| Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 :: one page |
| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 4 post(s) |

Suddenly Forums ForumKings
Republic University Minmatar Republic
397
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 19:57:00 -
[1] - Quote
Yes they do. The AFK will stop reading here and flame me, but you won't
Although AFK mining will always generate an accounting profit (your ISK quantity goes up), AFK mining is one of the worst activities imaginable for making money.
This seems counter intuitive to some people - if you're making money, you're winning right? WRONG.
You see, there is this really cool thing called "implicit cost" also known as opportunity cost. When you do something you give up the chance to do something else. Normally, this is par for the course and totally ok. But AFK ice mining is special.
AFK ice mining is like collecting cans on the street to cash in at an aluminum recycling plant for some nickels. The entry barrier is nonexistent, any moron can do it. This, combined with perfect information (current ice prices are known to all and the locations of ice belts are readily available) means that ice prices are as low as they can possibly be in the market.
But we all know that miners mine themselves into poverty, they've done it since the start of EVE. They complain that they don't make enough money and ask for more yield, which causes them to make either the same or often less than they did before. They then proceed to ask for more yield again
AFK takes stupid up to 11. AFK miners are collectively mining themselves into mediocrity because "I can make teh isk while watching Kaylee on Firefly" mentality .
They may be making accounting profits but the facts are they make zero or worse economic profits. Quite literally, you'd be better of doing any other activity than AFK mining.
But since AFK miners only understand a wallet blink, they will think they're gaming the system by making money afk. But in reality they're selling themselves as short as you possibly could.
So, AFKers, you fail economics forever. |

Unit CA108AF
Unit Commune Celestial Imperative
2
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:03:00 -
[2] - Quote
Another quality thread brought by SFKFK.
In b4 the lock. |

Darth Gustav
Interwebs Cooter Explosion Fatal Ascension
1702
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:05:00 -
[3] - Quote
Unit CA108AF wrote:Another quality thread brought by SFKFK.
In b4 the lock. This is a legitimate treatment of how AFK mining devalues the whole profession of mining. He who trolls trolls best when he who is trolled trolls the troller. -Darth Gustav's Axiom |

Kale Eledar
Wolves and Knights The Irukandji
58
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:06:00 -
[4] - Quote
Oh god why am I taking the bait
Eh....well...yeah. I see your point, but I don't think it's about pure profit. It's profit for effort expended.
Granted, trading with good skills takes micromanagement but is generally easy and is actually legit, but someone not even playing Eve is certainly doing less work for isk.
The real stupidity is that they are missing out on all the cool stuff in the game. First come smiles, then lies. Last is gunfire. |

Dave stark
Black Nova Corp. R O G U E
643
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:06:00 -
[5] - Quote
Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:So, AFKers, you fail economics forever.
ah i love you GCSE business students.
once your teacher has covered motivation theory, come back here and realise how amusing and incorrect you are. Reading my posts is like panning for gold; most it will be useless, but occasionally you'll find a nugget of gold. |

Suddenly Forums ForumKings
Republic University Minmatar Republic
399
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:07:00 -
[6] - Quote
Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:So, AFKers, you fail economics forever. ah i love you GCSE business students. once your teacher has covered motivation theory, come back here and realise how amusing and incorrect you are.
So for AFK ice mining do you prefer the mackinaw or skiff types? |

Darth Gustav
Interwebs Cooter Explosion Fatal Ascension
1702
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:09:00 -
[7] - Quote
Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:So, AFKers, you fail economics forever. ah i love you GCSE business students. once your teacher has covered motivation theory, come back here and realise how amusing and incorrect you are. Your knowledge of economics is impressive to a human being, I'll grant you that.
AFK mining lasers and bots don't care how impressive your mention of motivation theory is, though.
AFK mining lasers and bots aren't motivated by anything. He who trolls trolls best when he who is trolled trolls the troller. -Darth Gustav's Axiom |

Dave stark
Black Nova Corp. R O G U E
643
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:11:00 -
[8] - Quote
Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:So, AFKers, you fail economics forever. ah i love you GCSE business students. once your teacher has covered motivation theory, come back here and realise how amusing and incorrect you are. So for AFK ice mining do you prefer the mackinaw or skiff types?
depends, ship and fittings largely depend on the length of the episode of each tv show. i like to time it so that my cargo is full at roughly the same time as the episode ends, or slightly longer if i need to grab snacks, or stuff like that. Reading my posts is like panning for gold; most it will be useless, but occasionally you'll find a nugget of gold. |

