Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 [16] 17 18 19 20 .. 22 :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 5 post(s) |
Leah Solo
State War Academy Caldari State
18
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:24:00 -
[451] - Quote
Tippia wrote:Leah Solo wrote:Might I ask what other issues, besides having some similar looking numbers, symbols and letters and being slightly too small, did the old font have? It didn't scale properly if I understood the devs correctly, and thus couldn't be used with the new font rendering.
Okay..thx for clearing that up. Too bad they didn't make the new font look as close as possible to the old one.
|
|
CCP t0rfifrans
C C P C C P Alliance
330
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:31:00 -
[452] - Quote
Hey all
Obviously there are divided opinions on the new font, it being in front of everyone the whole time and a big part of the overall EVE experience. When designing the new font, there were two major paths which we had to choose between. Make it legible, and improve accessibility or make it sci-fi and futuristic, risking usability for asthetics. We chose to go down the usability path.
Now from what we can see, there are very heated opinions on the topic. We did a little quasi-scientific analysis of the forums chatter. There were 1220 posts on the topic at the time of counting, 960 unique characters posting ( with the top 50 posting 31% of the posts ). We counted 6% objecting the new font, 49% somewhat neutral and 45% writing in a positive manner about it.
Looking at that date, we determine than while many people miss the old font and want the new one printed in books in order to be burned Farenheit 451 style, the majority of those writing on the topic like it and are enjoying the improved usability.
Also, the UI scaling is a very separate feature than the font, it was just lucky that we managed to get them both into Crucible. The font and the scaling had been developed by very different people at separate ends of the studio on very different schedules. Being able to launch both of then in Crucible made us pretty happy in terms of providing increased usability, which is something EVE sorely needs improved and we are committed to work on ad infinitum.
Finally, don't pick on Punkturis for implementing the new font or the UI scaling! She did a great job on both and I think EVE is a better product as a result of it! |
|
Amber Green Thorn
Federal Navy Academy Gallente Federation
25
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:34:00 -
[453] - Quote
Quote:We counted 6% objecting the new font,
No way
So basically you're saying you're going to do nothing about the scaling?? That's the real problem if you'd read the posts. Your game looks like a dogs dinner atm.
OK - scratch that -so you'll be working on it -reread the post - Font and Scaling being separate departments. Should be the same department really though.
Congrats on the rest of it -well done, |
Salpun
Paramount Commerce
93
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:38:00 -
[454] - Quote
CCP t0rfifrans wrote:Hey all
Obviously there are divided opinions on the new font, it being in front of everyone the whole time and a big part of the overall EVE experience. When designing the new font, there were two major paths which we had to choose between. Make it legible, and improve accessibility or make it sci-fi and futuristic, risking usability for asthetics. We chose to go down the usability path.
Now from what we can see, there are very heated opinions on the topic. We did a little quasi-scientific analysis of the forums chatter. There were 1220 posts on the topic at the time of counting, 960 unique characters posting ( with the top 50 posting 31% of the posts ). We counted 6% objecting the new font, 49% somewhat neutral and 45% writing in a positive manner about it.
Looking at that date, we determine than while many people miss the old font and want the new one printed in books in order to be burned Farenheit 451 style, the majority of those writing on the topic like it and are enjoying the improved usability.
Also, the UI scaling is a very separate feature than the font, it was just lucky that we managed to get them both into Crucible. The font and the scaling had been developed by very different people at separate ends of the studio on very different schedules. Being able to launch both of then in Crucible made us pretty happy in terms of providing increased usability, which is something EVE sorely needs improved and we are committed to work on ad infinitum.
Finally, don't pick on Punkturis for implementing the new font or the UI scaling! She did a great job on both and I think EVE is a better product as a result of it!
Thanks for posting. Did this include all posts with the word font included in the text? 90% with 11pt type and small text in the overview should become the new standard. What percent of the player base would have to change to that option for this to happen? |
Jarnis McPieksu
Aliastra Gallente Federation
57
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:38:00 -
[455] - Quote
I personally suspect this is some kind of a person-specific problem, possibly related to eyesight. Some people see the exact same things very differently, reacting in odd ways to visuals/text that look perfectly fine to others. In this case it may be related to kerning - to some people (as I understand it) the new EVE font appears to be spaced inconsistently. I can't see it and I have no problems, but I know people who are very frustrated with it (and some who have, over time, grown accustomed to the new norm)
The only real "fix" at this point would be to introduce fully switchable font typeface with at least a handful of different fonts that players could freely choose (with at least the ability to specify UI font and chat box font separately. Possibly also separate font for the overview).
I am aware that this is probably a non-trivial job, but I suspect that the small (and vocal) minority will never be happy until something like this is done.
(and no, reverting everyone back to the old crappy font... don't even think about it. Most of us are either neutral or happy with the font)
|
Veriasse Valence
Es and Whizz Hedonistic Imperative
15
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:44:00 -
[456] - Quote
at 1680x1050 I find that I have less space than before, however switching to 90% makes the fonts in many cases far too small to be legible and far far far far far worse than the old font ever was. So now Im stuck with the choice of less space or harder to read.
Amongst the many other issues I and others have pointed out, this right now is my biggest gripe. Its been an actual negative factor on my gameplay and the headache inducing font is certainly going to cause me to log in far less to do corp management type things. I will instead handle them via EVE Gate and other out of game comms. Given a choice between headaches and not logging in... |
|
CCP t0rfifrans
C C P C C P Alliance
330
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:47:00 -
[457] - Quote
Jarnis McPieksu wrote: The only real "fix" at this point would be to introduce fully switchable font typeface with at least a handful of different fonts that players could freely choose (with at least the ability to specify UI font and chat box font separately. Possibly also separate font for the overview).
In the short term, that's not that easy or cheap. The font has to be licensed and then adjusted to work within the client. That's expensive and time consuming.
Also, just be clear, we are totally aware that some people don't like it, and that's their opinion and we respect that. When it comes to something like a typeface, its there are no moral absolutes or right or wrong. What we're saying is that overall, we and the majority of people providing feedback on it feel that it improves usability. During testing and first implementation, we had pretty much exactly the same discussion and split opinions within the larger dev team, btw. |
|
Ranger 1
Ranger Corp
409
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:47:00 -
[458] - Quote
Jarnis McPieksu wrote:I personally suspect this is some kind of a person-specific problem, possibly related to eyesight. Some people see the exact same things very differently, reacting in odd ways to visuals/text that look perfectly fine to others. In this case it may be related to kerning - to some people (as I understand it) the new EVE font appears to be spaced inconsistently. I can't see it and I have no problems, but I know people who are very frustrated with it (and some who have, over time, grown accustomed to the new norm) The only real "fix" at this point would be to introduce fully switchable font typeface with at least a handful of different fonts that players could freely choose (with at least the ability to specify UI font and chat box font separately. Possibly also separate font for the overview). I am aware that this is probably a non-trivial job, but I suspect that the small (and vocal) minority will never be happy until something like this is done. (and no, reverting everyone back to the old crappy font... don't even think about it. Most of us are either neutral or happy with the font)
Exactly, although some combinations of monitor type, size, and resolution may also account for some of the discomfort. For those having difficulty I would suggest experimenting with the various settings in EVE and their basic game resolution until they find a combination they can live with.
The percentages listed jibe pretty closely with the estimate I had made myself after reading the various threads. To kill the enemy and break their toys!
It's not so much a mission statement,-áit's more like a family motto. |
Rion Deteisan
Forged Prophets
5
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:49:00 -
[459] - Quote
I have this absolutely crazy idea that would of saved so much time and money......
Keep the old font - Fix the ONLY the problem fonts in the old font.
Imagine how much money that would of saved. Perhaps the devs could of used font energy to do more important things for the expansion.
LEAKED: NEW Amarr CQ Ambient Sounds!! |
Ranger 1
Ranger Corp
409
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:52:00 -
[460] - Quote
Rion Deteisan wrote:I have this absolutely crazy idea that would of saved so much time and money......
Keep the old font - Fix the ONLY the problem fonts in the old font.
Imagine how much money that would of saved. Perhaps the devs could of used font energy to do more important things for the expansion.
Probably not possible, and I believe the old font would not work correctly with the new scaling options (although I could be mistaken on that point).
Font issues are one of the most brought up issues needing a fix over the last several years. Devoting some resources to it is far from unimportant.
To kill the enemy and break their toys!
It's not so much a mission statement,-áit's more like a family motto. |
|
Ris Dnalor
Fleet of Doom Ushra'Khan
82
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:52:00 -
[461] - Quote
Ohanka wrote:as we can see the new UI is inferior thanks to this.
aye
|
Selinate
131
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:52:00 -
[462] - Quote
Confirming also that this UI scaling thing makes some descriptions/numbers/etc. unreadable in certain parts of the UI. I have to increase it back up to 100% just so I can read the market price history numbers....
EDIT: Also, rollover information is completely garbled and unreadable. Things in places they shouldn't be, etc.... This really needs fixing |
Ris Dnalor
Fleet of Doom Ushra'Khan
82
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:52:00 -
[463] - Quote
Ohanka wrote:Shkolnica wrote:I can not play eve more than 15 minutes with this new ui. Because my eyes hurts. I'm now in skill switching mode till ui improvements. If there will be no improvements I will have to stop playing eve. yes the new font makes the game unplayable
i agree, or nearly so.
|
Ris Dnalor
Fleet of Doom Ushra'Khan
82
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:53:00 -
[464] - Quote
William Loire wrote:Velicitia wrote:you know things are good when the only whines are about the FONT I have to agree with this, but the font is pretty bad. Supporters: "I can finally read it!" Detractors: "It's ugly, amateurish, not scifi, wraps poorly, giving headaches and clashes with the EVE art style." Again why the old font couldn't have been optimized for clarity* rather then scrapping it entirely for a rush job is beyond me. (* Seriously? People had troubles reading it? Playing since 2005 no problem. If your upset because you need your glasses to read it: thats exactly what your glasses are for. We have poor vision, deal with it.)
sing it loud & proud. amen. |
Crosi Wesdo
Spiritus Draconis
58
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 21:58:00 -
[465] - Quote
Font and UI scaling may be separate. But if it wernt for 90% scaling the forum would be ablaze with many more people complaining about the huge font and annexing of monitor real-estate to solve a problem that the majority of people didnt have with the old font.
If you can allow a smaller font so that we dont have to distort other UI assets like icons with scaling you make have solved the problem. As it stands the icons and the text in the window tabs are the worst artefacts of the down scaling and font size across the UI needs to be normalized and a smaller font option introduced and/or icons need to be redrawn for the 90% UI rather than crudely shrunken or not scale at all. |
Ranger 1
Ranger Corp
409
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 22:00:00 -
[466] - Quote
Ris Dnalor wrote:William Loire wrote:Velicitia wrote:you know things are good when the only whines are about the FONT I have to agree with this, but the font is pretty bad. Supporters: "I can finally read it!" Detractors: "It's ugly, amateurish, not scifi, wraps poorly, giving headaches and clashes with the EVE art style." Again why the old font couldn't have been optimized for clarity* rather then scrapping it entirely for a rush job is beyond me. (* Seriously? People had troubles reading it? Playing since 2005 no problem. If your upset because you need your glasses to read it: thats exactly what your glasses are for. We have poor vision, deal with it.) sing it loud & proud. amen.
People have been screaming about the EVE font for far longer that 2005. There are links to various thread and even WIKI articles detailing this elsewhere in this thread.
Legibility is the primary purpose of a font in a game like this, everything else is secondary.
And frankly, the only people that need to get their glasses checked are the handful complaining of headaches now. People that apparently never read anything else on the web or in digital document form.
If your current resolution/monitor/preferences in scaling don't work well for you... change them, experiment a little. You'll find something you and the rest of the 6% can live with. To kill the enemy and break their toys!
It's not so much a mission statement,-áit's more like a family motto. |
Calon Seth
Deep Core Mining Inc. Caldari State
4
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 22:04:00 -
[467] - Quote
Ranger 1 wrote:Ris Dnalor wrote:William Loire wrote:Velicitia wrote:you know things are good when the only whines are about the FONT I have to agree with this, but the font is pretty bad. Supporters: "I can finally read it!" Detractors: "It's ugly, amateurish, not scifi, wraps poorly, giving headaches and clashes with the EVE art style." Again why the old font couldn't have been optimized for clarity* rather then scrapping it entirely for a rush job is beyond me. (* Seriously? People had troubles reading it? Playing since 2005 no problem. If your upset because you need your glasses to read it: thats exactly what your glasses are for. We have poor vision, deal with it.) sing it loud & proud. amen. People have been screaming about the EVE font for far longer that 2005. There are links to various thread and even WIKI articles detailing this elsewhere in this thread. Legibility is the primary purpose of a font in a game like this, everything else is secondary. And frankly, the only people that need to get their glasses checked are the handful complaining of headaches now. People that apparently never read anything else on the web or in digital document form. If your current resolution/monitor/preferences in scaling don't work well for you... change them, experiment a little. You'll find something you and the rest of the 6% can live with.
A small minority of clearly visually impaired people maybe. Everywhere I go now, I hear people complaining about the font. Never seen that kind of opposition for the old font. |
Mutie DaPig
University of Caille Gallente Federation
17
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 22:08:00 -
[468] - Quote
Quote:Legibility is the primary purpose of a font in a game like this, everything else is secondary.
Legibility - yeah make the font bigger - ofc it's going to be more legibile. The bit where the spaceships go suffers correspondingly.
PS - what's wrong with the font we're reading here now in the forum? I look at this then at the UI and back again.. mmmm |
Taedrin
Kushan Industrial
159
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 22:15:00 -
[469] - Quote
Shkolnica wrote:CCP Navigator wrote:It is currently not possible to toggle between the new font and the old one. While we appreciate that this is something a lot of people are asking for, it simply cannot be done in the current font rendering system. So made it possible. Dont you have any programmers?
Contrary to what the public may believe, real life programming is not the same as Hollywood Hacking. It takes time to "made [sic] it possible".
Although I would just like to mention that I think it would be a cool feature to be able to use whatever font we want to with our EVE Client. |
Takeshi Yamato
ALA Biomedical
5
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 22:20:00 -
[470] - Quote
Playing on 1920x1080 and the new font is an improvement over the old one. It could use a bit more space between the characters and menu borders above it. It looks cramped because in some parts it's used in menu boxes, buttons and rows that are a bit too small for it.
To sum it up, new font good (but not perfect), UI not yet fully adjusted to match it though. |
|
Miyu Wa
TERRIBLE EMO ALTS REGIME
0
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 22:32:00 -
[471] - Quote
Taedrin wrote:Shkolnica wrote:CCP Navigator wrote:It is currently not possible to toggle between the new font and the old one. While we appreciate that this is something a lot of people are asking for, it simply cannot be done in the current font rendering system. So made it possible. Dont you have any programmers? Contrary to what the public may believe, real life programming is not the same as Hollywood Hacking. It takes time to "made [sic] it possible". Although I would just like to mention that I think it would be a cool feature to be able to use whatever font we want to with our EVE Client.
However, as someone who actually knows what their talking about, the only reason you can have a system where it is impossible to use another font is that you made some amateurish, "look ma, it's my first renderer", mistake at the beginning, or equally embarassing amounts of poor planning. |
Ayanaya
Apple Industries Inc. Surely You're Joking
4
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 22:36:00 -
[472] - Quote
I like the new font. big Screen = readable.
Sure there are issues in game where it needs to be improved.. but it's a great step in my opinion.
-a |
MadMuppet
Jarts
1
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:10:00 -
[473] - Quote
Got home tonight and started to tinker with the font some more. I have it running at 13pt and 90% scale on a 1920x1080 display and it is pretty close to where I like it. Overall it is better than the old one, but it is pretty obvious that some of the scaling needs work (like long target names and the item counts text size) especially on the larger than 100% scales.
You need to tinker with font size (under general settings tab) AND the UI scale size (under display and graphics tab). By default, it was a major 'Do not want.", but now it is pretty good. Never trust a soldier wearing velcroed insignia
While not perfect, I find the font at 13 pt and scaling at 90% to be pretty good, and overall better than the old font.-á |
Yogsoloth
8
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:17:00 -
[474] - Quote
CCP t0rfifrans wrote:Hey all
Obviously there are divided opinions on the new font, it being in front of everyone the whole time and a big part of the overall EVE experience. When designing the new font, there were two major paths which we had to choose between. Make it legible, and improve accessibility or make it sci-fi and futuristic, risking usability for asthetics. We chose to go down the usability path.
Now from what we can see, there are very heated opinions on the topic. We did a little quasi-scientific analysis of the forums chatter. There were 1220 posts on the topic at the time of counting, 960 unique characters posting ( with the top 50 posting 31% of the posts ). We counted 6% objecting the new font, 49% somewhat neutral and 45% writing in a positive manner about it.
Looking at that date, we determine than while many people miss the old font and want the new one printed in books in order to be burned Farenheit 451 style, the majority of those writing on the topic like it and are enjoying the improved usability.
Also, the UI scaling is a very separate feature than the font, it was just lucky that we managed to get them both into Crucible. The font and the scaling had been developed by very different people at separate ends of the studio on very different schedules. Being able to launch both of then in Crucible made us pretty happy in terms of providing increased usability, which is something EVE sorely needs improved and we are committed to work on ad infinitum.
Finally, don't pick on Punkturis for implementing the new font or the UI scaling! She did a great job on both and I think EVE is a better product as a result of it!
When did 45% become a majority ?
I see what you did there, you created a seperate category (somewhat nuetral ???) so that you would not have to count those who were not supoortive or positive about the change as negative.
I see through your deceit though, if only 45% are positive that means there are 55% that do not feel positive about the change !
Clearly 55% of the people that do not feel positive about the change is the majority in this equation.
Stop playing symantics with us. |
Shakari Sween
Empirius Enigmus Navy C0NVICTED
3
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:21:00 -
[475] - Quote
The new font is way different.
I definitely prefer the old one, and would love the ability to switch between them. |
Rikki Sals
State War Academy Caldari State
16
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:24:00 -
[476] - Quote
While I personally prefer the new font, being able to select from a number of different fonts would be very nice. |
Krios Ahzek
Juvenis Iratus
159
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:29:00 -
[477] - Quote
ITT ''It changed now it sucks'' I live, I post, I slay. I am content. Alpha Flight --á an open-source initiative for newbies looking for PVP. Join channel ''Alpha Flight'' in game https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=40104 |
Endeavour Starfleet
Center for Advanced Studies Gallente Federation
49
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:30:00 -
[478] - Quote
CCP please keep the new font. Again these IDIOTS had TONS of time to provide feedback but diddnt bother getting on Sisi.
Too bad so sad. |
Endeavour Starfleet
Center for Advanced Studies Gallente Federation
49
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:33:00 -
[479] - Quote
CCP t0rfifrans wrote:Jarnis McPieksu wrote: The only real "fix" at this point would be to introduce fully switchable font typeface with at least a handful of different fonts that players could freely choose (with at least the ability to specify UI font and chat box font separately. Possibly also separate font for the overview).
In the short term, that's not that easy or cheap. The font has to be licensed and then adjusted to work within the client. That's expensive and time consuming. Also, just be clear, we are totally aware that some people don't like it, and that's their opinion and we respect that. When it comes to something like a typeface, its there are no moral absolutes or right or wrong. What we're saying is that overall, we and the majority of people providing feedback on it feel that it improves usability. During testing and first implementation, we had pretty much exactly the same discussion and split opinions within the larger dev team, btw.
This!
And people had their chance to provide feedback on the new font. They couldn't be bothered to test Sisi now they whine and scream on the forums.
CCP you did GREAT work on the new font. Please don't spend much dev time changing it because people can't be bothered to test. |
Just Lilly
Republic Military School Minmatar Republic
5
|
Posted - 2011.11.30 23:39:00 -
[480] - Quote
The new font is a vast improvement to the old one.
Hate it all you want haters...
I for one hope it's here to stay |
|
|
|
|
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 [16] 17 18 19 20 .. 22 :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |