| Pages: [1] 2 :: one page |
| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 12:30:00 -
[1]
OK i was wondering.
We have dreads which are rock We have carriers which are scissors We have sub-caps which are paper
Dreads beat carriers. Carriers beat subcaps. But there is slight problem: Subcaps dont work too well vs dread gangs. So am i missing some obvious counter to dreads or is it only "bring the bigger rock than they have"?
Was also discussing a bit about cap ship counters. Just some random ideas: 1. removing EWar from dreads = forces cap gangs to have support to actually remove enemy ewar 2. bringing something like massive stealth bomber which works only against cap ships. Even lets say around 100 000 damage per salvo but "bomb" can be targetted mid flight and destroyed (hello destroyer ship class? its been useless for ages now so it might become useful at least).
Anyways - what im saying bring some more player skill into cap fights because atm its who brings more wins (or who is lagged less in non-RF system).
|

Gnomes Rock
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 12:34:00 -
[2]
Edited by: Gnomes Rock on 21/12/2008 12:34:36 You bring a dread fleet vs a battleship fleet. The dreads will die, it'll just take a while.
Edit; aslong as the battleship gang has a few hictors |

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 12:44:00 -
[3]
Originally by: Gnomes Rock Edited by: Gnomes Rock on 21/12/2008 12:34:36 You bring a dread fleet vs a battleship fleet. The dreads will die, it'll just take a while.
Edit; aslong as the battleship gang has a few hictors
You are soooo dead wrong :) If enemy brings 80-100 dreads and you bring 100ish battleships there is no chance in hell you will win. Remember dread (not sieged) deals around 500dps (more than sniper battleship) unless its a moros (then its 1000+) while mantaining much better buffer tank.
But yeh - its not like we didnt kill dreads with BS gangs. Did you?
|

MotherMoon
Huang Yinglong
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 13:09:00 -
[4]
Originally by: Deva Blackfire
Originally by: Gnomes Rock Edited by: Gnomes Rock on 21/12/2008 12:34:36 You bring a dread fleet vs a battleship fleet. The dreads will die, it'll just take a while.
Edit; aslong as the battleship gang has a few hictors
You are soooo dead wrong :) If enemy brings 80-100 dreads and you bring 100ish battleships there is no chance in hell you will win. Remember dread (not sieged) deals around 500dps (more than sniper battleship) unless its a moros (then its 1000+) while mantaining much better buffer tank.
But yeh - its not like we didnt kill dreads with BS gangs. Did you?
your forgetting price.
if those 100 battleships kill 50 dreads but all 100 battleships are lost. Then the team with the battleships won.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 13:12:00 -
[5]
Originally by: MotherMoon
if those 100 battleships kill 50 dreads but all 100 battleships are lost. Then the team with the battleships won.
Except they will not kill 50 dreads. Unless you have actual proof that this happened in the past?
|

Jason Edwards
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 13:52:00 -
[6]
We have dreads which are rock & paper We have carriers which are scissors We have sub-caps which are cheese
Get enough carriers RRing each other with say 10 fighters each. Dreads wont stand a chance.
These guy's first vid showed it.
Keep your distance so they need long range weapons; which cuts off like 2000dps per dread.
While subcaps are cheese... ready to be served up in nice tiny cut up pieces along side some whine. ------------------------ To make a megathron from scratch, you must first invent the eve universe. ------------------------ Life sucks and then you get podded. |

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 14:08:00 -
[7]
i always thought 50 dreads IF they enter siege can break 10 carriers quite... fast. But yeah checking movie, when it DLs that is
|

Nhaz
Corp 1 Allstars PuPPet MasTers
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 14:28:00 -
[8]
10 Moros will beat off 10 carriers so long as are smart about it.
a Moros with heavy's and sentries easily kick the crap out of all the fighters from the carriers or if they are in a hurry just concentrate on a single carrier with the sentries and watch it die fast.
The carriers need to neut the crap out of one of the Moros asap in order to keep up.
This is a battle of a who can pull their drones in fastest before one dies. since, the heavys from a moros will pretty much two volley a fighter. _____________________________________________
It's NOT paranoia, If they REALLY ARE out to get you! |

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 14:38:00 -
[9]
Originally by: Nhaz 10 Moros will beat off 10 carriers so long as are smart about it.
a Moros with heavy's and sentries easily kick the crap out of all the fighters from the carriers or if they are in a hurry just concentrate on a single carrier with the sentries and watch it die fast.
The carriers need to neut the crap out of one of the Moros asap in order to keep up.
This is a battle of a who can pull their drones in fastest before one dies. since, the heavys from a moros will pretty much two volley a fighter.
I was more looking at just straight firing at carrier. 10 carrier RR will not keep up with 10 dread damage.
carrier RR's 300dps/1 module so if everyone is set properly - thats 600dps negated. Including resists its around 1200-1500. Dreads deal around 3500dps so thats 2000 leaking. Times 10 dreads = 20 000 hp vanishing per second. Thus under minute per carrier. Carriers wont neut one dread dry in one minute.
|

Von Kretschmer
Minmatar No Trademark
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 15:11:00 -
[10]
Originally by: Deva Blackfire But there is slight problem: Subcaps dont work too well vs dread gangs.
Dreads without support will get torn apart by a BS gang. We just had a fight like this yesterday as a matter of fact. Though the BS gang was much larger, the results would have been the same even with less numbers.
Credit goes to Cry Havoc of course
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 15:37:00 -
[11]
Im talking about so called "engame" problem not some random fights where you can bring 4x more BS than they have dreads. Im talking about the situation when you can bring both BS and dread and always bring dread to the table. Yeh - 200+ man dread gangs which can be ONLY killed by another dread gang.
|

Arkady Sadik
Gradient Electus Matari
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 15:54:00 -
[12]
I do think this is a mis-application of the rock/paper/scissors "ideal" - the advantage of smaller ships was never intended to be able to "defeat" the bigger ships. They are more mobile, which gives them certain advantages, but not the "we can blow them out of space because we're smaller." Hence the nano changes.
If you can bring more and bigger ships, you should have a distinct advantage. As pointed out, BS groups are not completely helpless against dread groups. Which is as it should be, IMHO.
This will hopefully get even better when the sov mechanics are changed - removing the focal "POS fights" from the equation should increase the mobility disadvantage of dreads even more, which is, I think, the best approach to "fix" this problem.
|

Polinus
Caldari State War Academy
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 16:50:00 -
[13]
BS will EASILY defeat dreads. Dreads do not fire at 200 km. Simple as that. Dreads will die slowly and painfully. Sure no way 100 BS will kill 100 dreads before server DT. But 100 BS can kill a dread before the dreads even start o fire at the BSs. 100 Apocs take 43 seconds to kill a revelation.
The larger the gangs, the more chance BS will cripple completely a dread fleet before being forced to disengage.
BSs do could receive some boost, but is not like you said , as if BS had no chance against dreads. CCP overdone on the CP hp boost, that is all. If caps had received 200% HP not 400%, then this "issue" would not exist.
|

Dave PSI
Haendlergilde
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 00:50:00 -
[14]
A dread fleet without backup is vulnerable to a BS fleet, as long as the fleet is big enough to break the dreads tank. When the Dreads sieged their tracking is so bad that they won't hit a transversal moving bs anymore (and when they don't siege their tracking still sucks and they make less damage than a bs). Shure they are still hard to destroy, but i think that is fair, if you compare the price of a BS with a dread. And your proposing with the "massive stealth bomber", bombing capital fleets away sound very unbalanced to me. If caps are too easy to destroy we are back in the time, when everybody had to shot towers with bs instead of dreads, because the could be so easily ganked by a normal bs fleet. If not everybody could remember that time, it was before the massive armor boost for Carriers / Dreads, when nearly nobody fielded them.
T R U S T shop: http://www.evetrust.com // Haendlergilde [HAE]
|

