. And... here's the best part... there should be ways to capture players and hold them as prisoners of war. Imagine that... not being able to play Eve until your corp ends the war and frees you. I'm sure there are some problems with that one, but nothing that cant be worked out. I'd love to hear all your thoughts on this.
Miso	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:43:00 - [2] My first thought on this, and this is not a flame, is that your an idiot. My second thought merely confirmed the first. -------------------------------------------- Dead
JazWan Qoi	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:47:00 - [3] Thanks for the "non-flame", but you obviously don't understand my thread, so please move on... perhaps to another game. I think Donkey Kong would suit your intelligence.
Rodge	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:47:00 - [4] Originally by: JazWan Qoi And... here's the best part... there should be ways to capture players and hold them as prisoners of war. Imagine that... not being able to play Eve until your corp ends the war and frees you. I'm sure there are some problems with that one, but nothing that cant be worked out. That idea is not going to work in any form. Why would anyone keep paying to play a game where they're locked in a jail and can't do anything? Alt wars are lame, certainly, but as long as it's in the game mechanics and the devs don't say it's an exploit, then it will go on happening. My solution to avoid alt-war abuse is to ban all alts. But that's not going to happen either anytime soon. [ 2005.04.17 00:34:30 ] Nagilam > u better leave Rodge, u will not gank any1 else 2nite......
Miso	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:49:00 - [5] Originally by: JazWan Qoi Thanks for the "non-flame", but you obviously don't understand my thread, so please move on... perhaps to another game. I think Donkey Kong would suit your intelligence. I think you need to move on. What you said was idiotic. Eve is a game with PvP. That means wars. If you don't like it, play something else. -------------------------------------------- Dead
Jarjar	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:50:00 - [6] Originally by: JazWan Qoi Thanks for the "non-flame", but you obviously don't understand my thread, so please move on... perhaps to another game. I think Donkey Kong would suit your intelligence. No offence, but I think that comments suits you better. Please move on to another game where you need to pay to NOT play. Also I see no problems with wars atm.
JazWan Qoi	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:50:00 - [7] Originally by: Rodge Originally by: JazWan Qoi And... here's the best part... there should be ways to capture players and hold them as prisoners of war. Imagine that... not being able to play Eve until your corp ends the war and frees you. I'm sure there are some problems with that one, but nothing that cant be worked out. That idea is not going to work in any form. Why would anyone keep paying to play a game where they're locked in a jail and can't do anything? Alt wars are lame, certainly, but as long as it's in the game mechanics and the devs don't say it's an exploit, then it will go on happening. My solution to avoid alt-war abuse is to ban all alts. But that's not going to happen either anytime soon. I understand the POW has some kinks in it, but I'm sure they can be wroked out... pehaps a time limit of a week? Anyway, they are just ideas to control what I feel is pure non-sense.
JazWan Qoi	Posted - 2004.05.17 15:51:00 - [8] Originally by: Miso Originally by: JazWan Qoi Thanks for the "non-flame", but you obviously don't understand my thread, so please move on... perhaps to another game. I think Donkey Kong would suit your intelligence. I think you need to move on. What you said was idiotic. Eve is a game with PvP. That means wars. If you don't like it, play something else. Are you in like 3rd grade... I want war, but there are wars out there that are complete idiotic. There needs to be standards Oh, btw... you dont need a war to PvP... that shows how much you really know. LOL
DeathBunny	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:00:00 - [9] Edited by: DeathBunny on 17/05/2004 16:02:10 EVE is war. War is EVE. You need the 2 to operate. Yes alt wars are lame but it happens. People hire others to kill of people that might of **ed them off. That happens. Yes half the wars you see are there and have been for ages and might never change (yes some very old wars still exist). Every war has an escuse, could be bored, saw you and aah yes theres someone to shoot easy kill for me in my free time. If they bug you enough move when you don't see them. Simple as that, not just next door talkin about half way across empire. Watch map learn map and check for systems not highly traveld during your playing time. BTW taking prisoners is well stupid. If the corp doesn't give a crap about you, you'd be stuck there for quiet a while unless you quit the corp to get away from the war. You can't do anything is a waste of money which CCP doesn't want people leaving because they are stuck in some prison cell. Agree with Miso on this your an idiot. Learn the ways or die like many have. Fear The Bunny**