Suddenly Forums ForumKings
Republic University Minmatar Republic
399
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:12:00 -
[9] - Quote
Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:So, AFKers, you fail economics forever. ah i love you GCSE business students. once your teacher has covered motivation theory, come back here and realise how amusing and incorrect you are. So for AFK ice mining do you prefer the mackinaw or skiff types? depends, ship and fittings largely depend on the length of the episode of each tv show. i like to time it so that my cargo is full at roughly the same time as the episode ends, or slightly longer if i need to grab snacks, or stuff like that.
This is the exact kind of person who I am going after in my post
Do you watch Firefly too? |

Dave stark
Black Nova Corp. R O G U E
643
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:13:00 -
[10] - Quote
Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:So, AFKers, you fail economics forever. ah i love you GCSE business students. once your teacher has covered motivation theory, come back here and realise how amusing and incorrect you are. So for AFK ice mining do you prefer the mackinaw or skiff types? depends, ship and fittings largely depend on the length of the episode of each tv show. i like to time it so that my cargo is full at roughly the same time as the episode ends, or slightly longer if i need to grab snacks, or stuff like that. This is the exact kind of person who I am going after in my post  Do you watch Firefly too?
nope, and it's pretty far down on my list of "things i might watch one day".
i understand exactly what you're saying in your post, however you make the flaw of thinking i give a **** about how much isk/hour i'm earning. Reading my posts is like panning for gold; most it will be useless, but occasionally you'll find a nugget of gold. |

Anslo
BHEI Galactic Construction The Unforgiven Alliance
572
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:15:00 -
[11] - Quote
Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:So, AFKers, you fail economics forever. ah i love you GCSE business students. once your teacher has covered motivation theory, come back here and realise how amusing and incorrect you are. So for AFK ice mining do you prefer the mackinaw or skiff types? depends, ship and fittings largely depend on the length of the episode of each tv show. i like to time it so that my cargo is full at roughly the same time as the episode ends, or slightly longer if i need to grab snacks, or stuff like that.
I lol'd, hard.
|

Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
1995
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:15:00 -
[12] - Quote
Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Yes they do. The AFK will stop reading here and flame me, but you won't  Although AFK mining will always generate an accounting profit (your ISK quantity goes up), AFK mining is one of the worst activities imaginable for making money.
It's the worst but it's better than making zero ISK and it comes with the equivalent effort of staying logged off.
So to talk along your line, the opportunity cost of making little ISK with zero effort is more favorable than making zero ISK with zero effort. Auditing | Collateral holding and insurance | Consulting | PLEX for Good Charity
Twitter channel |

Suddenly Forums ForumKings
Republic University Minmatar Republic
399
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:17:00 -
[13] - Quote
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Yes they do. The AFK will stop reading here and flame me, but you won't  Although AFK mining will always generate an accounting profit (your ISK quantity goes up), AFK mining is one of the worst activities imaginable for making money. It's the worst but it's better than making zero ISK and it comes with the equivalent effort of staying logged off. So to talk along your line, the opportunity cost of making little ISK with zero effort is more favorable than making zero ISK with zero effort.
Oh god it begins!
Here's a thought: you do pay for electricity right? you could have invested an hour of effort to make far more than you made leaving your system on all day AFK mining and then saved on power.
Of course you're making money, I acknowledged that. |

Darth Gustav
Interwebs Cooter Explosion Fatal Ascension
1702
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:18:00 -
[14] - Quote
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Yes they do. The AFK will stop reading here and flame me, but you won't  Although AFK mining will always generate an accounting profit (your ISK quantity goes up), AFK mining is one of the worst activities imaginable for making money. It's the worst but it's better than making zero ISK and it comes with the equivalent effort of staying logged off. So to talk along your line, the opportunity cost of making little ISK with zero effort is more favorable than making zero ISK with zero effort. Not on a macroeconomical scale, it isn't.
Devaluing professions through non-stop zero-effort resource uptake is not good for Eve.
He who trolls trolls best when he who is trolled trolls the troller. -Darth Gustav's Axiom |