PeachesAndCream
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 03:47:00 -
[15]
Deva, you must be smoking something. A sniper battleship does on average 400-500 DPS, more if its Amarr. A revelation has the best long range DPS, and its roughly 100 per gun outside of siege or ~300 dps. And unlike dreads vs POS, citadel torp speed would make those dreads worthless in a fleet fight.
Second, what is the point of sniping dreads? That would be helping the dreads track, and they still track horribly outside of siege. Only a Moros's drones (or sentries) would have any conceivable threat, and two equally matched fleets are usually going to be 25-30% Moroses.
Dread fleet vs BS fleet. Dread fleet gets murdered. There's also the part where one dread is worth a dozen BS, and more likely to be packing faction/deadspace/slaves.
|

Presidio
Minmatar ZipZoom Kaboom
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 04:40:00 -
[16]
Originally by: Polinus BS will EASILY defeat dreads. Dreads do not fire at 200 km. Simple as that. Dreads will die slowly and painfully. Sure no way 100 BS will kill 100 dreads before server DT. But 100 BS can kill a dread before the dreads even start o fire at the BSs. 100 Apocs take 43 seconds to kill a revelation.
The larger the gangs, the more chance BS will cripple completely a dread fleet before being forced to disengage.
BSs do could receive some boost, but is not like you said , as if BS had no chance against dreads. CCP overdone on the CP hp boost, that is all. If caps had received 200% HP not 400%, then this "issue" would not exist.
A 2 billion isk ship should have a decent HP pool imho.
Also dreads primary role is POS bashing anyways. -
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 06:28:00 -
[17]
Originally by: PeachesAndCream Deva, you must be smoking something. A sniper battleship does on average 400-500 DPS, more if its Amarr. A revelation has the best long range DPS, and its roughly 100 per gun outside of siege or ~300 dps. And unlike dreads vs POS, citadel torp speed would make those dreads worthless in a fleet fight.
Second, what is the point of sniping dreads? That would be helping the dreads track, and they still track horribly outside of siege. Only a Moros's drones (or sentries) would have any conceivable threat, and two equally matched fleets are usually going to be 25-30% Moroses.
Dread fleet vs BS fleet. Dread fleet gets murdered. There's also the part where one dread is worth a dozen BS, and more likely to be packing faction/deadspace/slaves.
Im just saying that you can number crunch all you want. And when one side deploys 150ish dreads there is not much you can do even if you can muster 200ish people. Been there, done that. Did you?
|

Carniflex
Caldari StarHunt Fallout Project
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 08:31:00 -
[18]
Originally by: Deva Blackfire OK i was wondering.
We have dreads which are rock We have carriers which are scissors We have sub-caps which are paper
Dreads beat carriers. Carriers beat subcaps. But there is slight problem: Subcaps dont work too well vs dread gangs. So am i missing some obvious counter to dreads or is it only "bring the bigger rock than they have"?
Was also discussing a bit about cap ship counters. Just some random ideas: 1. removing EWar from dreads = forces cap gangs to have support to actually remove enemy ewar 2. bringing something like massive stealth bomber which works only against cap ships. Even lets say around 100 000 damage per salvo but "bomb" can be targetted mid flight and destroyed (hello destroyer ship class? its been useless for ages now so it might become useful at least).
Anyways - what im saying bring some more player skill into cap fights because atm its who brings more wins (or who is lagged less in non-RF system).
Yes. You are missing NOS/Neuts. Sieged dreads wont hit crap and unsieged ones can't fight their way out of wet paper bag.
|

geno effort
GoonFleet GoonSwarm
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 10:25:00 -
[19]
Edited by: geno effort on 22/12/2008 10:27:04 All this problem arose from, and started with capital hitpoint buff a little over a year ago, plus rigs. It used to be far more viable to kill capitals with subcapitals, when for 10 times the cost they didn't have 40-50 times more EHP than battleships. Even the capital-heavy veteran alliances spoke against that change back in the day, IIRC.
|

Kagura Nikon
Minmatar Infinity Enterprises
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 13:03:00 -
[20]
Originally by: Deva Blackfire Edited by: Deva Blackfire on 22/12/2008 06:37:08
Originally by: PeachesAndCream Deva, you must be smoking something. A sniper battleship does on average 400-500 DPS, more if its Amarr. A revelation has the best long range DPS, and its roughly 100 per gun outside of siege or ~300 dps. And unlike dreads vs POS, citadel torp speed would make those dreads worthless in a fleet fight.
Second, what is the point of sniping dreads? That would be helping the dreads track, and they still track horribly outside of siege. Only a Moros's drones (or sentries) would have any conceivable threat, and two equally matched fleets are usually going to be 25-30% Moroses.
Dread fleet vs BS fleet. Dread fleet gets murdered. There's also the part where one dread is worth a dozen BS, and more likely to be packing faction/deadspace/slaves.
Im just saying that you can number crunch all you want. And when one side deploys 150ish dreads there is not much you can do even if you can muster 200ish people. Been there, done that. Did you?
EDIT: search for battles around X-70 to VFK area. CBA to check exact systems atm. IIRC it should be in ROIR and CCP-.
I was there, and the reason you can't do anything is because they can obliterate the target POS before you can even prepare your sniper fleet.
But without any support 150 dreads will take HORRENDOUS casualities against 150 battleships if the BS are ready and waiting for them.
150 sniper Battleships can easily kill 10 dreads before they leave siege. But dreads are never deployed without at least a moderate sub capital support.
Also the main reason why 150 BS loose is because if you have 150 dreads on field you also have 2 + titans ready to jump in and obliterate those 150 snipers. ------------------------------------------------- If brute force doesn't solve your problem... you are not using enough
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 13:52:00 -
[21]
Originally by: geno effort Edited by: geno effort on 22/12/2008 10:27:04 All this problem arose from, and started with capital hitpoint buff a little over a year ago, plus rigs. It used to be far more viable to kill capitals with subcapitals, when for 10 times the cost they didn't have 40-50 times more EHP than battleships. Even the capital-heavy veteran alliances spoke against that change back in the day, IIRC.
Cant not agree here. But removing their HP would have much more consequences = being more prone to multi-DD (which WILL come off sooner or later versus caps).
Quote:
Yes. You are missing NOS/Neuts. Sieged dreads wont hit crap and unsieged ones can't fight their way out of wet paper bag.
Nos/neuts are useless vs whole dread fleets. They might be good vs 1-5 dreads (while you have like 20 BS total) but as soon as numbers reach "critical mass" its just better to add more DPS instead of playing cap warfare.
Quote:
Also the main reason why 150 BS loose is because if you have 150 dreads on field you also have 2 + titans ready to jump in and obliterate those 150 snipers.
And here we go back to the beggining. Sub caps are useless vs caps because there are specific caps that can kill any sub-cap they can find in one go. Thus rock-paper-scissors circle (actually its way larger but w/ever) is again screwed up.
So lemme guess when CCP is gonna acknowledge "caps-online" issue: as soon as only subcaps needed will be cyno ships. Amrite?
|

MotherMoon
Huang Yinglong
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 14:30:00 -
[22]
Originally by: Presidio
Originally by: Polinus BS will EASILY defeat dreads. Dreads do not fire at 200 km. Simple as that. Dreads will die slowly and painfully. Sure no way 100 BS will kill 100 dreads before server DT. But 100 BS can kill a dread before the dreads even start o fire at the BSs. 100 Apocs take 43 seconds to kill a revelation.
The larger the gangs, the more chance BS will cripple completely a dread fleet before being forced to disengage.
BSs do could receive some boost, but is not like you said , as if BS had no chance against dreads. CCP overdone on the CP hp boost, that is all. If caps had received 200% HP not 400%, then this "issue" would not exist.
A 2 billion isk ship should have a decent HP pool imho.
Also dreads primary role is POS bashing anyways.
it does have a desnt HP pool, if it was one battleship it would be a 2 second life.
|

MotherMoon
Huang Yinglong
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 14:34:00 -
[23]
Originally by: Deva Blackfire
Originally by: geno effort Edited by: geno effort on 22/12/2008 10:27:04 All this problem arose from, and started with capital hitpoint buff a little over a year ago, plus rigs. It used to be far more viable to kill capitals with subcapitals, when for 10 times the cost they didn't have 40-50 times more EHP than battleships. Even the capital-heavy veteran alliances spoke against that change back in the day, IIRC.
Cant not agree here. But removing their HP would have much more consequences = being more prone to multi-DD (which WILL come off sooner or later versus caps).
Quote:
Yes. You are missing NOS/Neuts. Sieged dreads wont hit crap and unsieged ones can't fight their way out of wet paper bag.
Nos/neuts are useless vs whole dread fleets. They might be good vs 1-5 dreads (while you have like 20 BS total) but as soon as numbers reach "critical mass" its just better to add more DPS instead of playing cap warfare.
Quote:
Also the main reason why 150 BS loose is because if you have 150 dreads on field you also have 2 + titans ready to jump in and obliterate those 150 snipers.
And here we go back to the beggining. Sub caps are useless vs caps because there are specific caps that can kill any sub-cap they can find in one go. Thus rock-paper-scissors circle (actually its way larger but w/ever) is again screwed up.
So lemme guess when CCP is gonna acknowledge "caps-online" issue: as soon as only subcaps needed will be cyno ships. Amrite?
I wish capital ships instead had WAY more hp in the sturture, but we had sub system targeting. I don't know but something like... if capital ships were only good in some situations...
I know the fighter change would of made this game non-captial ships online but too many people whined about that. For good reason...
I think a complete rethink in cap ships is needed.
also the moros is silly overpowered, they should give it the right to use 5 fighter and no drones or something so it would still be overpowered but not AS overpowered as fighert can be shot down and it should only be able to hold 5 of them TOPs.
or...
god that doesn't work ether what do other rts games do with gaint ships?
|

BiggestT
Caldari Resurrection Skunk-Works
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 16:03:00 -
[24]
Edited by: BiggestT on 22/12/2008 16:02:53 A battleship gang couldnt even kill one dread if it vs'd a dread gang.
The moros pilots wld just focus fire with drones, and all other dreads wld put weapons on said bs to get every scrap of dps in to break rr chain and pick them off one by one.
If dread even gets anywhere near trouble, it can simply siege and laugh as it tanks a mofo amount of damage. EVE history
t2 precisions |

PeachesAndCream
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 18:04:00 -
[25]
Originally by: Deva Blackfire Im just saying that you can number crunch all you want. And when one side deploys 150ish dreads there is not much you can do even if you can muster 200ish people. Been there, done that. Did you?
I've probably been in more dread battles than you. In a 1 to 1 comparison of the two ships, a battleship does more damage and has less HP. The major difference is in tracking and lock times. In siege, the dreads are screwed, especially at close range. Out of siege they are susceptible to EWAR, and still have terrible tracking.
Your scenario is ridiculous because it's never been that perfect. A BS fleet needs dictors to keep the dreads from jumping out, and dreads usually have some support. The times when they don't, they have a doomsday or two backing them. Or carriers in their gang. Then there's the part where a BS fleet wouldn't lose in a perfect scenario because dreads can't tackle them, and so on..
Given 150 dreads vs 200 bs where neither side could run away, I'd choose to be on the BS side because it would win hands down.
|

CrestoftheStars
Recreation Of The World
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 19:07:00 -
[26]
okey so been reading this and too my understanding the main defence in the "bs fleet can take dreads" is that bs's will engage at 200km+. well you don't engage at that range, or at least you will not get the dreads to stay awaiting for you too kill em.
a hictor you say (well each moros have a 500+ dps, with med drones, on one of those, just 10 of em would destroy the poor hictor in a matter of secunds), there is no realistic situation where there will be NO kind of support.
matter of fact is that dreads (especially the moros which have a higher drone dps then most gank battleships dps) are way too powerfull and don't have a real counter (thus being too powerfull) ___________________________________________ Whoever appeals to the law against his fellow man is either a fool or a coward. Whoever cannot take care of himself without that law is both. For a wounded |

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 19:22:00 -
[27]
Originally by: PeachesAndCream
Originally by: Deva Blackfire Im just saying that you can number crunch all you want. And when one side deploys 150ish dreads there is not much you can do even if you can muster 200ish people. Been there, done that. Did you?
I've probably been in more dread battles than you. In a 1 to 1 comparison of the two ships, a battleship does more damage and has less HP. The major difference is in tracking and lock times. In siege, the dreads are screwed, especially at close range. Out of siege they are susceptible to EWAR, and still have terrible tracking.
Your scenario is ridiculous because it's never been that perfect. A BS fleet needs dictors to keep the dreads from jumping out, and dreads usually have some support. The times when they don't, they have a doomsday or two backing them. Or carriers in their gang. Then there's the part where a BS fleet wouldn't lose in a perfect scenario because dreads can't tackle them, and so on..
Given 150 dreads vs 200 bs where neither side could run away, I'd choose to be on the BS side because it would win hands down.
Ofc im counting support. Thought it was obvious...
|

Straight Chillen
Gallente Solar Wind
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 20:39:00 -
[28]
Edited by: Straight Chillen on 22/12/2008 20:46:06 Ever see a dread try to hit a bs orbiting at close range with an AB? Its next to impossible for a dread to get a solid hit. While it is highly unlike that 100bs would kill 100 dreads, id say that 50bs could kill 10 dreads quite easily if they know what they are doing. When your talking 100 dreads, the sheer amount of drones they can field would put a serious hurting on the BS.
But then again, Dont all battles in eve basically end up as who brings more?
Also linky dreads & carriers being killed by BS fleet Battle report is a little messed up as the Space Weaponry and Trade Loses got mixed into the wrong side, As they were allied with Huzzah, NOTR, & The OSS. So essentially 70 BS with support killed 3 dreads and 2 carriers. The fight lasted probably less then 20 minutes.
Please resize image to a maximum of 400 x 120, not exceeding 24000 bytes. If you would like further details please mail [email protected] ~Saint |

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 20:55:00 -
[29]
Originally by: Straight Chillen Edited by: Straight Chillen on 22/12/2008 20:46:06 But then again, Dont all battles in eve basically end up as who brings more?
When we look at sub-caps? No. You can win even having 3:1 or 4:1 odds doing strafe runs, keeping distance, having logistics working properly etc. On cap ship level its almost impossible to win while having 1,5:1 odds. Problems arise when one side can use caps other cant (cyno jammed systems anyone?) - suddenly there is not much you can do except logging off for the night.
As for ganking dreads while having 5:1 or more numbers - uhm its overkill. Tho it still depends on numbers. If you have 20 rr BS vs 10 dreads - its doable (and not that hard). If you have 60 vs 30 dreads its starting to get tricky (depends on amount of moroses). 60 dreads? ugh this hurts (+ lag generated and stuff which reduces rr BS effectiveness). At some point BS's just pop so fast you cant rep em.
(yes it is counting support, ewar, maybe odd dozen of carriers on dreads side).
|

Goumindong
Amarr Merch Industrial GoonSwarm
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 21:38:00 -
[30]
Edited by: Goumindong on 22/12/2008 21:38:05
Originally by: PeachesAndCream A sniper battleship does on average 400-500 DPS, more if its Amarr.
No. It doesn't. Most sniping BS do between 250 and 350 DPS depending on skills and range. Sniping BS that do more are typically inefficient fits. The best DPS you're going to be doing with an reasonably efficient BS is going to be around 391 in an Abaddon at 154+25 at max skills.
|
| |
|
| Pages: [1] 2 :: one page |
| First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |