You missed the point. And, as an aside, you've already done a good job of showing us why character transfers are not the same as SP transfers:

I don't use the character bazaar myself so I can't give you a conclusive answer to that. But going by CCP Rise's devblog the characters history and being stuck with a name he didn't want was a big drawback to using the bazaar. I can understand that point and so that is why I suggested a compromise could possibly be to erase history at the cost of SP loss.

If someone is willing to lose 25% of their SP to wipe their character then I'd say that is pretty reasonable. And after all it isn't unthinkable that in a high tec sci fi universe that there wouldn't be some way to erase ones identity at a cost.

Lots of hysteria here without any reasons behind it.
Eve is already pay to win and some "pro" vets are now crying.
Just show me the difference between:
a) Buying plex with money, selling it on market and then buying a char for isk on the character market.
b) Buying plex with money, seling it on market and then buying skill points for isk from another character.

Yep there is none :P
Apart from the fact that the new idea is a lot more comfortable.
But hey we have a "vets cry thread" now. Sometimes I think the old players are killing this game.
Eve is already pay to win. All you need is isk or RL money to buy toons and multibox.

If, some years ago, you told me that by paying a small fee to CCP + some in-game mechanism I could directly add as much SP as I desired, to any character that I desired? I would've laughed. Eve was about meaningful choices, long term planning.

But now? Well....like the man said: "It's not the end of the world, but you can see it from here."

This idea has very gamebreaking implications. As it is right now, each individual character has a theoretical maximum sp. If I had been perfectly optimized and training skills at a rate of roughly 2500sp/hr, I would have significantly more sp than I do now. This of course would have been impossible, or near to it, given that this character's attributes were static based on my race and lineage choices.

This idea could, and will, for those with deep enough pockets, push characters beyond their theoretical maximum and effectively trivialize pilots who have been faithfully playing for years.

The only way I would support this idea is if characters could never exceed that theoretical sp number, because as someone who has stopped training for months at a time, it would benefit me immensely. If however, one could not inject skills or sp beyond theoretical maximum limits, then new players could never benefit from it. On the same token, characters my age who were more "dedicated" (loosely using the term because my commitment to my subscription has always been linked to my rl finances rather than my desire to pay/play) than i see less benefit as well.

Not gonna lie, I've often fantasized about being able to buy my "missing" skill points in one fell swoop, but just because I would stand to gain tremendously from this idea doesn't mean it isn't a terrible idea.

No, CCP. Don't do it. Eve has always been a long term game. Do not radically alter the purest, most brilliant game to date for the pursuit of a few more subs. Instant gratification types never last here in New Eden, and completely breaking the game isn't going to keep them around any longer. You're just going to betray your loyal followers. The blowback from this will be disastrous.

"Some small in-game mechanism" is literally liquidating the SP of others, and applying it imperfectly towards your character.

I suppose if you were deliberately obtuse and boiling down the whole thing into that disingenuous quip then it'd be different.