Bohr	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:04:00 - [10] Edited by: Bohr on 17/05/2004 16:08:18 Originally by: Miso Eve is a game with PvP. That means wars. If you don't like it, play something else. PvP = Player vs. player. Now.. that is a whole lot more than just WAR!!!!(insert smiley banging his head against a wall). He actually has a good point about the way of exploiting war declarations. Try to comment on that instead of the neverending; "war is good", "war is fine", "EvE is nothing but war!!" Heavy trolling btw
Nafri	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:07:00 - [11] Originally by: JazWan Qoi Originally by: Miso Originally by: JazWan Qoi Thanks for the "non-flame", but you obviously don't understand my thread, so please move on... perhaps to another game. I think Donkey Kong would suit your intelligence. I think you need to move on. What you said was idiotic. Eve is a game with PvP. That means wars. If you don't like it, play something else. Are you in like 3rd grade... I want war, but there are wars out there that are complete idiotic. There needs to be standards Oh, btw... you dont need a war to PvP... that shows how much you really know. LOL ouch that hurts Wanna fly with me?
JazWan Qoi	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:08:00 - [12] Originally by: DeathBunny Edited by: DeathBunny on 17/05/2004 16:02:10 EVE is war. War is EVE. You need the 2 to operate. Yes alt wars are lame but it happens. People hire others to kill of people that might of ****ed them off. That happens. Yes half the wars you see are there and have been for ages and might never change (yes some very old wars still exist). Every war has an escuse, could be bored, saw you and aah yes theres someone to shoot easy kill for me in my free time. If they bug you enough move when you don't see them. Simple as that, not just next door talkin about half way across empire. Watch map learn map and check for systems not highly traveld during your playing time. BTW taking prisoners is well stupid. If the corp doesn't give a crap about you, you'd be stuck there for quiet a while unless you quit the corp to get away from the war. You can't do anything is a waste of money which CCP doesn't want people leaving because they are stuck in some prison cell. Agree with Miso on this your an idiot. Learn the ways or die like many have. LOL... Can't anyone have any ideas anymore... Thanks for actually spending time to give me a detailed and imformative answer, but ending it with such haste shows you're just as retarted as the rest. I spend time and work had to get new skills, new items, new ships... if it takes you time to aquire a battleship, why not have it take time to acuire a declaration of war skill? Its not that hard to understand... and it'll stop these alt wars, and make the game better. Besides... players have been known to quit when lamers start alt wars... so yes, this is a problem.
Falbala	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:18:00 - [13] JazWan, wars are declared for: -territory or economics reasons (for example if you come sell stuff in the same station than another corp but 1k cheaper so their order vanishes until you sell your stuff), -roleplay reasons (for example PIE against the Minmattars) -Pvp Reasons (friendly corps often declare war just for Pvp fun) -assassination (they want the corpse of one of your corps mate, this is why a small corp attacks a big corp) -others reasons (yes griefing is one) Without wars you would see ore thiefs corps, scammer corps, market griefing corps and a lot of other things you don't even want to know. You would see corps come kill people randomly in 0.0 then go back safely in empire space to mine. Also people don't declare war on small corps. Maybe there are some exceptions but why would someone spend time hunting MrNobody and his 3 members corp? I created my corp after 2 days of game and never had any war declared on me after 5 monthes lol. If you are concerned about this for your corp then you should join an alliance.
Gib Goblin	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:24:00 - [14] Quote: There should also be a peaceful end to war when the two sides never bother to attack eachother in a month. I believe this idea in its simplest form has merit. Simple creating a timer when a war is declared. Reset the count to zero each time one or other corp makes an attack. The timer could be set for say 4 weeks. So that after a month a war become resolved through zero conflict. Gib -- Vice Admiral - Military Command -- -- --- --- ---- ----- ------ I don't 'do' dead. ------ ----- ---- --- --- --
Silverlancer	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:25:00 - [15] In a perfect world, war would be able to be declared for any reason other than griefing. In EVE of course, thats completely impossible. The corp could always claim that "they were paid" or some other excuse. What I think is that there should be a way for a corp to get out of a war that is declared on them. It should be costly, maybe as costly as an actual war. Maybe if not a single ship is killed on a particular side in 2 weeks the war ends. So that would mean that the corp warred upon would have to cease ALL OPERATIONS to avoid being killed. And once the war ends due to this, no war could be declared for a month.
Maud Dib	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:30:00 - [16] Edited by: Maud Dib on 17/05/2004 16:42:19 There are a lot of reasons why people aren't responding to your post. 1. This topic has already been beaten to death several times. 2. You look like an alt and posting with an alt is ghey. 3. Most people suspect you have just been WTFPWNED in a corp war and thats why your here. 4. You say war isn't about killing people but thats exactly what it's about. 5. The idea to capture people is perhaps the worst idea ever posted here and that's saying a lot. 6. There are a good many people in EVE who are worried that slowly many of the ex-EnBer's will complain enough to get PvP mostly destroyed. They may be wrong and you may not be an ex-EnBer but it certainly smells that way. Hope this helps.
Cartiff	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:32:00 - [17] Originally by: Miso My first thought on this, and this is not a flame, is that your an idiot. My second thought merely confirmed the first. LMAO that made me laugh so loud Cartiff, CEO Euphoria Released NBSI 4TW
Lord Frost	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:33:00 - [18] I can see a point here somewhere. A skill to declare war is a good idea. People aquire everything else in EVE, why not aquire a skill to enable a CEO to declare war? Thats a very simple solution in my opinion.
Falbala	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:34:00 - [19] Originally by: Lord Frost I can see a point here somewhere. A skill to declare war is a good idea. People aquire everything else in EVE, why not aquire a skill to enable a CEO to declare war? Thats a very simple solution in my opinion. Sorry, but a solution to what problem?
Lord Frost	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:38:00 - [20] Sorry, but a solution to what problem? You... the above... are an idiot.
Shevaun Ashnirelim	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:38:00 - [21] The problem with trying to "justify" wars, is that 95% of people who have war declared against them will claim that it is because of griefing and try to get it stopped on that reason. This is why CCP will never, ever, in a million years give in to your deranged requests that every war have some sort of reason behind it other than "fun" or "killing you". War will never be declared an exploit. Lie back, relax. Think of England.
Falbala	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:41:00 - [22] Originally by: Lord Frost Sorry, but a solution to what problem? You... the above... are an idiot. Alright I am an idiot. Now would you be kind and explain to me what the problem is that you want to solve?
Bohr	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:45:00 - [23] Originally by: Shevaun Ashnirelim The problem with trying to "justify" wars, is that 95% of people who have war declared against them will claim that it is because of griefing and try to get it stopped on that reason. This is why CCP will never, ever, in a million years give in to your deranged requests that every war have some sort of reason behind it other than "fun" or "killing you". War will never be declared an exploit. Lie back, relax. Think of England. As well as 95% of the combat chars will be for it And yes, war in EvE, given that there is an amount of roleplay in it, can have a reason. And why d i have to think about England?
Istvaan Shogaatsu	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:50:00 - [24] Probably for the best that you don't know the origin of that quote. As for roleplay - I'm probably one of the bigger roleplayers/fiction nerds in the Eve community and I don't feel that wars need RP-justification either. If I want to fight for the pure thrill of hearing people scream obscenities at me as their ship comes apart around them, that is perfectly reasonable justification. Remember - you are no-one to dictate what is "right" and what is "wrong" when it comes to war declarations - if you object, declare a war of your own and take the fight to your enemy.
Miso	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:56:00 - [25] Originally by: Maud Dib Edited by: Maud Dib on 17/05/2004 16:42:19 There are a lot of reasons why people aren't responding to your post. 1. This topic has already been beaten to death several times. 2. You look like an alt and posting with an alt is ghey. 3. Most people suspect you have just been WTFPWNED in a corp war and thats why your here. 4. You say war isn't about killing people but thats exactly what it's about. 5. The idea to capture people is perhaps the worst idea ever posted here and that's saying a lot. 6. There are a good many people in EVE who are worried that slowly many of the ex-EnBer's will complain enough to get PvP mostly destroyed. They may be wrong and you may not be an ex-EnBer but it certainly smells that way. Hope this helps. Exactly. :) -------------------------------------------- Dead
Bohr	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:57:00 - [26] Originally by: Istvaan Shogaatsu Probably for the best that you don't know the origin of that quote. As for roleplay - I'm probably one of the bigger roleplayers/fiction nerds in the Eve community and I don't feel that wars need RP-justification either. If I want to fight for the pure thrill of hearing people scream obscenities at me as their ship comes apart around them, that is perfectly reasonable justification. Remember - you are no-one to dictate what is "right" and what is "wrong" when it comes to war declarations - if you object, declare a war of your own and take the fight to your enemy. As well as you now are dictating that war is about the only way in EvE People have different ideas of what they want from this game. Don't see why they can't have their part of space (i.e highsec).
Lord Frost	Posted - 2004.05.17 16:57:00 - [27] Originally by: Falbala Originally by: Lord Frost Sorry, but a solution to what problem? You... the above... are an idiot. Alright I am an idiot. Now would you be kind and explain to me what the problem is that you want to solve? There is no problem, I was just pointing out that it makes sense to train a skill to declare war if your CEO has to train for such other things like ethnic relations. Why give a noob the power to declare war? War is the most powerful experience in EVE.
Falbala	Posted - 2004.05.17 17:04:00 - [28] Originally by: Lord Frost Originally by: Falbala Originally by: Lord Frost Sorry, but a solution to what problem? You... the above... are an idiot. Alright I am an idiot. Now would you be kind and explain to me what the problem is that you want to solve? There is no problem, I was just pointing out that it makes sense to train a skill to declare war if your CEO has to train for such other things like ethnic relations. Why give a noob the power to declare war? War is the most powerful experience in EVE. Exactly. There is no problem. You are trying to solve inexistant problems and I am the idiot. And since when newbies can grief experienced players? Do you think megacorps are in danger because a newbie could come tomorrow and declare war on them?
Istvaan Shogaatsu	Posted - 2004.05.17 17:06:00 - [29] Because, Bohr - if you make a part of Eve that wars cannot extend to, you essentially give a home to all people who want to gain resources exponentially without the fear of being attacked. All reward, zero risk. Such an area would rapidly become home to every carebear in Eve, allowing them to wage economic war on those outside without fear of repercussion. Remember that war is not only a way for griefers to cruelly murder innocent doe-eyed carebears - it is also an element in that economic warfare. What happens when one economically oriented corporation hires a band of cutthroat pirates to harass and attack their competition? I know from first-hand experience that this happens. If some corporations are allowed a safe haven, then they are effectively immune from that aspect of the game which helps serve as a check and balance against runaway expansion.
Miso	Posted - 2004.05.17 17:08:00 - [30] Edited by: Miso on 17/05/2004 17:51:43 I think CCP should introduce ammunition that has suckers on the end, so that the round sticks to the targets ship, but doesn't injure anyone... Or maybe a tachyon laser which when you fire it unfurls a banner in space with BANG! on it? -------------------------------------------- Dead

Pages: [1] 2 :: one page
First page \| Previous page \| Next page \| Last page

COPYRIGHT NOTICE
EVE Online, the EVE logo, EVE and all associated logos and designs are the intellectual property of CCP hf. All artwork, screenshots, characters, vehicles, storylines, world facts or other recognizable features of the intellectual property relating to these trademarks are likewise the intellectual property of CCP hf. EVE Online and the EVE logo are the registered trademarks of CCP hf. All rights are reserved worldwide. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. CCP hf. has granted permission to EVE-Search.com to use EVE Online and all associated logos and designs for promotional and information purposes on its website but does not endorse, and is not in any way affiliated with, EVE-Search.com. CCP is in no way responsible for the content on or functioning of this website, nor can it be liable for any damage arising from the use of this website.