Malphilos
State War Academy Caldari State
210
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:22:00 -
[15] - Quote
Darth Gustav wrote:Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Yes they do. The AFK will stop reading here and flame me, but you won't  Although AFK mining will always generate an accounting profit (your ISK quantity goes up), AFK mining is one of the worst activities imaginable for making money. It's the worst but it's better than making zero ISK and it comes with the equivalent effort of staying logged off. So to talk along your line, the opportunity cost of making little ISK with zero effort is more favorable than making zero ISK with zero effort. Not on a macroeconomical scale, it isn't. Devaluing professions through non-stop zero-effort resource uptake is not good for Eve.
For the unenlightened, please explain how it's worse than mining with someone at the keyboard.
|

Torvin Yulus
State War Academy Caldari State
115
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:24:00 -
[16] - Quote
YOU SUDDENLY FORUMS FORUM KINGS ARE NOTHING BUT A CONFIRME D GOON ALT GRIEFER. I CANS EE THROUGH YOU AND I KNOW WHAT YOU DO. YOU POST PRO GOON ANTI CAREBEAR PROPAGANDA AND IM GETTING ******* SICK OF IT. JESUS ******* CHRIST.
but i am not mad. im ok. because in the decade to come my people will be vidnicated
i pay my money and i am entitled to play the game the way i want to play it, not the way some goon griefer tell me to. i like afk mining i think its fun and it gives me the chance to do housework and homework and watch tv. and i made money.
i bet your one of the aspie neckbear fcs who yell at people for not fitting the damage control II instead of a damage control I. because that totally would have saved them im a pubby and im proud |

Dave stark
Black Nova Corp. R O G U E
643
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:25:00 -
[17] - Quote
Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Here's a thought: you do pay for electricity right? you could have invested an hour of effort to make far more than you made leaving your system on all day AFK mining and then saved on power.
incorrect assumption #2; the computer is only on in order to play eve.
in fact, if i did it your way it'd cost me more money on my bills because i'd have spent an hour playing eve and i wouldn't have got anything else done so i'd then have to spend more time with the computer on to get things finished... Reading my posts is like panning for gold; most it will be useless, but occasionally you'll find a nugget of gold. |

Darth Gustav
Interwebs Cooter Explosion Fatal Ascension
1703
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:25:00 -
[18] - Quote
Malphilos wrote:Darth Gustav wrote:Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Yes they do. The AFK will stop reading here and flame me, but you won't  Although AFK mining will always generate an accounting profit (your ISK quantity goes up), AFK mining is one of the worst activities imaginable for making money. It's the worst but it's better than making zero ISK and it comes with the equivalent effort of staying logged off. So to talk along your line, the opportunity cost of making little ISK with zero effort is more favorable than making zero ISK with zero effort. Not on a macroeconomical scale, it isn't. Devaluing professions through non-stop zero-effort resource uptake is not good for Eve. For the unenlightened, please explain how it's worse than mining with someone at the keyboard. That'd be fine..
People at keyboards have limits. Limits are actually good for economies. They reinforce minimum values, rather than allowing them to sag indefinitely.
When everyone can gather resources with zero effort those resources' value suffers. As a result, the value of the profession as a whole suffers, too.
Only when resources are finite in availability will there be no difference between a miner ATK and a bot/AFK miner.
Thanks for the great question. He who trolls trolls best when he who is trolled trolls the troller. -Darth Gustav's Axiom |

Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
1995
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:28:00 -
[19] - Quote
Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Here's a thought: you do pay for electricity right? you could have invested an hour of effort to make far more than you made leaving your system on all day AFK mining and then saved on power.
Of course you're making money, I acknowledged that.
I am not that much of a miner (I trade) but in any case, trading while mining justifies the electricity.
Watching a video while mining => the computer uses like 5 more watts out of 700 it's using anyway so.... who cares for those 5W?
Darth Gustav wrote: Devaluing professions through non-stop zero-effort resource uptake is not good for Eve.
Hey, in most other games mining is not this hideous farce we got in EvE. Make it less craptastic of a mechanic and you'll magically see people willing to actually play it. Auditing | Collateral holding and insurance | Consulting | PLEX for Good Charity
Twitter channel |

Kara Vix
Sanford and Son Salvage Peregrine Nation
87
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:28:00 -
[20] - Quote
These threads just keep going on and on and on. Get a life already. |

Telegram Sam
Shoot 2 Thrill
454
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:30:00 -
[21] - Quote
Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Here's a thought: you do pay for electricity right? you could have invested an hour of effort to make far more than you made leaving your system on all day AFK mining and then saved on power. incorrect assumption #2; the computer is only on in order to play eve. in fact, if i did it your way it'd cost me more money on my bills because i'd have spent an hour playing eve and i wouldn't have got anything else done so i'd then have to spend more time with the computer on to get things finished... Ha ha! Made me laugh in my cubicle, I might get fired now. |

Darth Gustav
Interwebs Cooter Explosion Fatal Ascension
1703
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:31:00 -
[22] - Quote
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Here's a thought: you do pay for electricity right? you could have invested an hour of effort to make far more than you made leaving your system on all day AFK mining and then saved on power.
Of course you're making money, I acknowledged that. I am not that much of a miner (I trade) but in any case, trading while mining justifies the electricity. Watching a video while mining => the computer uses like 5 more watts out of 700 it's using anyway so.... who cares for those 5W? Darth Gustav wrote: Devaluing professions through non-stop zero-effort resource uptake is not good for Eve.
Hey, in most other games mining is not this hideous farce we got in EvE. Make it less craptastic of a mechanic and you'll magically see people willing to actually play it. You mean as opposed to now, where tons of people are playing it "AFK" or by "macro"?
You really think all those subs won't change status if mining gets an "interestingness" buff? You really think they'll be excited?
Sometimes, Vaerah, I don't see what the points of your posts are. He who trolls trolls best when he who is trolled trolls the troller. -Darth Gustav's Axiom |

Malphilos
State War Academy Caldari State
210
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:31:00 -
[23] - Quote
Darth Gustav wrote:Malphilos wrote:
For the unenlightened, please explain how it's worse than mining with someone at the keyboard.
That'd be fine.. People at keyboards have limits. Limits are actually good for economies. They reinforce minimum values, rather than allowing them to sag indefinitely. When everyone can gather resources with zero effort those resources' value sufferes. As a result, the value of the profession as a whole suffers, too. Only when resources are finite in availability will there be no difference between a miner ATK and a bot/AFK miner. Thanks for the great question.
You're welcome! I have more:
When they're sitting at their keyboard, does it matter where their eyes are pointing? What if they're at the keyboard but asleep? How do wireless keyboards fit into this scheme? What's the impact of running EVE and Firefly on the same display? While sleeping? In what units are you measuring effort (as in "zero effort")?
|

Anslo
BHEI Galactic Construction The Unforgiven Alliance
573
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:33:00 -
[24] - Quote
Well, this escalated quickly.
|

Xercodo
24th Imperial Crusade Amarr Empire
1436
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:33:00 -
[25] - Quote
I think that miners simply need more yield to make prices go down. A tier 3 BS should not be over 250 mill dammit! They're supposed to be 150 D: and tier 2 should be 100 and tier 1 be 50 and BCs should be in the teens and high 20s D:
The mining profession isn't very much of a popular one and thus a relatively small % of the population does it. If this % stays roughly the same as the game grows then there will always been a obligation for the small mining population to keep up with the non-mining populaton's needs.
Give them more yield per person and you get lowered mineral prices and eventually everything levels out and the miners end up making exactly the same ISK they made with last season's best mining ship but the economy as a whole will benefit from lowered prices.
Hopefully, since the cost of living, so to speak, would go down then PLEX might too. The Drake is a Lie |

Dave stark
Black Nova Corp. R O G U E
647
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:34:00 -
[26] - Quote
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:Make it less craptastic of a mechanic and you'll magically see people willing to actually play it. but if they do that, and you have to pay attention to your screen to mine, it won't be viable to mine with 20 accounts, and ccp will lose subs.
so we all know that mining is never going to be less afkable. not to mention if less accounts are mining, less ore is being mined, supply is lower, prices go up, tears start flooding the forums... it's just unpleasant for every one. Reading my posts is like panning for gold; most it will be useless, but occasionally you'll find a nugget of gold. |

