|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 63 post(s) |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1225
|
Posted - 2012.09.18 13:33:00 -
[1] - Quote
First in an awesome thread!
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1225
|
Posted - 2012.09.18 13:58:00 -
[2] - Quote
Boogie Jones wrote:The powergrid nerf on the cane is a bit much imo. It should be able to fit a full rack of 425s + the neuts. 
Why?
Quote:wow 20% reduction in heavy missile damage is a bit too excessive IMHO. Considering the range is also nerf'd a fair bit.
Looks about equal to other LR medium guns, with the exception that it can actually hit things that are inside long point range.
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1225
|
Posted - 2012.09.18 15:11:00 -
[3] - Quote
Schmell wrote:Uhm...cough...did you check on armor cane fittings when you were working out that PG nerf? Because armor cane will be hit really hard by this, there wasn't so much free pg left even with 220mm guns
Aside this, pretty cool changes
1600mm + 220 IIs + Medium Neut IIs + MWD II without a single fitting mod is tight for you?
1600mm + 425 IIs + HML IIs + meta MWD also too tight?
Do you need to have free PG left even with all slots filled?
These minmatards 
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1228
|
Posted - 2012.09.18 17:34:00 -
[4] - Quote
ITT people who don't realize that HMLs are still the best medium sized long range weapons.
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1229
|
Posted - 2012.09.18 18:04:00 -
[5] - Quote
Ensign X wrote:Roime wrote:ITT people who don't realize that HMLs are still the best medium sized long range weapons.
With the plethora of evidence you've submitted to support this claim, I don't know how we could ever have doubted this. Thank you, Roime, for helping us all see the clear light of day. 
Open EFT or pyfa, test it out for yourself.
HMLs currently not only have almost 30% higher base damage, they also hit at 100% damage every time against BCs and larger, moving or not.
Also, chance to hit. Did you know that in addition to transversal, sig, falloff and vulnerability to TDs, turrets are rolled against a random number on every hit? Turrets can miss, how cool is that!
Now missiles have equal range and damage, but they still hit every single time.
So ITT "boohoo, my medium-sized LR weapon system is not completely and utterly insanely OP anymore"
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1230
|
Posted - 2012.09.18 18:24:00 -
[6] - Quote
Alara IonStorm wrote:Hans Jagerblitzen wrote: Yes, exactly. Many thanks for providing this. As you can see in the graph, heavy missiles pretty much dominate this range class of weapons, with the only weapons system providing any advantage at all being railguns on a Ferox - and at a huge DPS hit to achieve this.
If you run the same graph after the changes Fozzie is proposing, you will see that there are now actual advantages to using other weapons besides HML at these ranges.
Which other Medium Range Weapons Systems do you think will replace them. I will give you a hint, it starts with none and ends with none. Not gonna see anymore LOL Medium Beams or LOL Medium Rails, maybe a few 720mm Whelp Boats but only if they have the vaunted double DPS Bonus. So how does nerfing the good weapons system so none of them are good help EVE Hans. Why can we not see buffs to medium weapons and bonuses so Ferox's, Harbingers and Canes are seen as much as Drakes and keep the Drake as a viable fleet option instead of this Death to Drakes out of spite thing and every other Cruiser that uses Heavy Missiles along with it.
This is the only valid concern in this thread so far.
So what's the problem of other medium weapons, tracking, low dps or both?
(aka why HMs we're OP )
Or could it be that they only sucked in comparison to HMLs?
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1233
|
Posted - 2012.09.19 06:05:00 -
[7] - Quote
So how to make medium LR weapons viable?
- nerf AC falloff slightly - nerf TE falloff effect less slightly - nerf Scorch range slightly - buff warp disruptor range to 28km
?
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1233
|
Posted - 2012.09.19 06:12:00 -
[8] - Quote
Errand Girl wrote:Speaking as a relatively new pilot who doesn't have 50 million+ SP and had the misfortune to choose Caldari... What am I supposed to fly now? HMLs already have fairly weak DPS and a 20% damage nerf means that my ship options for both PVE and PVP are totally gimped.
Drakes have too much tank, fine. HMLs have too much range, fine. But the damage nerf means all Caldari cruiser and battlecruiser hulls now pretty much suck. I realize that drake blobs are an issue in null sec, but seriously.... find a way to nerf drake blobs without totally hosing carebears and small gang PVPers.
As a young player, I have very little cross training. I'm all Caldari ship skills and all missiles. Now I'm looking at what? 6+ months of training before I can be good at flying another race's ships and using another races weapons? Maybe that's not a long time to a lot of vets around here (who are much more likely to be well cross-trained already), but to a 1 year player that's a very long time. I'll wait until the final changes are announced, but I would very seriously consider quitting EVE rather than throwing away the millions of SP I have in soon-to-be-worthless crap, plus basically starting over on my ship/gun progression.
Two of the three Caldari battlecruisers use hybrid weapons. Are they useless now?
And just to repeat what has been said numerous time, and has been long known to all but dreaktards- HMLs have high dps compared to other medium LR weapons, better range and damage application, which is why they get rebalanced to be in line with the others.
Drakes and Tengus are ubiquitously good in PVE, other three races have been very lacking in comparison. Still players of the other races have been doing PVE all this time.
Take it chill, you will be just fine.
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1235
|
Posted - 2012.09.19 07:46:00 -
[9] - Quote
Errand Girl wrote: Considering that every other post in this thread mentions that medium hybrids stink... The other Caldari battlecruisers were already worthless. How many Ferroxes and Nagas do you see flying around?
While at extreme ranges HMLs have better DPS than guns, it's weaker at lower ranges, no? Especially when high damage ammo is used, an option that isn't available with missiles. Damage application is not necessarily better with missiles either, it's far from a straight comparison. Missiles do very low damage against fast and/or small sig targets while guns do full damage. Those targets are harder for guns to track, obviously, but when they do hit it's for full damage. With guns there are ways to at least try to lower transversal, but that's impossible to do with missiles.
Again, I don't really care about the range nerf so much, but a 20% damage nerf basically kills HMLs as far as I can see. If you have a real suggestion, I'd be happy to hear it and think it over but I don't think "fly a ferrox" counts as a real suggestion.
Medium LR turrets have problems hitting small, moving targets (all small ships move, or deserve to die) and especially so at shorter ranges. And when they hit, they don't hit for full damage. Turrets have a stat called signature resolution, which makes larger size guns worse at hitting smaller targets. Lowering transversal to a level where you get good hits is not that easy in a BC against a frig. Furthermore TEs or TC are pretty much mandatory on LR turret ships in order to hit anything at all. Now you can fit them on missile ships to the same effect, to improve your damage against small ships... which you hit every time for at least some damage.
Yes, I do see Feroxes and Nagas. Blaster Ferox looks like a fine ship to me (have even considered cross-training for it, it's a bit better at being a Brutix than Brutix, esp so now with ASBs), and Naga is a solid sniper.
Idk, I feel like medium rails have just sucked in comparison to HMLs. HMLs have been PVE easy mode, this change might have a big impact on markets, as it reduces farming and botting efficiency. Drake and Tengu are by far the most common ships in game, this winter will see a more equal spread of ships both in PVE and PVP. Which is pretty cool!
As what comes to the people complaining about the Cane fitting nerf, check this out:
Drake 850 + 525 = 1375 Myrm 1175 + 400 = 1574 Cane 1350 + 400 = 1750 Harbi 1500 + 375 = 1875
Cane had the second highest fitting capacity, but uses weapons that are the second easiest to fit, and is viable both in shield and armor tank setups. 175 more pg than the armor-tanking Myrm. You could only fit highest tier weapons with full T2 everything on the Cane, and even add T2 medium neuts.
Future:
Drake 850 + 525 = 1375 Cane 1125 + 400 = 1525 Myrm 1175 + 400 = 1574 Harbi 1500 + 375 = 1875
Looks balanced to me. On a nano-Cane, all you need to do is drop to meta 4 neuts. On armor cane, drop to meta neuts and add one ACR rig. It's still damn easy to fit IMHO.
I fly Gallente, and 90% of my fits are impossible without a shitload of fitting hardwires, and usually I still need fitting mods.
Fitting resources and requirements make fitting ships and art of balancing between gank, tank and utility. Cane was an exception to this, you could always get the very best modules for everything. No dropping to meta, no fitting mods or rigs.
Consider it fixed! Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1237
|
Posted - 2012.09.19 09:00:00 -
[10] - Quote
Signal11th wrote:
Probably even less but their only seems to be 3 or 4 of the usual people supporting this and everyone else hating it.
What happens when the "new thing" that replaces the Drake and Tengu becomes too popular... It's the same old crappy circles that CCP do instead of concentrating on things people have actually asked for.
Haters don't seem to be capable of presenting any sensible arguments.
Anyway, Drakes and Tengus are the single anomaly, their overwhelming popularity dwarfing anything else in the game. Why do you think rabalancing this would lead to a similar ridiculous spike, when the other ships are more or less balanced?
Embrace the change, winter will be awesome with a huge number of revamped ships, which will lead into a much more varied field of gang compositions and tactics.
<3
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |
|

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1239
|
Posted - 2012.09.19 10:20:00 -
[11] - Quote
baltec1 wrote:Signal11th wrote:
Yes and in that is the problem it isn't affecting one ship it's affecting lots.
Indeed it is. Many ships are now going to be viable.
This is the other side of the coin that Draektards refuse to acknowledge.
Nerfing HML efficiency to be on par with other LR med weapons will shift the meta of PVE, making other races just as good choices for many players across New Eden. No longer "train Drake, then Tengu" as the only correct answer for budding bears, now you can choose other ships and not be shadowed by overpowered ships.
Obviously it will reduce the total output of farming and botting as well, making our economy healthier.
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace Dead On Arrival Alliance
1239
|
Posted - 2012.09.19 10:44:00 -
[12] - Quote
Salmon Ella wrote: Then what is the point of different races different modules different ships, everything will be the same in your Utopia so it won't matter what we turn up in. I see that the people who don't agree with this now have a name or a label. First rule of dehumanisation.
Only their relative efficiency is balanced, that doesn't make them "the same".
Gallente - the choice of the interstellar gentleman |

Roime
Shiva Furnace
1384
|
Posted - 2012.11.03 11:56:00 -
[13] - Quote
So, after all this bloobloo Tengu and Drake got buffed
awesome
Shiva Furnace - recruiting again! |
|
|
|