Maybe they bumped it by accident :) Nothing in this video proves otherwise.

Little do you know mittens paid for that victory to buy some moral.

Aside from the fact that we can see where the bump happened which just happens to be on the edge of the pos shields, exactly where a bridging titan sits.

Could you point out the time in the video where you see exactly where the orange titan was before the footage began.

I'd be real interested to examine that bit.

Could you point out the time in the video where you see exactly where the orange titan was before the footage began.

I'd be real interested to examine that bit.

You simply look at where the titans are all moving from. The point where the bump happened can be seen simply by looking at the direction all of the ships are moving from.

Its rather shocking to see so many people willing to ignore the factthat an eploit has happened here simply because it was a goon titan that died.

You simply look at where the titans are all moving from. The point where the bump happened can be seen simply by looking at the direction all of the ships are moving from.

Its rather shocking to see so many people willing to ignore the factthat an eploit has happened here simply because it was a goon titan that died.

You simply look at where the titans are all moving from. The point where the bump happened can be seen simply by looking at the direction all of the ships are moving from.

Its rather shocking to see so many people willing to ignore the factthat an eploit has happened here simply because it was a goon titan that died.

NC.dot has been trying to declare based on a Screen shot that the titans jumped in at ranges of 100km plus

You simply look at where the titans are all moving from. The point where the bump happened can be seen simply by looking at the direction all of the ships are moving from.

Its rather shocking to see so many people willing to ignore the factthat an eploit has happened here simply because it was a goon titan that died.

Just pointing out the video, everyone deserves to judge themselves.

So somewhere in that general direction *waves hand at left side of screen*. Very nice and exact, or "simple" as you put it.

I'm not ignoring an exploit, I simply don't see it. Maybe its a simple thing for you to pinpoint the exact position of every single ship in that video at every single sever tick before the footage began.

Regrettably, I have no such ability. All I see is an orange titan moving in some vague direction toward the right of the screen.

What I am seeing is someone making a thread in GD claiming an "exploit" in the thread title to stir things up and then the OP backpedals by later saying:



It's been 3 weeks since that video was posted, so either you guys petitioned and it did not come out the way you expected, or you didn't and are breaking the rules now regarding positing exploits and/or rumor mongering for :reasons:

The video may in fact show the *result* of POS bowling, it does not however show the exploit being initiated. Assuming that it was the exploit at issue, it would have happened at a time prior to the video you are showing as evidence. Also if true, CCP will have evidence to back that up.

This is up to CCP to decide, and if they already have and you guys just don't like the answer, I can certainly sympathize, but you are gonna have to show me something a LOT more convincing before I start sharpening pitchforks and calling for blood. I am otherwise 100% in agreement, IF this is in fact an exploit, punitive and corrective actions should be handed out.

You dont see it because you are chosing to not see it.

It is very very easy to see where the titans are moving and draw a line back to where they were.

Aside from the fact that we can see where the bump happened which just happens to be on the edge of the pos shields, exactly where a bridging titan sits.

You dont see it because you are chosing to not see it.

You can track the titans back to where the bump happened based on their movement. Point of impact is on the edge of the POS shields, exactly where a bridging titan sits.

You're saying: This footage is the result of POS Bowling.
I'm saying: There's no POS Bowling in that footage.

I'm not disagreeing with the possibility that you are right. You could be correct.
But there is no actual footage of POS Bowling. Which means theirs no evidence of POS Bowling. Extrapolation? Sure. But extrapolation isn't proof.

[quote=baltec1][quote=PotatoOverdose][quote=baltec1]


It's been 3 weeks since that video was posted, so either you guys petitioned and it did not come out the way you expected, or you didn't and are breaking the rules now regarding positing exploits and/or rumor mongering for :reasons:

We have literally caught them in the act in a video.

The video was made PUBLICLY viewable in the last day. None of us had seen it either. They had it private for the last 3 weeks and nobody knew the video was out there. How hard is that to understand?

How much more evidence do you want exactly? We have literally caught them in the act in a video.

Well, first you need to actually catch them in the act on video.

We have literally caught them in the act in a video.

No you haven't. You might have caught them after the act.

In order to know where any collision occurred, and at what time, you would need to know the speed of every single titan in that video and the rate at which each of them decelerated. Do you know this? If not, any extrapolation you do will be woefully inaccurate.

As for how much evidence I want?
I would like to see either (1) footage of the actual bump or POS-bowl taking place or (2) logged physical data from CCP. Either of those would be completely satisfactory.

I hate to be a pedant, but your use of the word "literally" would imply that the video showed the cause rather than the consequence.

Probably is bowling .. but no way to know for sure without actually seeing it happen.


Does the cut first part of the vid exist somewhere? Wouldn't it be better to post the "proof" rather than just make people speculate as to the cause?


The fact that the video doesn't cover the whole event is likely to make people sceptical, or at least suspicious as to the motivation of this thread.

You dont need to see the bump,

Well, you kinda do if you are touting the vid as proof.

The bump could have happened just inside or just outside of the shield .. I guess we will never know.

Why would someone bump a titan into a POS rather than use their DD?

Why is it so hard for people to backtrack these ships to the point of impact?

Why would someone bump a titan into a POS rather than use their DD?

Why is it so hard for people to backtrack these ships to the point of impact?