Darth Gustav
Interwebs Cooter Explosion Fatal Ascension
1703
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:35:00 -
[27] - Quote
Malphilos wrote:Darth Gustav wrote:Malphilos wrote:
For the unenlightened, please explain how it's worse than mining with someone at the keyboard.
That'd be fine.. People at keyboards have limits. Limits are actually good for economies. They reinforce minimum values, rather than allowing them to sag indefinitely. When everyone can gather resources with zero effort those resources' value sufferes. As a result, the value of the profession as a whole suffers, too. Only when resources are finite in availability will there be no difference between a miner ATK and a bot/AFK miner. Thanks for the great question. You're welcome! I have more: When they're sitting at their keyboard, does it matter where their eyes are pointing? What if they're at the keyboard but asleep? How do wireless keyboards fit into this scheme? What's the impact of running EVE and Firefly on the same display? While sleeping? In what units are you measuring effort (as in "zero effort")? Only the last question deserves any answer.
Effort is described in terms of work, or force divided by distance, to achieve it.
In this case I'm going to use Joules (J) for the unit. Nevertheless, a zero value here is equal to a zero value for any other unit of work I'm familiar with.
I hope that helps. He who trolls trolls best when he who is trolled trolls the troller. -Darth Gustav's Axiom |
|

CCP Eterne
C C P C C P Alliance
529

|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:39:00 -
[28] - Quote
Deleted some trolling posts. Community Representative GÇ+ EVE Illuminati GÇ+ Fiction Adept
@CCP_Eterne GÇ+ @EVE_LiveEvents |
|

Malphilos
State War Academy Caldari State
210
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:40:00 -
[29] - Quote
Darth Gustav wrote:Malphilos wrote:Darth Gustav wrote:Malphilos wrote:
For the unenlightened, please explain how it's worse than mining with someone at the keyboard.
That'd be fine.. People at keyboards have limits. Limits are actually good for economies. They reinforce minimum values, rather than allowing them to sag indefinitely. When everyone can gather resources with zero effort those resources' value sufferes. As a result, the value of the profession as a whole suffers, too. Only when resources are finite in availability will there be no difference between a miner ATK and a bot/AFK miner. Thanks for the great question. You're welcome! I have more: When they're sitting at their keyboard, does it matter where their eyes are pointing? What if they're at the keyboard but asleep? How do wireless keyboards fit into this scheme? What's the impact of running EVE and Firefly on the same display? While sleeping? In what units are you measuring effort (as in "zero effort")? Only the last question deserves any answer. Effort is described in terms of work, or force divided by distance, to achieve it. In this case I'm going to use Joules (J) for the unit. Nevertheless, a zero value here is equal to a zero value for any other unit of work I'm familiar with. I hope that helps.
Oh, I think they're all valid and reasonable questions. I think it's just that the answers lack the punch you're seeking.
I am also saddened that you've seen fit to so effectively rebut the entire premise of the "zero effort" claim before we're finished having fun with it. Now the OP will have to re-work the entire screed.  |

De'Veldrin
East India Ore Trade Intrepid Crossing
483
|
Posted - 2012.11.16 20:42:00 -
[30] - Quote
Dave stark wrote:Suddenly Forums ForumKings wrote:Here's a thought: you do pay for electricity right? you could have invested an hour of effort to make far more than you made leaving your system on all day AFK mining and then saved on power. incorrect assumption #2; the computer is only on in order to play eve.
Incorrect assumption 2a: I turn my computer off. My computer is on when I sleep, when I'm at work, when I take my cats to the vet. The only time it's not on, is if the electricity goes off, or I go on vacation for more than a weekend.
The real problem with the opportunity cost argument is that you make the assumption that actively playing Eve to increase ISK/hour is more important to these people than whatever else they're doing at that time. It's obviously not, or they'd be actively playing EvE instead of AFKing.
Hell I know people that afk mine on one account while actively running null sec anoms on the other, thereby increasing their ISK/hour over doing each activity separately.So by actively mining, you're actually giving up the opportunity make more ISK than you could by AFK mining and doing something else more profitable. Unsub or don't.-á I don't care what your reasons are, and neither does anyone else.-á Just click the button and go away - or don't. |
| |
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 :: one page |
| First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |