Pages: [1] 2 3 4 :: one page |
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:06:00 -
[1] - Quote
Hi Is the Invention & T2 BPO situation ever likely to change? The problem being that where originally BPOs were given out, which can be researched and all that jazz, but now only invention works giving you some crappy ME copy. This means that if you don't own a T2 BPO, you will NEVER be able to produce at a price that is competetive to an alliance with a T2 BPO.
It doesnt even matter if it's ridiculously hard to produce a BPO, make it a 1 in 1,000,000 chance on invention or something, but either BPOs need to start working their way back into the game, or the existing T2 BPOs need to go, because without that you are basically saying there's no point in working towards industry since you'll never be able to beat the already exising industial corps. |

Smoking Blunts
Zebra Corp BricK sQuAD.
69
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:10:00 -
[2] - Quote
you can out produce any t2 bp through invention, which will net you way more profit in the long run. CCP-áare full of words and no action. We watch what they do and its nothing but false statements and lies.
|

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:15:00 -
[3] - Quote
How can you out produce t2 BPOs? A T2 BPO with 50 ME is going to be a hell of a lot cheaper than a -4 ME BPC, on top of the fact that it has already cost you to do the invention to produce the BPC in the first place. |

Smoking Blunts
Zebra Corp BricK sQuAD.
69
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:18:00 -
[4] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote:How can you out produce t2 BPOs? A T2 BPO with 50 ME is going to be a hell of a lot cheaper than a -4 ME BPC, on top of the fact that it has already cost you to do the invention to produce the BPC in the first place.
pretty easily.
a t2 bpo runs in 1 build slot. if you use teh other 10 slots, you can out produce the t2 bpo easily. each item maybe slighlty higher build cost, but your making way more of them, so over all you make more isk CCP-áare full of words and no action. We watch what they do and its nothing but false statements and lies.
|

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:22:00 -
[5] - Quote
I think youv'e missed the point. I'm not talking about build time, I'm talking about cost.
If it costs me 50 mil to produce something (including invention cost) but a T2 BPO can produce it at 45 mil, they can just sell the product at 49.5 mil, and make 4.5 mil profit per item, and I can't possibly undercut them, as I am totally unable to get my manufacture cost down low enough to make profit. And it's not though a fault of my own, I've produce the BPC the way the game intends, but because they got a BPO back in the day, and that was never removed, they automatically win the profit battle. |

Big Bad Mofo
Comply Or Die
25
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:22:00 -
[6] - Quote
t2 bpos should of been removed from the game when invention was errr invented...ofc the people owning them paid handsomely for it however... |

Smoking Blunts
Zebra Corp BricK sQuAD.
69
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:24:00 -
[7] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote:I think youv'e missed the point. I'm not talking about build time, I'm talking about cost.
If it costs me 50 mil to produce something (including invention cost) but a T2 BPO can produce it at 45 mil, they can just sell the product at 49.5 mil, and make 4.5 mil profit per item, and I can't possibly undercut them, as I am totally unable to get my manufacture cost down low enough to make profit. And it's not though a fault of my own, I've produce the BPC the way the game intends, but because they got a BPO back in the day, and that was never removed, they automatically win the profit battle.
i understand fully what you mean. t2 bpo produces say 1000 items / month netting you about 500 t2 bpc's produce say 750 per slot so x 10, netting you a bit less per item, but way more over all.
i make a lot of t2 items via invention, its profitible, very if you do it right CCP-áare full of words and no action. We watch what they do and its nothing but false statements and lies.
|

Arbiter Reborn
Saiph Industries SRS.
4
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:25:00 -
[8] - Quote
yeh allot of t2 ships are almost impossible to build at a profit allot are built at a loss. most t2 items are rediculously underpriced |

Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
407
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:26:00 -
[9] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote:How can you out produce t2 BPOs? Volume GÇö the thing that already makes invention outproduce BPOs by a large margin in any area where T2 manufacturing is profitable.
Lucas Kell wrote:Is the Invention & T2 BPO situation ever likely to change? Since there's no actual need for it to change, no. Not particularly likely. GÇöGÇöGÇö GÇ£If you're not willing to fight for what you have in GëívGëí you don't deserve it, and you will lose it.GÇ¥ GÇö Karath Piki-á |

Arbiter Reborn
Saiph Industries SRS.
4
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:28:00 -
[10] - Quote
Tippia wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:How can you out produce t2 BPOs? Volume GÇö the thing that already makes invention outproduce BPOs by a large margin in any area where T2 manufacturing is profitable. Lucas Kell wrote:Is the Invention & T2 BPO situation ever likely to change? Since there's no actual need for it to change, no. Not particularly likely.
the need is in the fact that things are too cheap, and therefore unproifitbale for those who wernt lucky in a lottery
your argument is invalid because so what if you can produce 50 sleipnirs a month if you loose 10 mill on every one |

Smoking Blunts
Zebra Corp BricK sQuAD.
69
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:28:00 -
[11] - Quote
Arbiter Reborn wrote:yeh allot of t2 ships are almost impossible to build at a profit allot are built at a loss. most t2 items are rediculously underpriced
i think generally too thing are way to cheap in eve atm, t2 bpos would be a massive boost to the market
could try inventing teh ships that were introduced after t2 bpo's stopped. you know the ones CCP-áare full of words and no action. We watch what they do and its nothing but false statements and lies.
|

Arbiter Reborn
Saiph Industries SRS.
4
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:29:00 -
[12] - Quote
Smoking Blunts wrote:Arbiter Reborn wrote:yeh allot of t2 ships are almost impossible to build at a profit allot are built at a loss. most t2 items are rediculously underpriced
i think generally too thing are way to cheap in eve atm, t2 bpos would be a massive boost to the market could try inventing teh ships that were introduced after t2 bpo's stopped. you know the ones
yeh sure, i mean i do. but then why should i have to do that
|

Smoking Blunts
Zebra Corp BricK sQuAD.
69
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:30:00 -
[13] - Quote
Arbiter Reborn wrote:Tippia wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:How can you out produce t2 BPOs? Volume GÇö the thing that already makes invention outproduce BPOs by a large margin in any area where T2 manufacturing is profitable. Lucas Kell wrote:Is the Invention & T2 BPO situation ever likely to change? Since there's no actual need for it to change, no. Not particularly likely. the need is in the fact that things are too cheap, and therefore unproifitbale for those who wernt lucky in a lottery
the market is over stocked atm, thats due imo to reduced players. look at the online numbers. its not the bpo's fault ccp have shafted the game in teh last year CCP-áare full of words and no action. We watch what they do and its nothing but false statements and lies.
|

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:32:00 -
[14] - Quote
Smoking Blunts wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:I think youv'e missed the point. I'm not talking about build time, I'm talking about cost.
If it costs me 50 mil to produce something (including invention cost) but a T2 BPO can produce it at 45 mil, they can just sell the product at 49.5 mil, and make 4.5 mil profit per item, and I can't possibly undercut them, as I am totally unable to get my manufacture cost down low enough to make profit. And it's not though a fault of my own, I've produce the BPC the way the game intends, but because they got a BPO back in the day, and that was never removed, they automatically win the profit battle. i understand fully what you mean. t2 bpo produces say 1000 items / month netting you about 500 t2 bpc's produce say 750 per slot so x 10, netting you a bit less per item, but way more over all. i make a lot of t2 items via invention, its profitible, very if you do it right Then clearly you are producing items that don't have people competign witha T2 BPO. Not only can they still produce copies so they can produce just as many, they dont pay invention costs, dont risk invention failure, and can sell at a price you simply can't match. It's nto that you would make little profit, its that you would make no profit at all. |

Linda Shadowborn
Dark Steel Industries
20
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:32:00 -
[15] - Quote
Didnt we have this discussion... oh yeah.... 40 pages of it |

Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
407
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:33:00 -
[16] - Quote
Arbiter Reborn wrote:the need is in the fact that things are too cheap, and therefore unproifitbale for those who wernt lucky in a lottery If things are too cheap, then it's because they are so over-produced that demand can't keep up, which means that BPOs are not to blame GÇö they are far too few to generate that amount of production.
Quote:your argument is invalid because so what if you can produce 50 sleipnirs a month if you loose 10 mill on every one That doesn't make my argument invalid GÇö it only means that you need to be more market rational. Removing BPOs would not solve that problem because they are not the cause of it. GÇöGÇöGÇö GÇ£If you're not willing to fight for what you have in GëívGëí you don't deserve it, and you will lose it.GÇ¥ GÇö Karath Piki-á |

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:36:00 -
[17] - Quote
Smoking Blunts wrote:Arbiter Reborn wrote:Tippia wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:How can you out produce t2 BPOs? Volume GÇö the thing that already makes invention outproduce BPOs by a large margin in any area where T2 manufacturing is profitable. Lucas Kell wrote:Is the Invention & T2 BPO situation ever likely to change? Since there's no actual need for it to change, no. Not particularly likely. the need is in the fact that things are too cheap, and therefore unproifitbale for those who wernt lucky in a lottery the market is over stocked atm, thats due imo to reduced players. look at the online numbers. its not the bpo's fault ccp have shafted the game in teh last year All I'm saying is, they should bring back BPOs so everyone has a fighting chance. The player base is never going to grow if everything good is owned by the long standing alliances and noone new has a chance to get the same thing.
I mean, from a newbie point of view, whats the point of going into T2 production, when you know theres a large portion of the market you won't be able to compete in? Sure you can produce the new stuff, but why should you have to be limited? It should be fair across the board for everyone. This is the problem you get when the rules get changed half way through. |

Smoking Blunts
Zebra Corp BricK sQuAD.
69
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:36:00 -
[18] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote:Smoking Blunts wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:I think youv'e missed the point. I'm not talking about build time, I'm talking about cost.
If it costs me 50 mil to produce something (including invention cost) but a T2 BPO can produce it at 45 mil, they can just sell the product at 49.5 mil, and make 4.5 mil profit per item, and I can't possibly undercut them, as I am totally unable to get my manufacture cost down low enough to make profit. And it's not though a fault of my own, I've produce the BPC the way the game intends, but because they got a BPO back in the day, and that was never removed, they automatically win the profit battle. i understand fully what you mean. t2 bpo produces say 1000 items / month netting you about 500 t2 bpc's produce say 750 per slot so x 10, netting you a bit less per item, but way more over all. i make a lot of t2 items via invention, its profitible, very if you do it right Then clearly you are producing items that don't have people competign witha T2 BPO. Not only can they still produce copies so they can produce just as many, they dont pay invention costs, dont risk invention failure, and can sell at a price you simply can't match. It's nto that you would make little profit, its that you would make no profit at all.
no the items i producing do have t2 bpo's. i just out produce them and rely on volume of items to make the isk. CCP-áare full of words and no action. We watch what they do and its nothing but false statements and lies.
|

Akrasjel Lanate
Naquatech Conglomerate
101
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:39:00 -
[19] - Quote
Big Bad Mofo wrote:t2 bpos should of been removed from the game when invention was errr invented...ofc the people owning them paid handsomely for it however...
|

Breaker77
Reclamation Industries
10
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:40:00 -
[20] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote: Then clearly you are producing items that don't have people competign witha T2 BPO. Not only can they still produce copies so they can produce just as many, they dont pay invention costs, dont risk invention failure, and can sell at a price you simply can't match. It's nto that you would make little profit, its that you would make no profit at all.
1. it takes longer to make a 1 run copy from a T2 BPO than it does to build 1 item from a T2 BPO
2. Items with a T2 BPO are more profitable to invent and build than items without a T2 BPO. If you want proof compare the profit per item of a cap recharger II compared to a salvager II. Even after datacores, failed invention attempts, and extra materials, there is still more profit on cap recharger IIs than salvager IIs.
The only real advantage a T2 BPO provides is that you can set a 30 day build job instead of having to restart jobs every few hours.
|

Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
407
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:40:00 -
[21] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote:All I'm saying is, they should bring back BPOs so everyone has a fighting chance. Everyone does have a fighting chance. Invention ensures just that. If you believe that a BPO will give you some kind of advantage (which, given the copy comment, will probably turn out to be false), then go ahead and buy one GÇö it's what most of the current BPO holders did, after allGǪ
Quote:It should be fair across the board for everyone. Fun fact: it is.
Quote:I mean, from a newbie point of view, whats the point of going into T2 production From a newbie point of view, why do you think that T2 manufacturing is for you? Maybe it's something you should get into once you know the ropes a bit betterGǪ
GǪonce you do, the point of going into T2 production is obvious: it earns you more money than plain old T1. GÇöGÇöGÇö GÇ£If you're not willing to fight for what you have in GëívGëí you don't deserve it, and you will lose it.GÇ¥ GÇö Karath Piki-á |

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:40:00 -
[22] - Quote
Smoking Blunts wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:Smoking Blunts wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:I think youv'e missed the point. I'm not talking about build time, I'm talking about cost.
If it costs me 50 mil to produce something (including invention cost) but a T2 BPO can produce it at 45 mil, they can just sell the product at 49.5 mil, and make 4.5 mil profit per item, and I can't possibly undercut them, as I am totally unable to get my manufacture cost down low enough to make profit. And it's not though a fault of my own, I've produce the BPC the way the game intends, but because they got a BPO back in the day, and that was never removed, they automatically win the profit battle. i understand fully what you mean. t2 bpo produces say 1000 items / month netting you about 500 t2 bpc's produce say 750 per slot so x 10, netting you a bit less per item, but way more over all. i make a lot of t2 items via invention, its profitible, very if you do it right Then clearly you are producing items that don't have people competign witha T2 BPO. Not only can they still produce copies so they can produce just as many, they dont pay invention costs, dont risk invention failure, and can sell at a price you simply can't match. It's nto that you would make little profit, its that you would make no profit at all. no the items i producing do have t2 bpo's. i just out produce them and rely on volume of items to make the isk. I didnt say there wasnt a BPO, I said clearly theres no BPO owner competing with you. If there was, he/she could undercut you to the point you can't make profit, and your production would become redundant.
I've done the math on a number of T2 items, and some of them, no matter how much you throw into invention, you could never even produce cheap enough to make profit over existing sell orders, you'd actually be losing alot of ISK. Sure you might be lucky enough to avoid that market, and for me, I currently do, so can make a decent amount, but that doesnt change the experience I gained previously from attempting profitable T2 production. |

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:44:00 -
[23] - Quote
Tippia wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:All I'm saying is, they should bring back BPOs so everyone has a fighting chance. Everyone does have a fighting chance. Invention ensures just that. If you believe that a BPO will give you some kind of advantage (which, given the copy comment, will probably turn out to be false), then go ahead and buy one GÇö it's what most of the current BPO holders did, after allGǪ Quote:It should be fair across the board for everyone. Fun fact: it is. Of course a T2 BPO gives you an advantage... Unless you're saying that -4ME is better than 50 ME. Sure people buy and sell them but thats beside the point really. The fact is that the owners of T2 BPOs can produce at a cost that invention couldnt dream of getting to. |

Breaker77
Reclamation Industries
10
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:44:00 -
[24] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote: I've done the math on a number of T2 items, and some of them, no matter how much you throw into invention, you could never even produce cheap enough to make profit over existing sell orders, you'd actually be losing alot of ISK. Sure you might be lucky enough to avoid that market, and for me, I currently do, so can make a decent amount, but that doesnt change the experience I gained previously from attempting profitable T2 production.
You are right, some items are just not profitable.
However When I was doing T2 invention and production I was doing around 300-500 invention jobs per day building around 2000 items per day. The amount of work was insane, but I was making billions per month.
You have to find the right items.
|

Smoking Blunts
Zebra Corp BricK sQuAD.
69
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:45:00 -
[25] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote:Smoking Blunts wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:Smoking Blunts wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:I think youv'e missed the point. I'm not talking about build time, I'm talking about cost.
If it costs me 50 mil to produce something (including invention cost) but a T2 BPO can produce it at 45 mil, they can just sell the product at 49.5 mil, and make 4.5 mil profit per item, and I can't possibly undercut them, as I am totally unable to get my manufacture cost down low enough to make profit. And it's not though a fault of my own, I've produce the BPC the way the game intends, but because they got a BPO back in the day, and that was never removed, they automatically win the profit battle. i understand fully what you mean. t2 bpo produces say 1000 items / month netting you about 500 t2 bpc's produce say 750 per slot so x 10, netting you a bit less per item, but way more over all. i make a lot of t2 items via invention, its profitible, very if you do it right Then clearly you are producing items that don't have people competign witha T2 BPO. Not only can they still produce copies so they can produce just as many, they dont pay invention costs, dont risk invention failure, and can sell at a price you simply can't match. It's nto that you would make little profit, its that you would make no profit at all. no the items i producing do have t2 bpo's. i just out produce them and rely on volume of items to make the isk. I didnt say there wasnt a BPO, I said clearly theres no BPO owner competing with you. If there was, he/she could undercut you to the point you can't make profit, and your production would become redundant. I've done the math on a number of T2 items, and some of them, no matter how much you throw into invention, you could never even produce cheap enough to make profit over existing sell orders, you'd actually be losing alot of ISK. Sure you might be lucky enough to avoid that market, and for me, I currently do, so can make a decent amount, but that doesnt change the experience I gained previously from attempting profitable T2 production.
if you lost money, you didnt do enough checking double and triple checking. most peopel dont when they start off, blindly invent stuff there is so little demand for the price is low.
CCP-áare full of words and no action. We watch what they do and its nothing but false statements and lies.
|

Big Bad Mofo
Comply Or Die
25
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:47:00 -
[26] - Quote
Tippia wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:All I'm saying is, they should bring back BPOs so everyone has a fighting chance. Everyone does have a fighting chance. Invention ensures just that. If you believe that a BPO will give you some kind of advantage (which, given the copy comment, will probably turn out to be false), then go ahead and buy one GÇö it's what most of the current BPO holders did, after allGǪ Quote:It should be fair across the board for everyone. Fun fact: it is. Quote:I mean, from a newbie point of view, whats the point of going into T2 production From a newbie point of view, why do you think that T2 manufacturing is for you? Maybe it's something you should get into once you know the ropes a bit betterGǪ GǪonce you do, the point of going into T2 production is obvious: it earns you more money than plain old T1.
not many people have 20-100billion liquid cash Tippia.. Talk sense man... Thats why t2 invention was made also to give people a chance. Not much of one however...
On the note of t2 not being expensive enough, well i agree perhaps for mods, but I think t2 ships are a bit overpriced tbh. But anyway perhaps the cost of creatig t2 should be cheaper not end product being more expensive,
|

Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
407
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:47:00 -
[27] - Quote
Lucas Kell wrote:Of course a T2 BPO gives you an advantage... So go buy one.
Quote:Sure people buy and sell them but thats beside the point really. No, it's not besides the point GÇö it is in fact critical ot the point because it completely annihilates what remains of the GÇ£it is unfairGÇ¥ argument once you remove the massive volume advantage that invention allows.
Big Bad Mofo wrote:not many people have 20-100billion liquid cash Tippia. So? Just because you don't want to/can't be bothered to invest that much (and hope that the game doesn't go out of business before it pays off) doesn't mean it's not an option.
Quote:Thats why t2 invention was made also to give people a chance. No it was not. It was made to break the monopoly of BPO holders, and it did just that.
In fact, wtf am I doing repeating all this. Just go read this thread (that has already been linked twice) and try to come up with some proper argument that haven't already been refuted a bajillion times already. GÇöGÇöGÇö GÇ£If you're not willing to fight for what you have in GëívGëí you don't deserve it, and you will lose it.GÇ¥ GÇö Karath Piki-á |

Ruby Hotrod
X Generation
2
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:47:00 -
[28] - Quote
BPO's should have been removed a long time ago. The old lottery style before R+D changed was a farce anyway, it was strange how some of the big name alliances won most of them and they are now the ones complaining that it is not more profitable than a BPC 
Also had a lot of dodgy dev dealing back then too. |

Tanya Powers
Science and Trade Institute Caldari State
13
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:48:00 -
[29] - Quote
Still waiting my agents to give me a single T2 BPO 
Ho, I can't have it ?? - really?
WTF ! -Me too I WANT IT NAO !! |

Lucas Kell
Lost Enterprises... SOLAR WING
0
|
Posted - 2011.10.10 11:49:00 -
[30] - Quote
Smoking Blunts wrote: if you lost money, you didnt do enough checking double and triple checking. most peopel dont when they start off, blindly invent stuff there is so little demand for the price is low.
LOL. I didnt just go willy nilly producing stuff. But doing the math you think "hold up, I can't possibly produce an item for the price that guy is selling at." So that's that item out the window, cos its already being done from a high ME BPO. I shouldnt have to disregard items just cos someones got a BPO. It's not a fair and level playing field. |
|
|
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |