| Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 .. 16 :: [one page] |
| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 4 post(s) |
|

CCP kieron

|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:42:00 -
[1]
The recent MotD mentioning the sale or purchase of ISK for real money generated some questions about how Game Time can be traded for ISK, Game Time that was purchased with real world cash. In some of my replies, I was unclear. This wasn't by intention, but because of the information I am authorized to release at this time.
In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK. In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
We still have a number of details to work out, as well as implementation and integration, but that will hopefully clear up some of the confusion created earlier.
kieron Community Manager, EVE Online |
|

M Counts
Sniggerdly Pandemic Legion
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:45:00 -
[2]
would you mind explaining why, exactly, elimination of the "middleman" (and further complication of the already byzantine and horribly slow account management page) is, as you said it, "for the good of the community?"
loaded question but I still get my point across, i still have not seen any concise logic as to why this is for the "good of the community," especially seeing as the last change to gtc mechanics caused only inconvenience, at least from my, a non-seller's perspective -----
|

Team Chk
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:46:00 -
[3]
So basically you can't sell GTC's for ISK anymore. Don't see how CCP is going to make money from this though?
|

The Slayette
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:47:00 -
[4]
Ok direct question, easy to answer.
Will I be able to send $20 to *someone* take a code from *someone* and sell it to *someone* in game for isk?
Will I be able to take my $20 and turn it into ISK through the magic of timecards. Yae or Nae. Your mic.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:48:00 -
[5]
Originally by: M Counts
would you mind explaining why, exactly, elimination of the "middleman" (and further complication of the already byzantine and horribly slow account management page) is, as you said it, "for the good of the community?"
loaded question but I still get my point across, i still have not seen any concise logic as to why this is for the "good of the community," especially seeing as the last change to gtc mechanics caused only inconvenience, at least from my, a non-seller's perspective
Because people can't buy ISK any more.
Oh and this is win.
There is no other way to describe it. Pure win.
|

Del Narveux
Obsidian Angels Enterprises
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:51:00 -
[6]
Wait...so buying GTC from sellers, or selling themself, is bad, but getting them from CCP is okay? And is this going to affect those big third party resellers that currently do most of the sales? Im a bit confuzzled, though Ive never been a big fan of getting cash for game money or vice versa so it doesnt really affect me. _________________ [SAK] Alumnus--And Proud Of It! -- aka Cpt Bogus Is that my torped sig cloaking your base?
Originally by: Wrangler Well, at least we have forum PvP..
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:53:00 -
[7]
Edited by: Nero Scuro on 04/05/2007 22:49:27
Originally by: Del Narveux Wait...so buying GTC from sellers, or selling themself, is bad, but getting them from CCP is okay? And is this going to affect those big third party resellers that currently do most of the sales? Im a bit confuzzled, though Ive never been a big fan of getting cash for game money or vice versa so it doesnt really affect me.
As I read it (and correct me if I'm wrong) Kieron said nothing about turning gametime into ISK, or any other such isk-for-cash (or vice versa) style transaction being possible.
I hope I'm right on that.
|

Athena Attom
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:53:00 -
[8]
Edited by: Athena Attom on 04/05/2007 22:49:59
Originally by: Del Narveux Wait...so buying GTC from sellers, or selling themself, is bad, but getting them from CCP is okay? And is this going to affect those big third party resellers that currently do most of the sales? Im a bit confuzzled, though Ive never been a big fan of getting cash for game money or vice versa so it doesnt really affect me.
Its because people are purchasing GTCS with RL money and selling them for ingame ISK effectively buying ISK from a website, except CCP get paid this way...
its an unfair advantage that some people use to fund their entire accounts ship losses etc and also certain alliances :) fix it dont nerf it. |

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:55:00 -
[9]
Originally by: CCP kieron The recent MotD mentioning the sale or purchase of ISK for real money generated some questions about how Game Time can be traded for ISK, Game Time that was purchased with real world cash. In some of my replies, I was unclear. This wasn't by intention, but because of the information I am authorized to release at this time.
In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK. In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
We still have a number of details to work out, as well as implementation and integration, but that will hopefully clear up some of the confusion created earlier.
I love you.
|

The Slayette
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:55:00 -
[10]
What you guys are suggesting is that CCP Are going to start selling timecards for ISK. This makes no business sense at ALL. How, in this happy little equation of yours, do CCP make money from our subscriptions?
That is not what Kieron meant at all. I hope.
|

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:56:00 -
[11]
Repost from last thread: Somewhere, the Overlord of Macrominers is rubbing his hands together with glee. Why? Well...
CCP charges $15 or (random made-up figure) 250mil ISK for a timecard? Fine. The ISK-farmers will charge $15 for 275mil isk. Players buy from them and then use the isk for buying a timecard as it is (effectively) cheaper than buying direct from CCP as they're paying the same amount of RL cash but get some extra isk on top.
Everybody wins...except CCP and non-macrominers. 
|

Del Narveux
Obsidian Angels Enterprises
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:59:00 -
[12]
I know what people are doing, Im just trying to get a handle on the scope of this change. OP still seemed a bit vague as to whether the big reseller sites would get shut down, i.e. if their 'new and improved' system involves them or not.
Which brings me to my followup question, if in fact the resellers are shut out of the picture will CCP be accepting more payment options? Specifically, Paypal and/or checks? I recently tried to get a friend in New Zealand signed up and came to the realization that a lot of folks in that part of the world dont have a credit card, at least not one endorsed by Visa/Amex/Mastercard. _________________ [SAK] Alumnus--And Proud Of It! -- aka Cpt Bogus Is that my torped sig cloaking your base?
Originally by: Wrangler Well, at least we have forum PvP..
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 22:59:00 -
[13]
Originally by: Briana Flametop Repost from last thread: Somewhere, the Overlord of Macrominers is rubbing his hands together with glee. Why? Well...
CCP charges $15 or (random made-up figure) 250mil ISK for a timecard? Fine. The ISK-farmers will charge $15 for 275mil isk. Players buy from them and then use the isk for buying a timecard as it is (effectively) cheaper than buying direct from CCP as they're paying the same amount of RL cash but get some extra isk on top.
Everybody wins...except CCP and non-macrominers. 
Except GTC for ISK won't be supported, so if you get scammed CCP won't do anything.
They'll possibly even ban offenders (buyer and seller) under the usual ebaying for ISK rules..?
|

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:00:00 -
[14]
Edited by: ToxicFire on 04/05/2007 22:59:08 Edited by: ToxicFire on 04/05/2007 22:58:47 Your accountants must be panicked?
Kieron I find it very very hard to believe an option that is clearly very profitable would be undermined by ccp itself without some other way to recoup the potential losses that will occur. Thus leads me to suspect we're going to get an extra charge somewhere in the near future be it increased subscription costs, payments for major expansions.
Its quite literally offering your subscriptions for an almost free amount.... unless you require insane amounts of isk compared to the accepted isk to gtc conversions currently.
I just don't see how this can work, the only other example thats even close is GW offering free time but full game costs on regular expansions.... a system which i feel certain would not work with the level of eves expansions as they do not offer the level of content.
Something like this is just gonna cause rampant inflation as people try and make as much isk as possible in the shortest ammount of time. In short big alliances will all be playing for free while the more casual gamer and small corps are worse off. Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

RightYouAre Ken
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:00:00 -
[15]
Is English your 8th language or something, kieron, because seriously every post you make on this subject just confuses it more. Please tell us which of the following statements about the new system are false, if any:
1) Player A can buy timecards from CCP for Real Money. 2) Player B can buy timecards from Player A for ISK, (using CCP as a broker for the transaction). 3) All timecard affiliate programs will be shut down - the only valid timecard transactions will be handled directly through CCP. 4) This new system is intended to end timecard scams and put more money into CCP's wallet, (because they wouldn't be selling to affiliates at a discounted rate).
|

Countess Amarra
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:01:00 -
[16]
Edited by: Countess Amarra on 04/05/2007 22:58:50
Originally by: CCP kieron but that will hopefully clear up some of the confusion created earlier.
You're a funny guy.
Why even bring this up at all?
|

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:01:00 -
[17]
Edited by: Briana Flametop on 04/05/2007 22:57:55
Originally by: Nero Scuro Except GTC for ISK won't be supported, so if you get scammed CCP won't do anything.
They'll possibly even ban offenders (buyer and seller) under the usual ebaying for ISK rules..?
Pretty much every single other MMOG has banned 3rd party "game cash for RL cash" sales, regularly take action against farmers...and yet they still go on.
CCP is basically handing a sizable chunk of what is now subscription money being paid to them over to the ISK-farmers. Not the greatest plan ever.
|

Nerogk Shorn
Caldari Royal Hiigaran Navy
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:01:00 -
[18]
No gaming company will ever be able to completely get rid of people buying isk with real cash, but at least CCP will no longer make it easy and legal for them to do so. Not allowing people to buy isk with money in any fashion, and even though it will still happen, those people will have to risk getting into trouble. If I am understanding this correctly, I think this is definitely a step in the right direction.
D-F-A-A-B-A-A-S |

M Counts
Sniggerdly Pandemic Legion
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:02:00 -
[19]
A large portion of the accounts in eve right now are paid for by isk-bought GTCs. To sell game time for isk - essentially free - would eliminate an equally large portion of CCP's income
So, what we're looking at is a change to the account management page, something i am NOT optimistic about, seeing CCP's past track record with it, and a possible elimination of a large portion of CCP's revenue stream. I cannot see any way in which that would be "for the good of the community" -----
|

Easy Target
Minmatar Black Nova Corp Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:02:00 -
[20]
Originally by: Briana Flametop Repost from last thread: Somewhere, the Overlord of Macrominers is rubbing his hands together with glee. Why? Well...
CCP charges $15 or (random made-up figure) 250mil ISK for a timecard? Fine. The ISK-farmers will charge $15 for 275mil isk. Players buy from them and then use the isk for buying a timecard as it is (effectively) cheaper than buying direct from CCP as they're paying the same amount of RL cash but get some extra isk on top.
Everybody wins...except CCP and non-macrominers. 
Reading comprehension 4TW???
You can buy from CCP through the account page, or you can buy them for yourself from retailers as you can now.
Re-selling the timecards is no longer an approved method...
So as it reads the only way CCP lose is if you buy off them, as the isk goes to the big money graveyard in space and CCP dont get money from that.
May have got that bit wrong. :) -----------------------------------------------
No i'm not good... but i have never claimed to be -------------------- |

Baji Core
Privateers Privateer Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:02:00 -
[21]
I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
|

Argenton Sayvers
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:04:00 -
[22]
Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 04/05/2007 23:04:39
Originally by: Athena Attom
its an unfair advantage that some people use to fund their entire accounts ship losses etc and also certain alliances :)
I doubt that CCP will sacrifice huge parts of their income to create a medicore ISK sink.
No matter how you spin it, someone has to "pay" for every 30d a account gets. Be it a rich kid, a sponsor that feeds "ISK for gametime"-accounts commercials, be it CCP by losing out on the possiblity that someone would have paid.
If you ban the "buying" of ISK by selling GTC, people still have the option of ebay (ebay = doing RMT via a myriad of websites, doesnt matter wether "Ebay" actually allows it or not, typical case of brand -> common term, see band-aid, kleenex).
This may be against the EULA, but even if the EULA is a legally binding contract (which it is not in some places) - since when can a contract between a end customer and a corporation regulate who receives money from the end customer?
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:05:00 -
[23]
Edited by: Nero Scuro on 04/05/2007 23:01:20
Originally by: Nerogk Shorn No gaming company will ever be able to completely get rid of people buying isk with real cash, but at least CCP will no longer make it easy and legal for them to do so. Not allowing people to buy isk with money in any fashion, and even though it will still happen, those people will have to risk getting into trouble. If I am understanding this correctly, I think this is definitely a step in the right direction.
Beat me to it.
But for clarity;
CCP will never get rid of macrominers. So I suppose they should stop banning them?
CCP will never get rid of abusive or inappropriate behaviour from 12 year olds ingame, so they should stop caring too?
CCP will never get rid of every bug, so why bother fixing the current ones?
|

Vidar Kentoran
Minmatar Provenance.
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:06:00 -
[24]
I think it's pretty safe to say that your clarification is not actually clearer.
|

Dark Shikari
Caldari Imperium Technologies Firmus Ixion
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:06:00 -
[25]
Originally by: Nero Scuro Edited by: Nero Scuro on 04/05/2007 23:01:20
Originally by: Nerogk Shorn No gaming company will ever be able to completely get rid of people buying isk with real cash, but at least CCP will no longer make it easy and legal for them to do so. Not allowing people to buy isk with money in any fashion, and even though it will still happen, those people will have to risk getting into trouble. If I am understanding this correctly, I think this is definitely a step in the right direction.
Beat me to it.
But for clarity;
CCP will never get rid of macrominers. So I suppose they should stop banning them?
CCP will never get rid of abusive or inappropriate behaviour from 12 year olds ingame, so they should stop caring too?
CCP will never get rid of every bug, so why bother fixing the current ones?
Awesome post, QFT Nero.
--23 Member--
Listen to EVE-Trance Radio! |

Team Chk
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:06:00 -
[26]
On a side note, will Character sales for ISK still be allowed? If so then you can expect a massive increase on teh sales forum 
|

The Slayette
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:06:00 -
[27]
Originally by: Easy Target
So as it reads the only way CCP lose is if you buy off them, as the isk goes to the big money graveyard in space and CCP dont get money from that.
May have got that bit wrong. :)
This is what worries me. If this is right CCP are going to lose a LOT of money. I PRAY this isnt what is happening.
|

Merrick Vale
ACCORD Industries
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:07:00 -
[28]
Hmm.
Stopping players from using their real world wealth to by in-game currency is a good thing. Ending third-party GTC for isk sales won't entirely accomplish that, but eliminating the sanctioned method improves your moral standing when going after those who use unsanctioned methods.
Allowing players who generate a lot of income in-game to use it to pay for their accounts is, I think, generally good. If nothing else, it lets them fund alts to compete with those who can afford to pay cash.
The major problems are that CCP loses part of it's revenue stream, which could obviously lead to in-game problems, and that you're changing a zero-sum transaction into an isk sink. Even a layman can see the deflationary pressure that could lead to. I hope CCP has a good economist on staff to monitor the effects of this sort of change and a willingness to tweak the rules as needed to maintain a stable money supply.
|

Jin Tan
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:08:00 -
[29]
So I give CCP a virtual currency that already belongs to them and I get game time back that is worth 15 real bucks? 
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:08:00 -
[30]
Originally by: Baji Core I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
The gametime will probably be fairly expensive, it will probably serve as an ISK sink as well, and deflation is probably important to CCP.
|

Blind Man
Kemono.
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:09:00 -
[31]
good to see something is finally being done 
|

Space Pirate
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:09:00 -
[32]
I'm sorry but I don't see how this is anything but an absolutely horrible idea. It won't stop isk for cash resellers at all, and it cuts into CCP's revenue if I'm understanding it correctly (that CCP will start selling game time themselves for isk).
If the concern is the costs of support staff to deal with the fraud reports and whatnot, I can't imagine the extra time and staffing costing more than potential loss of revenue in timecards by giving them away for in-game money.
Otherwise all I can tell is that CCP is spending too much time listening to junior high students who don't even know what the word "macroeconomics" means and play 16 hours a day and whine about how people aren't playing "purely" if they don't spend their entire life playing internet spaceships. It's good for EvE to appeal to both the hardcore and the casual player, and it does a good job of that. Allowing people to buy a bit of isk by buying game time for others is an ingenious system that feeds off of two playing styles at once, and does nothing to the so-called "purity" of the game.
There's a saying that goes if it ain't broke, don't fix it. There are a lot of things in EvE that deserve the attention and manpower, and breaking and convoluting one of the golden gooses of the current design is a terrible mismanagement of resources.
|

Mox Trident
Minmatar Erimus Blueprints
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:10:00 -
[33]
Quote: In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK
This is the part that some people have missed.
The way I read it is that you will no longer be able to buy GTC's from third parties like shatteredcrystal.com or ebay.
From now on you'll buy your GTC directly from CCP through account management.
This is how I think it will work:
Player A will purchase a GTC for RL cash from CCP.
Player A will be given an option to either use the GTC himself or sell it to player B for ISK.
When player B buys a GTC from a seller, the GTC is automatically added to his subscription time. This prevents player B from re-selling the GTC out of game for RL cash.
This way CCP get the RL cash, all transactions are through account management, and third party middlemen are removed from the equation altogether.
Capital Ship BPC packages now available from Erimus Blueprints |

Gnulpie
Minmatar Miner Tech
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:11:00 -
[34]
Originally by: The Slayette ...CCP are going to start selling timecards for ISK...
LOOOOOL
Yes, that is exactly how I understand it also after reading Kierons statement several times slowly and carefully. That makes absolutely no sense.
I wonder what their bookkeeping office will say about that 
|

Kramer Verone
Amarr
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:11:00 -
[35]
Edited by: Kramer Verone on 04/05/2007 23:07:09
Originally by: Briana Flametop Repost from last thread: Somewhere, the Overlord of Macrominers is rubbing his hands together with glee. Why? Well...
CCP charges $15 or (random made-up figure) 250mil ISK for a timecard? Fine. The ISK-farmers will charge $15 for 275mil isk. Players buy from them and then use the isk for buying a timecard as it is (effectively) cheaper than buying direct from CCP as they're paying the same amount of RL cash but get some extra isk on top.
Everybody wins...except CCP and non-macrominers. 
macroing is getting harder and harder it' snot going to be worth paying 275m isk for 15 U$
|

Easy Target
Minmatar Black Nova Corp Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:11:00 -
[36]
Originally by: The Slayette
Originally by: Easy Target
So as it reads the only way CCP lose is if you buy off them, as the isk goes to the big money graveyard in space and CCP dont get money from that.
May have got that bit wrong. :)
This is what worries me. If this is right CCP are going to lose a LOT of money. I PRAY this isnt what is happening.
How much do they make from GTC sales anyway? Without all the figures, which we are never gonna get it isnt really beneficial to predict.
And of them time cards sold, how many get resold? (market they are removing)
The guy that mentioned something about the EULA, i didnt get the question But legally binding or not u agree to it to play the game if u break that agreement the provider has the power to stop you recieveing said service
Doesnt need to be legally binding to use it as the reason for stopping someone playing the game. Standing up in court yeah, but i cant see CCP wasnting to take a macro miner to court.. :) -----------------------------------------------
No i'm not good... but i have never claimed to be -------------------- |

The Slayette
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:11:00 -
[37]
Originally by: Craam Hustler
Originally by: Baji Core I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
The gametime will probably be fairly expensive, it will probably serve as an ISK sink as well, and deflation is probably important to CCP.
As important as a monthly subscription?
|

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:12:00 -
[38]
Originally by: Craam Hustler
Originally by: Baji Core I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
The gametime will probably be fairly expensive, it will probably serve as an ISK sink as well, and deflation is probably important to CCP.
10iskies says we're looking at over a billion for 30 days Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:12:00 -
[39]
I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Argenton Sayvers
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:13:00 -
[40]
Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 04/05/2007 23:11:33 My bet:
It has nothing to do with the RMT angle*.
I think its about restricting or eliminating resale (as in, the big reseller sites or just selling of the GTCs you got for christmans because your parents didnt realize that you are fed up with cap blobs online) of GTCs via reworked licencing rules. Benefits are bigger cuts and more controll over the entire process.
*The only thing that can stop RMT is governments using armed forces to combat it around the world far beyond the scope of the "war on drugs". There are actually reasons to do so - MMOs are so big that they create shadow ecomomies and fiscal systems outside the reach of the conventional instruments to controll them.
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:13:00 -
[41]
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:14:00 -
[42]
Edited by: ToxicFire on 04/05/2007 23:13:25
Originally by: Mox Trident
Quote: In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK
This is the part that some people have missed.
The way I read it is that you will no longer be able to buy GTC's from third parties like shatteredcrystal.com or ebay.
From now on you'll buy your GTC directly from CCP through account management.
This is how I think it will work:
Player A will purchase a GTC for RL cash from CCP.
Player A will be given an option to either use the GTC himself or sell it to player B for ISK.
When player B buys a GTC from a seller, the GTC is automatically added to his subscription time. This prevents player B from re-selling the GTC out of game for RL cash.
This way CCP get the RL cash, all transactions are through account management, and third party middlemen are removed from the equation altogether.
Your grammer understanding of that line sucks that line say that current system WHICH allows people to buy game time from third parties for isk will be replaced if you read the next line the context becomes apparent
From kierons post
In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing See here kieron is saying what is been replaced the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK. In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCPSee this is where kieron has said what will replace it note the part that says isk rich players will be able to purchase direct from ccp. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option. Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

Roscoe Rhoads
Caldari Provisions
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:15:00 -
[43]
Worst ******* idea ever. Hope it bites you in the ass, hard. Then again with BoD, Kugutsumen blanket bannnings, Titans this is starting to look like SWG, which is still swinging... so enjoy, I guess. |

Space Pirate
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:16:00 -
[44]
Oh and if the real issue is to cut out the commission check for certain large alliances, that's also a stupid move. Setting up the out-of-game infrastructure to allow such an alliance to communicate effectively is very expensive, and the money from those commissions go to efforts that among other things, allow said alliances to bring in new subscribers. Once again, don't kill the golden goose, CCP.
|

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:16:00 -
[45]
Originally by: Craam Hustler
Originally by: Baji Core I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
The gametime will probably be fairly expensive, it will probably serve as an ISK sink as well, and deflation is probably important to CCP.
Deflation will become a lower priority the second that their subscription income drops below their targets. ;) Let's use hyperbole - what happens to CCP if 90% of the playerbase starts paying subs with ISK? Do you seriously think that they'll be happy to keep the game running on 1/10th their previous income?
Nope. Next up, a few months down the line, is the removal of ISK->timecards. It's the only logical assumption to make. |

SiJira
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:17:00 -
[46]
i believe this will stop people from buying isk from other people by money because if you got extra isk you can work it out with ccp and if you got extra cash you wont be able to buy isk
is my understanding correct? ____ __ ________ _sig below_ the jet cans are made so that people that dont mine can get free ore
miners ritually donate the ore to anyone wishing to take some |

Jigglepantaloons
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:17:00 -
[47]
Originally by: Craam Hustler
Originally by: Baji Core I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
The gametime will probably be fairly expensive, it will probably serve as an ISK sink as well, and deflation is probably important to CCP.
NO gaming company would give up cash revenue for an in-game currency. From a strict business perspective that's absolutely idiotic, especially with so many more options to remove isk from the market avaliable.
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:18:00 -
[48]
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space.
Why oh WHY would you say this?
I quit WoW because it became a horrible, ****ty grindfest past level 45. I play EVE for the PvP - I enjoy it and it's a great, unique experience. I don't like having to mine for six hours to fit out a HAC. EVE has always been very attractive to casual players with the GTCs and the offline skill training, and removing this is a slap in A) The face of casual MMO-players everywhere and B) CCP's accounting deparment. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:19:00 -
[49]
This is going to turn eve into meta gaming for big alliances. Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

Frug
Zenithal Harvest
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:19:00 -
[50]
Originally by: ToxicFire Your grammer understanding of that line sucks that line say that current system WHICH allows people to buy game time from third parties for isk will be replaced if you read the next line the context becomes apparent
You're commenting on grammar?
It sounds like a good step. I'm concerned like people above are, regarding what that means for CCP. Surely -they- know what they're doing, right? I think the GTC's from ccp would have to be pretty expensive to justify playing for free...
Otherwise I think we (or at least I) am still confused.
- - - - - - - - - Do not use dotted lines - - - - - - - If you think I'm awesome, say BOOO BOOO!! - Ductoris Neat look what I found - Kreul Hey, my marbles |

clone 1
Caldari The Short Bus Squad The SUdden Death Squad
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:19:00 -
[51]
Bree is one powerful substance 
Always Moaning About Race Retardations |

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:19:00 -
[52]
Originally by: The Slayette
Originally by: Craam Hustler
Originally by: Baji Core I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
The gametime will probably be fairly expensive, it will probably serve as an ISK sink as well, and deflation is probably important to CCP.
As important as a monthly subscription?
Not everyone will be able to afford the time codes, and those that may want to keep their ISK might rather pay with $$$$
|

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:22:00 -
[53]
Originally by: Frug
Originally by: ToxicFire Your grammer understanding of that line sucks that line say that current system WHICH allows people to buy game time from third parties for isk will be replaced if you read the next line the context becomes apparent
You're commenting on grammar?
It sounds like a good step. I'm concerned like people above are, regarding what that means for CCP. Surely -they- know what they're doing, right? I think the GTC's from ccp would have to be pretty expensive to justify playing for free...
Otherwise I think we (or at least I) am still confused.
Yup i know my spelling and some of the grammar is all over the place but you did kinda take the line out of the context of the paragraph it was in changing its meaning. CCP knows what its doing I just don't think the accountants do yet. Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

Plutoinum
German Cyberdome Corp Cult of War
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:23:00 -
[54]
Originally by: The Slayette
Originally by: Easy Target
So as it reads the only way CCP lose is if you buy off them, as the isk goes to the big money graveyard in space and CCP dont get money from that.
May have got that bit wrong. :)
This is what worries me. If this is right CCP are going to lose a LOT of money. I PRAY this isnt what is happening.
Only if CCP doesn't start to offer isk for $$ themselves as a 'service'. So a certain amount of isk that they took out of the game in exchange for gametime could flow back into the game being sold for cash to the ones, who want to buy isk. ___________ Muuuhhh !!! |

Hannisk
Gallente Federal Navy Academy
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:24:00 -
[55]
Thanks CCP for fixing this huge issue that was causing massive damage to the game and ruining it for players everywhere.
I'm also happy you got your priorities straight and fixed it before less important issues like:
a) lag. Fleet fights being unplayable. b) fleet system causing lag. c) supercapitals.
None of the above are important issues that need fixing, no not at all.
Somtimes I really hate you CCP.
|

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:25:00 -
[56]
Originally by: Craam Hustler Not everyone will be able to afford the time codes, and those that may want to keep their ISK might rather pay with $$$$
They might just quit. Or buy ISK from the black market. Neither of these is good for the game, or for CCP.
|

Xelios
Minmatar Rampage Eternal Ka-Tet
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:26:00 -
[57]
Maybe it's just because I'm really tired, but I'm totally lost here.
Quote: In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
 
So a financially challenged person will be able to *buy* GTC's directly from CCP, but trading GTC's for ISK will no longer be allowed? What am I missing here?
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:28:00 -
[58]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space.
Why oh WHY would you say this?
I quit WoW because it became a horrible, ****ty grindfest past level 45. I play EVE for the PvP - I enjoy it and it's a great, unique experience. I don't like having to mine for six hours to fit out a HAC. EVE has always been very attractive to casual players with the GTCs and the offline skill training, and removing this is a slap in A) The face of casual MMO-players everywhere and B) CCP's accounting deparment.
You don't have to mine. Having to buy your stuffs with RL money because you fail at Eve means, well, you fail at Eve.
There is a reason the good stuff has to be earned. Don't circumvent the game's design. FFS. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:28:00 -
[59]
Originally by: Hannisk Thanks CCP for fixing this huge issue that was causing massive damage to the game and ruining it for players everywhere.
I'm also happy you got your priorities straight and fixed it before less important issues like:
a) lag. Fleet fights being unplayable. b) fleet system causing lag. c) supercapitals.
None of the above are important issues that need fixing, no not at all.
Somtimes I really hate you CCP.
Yeah, getting (for example) your POS you've worked hard to earn blown up by some kid who used daddy's credit card to buy a Dread isn't an issue at all.
|

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:28:00 -
[60]
Originally by: Xelios Maybe it's just because I'm really tired, but I'm totally lost here.
Quote: In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
 
So a financially challenged person will be able to *buy* GTC's directly from CCP, but trading GTC's for ISK will no longer be allowed? What am I missing here?
Nothing your reading it as everyone else is Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

Team Chk
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:28:00 -
[61]
Originally by: Hannisk Thanks CCP for fixing this huge issue that was causing massive damage to the game and ruining it for players everywhere.
I'm also happy you got your priorities straight and fixed it before less important issues like:
a) lag. Fleet fights being unplayable. b) fleet system causing lag. c) supercapitals.
None of the above are important issues that need fixing, no not at all.
Somtimes I really hate you CCP.
It's called: procrastination
|

Ionia
Advanced Manufacturing
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:28:00 -
[62]
If this change is what I think it is, FANTASTIC!
I have had concerns about players that have been doing this, and even asked questions by petition recently that confirmed that it was not a EULA violation.
What people have been doing is buying GTCs with ISK then selling the GTCs on ebay for cash.
Doing it that way is NOT a violation of the eula.
I think what they are proposing is to get rid of the actual code itself, so that people can buy game time credit through the CCP web site and sell it for isk, but people cant buy codes and sell them on ebay for isk.
I think they will handle 3rd party sales by either a referral program or a simple API so that reselling companies wont be affected.
This plan is a great one, why? Ill give you an example..
There is one person in particular who does not actually play eve, they spend their whole day reselling GTCs, which makes them a fortune, 20-50m profit per GTC, and moving about 100 per day, these numbers are from the person's own info. Recently they started 50 new accounts, yes, 50, which they plan to train up, sell, buy GTCs with that ISK, and sell it on ebay. They mentioned in Jita local a few weeks ago that they forcast a net profit of $15,000 from this.
That kind of thing is disgusting to me, so any change to make it harder is fantastic.
The system CCP mentions could eliminate the problem competely if they make the system such that a GTC credit can only be sold for isk ONCE through the system, this would eliminate any way to buy them with ISK and resell them for cash.
Overall, a good step by CCP.
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:29:00 -
[63]
Edited by: Craam Hustler on 04/05/2007 23:28:17
Originally by: Briana Flametop
Originally by: Craam Hustler Not everyone will be able to afford the time codes, and those that may want to keep their ISK might rather pay with $$$$
They might just quit. Or buy ISK from the black market. Neither of these is good for the game, or for CCP.
And they risk getting banned. 
Originally by: Ionia If this change is what I think it is, FANTASTIC!
I have had concerns about players that have been doing this, and even asked questions by petition recently that confirmed that it was not a EULA violation.
What people have been doing is buying GTCs with ISK then selling the GTCs on ebay for cash.
Doing it that way is NOT a violation of the eula.
I think what they are proposing is to get rid of the actual code itself, so that people can buy game time credit through the CCP web site and sell it for isk, but people cant buy codes and sell them on ebay for isk.
I think they will handle 3rd party sales by either a referral program or a simple API so that reselling companies wont be affected.
This plan is a great one, why? Ill give you an example..
There is one person in particular who does not actually play eve, they spend their whole day reselling GTCs, which makes them a fortune, 20-50m profit per GTC, and moving about 100 per day, these numbers are from the person's own info. Recently they started 50 new accounts, yes, 50, which they plan to train up, sell, buy GTCs with that ISK, and sell it on ebay. They mentioned in Jita local a few weeks ago that they forcast a net profit of $15,000 from this.
That kind of thing is disgusting to me, so any change to make it harder is fantastic.
The system CCP mentions could eliminate the problem competely if they make the system such that a GTC credit can only be sold for isk ONCE through the system, this would eliminate any way to buy them with ISK and resell them for cash.
Overall, a good step by CCP.
Yes, this was one of my biggest concerns. I petitioned about this very issue and I was shocked to have the GM say it was legit, they mentioned they didn't like it, but it was legit none the less. And there are some players that are very blatantly doing this.
|

Montague Zooma
Imperial Dreams Curatores Veritatis Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:30:00 -
[64]
It's the latest trend in the game biz. I hear Hasbro will now let you buy games with Monopoly money.
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:31:00 -
[65]
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Originally by: Hannisk Thanks CCP for fixing this huge issue that was causing massive damage to the game and ruining it for players everywhere.
I'm also happy you got your priorities straight and fixed it before less important issues like:
a) lag. Fleet fights being unplayable. b) fleet system causing lag. c) supercapitals.
None of the above are important issues that need fixing, no not at all.
Somtimes I really hate you CCP.
Yeah, getting (for example) your POS you've worked hard to earn blown up by some kid who used daddy's credit card to buy a Dread isn't an issue at all.
If I may say, using that argument, that kid would have to drop $500+ on ISK for a dread character alone, and $200+ for his dread and fittings. He won't know how to fly it for jack **** so it will be a free $700 kill for you and your corp. And really, how many parents are there that give their kids a thousand dollars to spend on a single video game? This argument comes up very often and is fallacious due to its extreme improbability. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:32:00 -
[66]
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space.
Why oh WHY would you say this?
I quit WoW because it became a horrible, ****ty grindfest past level 45. I play EVE for the PvP - I enjoy it and it's a great, unique experience. I don't like having to mine for six hours to fit out a HAC. EVE has always been very attractive to casual players with the GTCs and the offline skill training, and removing this is a slap in A) The face of casual MMO-players everywhere and B) CCP's accounting deparment.
You don't have to mine. Having to buy your stuffs with RL money because you fail at Eve means, well, you fail at Eve.
There is a reason the good stuff has to be earned. Don't circumvent the game's design. FFS.
You are quite the moron. Not everybody is going to be able to make their money in-game without having to grind for it, not even all the people who don't want to grind their ISK are going to be able to because economy doesn't work that way. Unless you think the guy down at the corner gas station really wants to be working that job for $5.50 an hour.
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:32:00 -
[67]
Originally by: Ionia
words
Don't believe everything you hear in Jita local. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Roscoe Rhoads
Caldari Provisions
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:33:00 -
[68]
Originally by: Roscoe Rhoads *snip*- don't troll
Wasn't trolling really as much as an honest and clear appraisal of CCP's recent moral fiber.
To add content: holy cow are macro miners gonna get an upswing out of this!
Also, I'm unsubbing my accounts ofcourse.
-- Human action is purposeful behavior. |

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:34:00 -
[69]
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space.
Why oh WHY would you say this?
I quit WoW because it became a horrible, ****ty grindfest past level 45. I play EVE for the PvP - I enjoy it and it's a great, unique experience. I don't like having to mine for six hours to fit out a HAC. EVE has always been very attractive to casual players with the GTCs and the offline skill training, and removing this is a slap in A) The face of casual MMO-players everywhere and B) CCP's accounting deparment.
You don't have to mine. Having to buy your stuffs with RL money because you fail at Eve means, well, you fail at Eve.
There is a reason the good stuff has to be earned. Don't circumvent the game's design. FFS.
Sometimes people with less free time play MMOs for the community but want the game to remain FUN. Mining is not fun. You'll understand when you're out of high school/college. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:35:00 -
[70]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space.
Why oh WHY would you say this?
I quit WoW because it became a horrible, ****ty grindfest past level 45. I play EVE for the PvP - I enjoy it and it's a great, unique experience. I don't like having to mine for six hours to fit out a HAC. EVE has always been very attractive to casual players with the GTCs and the offline skill training, and removing this is a slap in A) The face of casual MMO-players everywhere and B) CCP's accounting deparment.
You don't have to mine. Having to buy your stuffs with RL money because you fail at Eve means, well, you fail at Eve.
There is a reason the good stuff has to be earned. Don't circumvent the game's design. FFS.
You are quite the moron. Not everybody is going to be able to make their money in-game without having to grind for it, not even all the people who don't want to grind their ISK are going to be able to because economy doesn't work that way. Unless you think the guy down at the corner gas station really wants to be working that job for $5.50 an hour.
Opens with an insult, closes with a comparison to RL, and suggests in middle that Eve is supposed to cater to people who can't or won't play it the way it is designed to be played.
Fail. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

Akita T
Caldari Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:35:00 -
[71]
Originally by: CCP kieron In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
Either way, CCP loses a portion of their real-life income, while creating an ISK sink.
Sounds like a noble thing to do, assuming it would do any good. So, let's see what good it does.
1. The issue of RMT-ers. True, they can no longer buy GTCs to resell for real money, so that avenue for income gets shot down. That however assumes this was alway the main method of RMTers to sell ISK... I somehow really doubt it. Sure, you get a larger "traceable footprint" in-game for them, and a higher chance of discovery, but you might end up rounding up people for EULA breaches where no actual breach took part on one hand, or not being able to catch actual EULA breachers masking their RMTs as, say corp theft, scamming or whatnot.
2. The issue of borderline-cheaters (pay $ to get GTC to get ISK) Right now, no matter how much you try to deny it, there are people playing simply because they are willing and able to pay real money to finance their expensive tastes, without having to resort to grinding. While a vast majority of players (myself included) don't like the idea that some people can get an in-game advantage just by spending more real-life money directly, you'd be hard-pressed to deny the fact there ARE legitimate loopholes for them to keep shifting money for ISK even if you cease the simple "via GTC" method (for instance, research alts churning out datacores, or pre-skilled but otherwise unused character sales). All it solves is make it more complicated, driving even more people to either purchase ISK from RMTers or just quit playing.
3. The issue of the time-rich, real-life-poor more or less casual player I can only assume the "going rates" for ISK-to-gametime conversions will not be as "forgiving" as the current GTC trade levels. I mean, come on, a highsec L4 missionrunner barely needs 20 to 30 hours of gametime to pay for a month of gametime with the current GTC trade rates. And don't get me started on traders or "profitable" T2 BPO manufacturers, or complex farmers, they barely have to "work" a day for that. Either way, this would only mean true casual players get shifted out, farmers get a free ride. The ones taxing the system play for free, the ones barely logging in but still providing (with current GTC rules) the same amount of income to CCP get phased out.
So basically, you are shooting your own foot. _ MySkills | Module/Rig stacknerfing explained |

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:35:00 -
[72]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Ionia
words
Don't believe everything you hear in Jita local.
I believe what I see with my eyes. I saw the same thing going on with my eyes. This person doesnt sleep and is online all day. So obviously they have to be making money somehow in order to live.
And if they are in EVE 23/7, I dont see how they could make any money elsewhere.
|

Stakhanov
Shih Yang Tong
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:35:00 -
[73]
I had an intense , but 2-tiered reaction to this...
1) Yay !
2) ...wtf ?
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:37:00 -
[74]
Seriously CCP, somehow prevent people from re-selling GTCs bought with isk for RL cash, but do not ruin EVE for thousands of casual players. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:38:00 -
[75]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Originally by: Hannisk Thanks CCP for fixing this huge issue that was causing massive damage to the game and ruining it for players everywhere.
I'm also happy you got your priorities straight and fixed it before less important issues like:
a) lag. Fleet fights being unplayable. b) fleet system causing lag. c) supercapitals.
None of the above are important issues that need fixing, no not at all.
Somtimes I really hate you CCP.
Yeah, getting (for example) your POS you've worked hard to earn blown up by some kid who used daddy's credit card to buy a Dread isn't an issue at all.
If I may say, using that argument, that kid would have to drop $500+ on ISK for a dread character alone, and $200+ for his dread and fittings. He won't know how to fly it for jack **** so it will be a free $700 kill for you and your corp. And really, how many parents are there that give their kids a thousand dollars to spend on a single video game? This argument comes up very often and is fallacious due to its extreme improbability.
It's an extreme example to prove a point. And your own point is invalid for many reasons;
1. You assume the person doesn't already have a dread capable character. I never said they didn't.
2. You assume they wouldn't know how to fly it. Again, I never said anything of the sort. Buying isk with cash != not knowing how to play the game.
3. The daddy's creditcard is a line used as insult to those who buy ISK. Chances are they are not really kiddies, chances are they're losers who take their game waaaaay too seriously, to the point they'll do anything to win, metagaming most definately included.
4. Again, it was an extreme example. If he buys a HAC and blows up my HAC I earned ingame, I'd be annoyed. He's circumnavigating my effort with his wallet. That's not on.
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:42:00 -
[76]
Originally by: Nero Scuro
It's an extreme example to prove a point. And your own point is invalid for many reasons;
1. You assume the person doesn't already have a dread capable character. I never said they didn't.
2. You assume they wouldn't know how to fly it. Again, I never said anything of the sort. Buying isk with cash != not knowing how to play the game.
3. The daddy's creditcard is a line used as insult to those who buy ISK. Chances are they are not really kiddies, chances are they're losers who take their game waaaaay too seriously, to the point they'll do anything to win, metagaming most definately included.
4. Again, it was an extreme example. If he buys a HAC and blows up my HAC I earned ingame, I'd be annoyed. He's circumnavigating my effort with his wallet. That's not on.
If he's been around long enough to be able to fly dreads, he very likely knows the game well enough to grind up the cash (at least partially) in a short amount of time, circumventing a spending of RL cash.
Metagaming is already a huge part of EVE and an attractive quality - how many people have joined because of friends talking about the political landscape and spying and all that? I know I did.
He put effort into getting the money for that HAC too, he just did it in one currency and then converted to another. And learn how to fly your HACs better :P
- Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:43:00 -
[77]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space.
Why oh WHY would you say this?
I quit WoW because it became a horrible, ****ty grindfest past level 45. I play EVE for the PvP - I enjoy it and it's a great, unique experience. I don't like having to mine for six hours to fit out a HAC. EVE has always been very attractive to casual players with the GTCs and the offline skill training, and removing this is a slap in A) The face of casual MMO-players everywhere and B) CCP's accounting deparment.
You don't have to mine. Having to buy your stuffs with RL money because you fail at Eve means, well, you fail at Eve.
There is a reason the good stuff has to be earned. Don't circumvent the game's design. FFS.
Sometimes people with less free time play MMOs for the community but want the game to remain FUN. Mining is not fun. You'll understand when you're out of high school/college.
Eve is not the game they are looking for. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

Al Thorr
Caldari The Wheel
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:44:00 -
[78]
Sorry Im a tad slow - but when has isk become real currency aka IMF etc??
So ccp who( can manufacture isk at will) will sell to players , game time for isk.
or are ccp going to add a currency conversion charge?
I really would like to know ,where ccp are going get their "proper money" from, should, in the real, worst case scenario, everyone exchanges isk for game time ?
Any way apologies for being slow
Al Thorr
"You cant polish a turd" - The new rendered font is living proof.
|

Vidar Kentoran
Minmatar Provenance.
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:44:00 -
[79]
It's not financially sensible for CCP to sell game time for isk directly, not going to happen. It would be nice if this was clarified into a real description of the way the new transactions will work.
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:45:00 -
[80]
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Eve is not the game they are looking for.
It has been for several years, and an enjoyable one. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:46:00 -
[81]
Additionally, if CCP did this, how the HELL would the conversion rate be determined? - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Firane
0utbreak
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:46:00 -
[82]
Its funny how all the ISK buyers (aka GTC resellers) are now worried about 'CCPs income'.
You are only worried about now not being able to buy ISK. God forbid CCP take a step in the right direction for a small decline in profits.
-----
|

Whalesaver
mega mining corporation Hydra Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:47:00 -
[83]
Surely the obvious next step to this is that CCP will start selling isk for $ (I understand some Korean MMORPG's do this already)
Revenue streams replaced, middlemen bite the dust and casual players essentially pay for hardcore players accounts.
Win Win. -----------------------
Doesn't shoot first Will ask questions later And enjoys a nice cup of tea |

Rod Blaine
Evolution Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:47:00 -
[84]
I think youre all reading way too much in this.
In practice, i read it as the current system NOT changing at all, other then that any and all GTC for isk trades will be going through the account management page, and that every buyer has to either use the gtc himself right away, or sell it to someone that uses it right away or something like that. There will be no more reselling of gtc's by players.
Buying isk indirectly would still work, but selling isk for cash wholesale by using gtc's as go-between would not.
It's like, a method to keep tabs on whose selling how many gtc's to whom for what isk. Sounds pretty logical to me, especially if they plan on taking it further at a later stage.
Oh, but it's not exactly comforting to see that CCP somehow equate this with something that increases their ability to stop the sale of isk for rl cash. For some unfathomable reason there's still absolute craploads of farming going on, while there should be alot less market for all that isk. Who is buying all that isk that doesn't go through gtc's ?
[center] Old blog |

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:48:00 -
[85]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Eve is not the game they are looking for.
It has been for several years, and an enjoyable one.
No, if they get their stuffs using RL money, it's not. Eve is a lot about earning the stuff you have, it can be quite satisfying. You'll understand that when you're out of high school/college. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

Roscoe Rhoads
Caldari Provisions
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:48:00 -
[86]
Last input from the mind of a GTC'er.
I earn ~$65 per hour IRL.
One hour of mindlessly boring ratting or mission running is at tops 100 million ISK.
One GTC, with a ____MARKET ECONOMY THAT CCP WON'T BE ABLE TO MATCH____ costs me $15 for 120-160 million ISK.
I play EVE Online for the PvP, and I will quit playing and quit giving CCP upwards $100 when this is implemented - and I'm guessing thousands of others will too. I don't understand how you feel this is a good idea.
-- Human action is purposeful behavior. |

Akita T
Caldari Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:48:00 -
[87]
Originally by: CCP kieron [stuff] that will hopefully clear up some of the confusion created earlier.
Actually, it confuses us even more.
As most of us understand, you just said people can buy gametime from CCP with ISK. For the most of us, the ones that understood it like that, IT MAKES NO SENSE.
If you somehow mean that you will make it able to transfer gametime from char A to char B in exchange for some ISK going from char B to char A, then say it like that. That one makes sense to a degree, but it's not what you said. _ MySkills | Module/Rig stacknerfing explained |

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:51:00 -
[88]
Kieron you're a really nice guy and I don't mean any offense at all by this but please run announcement posts like this by someone with a more comprehensive grasp of English grammar, these threads always devolve into 20-page circular arguments about what exactly you meant. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:51:00 -
[89]
Originally by: Crumplecorn Eve is not the game they are looking for.
No, Eve as you perceive it is not the game he's looking for. You however are an idiot so its not much of a stretch to realize that you have zero clue what the hell you're talking about, and can safely be ignored on that fact.
As far as your pathetic attempt to wittily reply to my earlier attempt at educating you on realities, economy doesn't care about in-game or out of game. The fact remains that there are not enough "high-end" jobs where you don't end up grinding for your money that everyone who so wishes them can have one, thats a basic premise of having something to lose in the game. Unfortunately you're too retarded to understand that fact.
|

Smelly Kelly
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:51:00 -
[90]
Originally by: Rod Blaine I think youre all reading way too much in this.
In practice, i read it as the current system NOT changing at all, other then that any and all GTC for isk trades will be going through the account management page, and that every buyer has to either use the gtc himself right away, or sell it to someone that uses it right away or something like that. There will be no more reselling of gtc's by players.
Buying isk indirectly would still work, but selling isk for cash wholesale by using gtc's as go-between would not.
It's like, a method to keep tabs on whose selling how many gtc's to whom for what isk. Sounds pretty logical to me, especially if they plan on taking it further at a later stage.
Oh, but it's not exactly comforting to see that CCP somehow equate this with something that increases their ability to stop the sale of isk for rl cash. For some unfathomable reason there's still absolute craploads of farming going on, while there should be alot less market for all that isk. Who is buying all that isk that doesn't go through gtc's ?
CCP said players will no longer be able to sell GTC for isk. So your theory doesn't fit.
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:52:00 -
[91]
Edited by: Craam Hustler on 04/05/2007 23:49:37
Originally by: Montague Zooma It's the latest trend in the game biz. I hear Hasbro will now let you buy games with Monopoly money.
How would you feel if I play monopoly with you. After the game starts, I pay someone for a monoply board game, take that money out, and use it to buy all of the properties on the board.
Yeah thats real fair huh.
|

Argenton Sayvers
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:53:00 -
[92]
Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 04/05/2007 23:50:31
Originally by: Rod Blaine makes sense
You understood what kieron was saying. proof that there must be DEVS IN BOB!!!!!!
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:54:00 -
[93]
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Fail.
Lame over-played 4chan catchphrases do not valid points make. Though I understand what you're saying on the last one - how many people do you know that would actually do that? If such people even exist in any fashion (I've only heard of them rhetorically in arguments like these), they would comprise something ridiculous like 0.01% of the playing population. Therefore, the likelihood you would ever interact with one and have your game experience altered as a result is similarly low. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |
|

Rauth Kivaro
Forum Moderator Interstellar Services Department

|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:55:00 -
[94]
Just a word here by way of preventative maintenance: I know this is a subject that many of you have strong opinions on and I'm sure everyone wants to have a chance to have their voice heard on a topic of such importance to the EVE community.
But please, keep it civil and within the forum rules.
Thanks!
Rauth Kivaro, CRC, A division of ISD |
|

Akita T
Caldari Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:56:00 -
[95]
Edited by: Akita T on 04/05/2007 23:54:09
Originally by: PDoggy Kieron you're a really nice guy and I don't mean any offense at all by this but please run announcement posts like this by someone with a more comprehensive grasp of English grammar, these threads always devolve into 20-page circular arguments about what exactly you meant.
I grudgingly (anger management issues) endorse this post (due to the fact the post is spot on the problem).
Originally by: Rauth Kivaro I know this is a subject that many of you have strong opinions on and I'm sure everyone wants to have a chance to have their voice heard on a topic of such importance to the EVE community.
Now if we only knew what exactly we are arguing about in the first place... _ MySkills | Module/Rig stacknerfing explained |

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:57:00 -
[96]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Tetsujin or FNLN or whoever you are exactly stop calling people retards it's making you and me by proxy sound like *******s. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Smelly Kelly
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:57:00 -
[97]
Originally by: Argenton Sayvers Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 04/05/2007 23:50:31
Originally by: Rod Blaine makes sense
You understood what kieron was saying. proof that there must be DEVS IN BOB!!!!!!
I don't think he did understand it. Kieron mentioned that many players would be upset over this change, and those players may leave EVE. If they were simply cutting out GTC resellers like Amber Leonne and making the system automated through the account system then why would he say that?
|

Al Thorr
Caldari The Wheel
|
Posted - 2007.05.04 23:58:00 -
[98]
This has got to be a seriously late April fool ... Imho
CCp runs on Euros or dollars. to earn a living / reason for its existance. , from a player base ie us the player . Not an imaginary made up, in game, currency. CCp then decides to sell its 'Time' for the currency ingame. - Hmm how many RAMdiscs can be bought with isk / hoopaloopa / Make up name here... as many times as you like...
Gotta be an April fool.
Al Thorr
"You cant polish a turd" - The new rendered font is living proof.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:00:00 -
[99]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Fail.
Lame over-played 4chan catchphrases do not valid points make. Though I understand what you're saying on the last one - how many people do you know that would actually do that? If such people even exist in any fashion (I've only heard of them rhetorically in arguments like these), they would comprise something ridiculous like 0.01% of the playing population. Therefore, the likelihood you would ever interact with one and have your game experience altered as a result is similarly low.
While we're inventing figures, I say it's 56.2% of EVE's population.
I'm not going to bother arguing this with you. I've made my point, if you don't get it yet you never will.
|

Soulita
Gallente Inner Core
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:00:00 -
[100]
Edited by: Soulita on 04/05/2007 23:56:22
If CCP realy intends to outlaw private GTC selling and intends to sell GTC for isk themselves instead - all I can say is respect!
Nice isk sink, good for slowing inflation, and people can not buy isk for RL cash anymore.
Very nice. 
|

Ionia
Advanced Manufacturing
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:00:00 -
[101]
This is a partial copy of an email I sent to CCP with a proposed solution, I am posting it here as well so there is a better chance they will see it and take notice.
Your post created more questions than it provided answers I think, it was quite unclear what you are going to do. I have a suggestion here (I know my chances of being listened to are next to 0, but i've got to try)
This solution will do the following:
* Allow people with lots of time/isk to purchase game time with ISK * Allow people with little time/isk to sell game time for ISK * Stop resellers getting GTCs with ISK and selling them on eBay
This means that people can put cash into the game, which is good for those that want an isk boost, good for those that want to buy time for isk, and good for CCP because subscription numbers increase.
I know a lot of people with a lot of accounts (myself included) that would not be playing them if it was not for GTC to ISK.
Now, to my proposed solution...
Change GTC from Game Time Code to Game Time CREDIT
Have these credits as items accessable through the my account pages.
Allow people to buy them, as they already can, with the OPTION to activate them.
For those that want to sell them for ISK, allow them to do that as they already can, or, make a market type system in my account with buy and sell orders for game time.
The main feature is that when you buy game time credit from someone, it is automatically applied to your account. That means that you cant sell it on.
This will prevent people from buying GTC for ISK then selling them for CASH on eBay because there is no longer any code, and no longer any way to resell GTCs.
Now, the business side... This will maintain the status quo as far as CCP is concerned, they still make extra money from all the subscriptions that run from GTC to ISK, believe me, if you shut that option down, you would lose thousands if not tens of thousands in revenue.
The issue would be for the shatteredcrystal type resellers, since there are no longer any codes. You would get around this in one of two ways, the first would be a referral system, and the second, and by far the best, is to offer them a simple API.
With a simple API the GTC resellers (real ones) would simply have to add an 'account name' field to their order form, and the buyers would recieve a game time credit in their account, which they could either activate or sell for isk. Again, the only major difference is that there is no actual code.
Using the above solution, it is impossible to sell GTCs that have been bought with ISK, so this completely eliminates the ISK>GTC>EBAY situation which in my mind, is totally disgusting.
Hopefully you guys will use this solution or come up with another one that addresses all of the points. This situation, if you pardon my french, is very easy to **** up royally, so I hope you guys can get it right!
Thanks for reading once again, and thanks for doing something about these unscroupulous ********s that are ******* up our game.
-Ionia
|

Montague Zooma
Imperial Dreams Curatores Veritatis Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:00:00 -
[102]
Edited by: Montague Zooma on 04/05/2007 23:59:21
Originally by: Craam Hustler Edited by: Craam Hustler on 04/05/2007 23:49:37
Originally by: Montague Zooma It's the latest trend in the game biz. I hear Hasbro will now let you buy games with Monopoly money.
How would you feel if I play monopoly with you. After the game starts, I pay someone for a monoply board game, take that money out, and use it to buy all of the properties on the board.
Yeah thats real fair huh.
I'm not referring to the appropriateness of buying isk for real cash.
My remark is a reaction to Kieron's unclear post. It sounds like CCP will sell you game time for isk...which would be the same as Hasbro selling you games for Monopoly money. This doesn't make sense to me.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:02:00 -
[103]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Tetsujin or FNLN or whoever you are exactly stop calling people retards it's making you and me by proxy sound like *******s.
Sorry not either. And I'll stop calling him an idiot when he stops being one. The fact that he thinks that theres some magical way everyone can come up with a way to get their ISK for little effort shows he's an idiot. Either that or he thinks everyone plays to grind out ISK mining or ratting because staring at an asteroid belt with crappy, easy to beat NPC's because its somehow fun and an accomplishment. This is coming from someone who does grind out their ISK, enough to pay for the game without spending real money on it.
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:02:00 -
[104]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Originally by: Crumplecorn Eve is not the game they are looking for.
No, Eve as you perceive it is not the game he's looking for. You however are an idiot so its not much of a stretch to realize that you have zero clue what the hell you're talking about, and can safely be ignored on that fact.
As far as your pathetic attempt to wittily reply to my earlier attempt at educating you on realities, economy doesn't care about in-game or out of game. The fact remains that there are not enough "high-end" jobs where you don't end up grinding for your money that everyone who so wishes them can have one, thats a basic premise of having something to lose in the game. Unfortunately you're too retarded to understand that fact.
I understand that, you fail to grasp that Eve is, as you pointed out, designed this way, and people who buy ISK with RL money circumvent the design.
I wasn't trying to be witty, your posts simply don't warrant proper responses. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:03:00 -
[105]
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Fail.
Lame over-played 4chan catchphrases do not valid points make. Though I understand what you're saying on the last one - how many people do you know that would actually do that? If such people even exist in any fashion (I've only heard of them rhetorically in arguments like these), they would comprise something ridiculous like 0.01% of the playing population. Therefore, the likelihood you would ever interact with one and have your game experience altered as a result is similarly low.
While we're inventing figures, I say it's 56.2% of EVE's population.
I'm not going to bother arguing this with you. I've made my point, if you don't get it yet you never will.
When in doubt, claim aloofness and superiority to your opponent.  - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:04:00 -
[106]
ARGH! And stop posting 'CCP can't do this, they'll go bankrupt'. Clearly they can, or they wouldn't. They've almost certainly given it more thought that you have. And they've got access to there account books, so they'll know whether it's feasible or not.
For example - maybe if you play using ISK, you get ingame ads? That's where CCP will be getting their cash from? Kieron said he couldn't release all the details - that means there are more details yet to be disclosed (I shouldn't have to point this out, but apparently I do), we are not in possession of all the facts. CCP will no doubt not be giving out game time for free (although it's not beyond the realm of possible, I believe anarchy online is free?), wait and see what they have up their sleeve.
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:05:00 -
[107]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Tetsujin or FNLN or whoever you are exactly stop calling people retards it's making you and me by proxy sound like *******s.
Sorry not either. And I'll stop calling him an idiot when he stops being one. The fact that he thinks that theres some magical way everyone can come up with a way to get their ISK for little effort shows he's an idiot. Either that or he thinks everyone plays to grind out ISK mining or ratting because staring at an asteroid belt with crappy, easy to beat NPC's because its somehow fun and an accomplishment. This is coming from someone who does grind out their ISK, enough to pay for the game without spending real money on it.
I understand that not everyone can get ISK easily.
But, as a supporter of buying ISK with RL money, you think everyone should be able to, which negates the working to earn things and impact of loss on which Eve is based.
Who is the idiot here? -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

SiJira
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:05:00 -
[108]
Originally by: ToxicFire This is going to turn eve into meta gaming for big alliances.
thats a bad thing ? ____ __ ________ _sig below_ the jet cans are made so that people that dont mine can get free ore
miners ritually donate the ore to anyone wishing to take some |

J'Mkarr Soban
Amarr Viziam
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:05:00 -
[109]
Originally by: RightYouAre Ken Is English your 8th language or something, kieron, because seriously every post you make on this subject just confuses it more. Please tell us which of the following statements about the new system are false, if any:
1) Player A can buy timecards from CCP for Real Money. 2) Player B can buy timecards from Player A for ISK, (using CCP as a broker for the transaction). 3) All timecard affiliate programs will be shut down - the only valid timecard transactions will be handled directly through CCP. 4) This new system is intended to end timecard scams and put more money into CCP's wallet, (because they wouldn't be selling to affiliates at a discounted rate).
Woah, what?
You can buy game time (not the lack of the word card there) for ISK.
I.e instead of paying ú15 a month to play, you pay 125M ISK. (Or whatever the want).
The traditional method will still exist.
The GTCs will still exist.
You will not be able to buy GTC from another player for ISK, because you can buy the game time from CCP directly, for isk.
Not hard to follow, don't see why everyone is insulting Kieron. Makes perfect sense to me.
Look at it like this: I'm a student. I can pay all my bills, but this game is a luxury. I can spend the time to make 125M a week, I use one week to pay for my time in Eve, and the other three weeks what I want. Rinse and repeat. I don't have to pay CCP anything.
That's what has been posted.
To those few people that did pick up on it correctly: yes, that means that technically, everyone playing Eve doesn't need to pay any real money at all.
I love this idea because, like I said, I'm a poor student. But on the other hand, it makes no sense - where will CCP get the money from to generate new content etc? With a single shard universe like this, the pay-for-expansions won't work. The only other option is pay-for-content (i.e. I pay real money for a Scorpion). I quite like that idea, I think it's what Sony are/were trying to do with EQ. It reduces the ebuyers, makes it a safe transaction (cause it's being done with the developer), and would reduce farmers, unless they thought they could give you more isk for your real money.
Hmm.
-J --------------------------------- "He who 'hah hahs' last, 'hah hahs' best." - Nelson
Balanced != Nerfed |

Namingway
Important Yet Underrated Video Game Characters
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:06:00 -
[110]
Originally by: CCP kieron Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
Thank god.
One giant leap for stopping people with some extra cash IRL from cheating in EVE.
And yes, buying ISK, that involves you using RL $, is cheating.
People support wars and such with GTC ISK ffs. 
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:06:00 -
[111]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Fail.
Lame over-played 4chan catchphrases do not valid points make. Though I understand what you're saying on the last one - how many people do you know that would actually do that? If such people even exist in any fashion (I've only heard of them rhetorically in arguments like these), they would comprise something ridiculous like 0.01% of the playing population. Therefore, the likelihood you would ever interact with one and have your game experience altered as a result is similarly low.
While we're inventing figures, I say it's 56.2% of EVE's population.
I'm not going to bother arguing this with you. I've made my point, if you don't get it yet you never will.
When in doubt, claim aloofness and superiority to your opponent. 
I've made my point. There is no more point to make. What do you want me to do, endlessly repeat the same argument to you? I have better things to do myself.
|

Ionia
Advanced Manufacturing
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:06:00 -
[112]
This is why something needs to be done
The following logs are from Jita local, the only lines removed are ones that have no relavence whatsoever to the discussion.
[ 2007.04.28 05:47:49 ] Amber Leonne > Alrighty then, I'm outy, gonna try and start making these 50 characters. [[ 2007.04.28 05:47:57 ] Jurgen Cartis > 50 chars?!? [ 2007.04.28 05:48:18 ] Amber Leonne > For starters [ 2007.04.28 05:48:20 ] The Comatorium > hoo rah [ 2007.04.28 05:48:32 ] The Comatorium > split personalities? [ 2007.04.28 05:48:50 ] Amber Leonne > Nah, no one will ever hear a word out of these ones [ 2007.04.28 05:48:51 ] Ionia > o_O [ 2007.04.28 05:49:02 ] Ionia > what are you doing that for amber? [ 2007.04.28 05:49:14 ] Amber Leonne > Fleet of miners [ 2007.04.28 05:49:18 ] Ionia > lol [ 2007.04.28 05:49:19 ] The Comatorium > ($)-($) [ 2007.04.28 05:49:32 ] Ionia > how many PCs have you got? :p [ 2007.04.28 05:50:18 ] Amber Leonne > 0 [ 2007.04.28 05:50:39 ] Ionia > so what do you plan to do with them? [ 2007.04.28 05:50:51 ] Amber Leonne > Train them [ 2007.04.28 05:50:57 ] Ionia > then.. [ 2007.04.28 05:51:09 ] Anul Zakru > a SLave trader [ 2007.04.28 05:51:11 ] Anul Zakru > cool [ 2007.04.28 05:51:22 ] Ionia > sell them? [ 2007.04.28 05:51:30 ] Amber Leonne > ;) [ 2007.04.28 05:51:32 ] Anul Zakru > for iskys [ 2007.04.28 05:51:32 ] Amber Leonne > With assets [ 2007.04.28 05:51:37 ] Anul Zakru > more isky [ 2007.04.28 05:51:42 ] Amber Leonne > The fun part being that I can afford hundreds of Hulks too [ 2007.04.28 05:51:52 ] Ionia > you realise that will cost you USD$1000 for the transfer costs right? [ 2007.04.28 05:52:16 ] Anul Zakru > i working on buying skill books and needing cash for them and your planing too buy 100 hulks@@ [ 2007.04.28 05:52:28 ] Amber Leonne > And net about $15,000 after GTC conversion [ 2007.04.28 05:53:06 ] Ionia > you are selling gtcs for cash now too? [ 2007.04.28 05:53:18 ] Anul Zakru > it's legal [ 2007.04.28 05:54:56 ] Amber Leonne > Later folks =)
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:07:00 -
[113]
Originally by: Nero Scuro ARGH! And stop posting 'CCP can't do this, they'll go bankrupt'. Clearly they can, or they wouldn't. They've almost certainly given it more thought that you have. And they've got access to there account books, so they'll know whether it's feasible or not.
For example - maybe if you play using ISK, you get ingame ads? That's where CCP will be getting their cash from? Kieron said he couldn't release all the details - that means there are more details yet to be disclosed (I shouldn't have to point this out, but apparently I do), we are not in possession of all the facts. CCP will no doubt not be giving out game time for free (although it's not beyond the realm of possible, I believe anarchy online is free?), wait and see what they have up their sleeve.
Why would CCP as a business ever want to remove a feature that is making them money, ensuring that every account paid for in ISK is still getting them $15 per month except from someone else, and that has been working for well over a year; all in the vague and undefined hopes they can stop something the kind of dedicated idiots that are determined to cash out of EVE will manage one way or another anyhow? - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:08:00 -
[114]
Originally by: Soulita Nice isk sink, good for slowing inflation, and people can not buy isk for RL cash anymore.
Yes they can - they just don't do it via time-card sales or within the EULA. Instead of the $15 (or whatever) going to CCP, it'll go to the ISK-farmer's bank account. Sure, they can (and will) ban people for it - that's what every MMOG developer says and does. They absolutely will not be able to prevent it, though.
Unless there's a second part of this announcement which reads something like "You will now be able to buy ISK directly from CCP with RL cash", this plan has an incredibly high chance of being very bad for the game. |

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:11:00 -
[115]
Originally by: Ionia alot of somewhat unlikely stuff...
Maybe Amber Leonne should just get banned for GTC conversion. There goes your argument. ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:11:00 -
[116]
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Tetsujin or FNLN or whoever you are exactly stop calling people retards it's making you and me by proxy sound like *******s.
Sorry not either. And I'll stop calling him an idiot when he stops being one. The fact that he thinks that theres some magical way everyone can come up with a way to get their ISK for little effort shows he's an idiot. Either that or he thinks everyone plays to grind out ISK mining or ratting because staring at an asteroid belt with crappy, easy to beat NPC's because its somehow fun and an accomplishment. This is coming from someone who does grind out their ISK, enough to pay for the game without spending real money on it.
I understand that not everyone can get ISK easily.
But, as a supporter of buying ISK with RL money, you think everyone should be able to, which negates the working to earn things and impact of loss on which Eve is based.
Who is the idiot here?
You are, because there are people who can basically print ISK, but they got there by virtue of being A) lucky, B) in the right timezone, C) happened to sign up first. None of those seem like any kind of system for a GAME to determine who gets their stuff easiest. And like I said this comes from a person who works hard for their ISK, probably harder than you do, because I purchase gametime with ISK.
|

Rod Blaine
Evolution Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:13:00 -
[117]
Originally by: Smelly Kelly Edited by: Smelly Kelly on 04/05/2007 23:55:19
Originally by: Argenton Sayvers Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 04/05/2007 23:50:31
Originally by: Rod Blaine makes sense
You understood what kieron was saying. proof that there must be DEVS IN BOB!!!!!!
I don't think he did understand it. Kieron mentioned that many players would be upset over this change, and those players may leave EVE. If they were simply cutting out GTC resellers like Amber Leonne and making the system automated through the account system then why would he say that?
GTC resellers being cut out and the system being made automated would make things easier, why would so many people quit over this? I think theres more to it then CCP is letting on.
Wait and see.
I'm betting the ability to buy gamteime to resell though the acc management page is going to be limited. As in: you can sell only as much gametime as you're bought for your own accounts. Just as example, but that is one aspect that also always has been missing from the "arrangement" so far.
[center] Old blog |

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:13:00 -
[118]
Originally by: Ionia This is why something needs to be done
The following logs are from Jita local, the only lines removed are ones that have no relavence whatsoever to the discussion.
[ 2007.04.28 05:47:49 ] Amber Leonne > Alrighty then, I'm outy, gonna try and start making these 50 characters. [[ 2007.04.28 05:47:57 ] Jurgen Cartis > 50 chars?!? [ 2007.04.28 05:48:18 ] Amber Leonne > For starters [ 2007.04.28 05:48:20 ] The Comatorium > hoo rah [ 2007.04.28 05:48:32 ] The Comatorium > split personalities? [ 2007.04.28 05:48:50 ] Amber Leonne > Nah, no one will ever hear a word out of these ones [ 2007.04.28 05:48:51 ] Ionia > o_O [ 2007.04.28 05:49:02 ] Ionia > what are you doing that for amber? [ 2007.04.28 05:49:14 ] Amber Leonne > Fleet of miners [ 2007.04.28 05:49:18 ] Ionia > lol [ 2007.04.28 05:49:19 ] The Comatorium > ($)-($) [ 2007.04.28 05:49:32 ] Ionia > how many PCs have you got? :p [ 2007.04.28 05:50:18 ] Amber Leonne > 0 [ 2007.04.28 05:50:39 ] Ionia > so what do you plan to do with them? [ 2007.04.28 05:50:51 ] Amber Leonne > Train them [ 2007.04.28 05:50:57 ] Ionia > then.. [ 2007.04.28 05:51:09 ] Anul Zakru > a SLave trader [ 2007.04.28 05:51:11 ] Anul Zakru > cool [ 2007.04.28 05:51:22 ] Ionia > sell them? [ 2007.04.28 05:51:30 ] Amber Leonne > ;) [ 2007.04.28 05:51:32 ] Anul Zakru > for iskys [ 2007.04.28 05:51:32 ] Amber Leonne > With assets [ 2007.04.28 05:51:37 ] Anul Zakru > more isky [ 2007.04.28 05:51:42 ] Amber Leonne > The fun part being that I can afford hundreds of Hulks too [ 2007.04.28 05:51:52 ] Ionia > you realise that will cost you USD$1000 for the transfer costs right? [ 2007.04.28 05:52:16 ] Anul Zakru > i working on buying skill books and needing cash for them and your planing too buy 100 hulks@@ [ 2007.04.28 05:52:28 ] Amber Leonne > And net about $15,000 after GTC conversion [ 2007.04.28 05:53:06 ] Ionia > you are selling gtcs for cash now too? [ 2007.04.28 05:53:18 ] Anul Zakru > it's legal [ 2007.04.28 05:54:56 ] Amber Leonne > Later folks =)
Vonderful! 
|

Ionia
Advanced Manufacturing
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:14:00 -
[119]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Ionia alot of somewhat unlikely stuff...
Maybe Amber Leonne should just get banned for GTC conversion. There goes your argument.
Banned? What she is doing is within the EULA, that is why this situation needs to be addressed.
|

mother quafe
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:15:00 -
[120]
now casual players buy 100m and spend them on whatever.
if all the casual players cant afford whatever anymore, then a) prices for whatever will decrease or b) they will not be the only one who dont have whatever --> not hac vs hac, but cruiser vs cruiser
sounds pretty fair to me
1)  2)  3) ? 4) profit! .......?
|

Montague Zooma
Imperial Dreams Curatores Veritatis Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:15:00 -
[121]
Originally by: J'Mkarr Soban
To those few people that did pick up on it correctly: yes, that means that technically, everyone playing Eve doesn't need to pay any real money at all.
If no one pays any real money to CCP, they'll go out of business.
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:17:00 -
[122]
Originally by: Montague Zooma
Originally by: J'Mkarr Soban
To those few people that did pick up on it correctly: yes, that means that technically, everyone playing Eve doesn't need to pay any real money at all.
If no one pays any real money to CCP, they'll go out of business.
Yeah but if everyone gives all of their ISK to CCP to pay for a few months of codes everyone will run out of ISK and have to go back to $$$$
And a lot of people would rather spend the $$$ to keep the ISK.
|

Al Thorr
Caldari The Wheel
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:17:00 -
[123]
right last rant :)
To Kieron - you(as in CCP) initially allowed sale of GTCs for isk. As a way to generate income from an enlarging player base.
Now you are saying that ....
After hundreds of posts telling you ( ccp ) were fools to allow such transactions as it would destroy the loyalty/ integrity amongst the player base ( ie Cash - gtc - isk - gtc - cash)
- "Oops we are changing our minds."
Hate to say we 'told you so' but you were warned . and isnt there a phrase with the words "stable " " bolt" horse" and "door" in it.?
Regards
Al Thorr -( yes Ive bought gtcs for isk)
"You cant polish a turd" - The new rendered font is living proof.
|

Space Pirate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:17:00 -
[124]
To those of you whining about how absolutely TERRIBLE it is that people are paying for others' subscriptions to get some game money, can you at least TRY to grasp the concept of macroeconimcs? Just a little?
Large economies don't work the same way little ones do. A good example of a little economy is your wallet. When someone buys a timecard and sells it to someone for isk, it appears that money is "created" from nowhere from your perspective, but what actually happens is not isk appearing from nowhere. The person selling their isk for game time got it somewhere, be it mining (which is productive, introduces more minerals on the market making YOUR leet-o PVP pewpew master cheaper), ratting, renting out systems to tenants, mission running, whatever. The money doesn't come from nowhere, it is just redirected with the agreement that one party will pay for subscription time for another party.
I know you purists think you're some kind of leet badasses for spending forever playing and either spending lots of time mining/mission running/whatever to pay for your cool PVP ships or coming up with some kind of high-end job like being the director of a corporation that leases systems out to tenants, but the fact is that the game cannot support everyone having "big" jobs and lots of people don't have as much time to play and are willing to pay money to skip to the fun parts. There is nothing wrong with it, and it does not ruin YOUR game experience, and in fact does more to enhance it than ruin it (so some idiot buys an account and a mothership and he can't fly it? Easier for you to blow up! Then you can laugh that he spent hundreds of real dollars for something so stupid!) so really, stop *****ing about people who enjoy different play styles than you and enjoy the game doing whatever it is you do.
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:19:00 -
[125]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Tetsujin or FNLN or whoever you are exactly stop calling people retards it's making you and me by proxy sound like *******s.
Sorry not either. And I'll stop calling him an idiot when he stops being one. The fact that he thinks that theres some magical way everyone can come up with a way to get their ISK for little effort shows he's an idiot. Either that or he thinks everyone plays to grind out ISK mining or ratting because staring at an asteroid belt with crappy, easy to beat NPC's because its somehow fun and an accomplishment. This is coming from someone who does grind out their ISK, enough to pay for the game without spending real money on it.
I understand that not everyone can get ISK easily.
But, as a supporter of buying ISK with RL money, you think everyone should be able to, which negates the working to earn things and impact of loss on which Eve is based.
Who is the idiot here?
You are, because there are people who can basically print ISK, but they got there by virtue of being A) lucky, B) in the right timezone, C) happened to sign up first. None of those seem like any kind of system for a GAME to determine who gets their stuff easiest. And like I said this comes from a person who works hard for their ISK, probably harder than you do, because I purchase gametime with ISK.
Oh, are you one of those 'we should all have equal opportunities' people?
Yes, some people got there early and basically won EVE. That's part of the game. If you don't like it, once again, Eve is not the game you are looking for.
Also, your logic in that post is basically that some stuff in eve is wrong, so some other wrong stuff should be kept, because two wrongs make a right.
I must once again question the validity of the application of derogatory comments in this thread. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:21:00 -
[126]
Originally by: mother quafe now casual players buy 100m and spend them on whatever.
if all the casual players cant afford whatever anymore, then a) prices for whatever will decrease or b) they will not be the only one who dont have whatever --> not hac vs hac, but cruiser vs cruiser
sounds pretty fair to me
1)  2)  3) ? 4) profit! .......?
You misunderstand, the point is that the casual players can no longer purchase ISK legally. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

The Slayette
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:22:00 -
[127]
Originally by: Crumplecorn Oh, are you one of those 'we should all have equal opportunities' people?
Yes, some people got there early and basically won EVE. That's part of the game. If you don't like it, once again, Eve is not the game you are looking for.
Yeh man, Crumplecorn pays a higher subscription than you, he deserves to enjoy the game more with his isk printing machine. *snip*
No personal attacks, please. -Rauth Kivaro ([email protected])
|

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:24:00 -
[128]
Originally by: Craam Hustler Yeah but if everyone gives all of their ISK to CCP to pay for a few months of codes everyone will run out of ISK and have to go back to $$$$
If spending a couple of days a month farming ISK is enough to pay for a month's subscription, nobody will run out of ISK. If it takes significantly more time than that, people will either turn to the black market RL cash->ISK trade, or just quit.
Either there is something more which we don't know yet (CCP selling isk for $$$, in-game advertising, whatever), or CCP have made what appears at the moment to be a poor decision. |

Roscoe Rhoads
Caldari Provisions
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:25:00 -
[129]
Originally by: Nero Scuro ARGH! And stop posting 'CCP can't do this, they'll go bankrupt'. Clearly they can, or they wouldn't. They've almost certainly given it more thought that you have.
kieron's post was hardly intelligble, ffs.
-- Human action is purposeful behavior. |

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:28:00 -
[130]
Originally by: The Slayette
Originally by: Crumplecorn Oh, are you one of those 'we should all have equal opportunities' people?
Yes, some people got there early and basically won EVE. That's part of the game. If you don't like it, once again, Eve is not the game you are looking for.
Yeh man, Crumplecorn pays a higher subscription than you, he deserves to enjoy the game more with his isk printing machine. Idiot.
Oh you're right. The fact that ISK for GTC's meant anyone had access to extra ISK with little to no effort serverely hurt his bottom line, instead of evening the playing field. Thats beside the point that the whole "OMG you're paying real monies for teh ISK's" morality crap is just a bogus way of hiding peoples crying because they didn't have such a huge advantage over other people anymore.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:29:00 -
[131]
Originally by: Crumplecorn Yes, some people got there early and basically won EVE. That's part of the game. If you don't like it, once again, Eve is not the game you are looking for.
I've been playing for a year as of yesterday. You cannot now, ú240 later (ú300 including GTCs i've bought and sold on) that every single time I need to buy something expensive, e.g: Capital, POS, etc, i'm going to have to either ninja mine in 0.0 for a month or grind the increasingly broken Lvl4s for 2 weeks.
That's ridiculous.
Massive chunks of this game should not be denied to me because I didn't join 3 years ago and ingratiate myself with some powergaming alliance where everyone has 6 accounts and owns a dozen T2 BPOs.
At the end of the day, it's CCPs fault for their monumental f*ck up with the all T2 market, POS warfare, etc issues, but now that is the case, if a player wants a leg up so they can afford something through Eve's broken economy, let them. It's their real life money to spend. CCP needs to tighten up on GTC for cash sales, not change the whole system to punish all the wrong people.
---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

CmdrThor
FinFleet
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:31:00 -
[132]
Player 1 - a rich CEO of a big Real Life company, who buys his PVP battleships with $.
Player 2 - a poor nerd living in his student dorm/parents' basement, who buys his PVP battleships by having no Real Life and thus being able to grind missions for hours every day.
Player 3 - he has to PVP versus both other players at different times.
From Player 3's perspective, Player 1 and Player 2 are different... how exactly?
Another thing:
Player 4 - he is your Average Joe, he has a job and can afford paying for one account with his money. He can also earn enough ISK through in game activities so he can PVP too.
Player 5 - he is a poor student, barely has enough money to finance his studies, so he has to either pay for EVE with ISK, or not play at all.
How are Player 4 and Player 5 different from Player 3's perspective? If the ISK for Game Time option wasn't available, Player 3 would only have Player 4 to fight against, thus have a lot less fun, seeing that Player 5 wouldn't be playing at all.
With all that said, may I humbly ask the anti-"ISK for Game Time" crowd as to why they have such a negative stance towards the aforementioned Player 1 and/or Player 5? Is it really SO bad that more people can enjoy this great game?
Thank you for reading my opinion and thank you in advance for not resorting to flaming but having a civilized discussion. 
(a bonus tidbit of information that everyone will care about - I'm Player 5) 
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:33:00 -
[133]
Oh I forgot the best part of the whole deal. Crumplecorn, you've been playing for 3 years longer than I have, thereby dumping an extra... $540 more into the game than I have, even if I ran out and bought $540 worth of GTC's, and traded them for ISK would I even be nearly as caught up to the game?
You already spent your money for ISK you just don't realize it.
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:33:00 -
[134]
Every time I got as far as 'needing' a cap ship or a POS I realised I was talking **** and STFU.
Yes, Eve's economy has become unfair and broken. No, allowing the few people who can afford to buy their way around that fact with RL money to do so is not the solution. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

mother quafe
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:34:00 -
[135]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: mother quafe now casual players buy 100m and spend them on whatever.
if all the casual players cant afford whatever anymore, then a) prices for whatever will decrease or b) they will not be the only one who dont have whatever --> not hac vs hac, but cruiser vs cruiser
sounds pretty fair to me
1)  2)  3) ? 4) profit! .......?
You misunderstand, the point is that the casual players can no longer purchase ISK legally.
yeah, but if more people cant purchase isk, they cant afford expensive stuff. then the expensive stuff will get cheaper imo. depends on how great the influence of buying isk is. maybe we will see battleships for 50m in half a year? either that or a battleship will become sthg more special again.
im no economist, but that is what will happen imo. you can prove me wrong in summer 
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:35:00 -
[136]
Edited by: Craam Hustler on 05/05/2007 00:33:53
Originally by: CmdrThor Player 1 - a rich CEO of a big Real Life company, who buys his PVP battleships with $.
Player 2 - a poor nerd living in his student dorm/parents' basement, who buys his PVP battleships by having no Real Life and thus being able to grind missions for hours every day.
Player 3 - he has to PVP versus both other players at different times.
From Player 3's perspective, Player 1 and Player 2 are different... how exactly?
Another thing:
Player 4 - he is your Average Joe, he has a job and can afford paying for one account with his money. He can also earn enough ISK through in game activities so he can PVP too.
Player 5 - he is a poor student, barely has enough money to finance his studies, so he has to either pay for EVE with ISK, or not play at all.
How are Player 4 and Player 5 different from Player 3's perspective? If the ISK for Game Time option wasn't available, Player 3 would only have Player 4 to fight against, thus have a lot less fun, seeing that Player 5 wouldn't be playing at all.
With all that said, may I humbly ask the anti-"ISK for Game Time" crowd as to why they have such a negative stance towards the aforementioned Player 1 and/or Player 5? Is it really SO bad that more people can enjoy this great game?
Thank you for reading my opinion and thank you in advance for not resorting to flaming but having a civilized discussion. 
(a bonus tidbit of information that everyone will care about - I'm Player 5) 
I am not really against players spending $$$ for ISK, ever since GTCS were allowed.
What I am really against is players converting ISK, to GTC, to $$$ on eBay.
The main thing I like about this, is the fact that they will be killing ISK -> GTC -> eBay
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:36:00 -
[137]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Oh I forgot the best part of the whole deal. Crumplecorn, you've been playing for 3 years longer than I have, thereby dumping an extra... $540 more into the game than I have, even if I ran out and bought $540 worth of GTC's, and traded them for ISK would I even be nearly as caught up to the game?
You already spent your money for ISK you just don't realize it.
WTF are you talking about?
Even if I had played for as long as you suggest, or had the position in-game you suggest, your point would still be wrong.
Subs buy you access. There have been entire threads revolving around the fact that paying your sub does not guarantee fairness, equality or success in-game. ISK for $ buys you stuff you are supposed to have to earn. Not the same thing. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:36:00 -
[138]
Edited by: Briana Flametop on 05/05/2007 00:32:09 Yeah, that's a point: T2 BPO's need to die at the same time as this change goes live.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:37:00 -
[139]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Crumplecorn Yes, some people got there early and basically won EVE. That's part of the game. If you don't like it, once again, Eve is not the game you are looking for.
I've been playing for a year as of yesterday. You cannot now, ú240 later (ú300 including GTCs i've bought and sold on) that every single time I need to buy something expensive, e.g: Capital, POS, etc, i'm going to have to either ninja mine in 0.0 for a month or grind the increasingly broken Lvl4s for 2 weeks.
That's ridiculous.
Massive chunks of this game should not be denied to me because I didn't join 3 years ago and ingratiate myself with some powergaming alliance where everyone has 6 accounts and owns a dozen T2 BPOs.
At the end of the day, it's CCPs fault for their monumental f*ck up with the all T2 market, POS warfare, etc issues, but now that is the case, if a player wants a leg up so they can afford something through Eve's broken economy, let them. It's their real life money to spend. CCP needs to tighten up on GTC for cash sales, not change the whole system to punish all the wrong people.
What the hell are you talking about? That's just an excuse because you couldn't cut it in 0.0. When I joined my current corp they were all literally new. Barely 3 months old. By the time the corp was 6 months old we had a system in 0.0 to ourselves locked down.
The alliances of EVE are not permenant by any stretch of the imagination. When I started playing CA, SA, Xetic, FA and the like ruled everything. Now I believe they're all dead, at least in their original incarnations. And who's in their place? The guys who were new then. The guys who used teamwork and dedication to take 0.0.
And the same will happen now. BoB, D2 and so on will get sick of the game. That's what happens with games - you 'win' them and you move on to a new challenge. New blood takes over. Obviously you don't cut it though.
And no, short of sucking up to an alliance a casual player can not control 0.0. Such is the way 0.0 was designed, and such is the way it should be.
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:40:00 -
[140]
Originally by: Nero Scuro
I spent exactly 10 days in Empire before going to live out in 0.0 - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Farscape Hw
Black Omega Security GoonSwarm
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:40:00 -
[141]
ccp please do not remove the ability to buy time codes. i cannot pay for my 3 accounts atm but have plenty of isk. im having very hard RL issues and im sure alot of ppl are in the same boat as i.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:40:00 -
[142]
Originally by: CmdrThor lots of reasonable stuff
...but you missed the point somewhat.
People aren't complaining that players can buy GTCs for isk they earn in game. That's fine.
People are complaining that the people who irl have some spare cash are able to spend it on a few GTCs and sell them on other players... for isk. Essentially they buy isk with real world cash.
I've done that a few times, maybe spent about ú40 to get about 500 mil isk. I don't feel at all bad about it because I view it as grossly unfair that powergamers, macroers and sweatshop-running slavemasters are able to enjoy parts of this game that I don't have access to because CCP messed up the economy so badly and after 4 years, have totally failed to fix it (invention and HAC prices recently ar a big step in the right direction though). ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:44:00 -
[143]
Originally by: Marquis Dean (invention and HAC prices recently ar a big step in the right direction though).
And this is another step in the right direction. Less people buying ISK for $$$, Less people willing to pay high prices for T2, T2 bpo owners forced to sell cheaper.
|

Crumplecorn
Gallente Eve Cluster Explorations
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:45:00 -
[144]
Edited by: Crumplecorn on 05/05/2007 00:41:30
Originally by: Marquis Dean I've done that a few times, maybe spent about ú40 to get about 500 mil isk. I don't feel at all bad about it because I view it as grossly unfair that powergamers, macroers and sweatshop-running slavemasters are able to enjoy parts of this game that I don't have access to because CCP messed up the economy so badly and after 4 years, have totally failed to fix it (invention and HAC prices recently ar a big step in the right direction though).
I feel bad about it because it seems even more grossly unfair you can get around it and I can't just because you have more RL money than me.
Well, not really, but I figure I'll join the ISK4$ peeps on the ExcuseMobile. -
You keep using that word . . . I do not think it means what you think it means |

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:46:00 -
[145]
Originally by: Nero Scuro What the hell are you talking about? That's just an excuse because you couldn't cut it in 0.0. When I joined my current corp they were all literally new. Barely 3 months old. By the time the corp was 6 months old we had a system in 0.0 to ourselves locked down.
The alliances of EVE are not permenant by any stretch of the imagination. When I started playing CA, SA, Xetic, FA and the like ruled everything. Now I believe they're all dead, at least in their original incarnations. And who's in their place? The guys who were new then. The guys who used teamwork and dedication to take 0.0.
And the same will happen now. BoB, D2 and so on will get sick of the game. That's what happens with games - you 'win' them and you move on to a new challenge. New blood takes over. Obviously you don't cut it though.
And no, short of sucking up to an alliance a casual player can not control 0.0. Such is the way 0.0 was designed, and such is the way it should be.
Er, no, what the hell are you talking about?
Maybe I DON'T WANT TO BE IN A 0.0 ALLIANCE. Shocking eh?
Maybe I want to pirate in losec. Maybe I want to pirate in 0.0. Maybe I want to form a small corp of friends trying our hand at all aspects of Eve.
Individual alliances may not last, but there will always be huge 0.0 alliances controlling 90% of the BPOs, farming 10/10 plexes, enforcing mandatory mining ops, powergaming with their 6 accounts and their cynonets, and fighting massive lagged out fleet battles where if you don't follow your FC's screamed orders over TS you get kicked from the corp.
That doesn't really sound like fun to me. So I guess Eve isn't the game for me eh? Kinda makes a mockery of the original box saying ' you can be x, you can be y, you can be z...', cause actually, I have to be a 0.0 alliance drone or I fail at Eve. ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:46:00 -
[146]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: CmdrThor lots of reasonable stuff
...but you missed the point somewhat.
People aren't complaining that players can buy GTCs for isk they earn in game. That's fine.
People are complaining that the people who irl have some spare cash are able to spend it on a few GTCs and sell them on other players... for isk. Essentially they buy isk with real world cash.
I've done that a few times, maybe spent about ú40 to get about 500 mil isk. I don't feel at all bad about it because I view it as grossly unfair that powergamers, macroers and sweatshop-running slavemasters are able to enjoy parts of this game that I don't have access to because CCP messed up the economy so badly and after 4 years, have totally failed to fix it (invention and HAC prices recently ar a big step in the right direction though).
And what about people who are not powergamers nor feel inclined to spend 40 quid buying pretend money? Sucks to be them, they lose EVE?
You're using strawman arguments, address the real issue and not some worst-case-scenario in which every other player but you is a powergaming 12 hour a day player who played since day 1 and has 203 billion isk and so many skillpoints they could destroy your ship just by looking at you, who are forcing poor wittle you to cheat because it's the only way for you to compete otherwise.
|

Ionia
Advanced Manufacturing
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:46:00 -
[147]
Read the TOPIC people, you are so far off track.
Wtf is wrong with people that they miss the topic completely, start taking about other things, even t2 bpos. Get real, get on topic.
|

PDoggy
Minmatar Valid Character Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:47:00 -
[148]
Originally by: CmdrThor
I like you, wanna be friends? We can ride my bike. - Wait for your email, do not put it back - Ductoris |

Carsidava
Ars ex Discordia GoonSwarm
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:48:00 -
[149]
The forums that host my corporation (Ars Ex Discordia, not GoonSwarm) are partially funded by GTC sales, as the guy that runs the server that the forums run on has an affiliation account with Shattered Crystal. Running that server is not cheap, as our forums aren't just for EvE -- we're a general gaming community that plays a lot of different games, EvE being one of them. The commissions the server admin gets are very useful. With this new rule, he's going to be out money and will have to pay more money to keep the forums running. Every month I guy a GTC through this affiliate program to kick a bit of money back to the server admin. I have never sold a GTC for ISK.
Is CCP going to have an affiliate program? |

Trem Sinval
Sinval Enterprises
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:50:00 -
[150]
So, as I am to understand it, this change means that you can:
1. Pay for your gametime directly with a debit/credit card. 2. Purchase GTC's and redeem them for your gametime. 3. Purchase gametime directly from CCP for ISK.
This also means that you cannot resell your GTC's anymore for ISK, but only resell them for real money. This doesn't preclude sites like Shattered Crystal, nor anyone that chooses to use GTC's to pay for their gametime.
CCP's profits then become a function of the relative ease with which the population can generate ISK. I assume this change will coincide with the proposed changes to complexes and rat bounties, such that CCP can maintain essentially the same number of paid accounts, while offering customers the opportunity to earn their accounts with ISK instead.
Given the concerns voiced thus far about RMT websites and the greater incentive to use them under this change, I hope that this change also does not mean an end to large sum transfers of ISK. Sometimes, when decking out alts and the like, it is easier to simply transfer a large amount of ISK for things like implants and skills, which to the otherwise untrained observer may well look like an illicit ISK transfer being carried out to satisfy an RMT contract.
Are CCP employees sufficiently capable of rooting out these illicit transfers while maintaining the legitimate capabilities of the general population, or will we also see maximum transfer limits put in place?
- Trem |

Ethelda
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:52:00 -
[151]
hehe, sales must be down this quarter :P
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:53:00 -
[152]
Another thing just occured to me.
How are CCP going to set the prices?
Set them too high, people won't be able to afford the GTCs and they'll stop playing.
Set them too low, and lots more people will buy GTCs and CCP will lose out in revenue.
Or have I missed something? ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:53:00 -
[153]
Originally by: Ionia Read the TOPIC people, you are so far off track.
Wtf is wrong with people that they miss the topic completely, start taking about other things, even t2 bpos. Get real, get on topic.
T2 BPO = significant ISK generator = playing EVE for free forever, probably for multiple characters. Not that difficult a concept, really. |

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:55:00 -
[154]
I can see why the mods didnt bother stickying this thread.
|

James Duar
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:55:00 -
[155]
I like this move to purchase gametime directly from CCP for ISK. It's awesome, they're literally going to make everyone else pay for the multiple accounts of powergamers.
I SEE NO WAY THIS CAN BE A BAD IDEA.
|

Jordan Musgrat
Convergent Firmus Ixion
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 00:59:00 -
[156]
Dear CCP kieron.
Could you reply to this thread with a *clarification*? This is all I ask.
Don't cut out third party GTC sellers.
Change the process if you want, but don't make it more difficult for people to buy and sell GTCs.
Next time, make clearer anouncements. -----------
Primary is family values, secondary is 0.0... |

Elendor Xanadaph
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:00:00 -
[157]
Both my corpmates and I have only paid to play eve for one month, for the last year we have worked hard to generate enough ISK to play the game through GTC's. Without them all 4 of us would not play. We just dont have the money or want to spend that much money to play EVE.
If theres a CCP implemented way to buy gametime with ingame ISK im all for that, and will continue to play. If not there gos 4 accounts, along with all the hard work over the past year.
It wouldnt make sense for CCP to lose money like this, im sure theres tons of people that would switch to a different game because of this, one that you only have to pay once for.
CCP eliminating GTC's completely and adding a new ISK for Gametime process would be a win win, keep your subscribers and get rid of any connection between ISK/GTC's and real money.
|

Dangerously Cheesey
Anqara Expeditions The OSS
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:03:00 -
[158]
Uhhh so how does CCP make money? Instead of it going real life money -> GTC -> isk, its just going to go isk -> GTC? I feel the need to point out that all that will really change is that CCP wont get its 14.95 a month from thousands of accounts...
|

James Duar
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:03:00 -
[159]
Since apparently my meaning was lost this is the point: ISK for gametime is retardedly cyclical. CCP would make NO MONEY off giving people gametime for ISK.
This would mean that anyone financing their gametime with ISK is actually being financed by anyone who's still dumb enough to actually be paying the monthly subscription for this game. This means a vast number of 0.0 alt accounts for going to be effectively being paid for by those in Empire.
If ISK for Gametime via CCP becomes a reality, my recommendation is you cancel paying money immediately and do it that way - because you will only end up paying for some other guy to be able to play thanks to your money.
|

CmdrThor
FinFleet
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:05:00 -
[160]
Originally by: Craam Hustler I am not really against players spending $$$ for ISK, ever since GTCS were allowed.
What I am really against is players converting ISK, to GTC, to $$$ on eBay.
The main thing I like about this, is the fact that they will be killing ISK -> GTC -> eBay
I absolutely agree with you.
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: CmdrThor lots of reasonable stuff
...but you missed the point somewhat.
People aren't complaining that players can buy GTCs for isk they earn in game. That's fine.
Fair enough, maybe I misunderstood a comment here and there, or maybe there are just a few bad apples that like to badmouth everyone.
In any case, the "Player 1" part of my post is still valid - the "ships for $" supporters HAVE been getting a lot of heat about their opinion. Speaking of that and of the second part of your post, see below.
Originally by: Crumplecorn I feel bad about it because it seems even more grossly unfair you can get around it and I can't just because you have more RL money than me.
You are missing one thing though - the guy with more RL money than you and me has spent RL time to earn them. Using the usual $-to-ISK conversion rates, you can say that if he earns 15$ per hour IRL and then buys ISK with that $15, then he basically earns 150-200m ISK per hour. While this is most certainly nothing to laugh at, there are many people who can earn such amount by using only in-game resources and their own RL time to play.
So in the end, the rich-in-RL guy has still spent some RL time for his battleships/HACs/Dreads, he just spent that time out of game, as opposed to in-game (And maybe even doing a more boring thing at that. Or maybe not - who knows.). Maybe he earns technically more ISK/hour than some players that way, but then there are others, who earn more than him too - a circle that is seen everywhere in the day to day EVE-life.
So in the end I still don't understand why the hate towards those rich-in-RL guys.
|

James Duar
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:07:00 -
[161]
Originally by: CmdrThor So in the end I still don't understand why the hate towards those rich-in-RL guys.
Because this is freakin' internet spaceships. We don't come here to have the usual social order preserved.
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:09:00 -
[162]
Edited by: Craam Hustler on 05/05/2007 01:06:54
Originally by: CmdrThor I absolutely agree with you.
And in case it can't get any clearer to why I think ISK to GTC to eBay needs to be stopped, heres some history for everybody: The cost of ISK Selling in EVE
If players were allowed to convert their ISK into REAL MONEY, it would encourage more of this:
Quote: 4. Evil conglomerates are formed and prices go up!
As you probably realize by now, ISK sellers go to great lengths to get their hands on ISK. Recently we busted a blueprint conglomerate that was set up just to skim ISK off the top. That extra ISK was then sold for real life currency. The players involved bought a large number of expensive blueprints over a long period of time with the purpose of monopolizing the market on certain items. They attempted to drive prices as high as possible so that they could skim more money off the top and sell more ISK on eBay. This went on for some time and I am sure that a large number of the playerbase unknowingly felt the effect of this when buying ships and modules.
This conglomerate was found out and brought down by your friendly GMs and all those involved given a lifelong vacation from EVE. Their precious pile of blueprints will be reseeded to lucky players through the blueprint lottery. This is a perfect example of how those willing to buy ISK for real money can directly cause inflation and can end up costing the rest of the playerbase a lot of ISK.
I don't want an EVE-CHINA server, thanks.
|

Hank Cousteau
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:11:00 -
[163]
Originally by: Marquis Dean Another thing just occured to me.
How are CCP going to set the prices? Or have I missed something?
One supplier = one price. It may be at a commodity price, but yes... they are removing the market.
Is there a time line for this? Please do give a little heads up before you cut your financial throat here fellas.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:11:00 -
[164]
Originally by: James Duar
Originally by: CmdrThor So in the end I still don't understand why the hate towards those rich-in-RL guys.
Because this is freakin' internet spaceships. We don't come here to have the usual social order preserved.
Rich-in-RL guys create 6 accounts, puts Hulk in 5 of them and makes billions a day. Not a GTC in sight and he's still got a huge advantage because of his rl finances. ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Team Chk
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:15:00 -
[165]
A clearly written blog about this wouldn't have gone astray, instead of half-answers causing confusion 
|

Scarlet Azmodea
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:19:00 -
[166]
Personally I think its impossible to stop people from selling virtual currency. Even if CCP sold ISK the 3rd party companies would just sell for less creating a massive loss to the community as a whole. The only way you will see decreases in sales is if you made it harder to produce ISK in which case everyone in game would cry non stop.
I don't really know why people seem to think its such a huge advantage to have bought ISK. You all still need to go through the same time frames in training to use stuff. Sure it allows people to have "disposable ships" to some extent but does that really hurt anyone? Buying yer ship with ISK gained from money doesn't make you pvp better? It does however stimulate the economy for every builder selling their items.
You people also seem to blame ISK sales on "rich kids" yet have you thought of the fact that some people make good money in RL and don't feel like sacrificing their family/job to farm ISK from a roid field or mission site 16 hours a day, yet would like to enjoy the game also. Tell me this: If you make money grinding a roid, rat belt, pirating, mission running, building, and buy a carrier from a corporation versus making it yourself is that any different then: you sitting in your management office grinding out your hotels advertisement strategies, researching your market segments,working on insurance claims,training your employees,serving your customers etc. Can you honestly say its different?
You really can't because you have aquired an item purchased with "currency" doesn't really matter if said currency is ISK or canadian dollars; someone throughout each process had to work for that "currency" no matter the color. It is not a persons fault for growing a career so they have extra cash to toss into a game. Maybe you should spend less time ice mining and work harder IRL.
Scarlet
|

James Duar
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:19:00 -
[167]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: James Duar
Originally by: CmdrThor So in the end I still don't understand why the hate towards those rich-in-RL guys.
Because this is freakin' internet spaceships. We don't come here to have the usual social order preserved.
Rich-in-RL guys create 6 accounts, puts Hulk in 5 of them and makes billions a day. Not a GTC in sight and he's still got a huge advantage because of his rl finances.
Well then they can sit at their computer for the hours it takes to run those Hulks, the time it takes to train up those accounts and the chance that someone might just suicide bomb them in high sec for the comedy of it.
|

Life reaper
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:20:00 -
[168]
Originally by: Team Chk A clearly written blog about this wouldn't have gone astray, instead of half-answers causing confusion 
Seriously, kieron, the past few news items you've done about massive changes to the game have all been mediocre at best. C'mon man, get your facts straight and THEN inform your users. It's your damn job man.
|

Carsidava
Ars ex Discordia GoonSwarm
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:23:00 -
[169]
Originally by: Team Chk A clearly written blog about this wouldn't have gone astray, instead of half-answers causing confusion 
The shocking thing is that Kieron's supposed to be the community liason and therefore the best person at CCP to be reporting these sorts of things to the rest of us.
Kieron's the best they have. |

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:25:00 -
[170]
Originally by: Scarlet Azmodea Personally I think its impossible to stop people from selling virtual currency. Even if CCP sold ISK the 3rd party companies would just sell for less creating a massive loss to the community as a whole. The only way you will see decreases in sales is if you made it harder to produce ISK in which case everyone in game would cry non stop.
I don't really know why people seem to think its such a huge advantage to have bought ISK. You all still need to go through the same time frames in training to use stuff. Sure it allows people to have "disposable ships" to some extent but does that really hurt anyone? Buying yer ship with ISK gained from money doesn't make you pvp better? It does however stimulate the economy for every builder selling their items.
You people also seem to blame ISK sales on "rich kids" yet have you thought of the fact that some people make good money in RL and don't feel like sacrificing their family/job to farm ISK from a roid field or mission site 16 hours a day, yet would like to enjoy the game also. Tell me this: If you make money grinding a roid, rat belt, pirating, mission running, building, and buy a carrier from a corporation versus making it yourself is that any different then: you sitting in your management office grinding out your hotels advertisement strategies, researching your market segments,working on insurance claims,training your employees,serving your customers etc. Can you honestly say its different?
You really can't because you have aquired an item purchased with "currency" doesn't really matter if said currency is ISK or canadian dollars; someone throughout each process had to work for that "currency" no matter the color. It is not a persons fault for growing a career so they have extra cash to toss into a game. Maybe you should spend less time ice mining and work harder IRL.
Scarlet
Absolutely freakin' perfect. I 100% agree with every word. ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

James Duar
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 01:49:00 -
[171]
Oh snap I just looked at what I was sayng. My response to this is changed to: Dear CCP, Have better ideas and fix things which are actually broken.
Also, make Kieron actually communicate information rather then just randomly sort mangled sentences.
|

Octin
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:03:00 -
[172]
This is an incredibly stupid idea, so thank you CCP for addressing this when there are tons of other issues that are far more pressing that could be addressed instead.
I think Hippoking on the SHC boards said it the best: "Interesting. I can't say I'm sad to see a stop to buying ISK, but I'll be sad to see my accounts go."
|

Big Al
The Aftermath
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:10:00 -
[173]
Why exactly does this thread merit being in General Discussion over say, a certain thread admitting certain transgressions by CCP employees that was relegated to the Information forum that no one reads (yet still got 100k hits)
|

pyschosis
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:17:00 -
[174]
Buying 'Game Time" with isk is a good thing for the player base. It allows those with more RL time than money to continue to play, while removing some of the 'surplus' isk. The isk they use for GT cannot be used to buy ships/mods/implants so they are at disadvantage vs 'paid subscriptions' as they have an "Eve Rent" bill to pay every month, and while it seems it would hurt CCP financially some, it is the correct route to go to support long term play.
Allowing the buying Isk with Real currency (by any means) is stupid and shortsighted.. the Example of Monopoly applies, but it also breaks the entire point of a MMORG to begin with.. "YOU" (behind the keyboard) are not "YOUR CHARACTER". What YOU can do has no effect on the game.. (ie you don't have to fight against 'me'(RL pilot) and my 10,000 hours of flight time in RL.. why should I have to 'fight' against your RL wallet?)
those that are whining about not being competitive anymore (primarily PvPers with no industrial Incomes) Now have to suck it up, and bring a 'soft target' on the field to make the isk to support their PvP. They've had no problems killing the miners and ratters up until now who WERE earning an "Eve living" all the while you were using your RL living to kill them.
Welcome to a leveled playing field. Go ahead, Quit. The game wont miss you.
You want something in Eve.. You earn it IN EVE.
Cheers CCP!
|

James Duar
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:25:00 -
[175]
Edited by: James Duar on 05/05/2007 02:21:37
Originally by: pyschosis Buying 'Game Time" with isk is a good thing for the player base. It allows those with more RL time than money to continue to play, while removing some of the 'surplus' isk. The isk they use for GT cannot be used to buy ships/mods/implants so they are at disadvantage vs 'paid subscriptions' as they have an "Eve Rent" bill to pay every month, and while it seems it would hurt CCP financially some, it is the correct route to go to support long term play.
No it isn't you idiot. It means the paying playerbase is paying for the hardcore "12 hours a day, computer in my bathroom" playerbase. It's god damn social support structures in internet spaceships. ISK doesn't buy servers, money does - money comes from paying customers. Gametime for ISK from CCP means that paying customers are being made to pay for others.
|

Aslord
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:31:00 -
[176]
ccp just want to cut out the middlemen in real life, buying directly from ccp mean more real profit goes to the company instead of the timecard dealer web site
|

Carsidava
Ars ex Discordia GoonSwarm
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:38:00 -
[177]
Originally by: Aslord ccp just want to cut out the middlemen in real life, buying directly from ccp mean more real profit goes to the company instead of the timecard dealer web site
Previously:
CCP sells GTC to reseller for cash (CCP gets cash from reseller). Reseller sells GTC to player one (reseller gets cash from player one). Player one sells GTC to player two for ISK.
Now:
CCP sells GTC to player two for ISK (CCP gets cash from nobody).
Tell me how exactly CCP gets more money out of this? |

Petrothian Tong
Gallente
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:43:00 -
[178]
Edited by: Petrothian Tong on 05/05/2007 02:40:14 As much as I love the idea of playing for free.
I cannot support this,
currently, CCP Gets the cash for GTC, which is great, since CCP gets $$$
$$$ keeps Devs/GMs/Staff Paid.... Paid staff = working staff Working Staff = Eve is maintained and developed.
if it goes into the system proposed.
it would hurt CCP income ALOT. as I can say that most people who had over 5 mill SP would be able to afford paying for the game with isk. (at current isk for GTC rates..)
and CCP wont get any income due to it.
Please.. CCP , Take my money... TAKE THE MONEY!!!! you cant Live on ISK!!!!
as a pharse I used ALOT on the forum...
DO NOT CHOP OFF YOUR ARM FOR A WOODEN SPLINTER IN YOUR FINGER!!!! (yes those guys are a problem, but doing this will hurt Eve more than those guys..)
I repeat.. CCP: TAKE OUR MONEY!!!! not ISK!!!
-Siggi- ""PvP" isn't only direct person to person combat, it can be very indirect. Selling an item on the market which somebody buys from you is resulting in another guy not getting a sale." Oveur |

Ce Domina
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:43:00 -
[179]
This seems like a neat idea. Depending on the implementation (some details please, CCP) it could mean a sharp drop in the number of active accounts/players. This will help to curtail lag by reducing the strain on Tranquility, and help EVE return to its roots as a niche MMO.
An added bonus is that if CCP is selling game-time for ISK directly, their revenue will drop. I'm sure that benefits everyone who plays this game somehow.
|

pyschosis
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:44:00 -
[180]
Edited by: pyschosis on 05/05/2007 02:42:38 Edited by: pyschosis on 05/05/2007 02:42:10
Originally by: James Duar Edited by: James Duar on 05/05/2007 02:21:37
Originally by: pyschosis Buying 'Game Time" with isk is a good thing for the player base. It allows those with more RL time than money to continue to play, while removing some of the 'surplus' isk. The isk they use for GT cannot be used to buy ships/mods/implants so they are at disadvantage vs 'paid subscriptions' as they have an "Eve Rent" bill to pay every month, and while it seems it would hurt CCP financially some, it is the correct route to go to support long term play.
It means the paying playerbase is paying for the hardcore "12 hours a day, computer in my bathroom" playerbase. It's god damn social support structures in internet spaceships. ISK doesn't buy servers, money does - money comes from paying customers. Gametime for ISK from CCP means that paying customers are being made to pay for others.
CCP determines their profit margins not you. If you think they are going to create a system that means more of their income is isk than real currency you are simple ignorant. As long as the price is right those 'hard cores' will spend just as much time IN GAME earning money TO PLAY THE GAME as those who are actually working to pay for their subscription. (1 hour of my labor in RL can pay for 4 accounts for a month. How many hours will you grind for your monthly fee in isk? more than 1 I'm sure) the difference is that the 'paid' players can skip out on Eve for a month (or a year) and not lose anything, can come back right where they were whenever they want with no "Eve job" to do to play. If the 'play to play' types stop playing (stop grinding) they lose their entire account access.
the number of people who actually desire "yet another rent bill to occupy their gaming time" will be SIGNIFICANTLY lower than the number of people who can simply plop down 150.00 and be golden for a year.
once the majority of the 'play to play' crowd passes adolescence they wont have the leisure to keep grinding for their play time and will either quit (unlikely if they've invested that much time already) or realize the subscription fee is nothing for anyone with a 'real job'
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:51:00 -
[181]
Waaaait a minute...
CCP don't like ppl buying selling isk for cash...
Ppl make isk by selling GTCs...
This means you have to give CCP your isk instead of a third party...
So CCP will have more isk than anyone (except perhaps Red Alliance)...
ZOMG that's it! CCP are trying to corner the market in isk eBaying and make all the cash themselves!
   ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Petrothian Tong
Gallente
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:51:00 -
[182]
Psyc...
unless the GTC prices for isk increases drasticlly... at current rates..
ANY 5 mill SP char can easily make that amount of isk for a 90 days card in 2 or maybe 3 weekends....
and the system ALSO have to change so that the GTC is non-transferable for it to work.
since someone out there will undercut CCP if CCP set the Isk for timecode thing too high.
if its too low, everybody will be able to pay in isk...
hence the problem.
-Siggi- ""PvP" isn't only direct person to person combat, it can be very indirect. Selling an item on the market which somebody buys from you is resulting in another guy not getting a sale." Oveur |

James Duar
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:56:00 -
[183]
Originally by: pyschosis Edited by: pyschosis on 05/05/2007 02:42:38 Edited by: pyschosis on 05/05/2007 02:42:10
Originally by: James Duar Edited by: James Duar on 05/05/2007 02:21:37
Originally by: pyschosis Buying 'Game Time" with isk is a good thing for the player base. It allows those with more RL time than money to continue to play, while removing some of the 'surplus' isk. The isk they use for GT cannot be used to buy ships/mods/implants so they are at disadvantage vs 'paid subscriptions' as they have an "Eve Rent" bill to pay every month, and while it seems it would hurt CCP financially some, it is the correct route to go to support long term play.
It means the paying playerbase is paying for the hardcore "12 hours a day, computer in my bathroom" playerbase. It's god damn social support structures in internet spaceships. ISK doesn't buy servers, money does - money comes from paying customers. Gametime for ISK from CCP means that paying customers are being made to pay for others.
CCP determines their profit margins not you. If you think they are going to create a system that means more of their income is isk than real currency you are simple ignorant. As long as the price is right those 'hard cores' will spend just as much time IN GAME earning money TO PLAY THE GAME as those who are actually working to pay for their subscription. (1 hour of my labor in RL can pay for 4 accounts for a month. How many hours will you grind for your monthly fee in isk? more than 1 I'm sure) the difference is that the 'paid' players can skip out on Eve for a month (or a year) and not lose anything, can come back right where they were whenever they want with no "Eve job" to do to play. If the 'play to play' types stop playing (stop grinding) they lose their entire account access.
the number of people who actually desire "yet another rent bill to occupy their gaming time" will be SIGNIFICANTLY lower than the number of people who can simply plop down 150.00 and be golden for a year.
once the majority of the 'play to play' crowd passes adolescence they wont have the leisure to keep grinding for their play time and will either quit (unlikely if they've invested that much time already) or realize the subscription fee is nothing for anyone with a 'real job'
You don't seem to get it. CCP apparently can't buy server hardware fast enough as it is. Somehow, by earning less money because they are letting people play the game for what is effectively free, you are implying this does not hurt my net game experience or directly equal me paying for other people to play.
It does. Because CCP have less money, which means they can buy less new hardware and hire fewer employees. Explain to me how this doesn't effect my game experience (thus reducing my utility) or result in a straight price hike in subscription fees (accomplishing the same).
Hell, explain to me where giving your product away makes the remotest amount of business sense.
Your argument is akin to saying that it would be fine if only a few people skimmed money from the till since not many people will do it.
|

Vashi Dokumentu
The xDEATHx Squadron Legion of xXDEATHXx
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:57:00 -
[184]
so how much would 90 days time code for isk ?? 2-5b ??
|

Pax Uranus
Sofa.Kingdom
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 02:59:00 -
[185]
Originally by: Briana Flametop T2 BPO = significant ISK generator = playing EVE for free forever, probably for multiple characters. Not that difficult a concept, really.
Even with the T2 market dive, I think that just one of my BPOs can fund (at current exchange rates) about a dozen accounts infinitely (pre-dive, easily double that). So yeah, BPOs should probably go poof.
|

Deus Ex'Machina
Amarr Imperial Academy
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 03:28:00 -
[186]
Originally by: Mox Trident
Quote: In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK
This is the part that some people have missed.
The way I read it is that you will no longer be able to buy GTC's from third parties like shatteredcrystal.com or ebay.
From now on you'll buy your GTC directly from CCP through account management.
This is how I think it will work:
Player A will purchase a GTC for RL cash from CCP.
Player A will be given an option to either use the GTC himself or sell it to player B for ISK.
When player B buys a GTC from a seller, the GTC is automatically added to his subscription time. This prevents player B from re-selling the GTC out of game for RL cash.
This way CCP get the RL cash, all transactions are through account management, and third party middlemen are removed from the equation altogether.
Well, if this is true then it's perfect.
Note, seller = player A ;-) Note, buying from player A = trough account management
/signed this particular version of Engrish  *snip* - Image not appropriate for eve-o forums - hutch
true amarr tank shields! |

pyschosis
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 03:58:00 -
[187]
Edited by: pyschosis on 05/05/2007 03:58:22
Originally by: Petrothian Tong Psyc...
unless the GTC prices for isk increases drasticlly... at current rates..
ANY 5 mill SP char can easily make that amount of isk for a 90 days card in 2 or maybe 3 weekends....
ofc. But that is the key difference. "Play to Players" will spend 2 or 3 weekends 'paying rent' while 'paid' accounts make profit/have fun for that time. That means less overall capability in game, as I can buy and fit additional BS for what you have to spend simply to keep playing..
in fact it will make 'griefing' the 'play2play' people MORE EFFECTIVE as you are actually hitting them where it hurts most, in the income they need to keep playing.
oh btw I hate to break it to you, but server hardware WONT SOLVE most of the lag issues Eve has.. you are going to have to wait for World Wide Network upgrades.
also since no one here as the actual numbers in front of them, I'll leave it to CCP to decide when trading isk for playtime actually hurts their bottom line.
Less profit in the interests of a better gaming experience is a good thing for all.
|

Creepin
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 04:04:00 -
[188]
Originally by: Vashi Dokumentu so how much would 90 days time code for isk ?? 2-5b ??
Indeed. I don't give a damn whom exactly I'm buying GTC's from, but if prices will be increased at least twofold I'll have to give up EVE for good, as I'm barely making twice the price of GTC per month, so CCP may say farewell to all payments for my account 
And to think of all this mess while anyone who seriously intended to trade ISK for cash will always, ALWAYS, find a way to do so. As usual, CCP is going to create a problem not for macro-miners and stuff, but for casual players :(
|

Aaron Static
Igneus Auctorita GoonSwarm
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 04:58:00 -
[189]
Hey what's happening in this thread?
Oh I see, CCP is killing the game some more.
gg ccp
|

BubbaZanetti
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 05:08:00 -
[190]
Excellent news.
At the same time this goin in, you're going to be limiting all other players to only be allowed to play as long as I can, right? Or, really, whatever the least amount of logged in time per month is, really, that's how long we'll need to all be allowed to play now, yes?
After all, we can't have real world circumstances influencing people's ability to get ahead in the game. It's not fair that I, who make a good living can just buy isk by selling game time cards, so it's equally not fair that some one else, who works less than I do, should be able to play the game longer and just grind isk, right?
Ok, cool. Let me know how much time we're allowed to log in an play per month as soon as you geniuses of what's fair and equitable get it sorted out.
On the plus side, with no one being allowed to log in more than anyone else, this should help the lag quite a bit. Thans, guys.
Not that whatever sarcastic reply I make to the thread will ever be read or considered by anyone at CCP ever anyway. "Give us your feedback, we read it all, and then ignore it completely and do whatever we were planning to do anyway."
|

Zanarkand
Gallente Outer Heaven DARPA
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 05:51:00 -
[191]
Edited by: Zanarkand on 05/05/2007 05:53:08 Great job, CCP! Keep it up!
This change will only make the game better.
3 major issues to look at from now:
logging off & aggro timer problem titans local
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 05:58:00 -
[192]
I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
I do not think CCP really wanted to turn it into a legal ISK buying fest. With all of the GTC resellers it was becoming an issue as they were taking advantage of the situation to try and possibly cash out.
And we know what happens when players abuse game features. CCP steps in and changes them.
I welcome this change.
|

VossKarr
Caldari The 6th Directorate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 05:58:00 -
[193]
So, CCP is cutting the middleman to sell the ISK for real money themselves? Otherwise what else would they be doing with all that ISK gained from selling game time to players? They can't run their company on virtual currency, they'll have to convert it somehow to RL cash. 
|

VossKarr
Caldari The 6th Directorate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:05:00 -
[194]
Originally by: voogru I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
But what will they do with ISK? They can't run their company on virtual currency. They'll have to convert to RL money. The question is how?
|

Idara
Caldari Missioners Anonymous
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:13:00 -
[195]
Edited by: Idara on 05/05/2007 06:10:30
Originally by: VossKarr
Originally by: voogru I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
But what will they do with ISK? They can't run their company on virtual currency. They'll have to convert to RL money. The question is how?
They don't need the GTC sales to fund EVE, it was like icing on the cake for extra cash. But what the GTCs for ISK was doing to their game, their in-game economy must've been bad enough, or deviating too far from what they considered normal to keep it going.
The game can run on cash subs alone, yeah it might be a hit to CCP's income, but if they're willing to lose some RL money to balance out the whack inflation in the game, good on them.
They're always talking about ISK sinks, especially now with how the ingame economy is, this is a pretty good one. --- in EVE - Idara |

Thews Mortaza
Minmatar Brutor tribe
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:23:00 -
[196]
(Part 1 )
This is the worst decision I have ever seen CCP make regarding the future of EVE. To be clear the following post is not specifically directed at Kieron but at those people within CCP who made this decision and gave Kieron the related information. From what I've seen so far I think some good points have been made and I apologize if I'm repeating them.
Originally by: CCP kieron In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK.
A solution implies there is a problem. CCP has gone as far as to have posted a list of authorized ETC retailer sites available from the "My Account" menu and for a long time now has presented this method as a viable way for players to supply other players (who are in theory without the real-world financial means to do so) with the means to continue to play the game via trading codes for ISK. Indeed, the original trading rules were recently revised to protect both the seller-player and the buyer-player by introducing an accounts page interface to increase the levels of mutual protection. This allowed "hard-core" players with the time, but not the money, to play the game without paying for it themselves. It meant that one player would pay for the access of a second player.
Alternatively, it has provided a legitimate, CCP-allowed means to those players who want to increase their ISK balance at the expense of their real-world finances to purchase GTC from CCP via an authorized reseller and then trade that GTC to another player for an agreed amount of ISK from that second player. In this model, it is expected that CCP was making money from the original ETC sale, with a small percentage going to the authorized reseller for providing the third party service. Having dealt happily with such an authorized third party retailer in the past, I have no personal problem with paying a small premium on the base price of a GTC for them to continue their business of making that GTC selling service available.
The reason I am strongly in favor of this method and would argue firmly against eliminative changes is because it appeared to have provided viable competition to the practice of directly trading real-world currency for virtual currency from unauthorized third parties with disagreeable practices. An example of these parties are those who utilize mass EVE-mails, unsolicited in-game Local chat advertising, and even go as far as to position named containers around gates in the game to advertise their legally questionable services. These businesses operate at the expense of CCP hardware, software and staff resources and assuming they operate by automated ratting or missioning they create more ISK, rather than re-locate it (as trading ISK to someone for any reason where no in-game asset is exchanged in return does) - furthering inflation in the game at the cost of the wider customer base.
People who want to trade dollars for ISK are generally going to be gamers who are taking the path of least resistance for maintaining their recreation. By removing one of these paths (the one that appears to be the only legitimate one) CCP is going to be increasing the demand of those unauthorized services from those players and in turn increasing the damage caused by the unauthorized services.
(Sig) Your momma so fat ... when I tried to scoop her to my cargo hold, she don't fit ! |

Thews Mortaza
Minmatar Brutor tribe
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:24:00 -
[197]
(Part 2)
Originally by: CCP kieron In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP.
How is this any different from the current model? A sit stands, CCP still gets money for the GTC and isn't getting money you can use to fuel your business better for your business than your own in-game data being shuffled to a different location on one of your hard-disks? Or is CCP going to start throwing money away?
Will CCP pricing be competitive with the established "going rates", if you will? We're not going to magically forget what the established prices are. If you can't draw even for the current pricing you're actually going to make things harder for those customers you're claiming to be trying to help.
Or is this the elimination of competition to form what is effectively a cartel so you (By whom I mean CCP) can set your own ISK-sink price? This isn't my own paranoia here, this is taking note of the element of distrust I think is now existing within your customer base of which previous CCP decisions are partly to blame.
Originally by: CCP kieron Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
As I said, this smacks of CCP setting a pricing cartel by eliminating the player/customer competition element. I also dread the knock-on effects I've mentioned relating to ôgold tradersö and making their solution for players more viable.
Originally by: CCP kieron We still have a number of details to work out, as well as implementation and integration, but that will hopefully clear up some of the confusion created earlier.
Now we have confusion and fear, though. It appears as though nothing good is being done and as other customers have already pointed out, doesn't EVE face bigger problems then the GTC ôissueö? Or is there something (dare I suggest yet again) we aren't being told about this û which it cannot be denied has been done in the past.
A solution implies there is a problem. The information presented to us doesn't actually make it clear what the problem is and why such a draconian change is to be introduced to counter whatever this problem is. To sum up, at this moment in time it seems that these changes are actually going to make things worse.
For everyone. You. Me. CCP.
Why?
(Sig) Your momma so fat ... when I tried to scoop her to my cargo hold, she don't fit ! |

WhitePhantom
Gallente Edenists
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:24:00 -
[198]
Originally by: Farscape Hw ccp please do not remove the ability to buy time codes. i cannot pay for my 3 accounts atm but have plenty of isk. im having very hard RL issues and im sure alot of ppl are in the same boat as i.
Here is a solution, don't have 3 accounts 
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:24:00 -
[199]
Originally by: VossKarr
Originally by: voogru I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
But what will they do with ISK? They can't run their company on virtual currency. They'll have to convert to RL money. The question is how?
Well, the players who pay with ISK, wouldnt pay with $. Meaning CCP would lose that account when their time ran out.
Not all players are going to pay with ISK, and I think CCP knows this.
They are getting two things from this:
1. Deflation, Massive ISK Sink which EVE desperately needs. 2. A Player that remains playing because he is able to support his account with ISK rather than $, an account they wouldnt have if they didn't allow ISK to GTC.
Players are abusing GTCS far beyond what CCP wanted players to do with it, thats why they are stepping in now.
|

Creepin
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:26:00 -
[200]
Originally by: voogru I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
I do not think CCP really wanted to turn it into a legal ISK buying fest. With all of the GTC resellers it was becoming an issue as they were taking advantage of the situation to try and possibly cash out.
And we know what happens when players abuse game features. CCP steps in and changes them.
I welcome this change.
I strongly believe that the ACTUAL REAL reason that CCP ever meddled into whole isk->gtc affair in the first place was because they figured that if they are unable to stop isk trading completely (they were, are and will be unable to stop it anyway) then it's good at least to be those who get some part of money from isk->real->isk transactions, not those who are just watching it. Not that I'm criticize this position, but you had to understand that this has nothing in common with charity or generosity, usual business.
Also, I, for one, play EVE regularly, but without any isk-grinding sessions, so I make like 250kk per month. Well enough to pay for my account and to save a little for my own enjoyment. I really interested to know, what the f**k am I abusing here so much that I had to be thrown out from EVE???
|

Tek'a Rain
Gallente Isis Technologies
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:29:00 -
[201]
Originally by: CCP kieron The recent MotD mentioning the sale or purchase of ISK for real money generated some questions about how Game Time can be traded for ISK, Game Time that was purchased with real world cash. In some of my replies, I was unclear. This wasn't by intention, but because of the information I am authorized to release at this time.
In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK. In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
We still have a number of details to work out, as well as implementation and integration, but that will hopefully clear up some of the confusion created earlier.
quoted to try and make sense. is this clearing up the confusion by making a fairly vague statement and backing it up with total silence on the issue?
this would Seem to say that the "isk and time rich" folks will be on a free ride, which My sub money (yes, I pay with real, old fashioned money instead of fancy game money) will be paying for along with a net result of CCP making less cash. less cash meaning less support meaning a dead game.
|

VossKarr
Caldari The 6th Directorate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:30:00 -
[202]
Originally by: Idara Edited by: Idara on 05/05/2007 06:10:30
Originally by: VossKarr
Originally by: voogru I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
But what will they do with ISK? They can't run their company on virtual currency. They'll have to convert to RL money. The question is how?
They don't need the GTC sales to fund EVE, it was like icing on the cake for extra cash. But what the GTCs for ISK was doing to their game, their in-game economy must've been bad enough, or deviating too far from what they considered normal to keep it going.
Are you serious? What if everyone decides to fund their gametime with ISK? How will they pay their bills then?
Quote:
The game can run on cash subs alone, yeah it might be a hit to CCP's income, but if they're willing to lose some RL money to balance out the whack inflation in the game, good on them.
I don't think they're that stupid or naive. Their bean counters would murder them.
Quote:
They're always talking about ISK sinks, especially now with how the ingame economy is, this is a pretty good one.
Yeah, it is a good sink. In fact, it so good - it can sink the whole company if they follow through with it.
|

Idara
Caldari Missioners Anonymous
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:34:00 -
[203]
Edited by: Idara on 05/05/2007 06:30:03
Originally by: VossKarr
Originally by: Idara Edited by: Idara on 05/05/2007 06:10:30
Originally by: VossKarr
Originally by: voogru I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
But what will they do with ISK? They can't run their company on virtual currency. They'll have to convert to RL money. The question is how?
They don't need the GTC sales to fund EVE, it was like icing on the cake for extra cash. But what the GTCs for ISK was doing to their game, their in-game economy must've been bad enough, or deviating too far from what they considered normal to keep it going.
Are you serious? What if everyone decides to fund their gametime with ISK? How will they pay their bills then?
Considering this game was around before, with paying subscribers too (OMG!), this whole bull**** GTCs for ISK thing, methinks this game can survive. --- in EVE - Idara |

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:35:00 -
[204]
Edited by: voogru on 05/05/2007 06:31:45
Originally by: VossKarr Are you serious? What if everyone decides to fund their gametime with ISK? How will they pay their bills then?
I dont think there is that much ISK in EVE.
Originally by: Creepin I strongly believe that the ACTUAL REAL reason that CCP ever meddled into whole isk->gtc affair in the first place was because they figured that if they are unable to stop isk trading completely (they were, are and will be unable to stop it anyway) then it's good at least to be those who get some part of money from isk->real->isk transactions, not those who are just watching it. Not that I'm criticize this position, but you had to understand that this has nothing in common with charity or generosity, usual business.
Also, I, for one, play EVE regularly, but without any isk-grinding sessions, so I make like 250kk per month. Well enough to pay for my account and to save a little for my own enjoyment. I really interested to know, what the f**k am I abusing here so much that I had to be thrown out from EVE???
The problem comes when GTC resellers buy up all of the codes with ISK. Not to sell them for ISK, but on eBay for $$$.
And believe me, I think it was already happening.
|

VossKarr
Caldari The 6th Directorate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:46:00 -
[205]
Originally by: voogru
Originally by: VossKarr
Originally by: voogru I think the actual real reason for GTC for ISK was to allow players to save money by paying for their game with ISK.
But what will they do with ISK? They can't run their company on virtual currency. They'll have to convert to RL money. The question is how?
Well, the players who pay with ISK, wouldn't pay with $. Meaning CCP would lose that account when their time ran out.
Not necessarily. Anyone who could afford the option would have to be a pretty active player with lots of ISK. Anyone that active is not going to give up playing that easily.
Quote: Not all players are going to pay with ISK, and I think CCP knows this.
Yes. They also know that it could severely affect their bottom line if even 20-30 percent of all accounts go this way.
Quote: They are getting two things from this:
1. Deflation, Massive ISK Sink which EVE desperately needs.
They can easily solve this issue within the game (introduce new taxes for instance) without resorting to such measures that can affect their financial well being.
Quote:
2. A Player that remains playing because he is able to support his account with ISK rather than $, an account they wouldn't have if they didn't allow ISK to GTC.
Tell me, what good would such an account be to CCP from their POV? If such player is not even paying for server time and bandwidth he/she is not only not making CCP any money, he/she actually costs CCP money to keep.
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:51:00 -
[206]
Originally by: VossKarr Tell me, what good would such an account be to CCP from their POV? If such player is not even paying for server time and bandwidth he/she is not only not making CCP any money, he/she actually costs CCP money to keep.
I'm sure a lot of players don't quit, but they cancel cause of some finacial issues that they have currently run into.
They cancel, with intent to re-sub when they get out of a hole, but they forget and never resub.
Buying time with GTC, they might be able to take some ISK, buy a month of time, and continue paying as normally. I'm fairly sure CCP will price the time high enough so there will remain a strong incentive to pay with $.
|

Creepin
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:52:00 -
[207]
Originally by: voogru The problem comes when GTC resellers buy up all of the codes with ISK. Not to sell them for ISK, but on eBay for $$$.
And believe me, I think it was already happening.
I see your point, and I do agree that it could be somewhat unpleasant issue. But I do believe that this new CCP's hare-brained idea will mainly hit usual players, buying one 90dayer once in a few months, while those trading isks on industrial scale will always find some other way to do it. It's like in real life - each new law aimed against criminality usually hampers peaceful citizens, while criminals always manages to get away.
|

VossKarr
Caldari The 6th Directorate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:52:00 -
[208]
I guess my point is this: Either we're missing something (Hi Kieron ) or CCP is out of their freaking minds.
|

Creepin
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 06:55:00 -
[209]
Originally by: VossKarr Tell me, what good would such an account be to CCP from their POV? If such player is not even paying for server time and bandwidth he/she is not only not making CCP any money, he/she actually costs CCP money to keep.
Are you serious? Each and every GTC's are bought from CCP originally. So, from CCP's point of view, there's absolutely no difference if you pay 20 bucks for your GTC directly to CCP, or if someone else pays that same 20 bucks to that same CCP and later gives GTC for you in exchange of some of your isks.
|

Bozse
Caldari Reikoku Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:01:00 -
[210]
I doubt CCP will just sell the time for isk as it's not logical, what i see them removing is the resellable code that can be sold for RL cash. Player A buys time for RL cash, Player B can buy time from player A for isk both throu the account management page and no code is involved hence u can't sell the time for RL cash anymore which is the current problem.
Either way just wait and see what the final sollution is before u start speculating about how much RL cash CCP will lose on something u have no confirmation on how it will work.
btw. Thx Keiron for explaining that we will be able to pay with isk in one way or another still as that was realy unclear with your first post and a concern of mine, im sure u have a logical sollution that will make sense once u get the details finished.
Originally by: CCP Wrangler EVE is designed to be a dark and harsh world
|

VossKarr
Caldari The 6th Directorate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:01:00 -
[211]
Originally by: Creepin
Originally by: VossKarr Tell me, what good would such an account be to CCP from their POV? If such player is not even paying for server time and bandwidth he/she is not only not making CCP any money, he/she actually costs CCP money to keep.
Are you serious? Each and every GTC's are bought from CCP originally. So, from CCP's point of view, there's absolutely no difference if you pay 20 bucks for your GTC directly to CCP, or if someone else pays that same 20 bucks to that same CCP and later gives GTC for you in exchange of some of your isks.
I was talking about ISK for GTC directly from CCP. In the old system someone had to buy GTC from CCP for RL money before reselling it for ISK. In the proposed system CCP eliminates the middleman and sells GTC directly for ISK. The question is how will they support their company without RL cash being in the equation?
|

Zorda
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:09:00 -
[212]
Every day I see less reasons to log into EVE lately. 
|

Sarafi
The 2nd Coming
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:12:00 -
[213]

|

Creepin
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:13:00 -
[214]
Originally by: VossKarr I was talking about ISK for GTC directly from CCP. In the old system someone had to buy GTC from CCP for RL money before reselling it for ISK. In the proposed system CCP eliminates the middleman and sells GTC directly for ISK. The question is how will they support their company without RL cash being in the equation?
Oops, sorry. I've read what your quoted and your answer, but still made a mistake on a matter of discussion :)
I agree with you on this one - it's so losing to CCP to sell GTCs for iskies on their own, that even if they decide to actually do it, they had to be sure that this service will be used by as little people as possible, and easiest way to ensure it is to set GTC price up to like few billy's per month. :( I guess in this case many of us will be forced to turn to a black market for GTCs, so eventually CCP will get results opposite to ones they were hoping for, as prices on black-market GTCs will also rocket high, even if less then official prices, making this business even more profitable than ATM.
|

Cryten Jones
Gallente Eldritch Storm
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:17:00 -
[215]
Slightly off topic but I just be happy to see the direct debit option available in the UK. I mean we use DD for all bills why do we not get this option !!
-CJ
|

Contrary Mary
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:42:00 -
[216]
Only speculation here, but I suspect that CCP might just be only giving us part of the info here.
If they implement a program of
a) Selling players Game Time for ISK, and at the same time b) Removing the option of ISK transfer between characters, and c) Introduce the selling (from CCP direct only) of ISK for RL Cash
They will have the ability to monitor large fluctuations in character wallets.
Any large jump in a wallet that isn't directly linkable to an in-game market transaction, contract, or character sale (if that is still permitted), can then be flagged as a EULA violator.
It would give them an audit trail, and the ability to control the people making RL cash out of the current rules, while still allowing for both cash-rich/time-poor and cash-poor/time-rich players.
It makes more sense as a business-model I reckon.
No flames please - only speculation
|

VossKarr
Caldari The 6th Directorate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 07:57:00 -
[217]
Originally by: Contrary Mary
b) Removing the option of ISK transfer between characters
How? You can always sell 1 trit for 1 bil to transfer cash so.. really, impossible, unless you scrap the market along with contracts.
|

Creepin
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 08:15:00 -
[218]
I suspect half-community will leave EVE without second thought should they: Originally by: Contrary Mary
c) Introduce the selling (from CCP direct only) of ISK for RL Cash
EVE will be no better than Lineage freeshards then. But somehow I doubt that such a thing will be implemented - not only because of gameplay and community dissatisfaction issues, but because of RL legal and taxation issues as well.
Originally by: Contrary Mary b) Removing the option of ISK transfer between characters
What? So I'll be unable to give to my girlfriend's char birthday present of few billions? To help my RL friend in his need? To throw some cash on my Jita-resident alt to buy me a stuff while my main is 30 jumps away from Jita? What a... bad idea 
|

Goumindong
Amarr Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 08:42:00 -
[219]
Edited by: Goumindong on 05/05/2007 08:40:28
Originally by: Deus Ex'Machina
Originally by: Mox Trident
Quote: In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK
This is the part that some people have missed.
The way I read it is that you will no longer be able to buy GTC's from third parties like shatteredcrystal.com or ebay.
From now on you'll buy your GTC directly from CCP through account management.
This is how I think it will work:
Player A will purchase a GTC for RL cash from CCP.
Player A will be given an option to either use the GTC himself or sell it to player B for ISK.
When player B buys a GTC from a seller, the GTC is automatically added to his subscription time. This prevents player B from re-selling the GTC out of game for RL cash.
This way CCP get the RL cash, all transactions are through account management, and third party middlemen are removed from the equation altogether.
Well, if this is true then it's perfect.
Note, seller = player A ;-) Note, buying from player A = trough account management
/signed this particular version of Engrish 
Uhh. This is how it works right now.
Just because player A isnt named "www.shatteredcrystal.com" does not mean that player A isnt www.shatteredcrystal.com.
If its supposedly going to work like that then it doesnt change anything except make the middlemans accounting a little bit more difficult. ---------------------------------------- Thou Shalt "Pew Pew" |

ParMizaN
Body Count Inc. Mercenary Coalition
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 08:43:00 -
[220]
YES! Thank you!  [IMG]http://tinyurl.com/yuphfgIMG] BDCI sig ftp screwed.
|

Awox
Infinitus Odium
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 08:56:00 -
[221]
Originally by: PDoggy
Originally by: Crumplecorn
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
This is why it is good. A major nerf to UT2K4 in space.
Why oh WHY would you say this?
I quit WoW because it became a horrible, ****ty grindfest past level 45. I play EVE for the PvP - I enjoy it and it's a great, unique experience. I don't like having to mine for six hours to fit out a HAC. EVE has always been very attractive to casual players with the GTCs and the offline skill training, and removing this is a slap in A) The face of casual MMO-players everywhere and B) CCP's accounting deparment.
I don't have six hours to mine to fit out a HAC and yet I can still do it. Is it GTC sales? Or is it just because I might understand the game better than you.
Adapt or die, I can't wait to see the day when all these morons who are broke in-game (it's too easy to make ISK these days) leave EVE because they can no longer use their RL wallet to keep them in premium PvP vessels. - BOOST OUTLAWS (-10.0 and proud of it) |

James Lyrus
Lyrus Associates Betrayal Under Mayhem
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 09:14:00 -
[222]
This is the best thing CCP have ever done in EVE. There's been a LOT of cool stuff, but this, tops it.
ISK <-> cash trades are unhealthy for a game, in every single incidence. I can see the argument that you buy your friend game time, and he gives you isk, thus everyone's happy. I feel for your friend who is too poor.
But at the same time, the ability to gain in game advantage, for RL cash. Or worse, to actually turn 'playing EVE' into a way to make money (Buy GTC, Resell on Ebay style) is SERIOUSLY bad for the game.
I can see CCP considering that particular tradeoff pretty hard. I'm sure they'll have looked at revenue impact, and can see how much of it's happening. It may well be worth it, given that there's a lot of people who find the whole practice rather revolting.
|

Craam Hustler
Gallente ReTech
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 09:29:00 -
[223]
Originally by: James Lyrus This is the best thing CCP have ever done in EVE. There's been a LOT of cool stuff, but this, tops it.
But but, god forbid people learn how to earn ISK!!!!! WE CANT HAVE THAT! Cause once players learn to make ISK I might have to find new ways to make ISK!
Noes!
|

Briana Flametop
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 09:54:00 -
[224]
Originally by: Awox Adapt or die, I can't wait to see the day when all these morons who are broke in-game (it's too easy to make ISK these days) start buying ISK from ebay, with none of the RL money going to CCP (unlike how it works at the moment)
Fixed it for you. 
|

R3dSh1ft
FIRMA
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 09:59:00 -
[225]
GTC sellers will just go back underground again. The only people this hurts is the short-cashed ______________________________________
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:00:00 -
[226]
Edited by: voogru on 05/05/2007 09:56:33
Originally by: Briana Flametop
Originally by: Awox Adapt or die, I can't wait to see the day when all these morons who are broke in-game (it's too easy to make ISK these days) start buying ISK from ebay, with none of the RL money going to CCP (unlike how it works at the moment)
Fixed it for you. 
Originally by: R3dSh1ft GTC sellers will just go back underground again. The only people this hurts is the short-cashed
And they risk getting banned.
Way to go! Time to clean up the gene pool!
|

Avon
Caldari Black Nova Corp Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:00:00 -
[227]
Edited by: Avon on 05/05/2007 09:58:10 I have no problem with people selling some gametime to a friend for some ISK, and I doubt CCP has much of a problem with it either.
The problem is when it becomes either people selling gamtetime with intention of buying ISK (rather than helping someone out), or worse, selling ISK to buy $$ especially if that involves GTCs to "legitimise" the trade.
I welcome any change that reduces RMT, even if that may unfortunately mean a reduced ability to bail your mates out when they are short of cash to play.
CCP have seen their tolerance of "friendly" sales being abused on a large scale, and whilst it is sad for those who did it for the "right reasons", I can't see that CCP has been left with any choice other than to clamp down.
The Battleships is not and should not be a solo pwnmobile - Oveur
|

Dranadar
Gallente
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:05:00 -
[228]
I get to play for about 3 hours a week due to a VERY busy RL. I only PVP, the rest of the game doesnt interest me as much - if I had more game time maybe it would, but with such limited playtime I want to do the bit I most enjoy. I loose ships and refit when needed with an ETC trade.
I wont be spending my spare 3 hours/week 3 weeks/month grinding ISK so that at the end of the month I can PVP, and probably get a cap ship Zerg, or 50 man bubble camp pwn my ass within 15 mins of undocking, or having an FC send us on a suicide run.(its just my luck)
I dont spend RL to get "ahead" as such, just to dodge the grind - I fly BS/Recons and occiasionly need a new one. Altough I see the point if there was no ISK farming to sell for Cash/GameTime that inflation wouldnt be as bad.
But I just dont think that making time in my life for EVE is going to happen if I need to spend 75% of my time ingame doing something I dont enjoy.
Once my ship pops it looks like the account is going inactive until my RL is not so busy (but as its been like this for 4 Years I need to find some uber long skills to train)
damn shame 
Dranadar - Space Monkey
|

Avon
Caldari Black Nova Corp Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:13:00 -
[229]
Originally by: Dranadar I get to play for about 3 hours a week due to a VERY busy RL. I only PVP, the rest of the game doesnt interest me as much - if I had more game time maybe it would, but with such limited playtime I want to do the bit I most enjoy. I loose ships and refit when needed with an ETC trade.
I didn't have time to train like the other competitors, so I just had to take those performance enhancing drugs...
I don't get to play very much either, so when I have to grind for ISK I'm not doing what I want .. but I am doing what I must, as should you.
The Battleships is not and should not be a solo pwnmobile - Oveur
|

Xriss Ravana
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:23:00 -
[230]
Originally by: Avon I didn't have time to train like the other competitors, so I just had to take those performance enhancing drugs...
I don't get to play very much either, so when I have to grind for ISK I'm not doing what I want .. but I am doing what I must, as should you.
Its less using performance enhancing drugs and more skipping the qualifying stages. Him buying ISK doesnt make him better than you, like drugs would, just means he gets to compete at the same level.
|

Sorted
Privateers Privateer Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:26:00 -
[231]
Edited by: Sorted on 05/05/2007 10:22:53 Nice clear post there mister DEV
Learn More: Privateers Recruitment
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:34:00 -
[232]
Edited by: voogru on 05/05/2007 10:30:58
Originally by: Avon
Originally by: Dranadar I get to play for about 3 hours a week due to a VERY busy RL. I only PVP, the rest of the game doesnt interest me as much - if I had more game time maybe it would, but with such limited playtime I want to do the bit I most enjoy. I loose ships and refit when needed with an ETC trade.
I didn't have time to train like the other competitors, so I just had to take those performance enhancing drugs...

Originally by: Kerfira people would buy from illegal vendors anyway.
And risk getting banned. So not only will they spend RL money to advance themselves in a video game, they risk getting banned and losing what they paid for.
|

Dranadar
Gallente
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:38:00 -
[233]
Originally by: Kerfira I think a lot of people mis-understand due to some ambiguities in the OP. CCP would NEVER directly sell GTC's for ISK. It'd completely ruin their income if they did it at reasonable prices, and if their prices weren't reasonable, people would buy from illegal vendors anyway.
The scenario I think they plan is: 1. Player A buys a GTC from CCP, and instead of using it, marks it for sale (probably even setting his own price in ISK) 2. Player B wants to buy a GTC, so he looks at the list of GTC's for sale through CCP and buy one there.
This system is transparent for everyone, and 100% controllable. CCP don't need to spend ANY resources on petitions about GTC sales, and the sales forum gets cleaned up. Win-win.
The scenario they probably also want to get rid of is this: 1. All players in an alliance buys their GTC's through a 3rd party reseller. 2. The alliance gets a kick-back in RL money (maybe $1 per 90d GTC or whatever). 3. The alliance use that money to buy GTC's, which they then sell for ISK. 4. In effect, this alliance now has gotten ISK for free, in a manner approved by CCP since the current rules don't prevent it.....
Personally, I like EVERYTHING about this!!!! No free ISK for any alliances, and a secure way of buying/selling GTC's if you're poor/rich IRL.
What's not to like?????
Assumption? a Clear what is going to be and what isnt going to be, in nice bullet points from a DEV would be great.
If what you say does transpire - great. If not
Dranadar - Space Monkey
|

Dranadar
Gallente
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:42:00 -
[234]
Edited by: Dranadar on 05/05/2007 10:39:26
Originally by: Xriss Ravana
Originally by: BubbaZanetti
Excellent news.
At the same time this goin in, you're going to be limiting all other players to only be allowed to play as long as I can, right? Or, really, whatever the least amount of logged in time per month is, really, that's how long we'll need to all be allowed to play now, yes?
After all, we can't have real world circumstances influencing people's ability to get ahead in the game. It's not fair that I, who make a good living can just buy isk by selling game time cards, so it's equally not fair that some one else, who works less than I do, should be able to play the game longer and just grind isk, right?
Ok, cool. Let me know how much time we're allowed to log in an play per month as soon as you geniuses of what's fair and equitable get it sorted out.
This mans point is full of win and made of awesome, listen to him.
By grinding while on benifits the other player is getting ahead due to RL. I get it, and he gets a bigger and better ship than me. then I REALY GET IT> , hes pwning me in game by surviving on my tax money in RL.. ARGH!
narr.. seriously If he can play alot thats cool, I cant though and just want to play with the bits I enjoy. Not be forced to Mine,Mission,Scam or Trade ingame to get the ISK to do it.
Dranadar - Space Monkey
|

Kerfira
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:43:00 -
[235]
Originally by: voogru
Originally by: Kerfira people would buy from illegal vendors anyway.
And risk getting banned. So not only will they spend RL money to advance themselves in a video game, they risk getting banned and losing what they paid for.
A lot of ppl WILL risk that as long as they think they can get away with it.
What a system like this will also give to CCP, is a lot more transparency in how GTC money flows.
They can set up monitoring systems which can flag large ISK movements for investigation, and ppl will not longer have the excuse that they were doing GTC-ISK sales/buys. This'll make it easier for CCP to catch ISK-sellers/buyers and macro-farmers, while making the effort involved in illegal ISK trade go up.
If they're serious about this and implements it properly, it could make a decent dent in the ISK-trade for RL money.
|

Kerfira
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:45:00 -
[236]
Originally by: Dranadar
Originally by: Kerfira My stuff...
Assumption? a Clear what is going to be and what isnt going to be, in nice bullet points from a DEV would be great.
If what you say does transpire - great. If not
I agree, and it IS an assumption/interpretation on my part. However, this is how I read the OP, and applying a large amount of common sense 
|

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:50:00 -
[237]
Originally by: Kerfira
Originally by: Dranadar
Originally by: Kerfira My stuff...
Assumption? a Clear what is going to be and what isnt going to be, in nice bullet points from a DEV would be great.
If what you say does transpire - great. If not
I agree, and it IS an assumption/interpretation on my part. However, this is how I read the OP, and applying a large amount of common sense 
Your assumption forgot the fact ccp already has a secure gtc for isk trading system in place as part of the accounts section. The op clearly states that there getting rid of the current system that allows gtc and isk sales via third parties and that isk rich players will be able to buy gtc from ccp directly. Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

Pan Crastus
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:53:00 -
[238]
Originally by: CCP kieron In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP.
Well, that's a good way to keep your older players who are discontent with the current flaws in EVE (since they will no longer have to pay).
|

Rikako
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 10:54:00 -
[239]
Nine pages, most of it not even related to the original post: 0.0 alliances, pvp, pirating? Off topic.
Short and sweet folks, and honest to the core: If the wave of change washes over you and you don't like it, there are other places to go.
Everyone has missed the very fundamental of Kieron's post quote:
Originally by: "CCP kieron" We still have a number of details to work out
.
In essence, nothing is concrete yet. It is an idea in progress, and like it was mentioned by dear Big K himself, a number of details to work out.
A number of details to work out. Remember that, take a deep breath, hold for three seconds, let go. Now you may make your next post fellow capsuleers.
Warmly,
|

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:01:00 -
[240]
Originally by: Rikako Nine pages, most of it not even related to the original post: 0.0 alliances, pvp, pirating? Off topic.
Short and sweet folks, and honest to the core: If the wave of change washes over you and you don't like it, there are other places to go.
Everyone has missed the very fundamental of Kieron's post quote:
Originally by: "CCP kieron" We still have a number of details to work out
.
In essence, nothing is concrete yet. It is an idea in progress, and like it was mentioned by dear Big K himself, a number of details to work out.
A number of details to work out. Remember that, take a deep breath, hold for three seconds, let go. Now you may make your next post fellow capsuleers.
Warmly,
Even with a number of details to work out there is only a limited number of avenues CCP could go down and implement the basis kieron has confirmed for us, those been tiered account classes, those that buy with isk don't have access to all the content using a limitation system such as used on trial accounts currently. Charging for content expsansion packs like AO or GW. Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

Griffinator
Gallente Contraband Inc. Mercenary Coalition
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:02:00 -
[241]
Originally by: Mox Trident
Quote: In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK
This is the part that some people have missed.
The way I read it is that you will no longer be able to buy GTC's from third parties like shatteredcrystal.com or ebay.
From now on you'll buy your GTC directly from CCP through account management.
This is how I think it will work:
Player A will purchase a GTC for RL cash from CCP.
Player A will be given an option to either use the GTC himself or sell it to player B for ISK.
When player B buys a GTC from a seller, the GTC is automatically added to his subscription time. This prevents player B from re-selling the GTC out of game for RL cash.
This way CCP get the RL cash, all transactions are through account management, and third party middlemen are removed from the equation altogether.
in my opinion this would be the best and in fact easiest option boys and girls, btw keiron just so you know your original post was about as clear as a urine test after a stag night in amsterdam, a lot of us myself included as you can see from here and the amount of postage on this matter, are extreamly confused upon what exactly you meant.
but this chap i quoted has the best idea tbh good goin mox
|
|

Chribba
Otherworld Enterprises Otherworld Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:03:00 -
[242]
This could potentially mean that those of us who buys GTC's off american sites (since it's cheaper vs the euro price) would get forced into buying european gtc's via cpp ending up paying a lot more again because of the european VAT system, that doesn't sounds too good in my ears.
Either way it may turn out just fine, we'll see when some additional info is thrown at us on how the new system will work.
/c
Help me help you. |
|

Kerfira
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:04:00 -
[243]
Edited by: Kerfira on 05/05/2007 11:06:01 Edited by: Kerfira on 05/05/2007 11:03:24
Originally by: ToxicFire
Originally by: Kerfira My stuff...
Your assumption forgot the fact ccp already has a secure gtc for isk trading system in place as part of the accounts section. The op clearly states that there getting rid of the current system that allows gtc and isk sales via third parties and that isk rich players will be able to buy gtc from ccp directly.
Could be. I've never bought/sold ISK/GTC so I don't know their current system.
However, apply just a minimum of common sense to your last statement.... There is NO way (according to any business logic I know of), that'll allow ANY commercial company to basically GIVE AWAY their product......
EDIT: If I understand correctly, the current system is still dependent on a lot of 'outside' communication between seller and buyer (i.e. to find each other). If CCP implements a complete system, this'll not be needed.
2nd EDIT: I looked at the secure transfer system in the user account system. While this does provide secure transfer, it doesn't do anything at all about the scenario I described in my OP (#240) which outlines a way in which an alliance could get free ISK. This is what I think they primarily wish to get rid of.
|

Topaz Skydiver
Minmatar Narrative Freshfood
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:17:00 -
[244]
Edited by: Topaz Skydiver on 05/05/2007 11:16:02 Disappointing thread. Still see people believing that you can get gametime for isk from CCP and that this will be the whole story. CCP throwing money out of the window, no isk buying anymore.
Sounds stupid and so I don't believe that this will be the whole story.
If I assume that Kieron means it like he said that we can purchase gametime for isk directly from CCP, then I think either we will be able to purchase isk directly from CCP too as an account service or you can chose different subscription models later like a premium service that includes maybe something like xxx million isk.
The only other alternative that I see is that 'directly from CCP' was not really meant like many understood it and that the isk still goes to another customer in exchange for gametime, but with CCP sitting in the middle and no gtcs involved.
Kieron said with no word if isk purchasing will or won't be supported in any form in the future. I say it will in some form and the revenues from that will go to CCP, so don't be afraid that CCP throws money out of the window.
|

Angelo Dell'Agio
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:18:00 -
[245]
So, hang on. Essentially this is removing the real life value of the transaction involved. So, this isn't about an ISK sink, it is about preventing people from making RL money from EVE unless they are a registered and authorised reseller.
Now, the next time an alliance has a problem with customer support, what is stopping them from switching 2500 subscribers from their creditcard to GTC's for isk via CCP directly taking away the real life value of those GTC's for a few months until they see a bug fixed?
|

Sorted
Privateers Privateer Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:19:00 -
[246]
From what sense I can make out of the OP:
You can buy Game Time from CCP for ISK
You can not sell Game Time for ISK
You are still not allowed to buy ISK from the likes of Ebay etc.
That is all.
Learn More: Privateers Recruitment
|

Malachon Draco
eXceed Inc. INVICTUS.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:23:00 -
[247]
Read it 4 times, still doesn't make sense.
1. If CCP wants to do this and not lose tons of cash, they would need to set the isk price of gametime very high. Something like a billion for 30 days.
2. But if they do this, for the people who used to pay 150m isk for 30 days with GTCs (i.e. poor players with enough time) that breaks the game.
3. At the same time, for rich players wanting to buy isk with $, they can turn to the black market. And its very hard to determine who is an isk seller. How would CCP for example deal with someone who agreed to buy 1b isk from a website, but instead of just transferring the isk ingame, they agree to let the guy buying the isk put up a megathron on sale for 1.1 billion, name it 'Vindicator' and the isk seller 'accidentally' buying it for that price. There. 1.1 Billion changed hands ingame and you can't prove it was part of an iskselling deal.
4. It enables more pressure to be put on CCP. At the moment I think there are quite a few disgruntled veterans in Eve, who might want to express their dissatisfaction with CCP's handling of certain situations, but don't want to leave Eve just yet. They could massively shift their subscriptions to a 'isk for time' deal, paid for by their reserves to squeeze CCP hard on monthly revenue.
All in all, I really don't see how this is gonna be smart. signature removed - please contact us to find out why (include the URL of your sig) - Jacques([email protected]) |

Angelo Dell'Agio
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:25:00 -
[248]
Originally by: Sorted From what sense I can make out of the OP:
You can buy Game Time from CCP for ISK
You can not sell Game Time for ISK
You are still not allowed to buy ISK from the likes of Ebay etc.
That is all.
That is the way I read it as well. But it also means that there is a lot of RL money lost in the cycle, depending on the volume of transactions. Someone has to pay for the GTC's, at the end of the day someone has to actually pay with real life money. So say I switch to GTC's for ISK in this new mechanism, and I buy the GTC's directly from CCP under account management, who is paying the RL money equivalent to CCP? CCP itself in a way.
Now if I select an autorised reseller instead, CCP will have to pay that reseller the real life value essentially, after converting the ISK to dollars basically.
So, a lot of RL financial transaction value is essentially lost, unless I am missing something. If this is the case, what is stopping a disgruntled bunch of alliances from switching to GTC's from ISK from complexes and as such cutting drastically into the monthly revenue cycle of actual currency?
|

Angelus Damelon
Merch Industrial We Are Nice Guys
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:32:00 -
[249]
I'd pay an extra $5 a month if it meant CCP hired someone to release information clearly.
|

Elgar Lightfoot
Lightfoot Industries
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:40:00 -
[250]
Edited by: Elgar Lightfoot on 05/05/2007 11:39:22 Banning the selling of GTC's for RL cash sound illegal to me. A GTC is a RL item with ownership rights, just the same as any other item you purchase in any shop. Once you buy it, it's yours and yours to do with as you please.
Awating confirmation on this babble.
The other way I read it is CCP are going to force me to start buying GTC's in Euro's. If that happens I'll be leaving. No way am I paying more than I should be.
|

Topaz Skydiver
Minmatar Narrative Freshfood
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:41:00 -
[251]
Originally by: Sorted From what sense I can make out of the OP:
You can buy Game Time from CCP for ISK
You can not sell Game Time for ISK
You are still not allowed to buy ISK from the likes of Ebay etc.
That is all.
Yes, and Kieron claimed with no word completeness for his post. That it isn't mentioned, how things will look like for the rich casual gamer, who wants isk and is willing to spend cash for it, doesn't mean that CCP doesn't offer them a new means to do so without gtcs as an intermediate step.
Put those rich casual gamers, who want isk as an extra service that they are willing to pay for into the equation and CCP offering them that means and it all makes sense. CCP doesn't throw money out of the window, they can even make profit with this change.
|

Semtex'o
Minmatar eXceed Inc. INVICTUS.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:47:00 -
[252]
Originally by: Topaz Skydiver
Originally by: Sorted From what sense I can make out of the OP:
You can buy Game Time from CCP for ISK
You can not sell Game Time for ISK
You are still not allowed to buy ISK from the likes of Ebay etc.
That is all.
Yes, and Kieron claimed with no word completeness for his post. That it isn't mentioned, how things will look like for the rich casual gamer, who wants isk and is willing to spend cash for it, doesn't mean that CCP doesn't offer them a new means to do so without gtcs as an intermediate step.
Put those rich casual gamers, who want isk as an extra service that they are willing to pay for into the equation and CCP offering them that means and it all makes sense. CCP doesn't throw money out of the window, they can even make profit with this change.
CCP wouldn't make a profit from this simply because they would get paid in virtual money for their timecodes. And it doesn't take a genius to look that GTCs are wanted looking at all those sell orders in the trade section and how fast they are getting sold.
|

Sorted
Privateers Privateer Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:47:00 -
[253]
i was just stating what was said, not what wasnt, which is a whole lot.
There may well be alternatives for the ISK buyers, there may not be.
I dont know what they have planned for the future, and from the content in the OP neither do the DEVs
Learn More: Privateers Recruitment
|

AsmodeaN
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:52:00 -
[254]
So basically because BoB have lost most of the complexes they used to rent out/run themselves/whatever and have lost a large chunk of their income, ccp have decided to give them a new income source?
You sending them the ISK directly or going around the houses some?
|

Whu FlungPoo
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:55:00 -
[255]
Edited by: Whu FlungPoo on 05/05/2007 11:52:48 PVPer read this!
What you are failing to understand, is that your funding of your PVP adventures with your real world cash is turning the game one sided. You dont stay in your own space and fight other real world money funded PVPers, you sneak around cloaked and prey on the ones trying to live every aspect of the game. You dont fight each other, you seek out weaker targets, and then feel proud. You lose a ship and pull out the Visa to buy another, while I have to go hide in a belt for 4 days to build the one you blew up when I was just trying to run a mission. I had no beef with you. But you go around like a serial killer and blow up everything you can target.
I leave with this question for you PVPers to ask yourself. What about your real life makes you need to destroy others work?
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:57:00 -
[256]
Originally by: Whu FlungPoo PVPer read this!
What you are failing to understand, is that your funding of your PVP adventures with your real world cash is turning the game one sided. You dont stay in your own space the fight other real world money funded PVPers, you sneak around cloaked and prey on the ones trying to live every aspect of the game. You dont fight each other, you seek out weaker targets, and then feel proud. You lose a ship and pull out the Visa to buy another, while I have to go hide in a belt for 4 days to build the one you blew up when I was just trying to run a mission. I had no beef with you. But you go around like a serial killer and blow up everything you can target.
I leave with this question for you PVPers to ask yourself. What about your real life makes you need to destroy others work?
... so everyone who has ever sold a GTC is a Recon-piloting griefer?
Seriously stfu.
---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Topaz Skydiver
Minmatar Narrative Freshfood
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 11:58:00 -
[257]
Edited by: Topaz Skydiver on 05/05/2007 11:56:11 Edited by: Topaz Skydiver on 05/05/2007 11:55:01
Originally by: Semtex'o
Originally by: Topaz Skydiver
Originally by: Sorted From what sense I can make out of the OP:
You can buy Game Time from CCP for ISK
You can not sell Game Time for ISK
You are still not allowed to buy ISK from the likes of Ebay etc.
That is all.
Yes, and Kieron claimed with no word completeness for his post. That it isn't mentioned, how things will look like for the rich casual gamer, who wants isk and is willing to spend cash for it, doesn't mean that CCP doesn't offer them a new means to do so without gtcs as an intermediate step.
Put those rich casual gamers, who want isk as an extra service that they are willing to pay for into the equation and CCP offering them that means and it all makes sense. CCP doesn't throw money out of the window, they can even make profit with this change.
CCP wouldn't make a profit from this simply because they would get paid in virtual money for their timecodes.
I really wonder, how far you guys think.
Model 1: - CCP offers gametime for isk for the poor gamer with too much time. - CCP sells isk for cash or offers extra isk in form of a new premium service for the rich casual gamer.
Balance the exchange rates out and you can keep inflation under control and make profit.
Model 2: Player A buys gametime, transfers it via CCP as a middle man to Player B in exchange for isk. No GTCs involved in this transfer.
Current model: Play A buys GTC and sells it for isk to player B.
See, all 3 models offer gametime for isk, isk for cash, none of the models means a loss for CCP. Magic ! 
|

Whu FlungPoo
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:00:00 -
[258]
Ive bought GTCs and sold them. I didnt say anything like what you insenuated. But when you can go and wrecklessly lose 500m isk in ships in one day, and go buy some more time to do it over again exploits a flaw in the system.
|

Avon
Caldari Black Nova Corp Band of Brothers
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:04:00 -
[259]
Originally by: AsmodeaN So basically because BoB have lost most of the complexes they used to rent out/run themselves/whatever and have lost a large chunk of their income, ccp have decided to give them a new income source?
You sending them the ISK directly or going around the houses some?

How did this suddenly become a BoB issue? Get over yourself.
The Battleships is not and should not be a solo pwnmobile - Oveur
|

Shayla Sh'inlux
The Black Rabbits
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:10:00 -
[260]
Gonna be interesting to see how many accounts will get cancelled because they can no longer be payed for with ISK-bought GTC's.
The amount of people that I personally know that pay with GTC's is astounding. I'd be surprised if even 20% of them would get the CC's charged again...
Discussing moderation is a no-no - Tirg |

Eviloution
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:14:00 -
[261]
Originally by: AsmodeaN So basically because BoB have lost most of the complexes they used to rent out/run themselves/whatever and have lost a large chunk of their income, ccp have decided to give them a new income source?
You sending them the ISK directly or going around the houses some?
What a moronic deluded post, if you really think this is how it is QUIT EVE, stop playing and do the rest of us a favor.
Yes BoB lost their 10/10's while they are being fixed noone else did, thats clearly favortism that BoB lose billions of isk a week for the last month, grop up or go play WOW.
|

AsmodeaN
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:25:00 -
[262]
Originally by: Eviloution
Originally by: AsmodeaN So basically because BoB have lost most of the complexes they used to rent out/run themselves/whatever and have lost a large chunk of their income, ccp have decided to give them a new income source?
You sending them the ISK directly or going around the houses some?
What a moronic deluded post, if you really think this is how it is QUIT EVE, stop playing and do the rest of us a favor.
Yes BoB lost their 10/10's while they are being fixed noone else did, thats clearly favortism that BoB lose billions of isk a week for the last month, grop up or go play WOW.
Wow cry more. People get really sensitive about these things dont they? I never said anything about them losing their 10/10's while they were fixed. afaik they have lost pretty much all of them to RA so ccp had nothing to do with their loss of income, infact thats probably why they got fixed eh? lol 
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:26:00 -
[263]
Originally by: AsmodeaN
Originally by: Eviloution
Originally by: AsmodeaN So basically because BoB have lost most of the complexes they used to rent out/run themselves/whatever and have lost a large chunk of their income, ccp have decided to give them a new income source?
You sending them the ISK directly or going around the houses some?
What a moronic deluded post, if you really think this is how it is QUIT EVE, stop playing and do the rest of us a favor.
Yes BoB lost their 10/10's while they are being fixed noone else did, thats clearly favortism that BoB lose billions of isk a week for the last month, grop up or go play WOW.
Wow cry more. People get really sensitive about these things dont they? I never said anything about them losing their 10/10's while they were fixed. afaik they have lost pretty much all of them to RA so ccp had nothing to do with their loss of income, infact thats probably why they got fixed eh? lol 
You need to show your corp ticker before anyone will take you seriously.
Even then...
---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Heroldyn
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:45:00 -
[264]
well,
this was an interesting read.
its seems rather amusing to me tho, that people allways refer to the poor people having an unfair disadvantage compared to the people will real life income -
doesnt time-rich poor players also have an unfair advantage over people with less free time ?
both of theese kinds of people have advantages over each other due to their real-life environment. so you bascily have the choice to either allow thoose RL Conditions to affect the game (allow GTC->ISK and ISK->GTC trades) or to deny that by either disallowing ISK->GTC trades, forcing the unemployed time-rich playerbase to get a job in order to continue playing the game- or to restricted the amount of time people are allow to play it.
|

Stella Stardust
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:46:00 -
[265]
Of course CCP can pay their bills in ISK. They already do. http://www.oanda.com/convert/classic
Saturday, May 5, 2007 1 Iceland Krona = 0.01160 Euro 1 Euro (EUR) = 86.21090 Iceland Krona (ISK) Interbank rate +/- 0% This means: You buy 1 Iceland Krona : 0.01160 Euro You sell 1 Iceland Krona : 0.01156 Euro You buy 1 Euro : 86.21090 Iceland Krona You sell 1 Euro : 86.49968 Iceland Krona Median price = 0.01156 / 0.01160 (bid/ask) Estimated price based on daily US dollar rates. Having that out of the way....
It would be nice with a clarification, because the OP makes no sense whatsoever.
|

Tom Shandy
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 12:50:00 -
[266]
Originally by: Roscoe Rhoads Edited by: Roscoe Rhoads on 05/05/2007 00:06:41 Last input from the mind of a GTC'er.
I earn ~$65 per hour IRL.
One hour of mindlessly boring ratting or mission running is at tops 100 million ISK.
One GTC, with a ____MARKET ECONOMY THAT CCP WON'T BE ABLE TO MATCH____ costs me $15 for 120-160 million ISK.
I play EVE Online for the PvP, and I will quit playing and quit giving CCP upwards $100 / month on my two accounts (which where gonna become three) when this is implemented - and I'm guessing thousands of others will too. I don't understand how you feel this is a good idea.
cool, people that calculate how much thier time is worth need to get a life anyway, hope you find one soon outside of Eve. " The Coalition Vs BoD" |

max bygraves
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 13:07:00 -
[267]
The only thing i can actually make out from this thread is that Crumplecorn is very poor IRL and is jealous of those around him with $ to burn.
|

katz3
Aliastra
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 13:21:00 -
[268]
Very good change. Death to all those fgt gtc resellers. ___________________
|

Tamer
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 13:22:00 -
[269]
Edited by: Tamer on 05/05/2007 13:18:04 1. Idea for removing confusion: ingame timecode trading.
1) The Player buys a code for dollars. 2) The Player has two variants of input of a code: for prolongation of an account and for purchase of an item "timecode" for his character. 3) The Player can sell a "timecode" item in the game market for ISK. 4) The Player can use "timecode" item for prolongation of the account (right click menu). 5) The Player can set Buy Order in market for "timecode" item.
2. Idea for removing confusion: website Stock Exchange.
1) The Player buys a code for dollars 2) The Player establishes the lead on The Website Stock Exchange, and establishes its ISK price. 3) Other player buys the cheapest lead at The Website Stock Exchange.
--------------------- English language (100) ETA: 17d 13h 54m 13s |

Meren T'ia
Amarr
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 13:29:00 -
[270]
so I have 3 accounts atm, does this mean I will not be able to pay for them with ISK made in game ? if SO ME = 1 Account there is no way im spending mor than $20 on a MMO just on principle. 1 aacount will do but I will get a little bpored but hey theres loads of other MMO's out there 
|

Deus Ex'Machina
Amarr Imperial Academy
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 14:01:00 -
[271]
Originally by: Goumindong Edited by: Goumindong on 05/05/2007 08:40:28
Originally by: Deus Ex'Machina
Originally by: Mox Trident
Quote: In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK
This is the part that some people have missed.
The way I read it is that you will no longer be able to buy GTC's from third parties like shatteredcrystal.com or ebay.
From now on you'll buy your GTC directly from CCP through account management.
This is how I think it will work:
Player A will purchase a GTC for RL cash from CCP.
Player A will be given an option to either use the GTC himself or sell it to player B for ISK.
When player B buys a GTC from a seller, the GTC is automatically added to his subscription time. This prevents player B from re-selling the GTC out of game for RL cash.
This way CCP get the RL cash, all transactions are through account management, and third party middlemen are removed from the equation altogether.
Well, if this is true then it's perfect.
Note, seller = player A ;-) Note, buying from player A = trough account management
/signed this particular version of Engrish 
Uhh. This is how it works right now.
Just because player A isnt named "www.shatteredcrystal.com" does not mean that player A isnt www.shatteredcrystal.com.
If its supposedly going to work like that then it doesnt change anything except make the middlemans accounting a little bit more difficult.
Hold yer horses, this theory implied that buying a GTC from CCP with $ would give you a "GTC menu" inside account management with only two options -> "Sell for isk to character"(this option would consume the GTC directly in the process) "Use this gtc for this account".
The idea is you don't get to see the actual code. *snip* - Image not appropriate for eve-o forums - hutch
true amarr tank shields! |

phillie blunt
State War Academy
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 14:21:00 -
[272]
ccp nerf the goons!
about time, I like the idea
|

Mr Linderman
Selective Extinction
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 14:25:00 -
[273]
I'm slightly confused as to what CCP's intentions are.
Are they:
A. To introduce an in house system of buying time for your account with in game money ISK, and taking support off the current system of resellers selling GTC for ISK.
or
B. To introduce an in house system of buying time codes for eve with real money, and taking support off the current system of resellers selling GTC for ISK.
If it is "A" then i can see it working pretty well, after a few months allot of ISK will be sunk back in CCP's blackhole and only people who can make the required amount of Isk will probably use the system to get time on there accounts. This will however cut short on sales of GTC's from supported resellers.
But wouldn't this increase the amount of macro miners ?. I mean if there is a supported in house system for guying time with ISK the sale of ISK from macro'ers would rise would it not ?
I'm not to sure on whats happening and it would be nice if CCP would release a clear directive on there intentions so there is no more confusion.
Regards Mr L
www.eve-services.com - The only place to Shop for services
|

Purgatori
Minmatar Infinitus Odium
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 14:29:00 -
[274]
Edited by: Purgatori on 05/05/2007 14:25:08 ccp got cash someone got play time someone else got isk everyone is happy...
and now... i think its just going to increase macro miners+ chinese sweat shops... yay
|

Cremytos
Caldari Manticore.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 14:38:00 -
[275]
And CCP did (by making this thread WITHOUT proper explanations) bump up GTC sellers prices by 15%.
yey .
|

DarkElf
Veto. Veto Corp
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 14:43:00 -
[276]
Sounds all good to me if i'm reading it right. anything that further removes RL money from affecting a game is a good thing.
DE
|

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 14:43:00 -
[277]
The only way I can afford to PvP is to buy GTCs and sell them for in game ISK. I don't do it that often, but I still do it to pay the bills!
What CCP are saying here is basically, "If you want to PvP, you have to PvE". The only real incomes (ISK wise) in game are PvE based, either through construction, mining, ratting, or whatever. I play this game for the social element and for the PvP. I don't have enough time to sit and rat for a dozen hours in order to buy a ship to PvP in, so I buy a GTC to enjoy this game.
It may not sound much to CCP (lately they care little for what individuals think), but if you take out GTC for ISK sales by players, you will eventually lose me as a player. I'll have the ISK I have now, then sell my second character and use that ISK, then when that's gone, I'm gone. I refuse to PvE in order to PvP!
I know that it is PvE players that bring most of the money to CCP and PvPers are a minority, which is why we often get stitched in terms of a lot of gameplay features (not naming any to keep the topic on track). But this change leaves me with little choice as to how I play the game.
Now I know CCP don't care all too much what the individual thinks, so I'll just point out here that I mentioned the change in an ingame channel to people I play with, and one said the only solution was to mine, another said it was a lame decision and he'd probably end up quitting too.
Obviously not all PvP is like this. I could choose to join one of the massive blob alliances, spend most of my time making money in deep 0.0 space, then go round in a 100 man blob so I don't lose any ships, but this is not appealing to me, so I'm stuck around lowsec with no rats, no mining, no production. Just PvP. Now CCP wants to take my ISK away from me so I can no longer PvP.
I also want to point out at this stage that there are a few players that get a seriously easy ride in EVE. Those ones that get picked randomly for the t2 BPO lottery are the very same ones that will now be playing for game time with the ISK they got for free.
And I finally want to once again point out the risk versus reward system in the game being screwed up. Fix that and you'll fix the ISK problem that PvPers have...
Most responses to this topic talk about buying PvP ships with 'bought ISK', and they're right. The only people that generally 'buy ISK' are PvPers. This is because they enjoy PvE less than PvP. Forcing them to PvE in order to PvP (as I have just said) will make them dislike the game, and you'll lose a large player base in doing this.
Obviously, CCP don't care what the individual has to say, so I'll get ignored. I can only hope that other players agree with me and make enough noise to stop this plan going ahead.
Fely
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

Abyssal Angel
Caldari Solar Wind Interstellar Alcohol Conglomerate
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 15:04:00 -
[278]
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn The only way I can afford to PvP is to buy GTCs and sell them for in game ISK. I don't do it that often, but I still do it to pay the bills!
What CCP are saying here is basically, "If you want to PvP, you have to PvE". The only real incomes (ISK wise) in game are PvE based, either through construction, mining, ratting, or whatever.
Fely *formatted to take up less space*
First of, Kudos for actually admitting and defending your way of gaming.
But as you have said in your own post, in order to PVP one has to PVE.
That this way of gaming (EVE) does not appeal to you is unfortunate, but not something that should result in not introducing a change to the mechanics in order to "save" the economic aspect of the game, without it, what would be left? (WOW me thinks).
If I read CCP correctly the only thing they are working on changing is in fact that which you take advantage of, the ability to gain an ingame advantage for out of game money.
With the possibility of sounding harsh, I believe one of the most well known quotes and replies to pvp posts is:
"Don't fly what you cannot afford to lose".
Yes this change will mean a change in the way you play and possible result in you leaving the game, but then you should ask yourself if it was ever the correct game for you?
As always, if anyone was needlessly offended I apologize.
AA Your signature exceeds the maximum allowed dimensions of 400x120 pixels - Deckard ([email protected]) Again
|

Roscoe Rhoads
Caldari Provisions
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 15:07:00 -
[279]
Originally by: Tom Shandy cool, people that calculate how much thier time is worth need to get a life anyway, hope you find one soon outside of Eve.
Way to read. The implication here is that alot of us _have_ a life outside the game and aren't really willing to spend our meager online time doing the sub par and boring PvE content in order to afford to PvP.
-- Human action is purposeful behavior. |

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 15:08:00 -
[280]
1/ Why is this obviously very important thread not sticky?
2/ With all the obvious confusion and worry, isn't it time for Kieron to post again clarifying what he means? You can't drop a bombshell like that on friday night and saturday off K. ---
Originally by: Tista i dont like you much but i'm going to agree with you on that.
|

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 15:15:00 -
[281]
Originally by: Abyssal Angel
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn The only way I can afford to PvP is to buy GTCs and sell them for in game ISK. I don't do it that often, but I still do it to pay the bills!
What CCP are saying here is basically, "If you want to PvP, you have to PvE". The only real incomes (ISK wise) in game are PvE based, either through construction, mining, ratting, or whatever.
Fely *formatted to take up less space*
First of, Kudos for actually admitting and defending your way of gaming.
But as you have said in your own post, in order to PVP one has to PVE.
That this way of gaming (EVE) does not appeal to you is unfortunate, but not something that should result in not introducing a change to the mechanics in order to "save" the economic aspect of the game, without it, what would be left? (WOW me thinks).
If I read CCP correctly the only thing they are working on changing is in fact that which you take advantage of, the ability to gain an ingame advantage for out of game money.
With the possibility of sounding harsh, I believe one of the most well known quotes and replies to pvp posts is:
"Don't fly what you cannot afford to lose".
Yes this change will mean a change in the way you play and possible result in you leaving the game, but then you should ask yourself if it was ever the correct game for you?
As always, if anyone was needlessly offended I apologize.
AA
I'm not the kind of person that spends ú500 on GTCs then jumps in a Vindicator or Bhaalgorn or whatever, fully faction fitted just to gain some form of advantage. Like I said, I don't buy GTC often, but I like to fly good ships. Absolutions and Pilgrims are my favourite at the moment. I don't 'buy ISK' to put Centus mods on my ships, just to be able to afford to fly a nice t2 ship. True, this does give me an advantage over some players, but in a game where the biggest ships are flown by those people that have limitless access to ISK Faucets (no offence meant, but even IAC have their safe space in 0.0 where they can rat away and make reams of cash. Even you have a picture of a Vindicator in your signature). What I'm saying is that gap before you join a massive blob alliance (again, no offence) where you don't have safe 0.0 access. How do you expect me to make money? Buy some BPOs and start producing? But I'm -9.5, I can't get to highsec to produce. So I have to use a second character to make ISK? Hold on, I'm paying for that second character with real life money, and he's my ISK maker. That's exactly the same as buying some GTCs, surely?
I don't know if you'll get my point because nature made me a very abstract person, but if you do, I think you'll wind up agreeing with me in the end.
EVE is my favourite game, due to the social aspect, and the PvP. If I am forced to rat or build for money, then that takes away from the fun (you have to admit yourself that ratting for 3 hours a day to buy a new ship isn't fun). I don't have the time to PvE and PvP. So I make a choice to PvP (the more fun of the two), and consequently to pay for that, I buy GTCs and sell them for in game ISK.
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

Minmatar Citizen783212
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 15:28:00 -
[282]
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn I refuse to PvE in order to PvP!
Try Guild Wars, it's probably more "up your alley" so to speak.
|

Nyphur
Pillowsoft
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 15:33:00 -
[283]
A word before I start. This is not a discussion. A discussion is when both sides talk, this is a request for feedback on a vague concept. The difference is that most of posts in the thread will probably be ignored and we'd be lucky to get a reply at all.
I complained about gtcs for isk when they came out. I was quite adamant that it would be exploited to hell and I argued vehemently that I shouldn't be allowed to play eve for free just because I've got some more business sense than the average player. I warned about the exploitability of gtc-isk sales, re-warned every time the topic came up and when the decision was set in stone and you (you personally, kieron) were convinced it was a good decision, I gave up and started exploiting the system. I've bought gtcs for isk on a number of occasions and sold them to friends, corpmates and people I trust for cash.
I would never start some kind of large-scale business out of it as obtaining isk is my goal in eve as a player but there are those who have. I had a discussion about the GTC reseller Amber Leonne and while I reserve judgement, some people I chat to are convinced that Amber doesn't even play eve but is just using it to farm masses of isk to convert into gtcs for resale on websites such as ebay. As I warned over and over again, if you leave a loophole then it will be exploited. Most people will use a loophole occasionally when the need arises but there will always be someone who will abuse it out of all proportion. Teams of dozens of macrominers running on a server farm, hundreds trial accounts mining in cruisers, someone is always going to exploit anything they can out of all proportion.
In this case, the gtc-isk transactions were always intended to allow people who couldn't afford the cash a way to play eve while not losing CCP the money that would otherwise have been made. In line with that, a system that allows people to purchase game time directly with isk will not work. Reading through your post, I believe you are misleading people as to the nature of this new system, either intentionally or through bad use of the english language.
What your post conveys: - A new subscription method is coming out soon. - This new method will let you pay for your eve subscription with isk. - Your isk simply enters the system but doesn't go anywhere. CCP has essentially sold you game time for isk. - Game time code for isk sales will be banned. - CCP will lose income from those pilots who opt to use isk as their game time is effectively given for free.
There are only two ways I can see this ACTUALLY working: #1 - CCP simply acts as a gobetween - A new subscription method comes out. - This new method allows me to pay for my eve subscription with isk by purchasing a game time code (to be used immediately) from a sell order list. - This public sell order list is made by players who list their coes for sale. - The isk goes from player A to player B without any interaction other than selling or buying on the website. - People retain the ability to play for free (paying with isk) or to buy their way into eve as they see fit. - CCP retain profit as they currently do.
#2 - CCP start selling isk - A new subscription method comes out. - This new method allows me to pay for my eve subscription with isk directly from CCP. - CCP sell this isk for cash in some manner.
Since #2 is clearly not going to happen, the first scenario is infinitely more plausible. Also, given the fact that they've been working hard on the current secure transfer method, this is just the logical next step. It would get rid of the gtc sales threads and the money conversion method but keep the ability of people to buy their way into eve (characters and all).
So for those of you hoping gtc for isk sales are going to be banned to prevent people buying their way to the top, I find it highly unlikely that this will change a thing.
Eve-Tanking.com - For tanking spreadsheet and resources. |

Minuteman
Cereal Puff's Alektorophobia
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 16:06:00 -
[284]
Originally by: Montague Zooma It's the latest trend in the game biz. I hear Hasbro will now let you buy games with Monopoly money.
Bloody brilliant.
Minuteman's Comic |

TheEndofTheWorld
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 16:33:00 -
[285]
Edited by: TheEndofTheWorld on 05/05/2007 16:33:19
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn ...
Good thing that you are getting nerfed.
Use MSN/ICQ whatever if you want social aspect...
On Topic:
People in CCP are not idiots... They have thougth it over and decided it is better to redo the gtc stuff.
|

Beef Hardslab
The 5 Amigo's LLC.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 16:35:00 -
[286]
Originally by: TheEndofTheWorld
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn ...
Good thing that you are getting nerfed.
Use MSN/ICQ whatever if you want social aspect...
Jeez there were enough people in here speculating about whether or not you were coming, and now you show up. GG everyone! Why there should be a breathalyzer to login to Eve:
Originally by: Alliaanna Dalaii Podding my own alt in a gatecamp while drunk, he was carrying a hauler full of tech II goods, Oops.
|

Nyphur
Pillowsoft
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:03:00 -
[287]
Originally by: Elad Dranoel CCP trying to cut profits now eh?
Which is more likely, that CCP is going to willingly decimate their income or that they're misleading us as to the nature of the new system?
Eve-Tanking.com - For tanking spreadsheet and resources. |

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:04:00 -
[288]
Originally by: Nero Scuro Stop being a noob Fely. You PvPed before GTC>ISK was legal and you were top of the killboards then, too. Ever thought that if nobody can buy ISK you won't need to either, because their ships will be crappier (but so will yours).
You make it sound like everyone buys isk.
I can't compete with player X because player X has an alt in a major 0.0 alliance who farms 10/10s all day. He flies around in a Core X-type fitted Vindicator. What exactly can I do about that?
Lemme guess, join a 0.0 alliance? Stop whining? Go play WoW?
|

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:16:00 -
[289]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Nero Scuro Stop being a noob Fely. You PvPed before GTC>ISK was legal and you were top of the killboards then, too. Ever thought that if nobody can buy ISK you won't need to either, because their ships will be crappier (but so will yours).
You make it sound like everyone buys isk.
I can't compete with player X because player X has an alt in a major 0.0 alliance who farms 10/10s all day. He flies around in a Core X-type fitted Vindicator. What exactly can I do about that?
Lemme guess, join a 0.0 alliance? Stop whining? Go play WoW?
I love the way everyone on these forums as soon as you disagree with someone, they tell you to go and play a different MMO... After my post lage page I was told to go play 2 different MMOs, so I think I should get a medal for that...
And no, no-one can have my stuff...
Anyway, what I'm saying is similar to what you're saying here, player X has an alt that farms to get loads of isk, so what are the options for the rest of the players in EVE? 1) Join a major 0.0 blob alliance and farm 2) Only fly frigs, by which you can never kill anyone anyway, so you still have to go mine in highsec 3) Buy GTCs and sell them for ISK 4) Go play a different MMO
0.0 blob alliances are fun for a while, but don't hold a candle to the scale of PvP that I get in to every time I play EVE... I'm talking about little gangs, 5v5, 2v1, or in the case of last night, 4 of us vs a nidhoggur! 
The only viable option for people that like guerilla style warfare and small scale PvP with no access to a massive 0.0 alliance and 10/10 plex, is to buy GTCs... Meh!
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

BOSSMAN69
E X O D U S Imperial Republic Of the North
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:23:00 -
[290]
It wont work I'm afraid. I can buy GTC's from a third party hand the code over by MSN and then recieve the isk in game. Admittedly this will only be to people I can trust eg alliance members. The only way CCP can stop this is to stop selling codes to third parties and you aint gonna do that coz it generates too much money to throw away. Just leave it as it is. Nobody is harmed by it and you get your cash simple. You are pushing a lot of players away, myself included with Lag, Titans, Pos's, exploits and now trying to stop people who are ú strapped from using isk to be able to buy codes at a reasonable amount.
Victories are only possible if there is combat
Combat is only possible if there is WAR
|

Jayyne Cobb
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:29:00 -
[291]
Quote:
CCP will never get rid of every bug, so why bother fixing the current ones?
Some bugs SHOULDNT be fixed, as that can cause countless others as well as security flaws or data loss. EVE isn't immune to this.
Anyways, can CCP decipher WTF they are talking about? I understand the current rules on GTC:$ now, but am completely LOST from this quasi-"Engrish" blurb.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:32:00 -
[292]
Originally by: BOSSMAN69 Just leave it as it is. Nobody is harmed by it and you get your cash simple.
QFT. No some parts of the game aren't fair, but this is not the answer. Under the current system CCP gets all the cash it is due, people can pay for their gametime with isk and everyone is reasonably happy. Yes there are isk selling cartels but tbh who the hell cares, it doesn't really affect the game. All other MMO's have it.
Maybe you should focus your energies on all the other, vastly more pressing problems that Eve has.
|

Dominique Vasilkovsky
Techmart Industries
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:35:00 -
[293]
The way I understand the post by Kieron is that they will stop the isk -> gtc -> cash conversion which is something macrominers and other low lifes can use to legally convert isk to cash with.
Step one for this has already happened with the recent introduction of a secure GTC transfer system on the subscription page.
Next step is that instead of the GTC seller to enter a code he bought from a 3rd party site he will be able to buy a gametime token directly from CCP for cash and then either use it himself or transfer it using the system above.
So the end result will be as follow:
You will still be able to buy game time using ISK from other players. You will still be able to buy game time using cash and sell to other players for ISK. You will NOT be able to convert ISK from a T2 BPO/scam/hacking to cash using the current GTC loophole.
The only people that should be upset by this change are those using EVE for a living and not a game.
|

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:42:00 -
[294]
Originally by: Dominique Vasilkovsky The way I understand the post by Kieron is that they will stop the isk -> gtc -> cash conversion which is something macrominers and other low lifes can use to legally convert isk to cash with.
Step one for this has already happened with the recent introduction of a secure GTC transfer system on the subscription page.
Next step is that instead of the GTC seller to enter a code he bought from a 3rd party site he will be able to buy a gametime token directly from CCP for cash and then either use it himself or transfer it using the system above.
So the end result will be as follow:
You will still be able to buy game time using ISK from other players. You will still be able to buy game time using cash and sell to other players for ISK. You will NOT be able to convert ISK from a T2 BPO/scam/hacking to cash using the current GTC loophole.
The only people that should be upset by this change are those using EVE for a living and not a game.
I hope you're right...
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:44:00 -
[295]
Edited by: Marquis Dean on 05/05/2007 17:40:34
Originally by: Dominique Vasilkovsky The only people that should be upset by this change are those using EVE for a living and not a game.
That's what i'm hoping. Then again I don't have a damn clue what Kieron is on about, i've gleaned my understand from everyone else.
What i'm worried about is that this is stop people who are making a living with a regular job, using their rl money (and it is theirs to spend as they wish) to occasionally get a leg up in Eve instead of having to grind 2 weeks of missions or mining. Tbh I sincerely doubt there is anyone who actually funds their entire PvP game from GTC sales. $30 buys you a 90 day that sells for what, 320-340 mil? That's an exchange rate of $1:10mil. So to buy a pimped out capital would cost in excess of $200, and no kid on earth has parents that would allow that, especially several times a month. If it's a rich nerd who made millions of a new kind of non-stick mousemat or whatever, then if he doesn't know how to use his ships they're gonna die, if he does then more power to him.
|

NeellixTheTrader
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 17:49:00 -
[296]
Edited by: NeellixTheTrader on 05/05/2007 17:48:13 hm... hope this doesnt mean im out of eve, i mean if i cant buy etc with isk then i wasted 1 year for somethin that will not give me fun finaly after haveing basic skills to survive and start some serious pvp playing in eve, also whats wrong with [{MY TIME = ISK = ETC = MY TIME = ISK = ETC }=> all thougather => each player makes eve each day], without players theres no eve right, after all ETC code i bought from some player with isk is payed in real life money, seller of etc payed it, he wants bit more isk to afford somethin in eve and i want to extend my play days and thats called healty economy, i gain, etc seller gains and ccp gains as ppl buy mounths in front even if they dont need that much, im one of them, my english aint that great and hope u dont get me wrong, i think of ccp and eve very highly, eve is not just a game eve is THE GAME, im only wondering erm... can u tell me what exactly u gona do to this way of play pay(ISK for ETC) so i can see should i fear for my future in eve or not, if so then better prevent than heal, quit while i could make peace with the fact i invested 1 year in evolving my char and starting another few mounths ago insted to be suddnly squeezed on the wall. [just a thought] I wonder how many characters are running on ISK for ETC code princible?! well thats bout it, my concrns. all the best :) Neel
|

TheEndofTheWorld
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 18:24:00 -
[297]
Edited by: TheEndofTheWorld on 05/05/2007 18:20:42
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn
The only viable option for people that like guerilla style warfare and small scale PvP with no access to a massive 0.0 alliance and 10/10 plex, is to buy GTCs... Meh!
Hahaha. Don't be stupid. You need to buy gtcs for guerilla stlye warfare? Come on, geeet real. Maybe you should leave Enigma & Murder of Crows and find a new corp. You might get a whole new (and better) view on EVE.
You don't need high-end t2 absolution to have pvp fun.
Not to mention 0.0 ratting as a soloplayer is very, very easy. Or get friends and run plexes?
tbh RL cash -> isk is soo ruining any game out there, eve is no exception.
|

alexreborn
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 18:26:00 -
[298]
I got a simple solution:
a) make it easier to make ISK. right now small corps, individuals cannot make alot of isk unless they mission ***** for hours on end, and or mine for hours on end.
b) Get more 10/10 plexes THAT ARE NOT IN dead end regions held by big aliances.
c) T2 BPO's, make it possible for more players to have them.
Its hard enough playing in zero zero space, unless you want everyone in high sec being a care bear, there are several changes to ISK making that need to be had if youre going to remove the purchase options.
|

Dominique Vasilkovsky
Techmart Industries
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 18:34:00 -
[299]
Originally by: alexreborn c) T2 BPO's, make it possible for more players to have them.
Invention has solved that one. It do cost a bit to start up unless you are good at exploration but afterwards it is a good source of income.
|

AsmodeaN
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 18:36:00 -
[300]
Its not a case of not wanting to pve to pvp. Not for me atleast. Sure, i dont like mission running/ratting/mining/complexing etc but if I had time I would do it.
Those of us the buy GTC's and sell them for ISK have to work. Real jobs, jobs that take alot of your time away and if, like me your one real joy in this game is pvp why would i want to spend what little free time i have doing something that i dont find fun?
You people whine about us having an unfair advantage over you because of our real money input.. No. You have an advantage over us because you get to spend alot more time playing the game rather then having to work all week and then, making the choice to put a bit of that money we have earned into the game just to carry on doing what we enjoy/what makes the game fun for us.
|

Exortius Amarrus
The Clearwater Society Firmus Ixion
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 18:47:00 -
[301]
I really don't give a damn about CCPs profits, hence this = win.
Cash for ISK sucks.
Of course, CCP will now make a killing as many people attempt to stock up on isk, as the source is about to dry up. ------------------------
|

Maya Rkell
Forsaken Empire The Forsaken Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 18:56:00 -
[302]
Originally by: Craam Hustler
Originally by: Baji Core I do like this, but from a business perspective... huh? Is CCP really throwing away that money "for the good of the community?" I feel like something is being left out here.
The gametime will probably be fairly expensive, it will probably serve as an ISK sink as well, and deflation is probably important to CCP.
Guess what? If it's expensive, it's a gift to the ISK sellers.
//Maya |

Ciphero
Exiled.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 19:06:00 -
[303]
A first post that has my tired brain all addled, and a last page that doesn't answer my questions; can anyone give me a yes/no to the following?
1. Are CCP going to start selling game time codes for ISK? 2. Are players still going to be able to sell GTCs for ISK as they do currently?
Thanks. |

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 19:11:00 -
[304]
Originally by: Ciphero A first post that has my tired brain all addled, and a last page that doesn't answer my questions; can anyone give me a yes/no to the following?
1. Are CCP going to start selling game time codes for ISK? 2. Are players still going to be able to sell GTCs for ISK as they do currently?
Thanks.
1. We think so. (not sure) 2. Doesn't look like it. (not sure)
I REALLY think Kieron needs to come in and clear this up.
|

Ciphero
Exiled.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 19:15:00 -
[305]
Originally by: Marquis Dean 1. We think so. (not sure) 2. Doesn't look like it. (not sure)
Thanks.
Assuming Marquis is right, this is right up there in the list of mystifying ideas. We all know CCP like isk sinks, but they've just gone and put together a comfy way for GTC/ISK trading on the Account Management page. Why endorse the idea so warmly if they are to ban it shortly after?
I thought the GTC for ISK thing was a wonderful addition to the game. Miners and ratters have the resources to go and pew pew when they want. With GTC trading, pewpewers had the ability (at a cost, admittedly) to feed their habit without resorting to activities they didn't enjoy. So much for that. |

Stella Stardust
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 19:44:00 -
[306]
Edited by: Stella Stardust on 05/05/2007 19:41:26 Seems Kieron was more clear in the original thread, before he decided to "clear it up" in this thread...
Here it seems more like the issue is people farming ISK, trading it for a code, and then reselling that code for RL cash, resulting in using the game as a moneymaking machine in traditional gold farmer style. But that the direct trade ISK for gametime directly between two players, will be allowed to continue through CCP accounting.
Post from previous thread (think it was called "MOTD") (formatting is mine) ---------------- As for your question, some of the former, some of the latter.In regards to the comments about ISK for GTCs for Cash, we are putting the final touches on a billing solution that will replace the ISK/GTC/Cash system. Game time for ISK will no longer be a supported option and phased out.
-------------- later post: Some clarification is in order, I left out some important parts of the system.Game Time for ISK will still be a legit transaction, but a transaction that will take place within Account Management. There will not be a middleman purchasing GTCs for resale for ISK.As with any major change, there will be unhappiness and some members of the community will go on to another game. That is unavoidable, but the change being worked on is for the greater good of the community. ------------------------
|

Nines Tslaruk
Minmatar North Face Force
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 20:08:00 -
[307]
Edited by: Nines Tslaruk on 05/05/2007 20:06:19
Originally by: PDoggy I VERY MUCH protest this. This was a great way for casual players to enjoy EVE without the money grind and PvP to their hearts' content and I predict you will lose a SIGNIFICANT number of accounts over this.
Exactly how I feel. I have npced, mined, built ships, traded etc. At this point, the only thing I enjoy in EVE is pvping with my corp mates. If I npc or some other form of short-term isk making, I can make enough isk to pvp half of my game time. If I trade or produce to make large amounts of isk, I have no time for pvp. Why should I have to grind isk multiple hours each day and burn up hours of my free time to only be able to do something enjoyable part of the time? Eliminating the selling of GTC for isk, through CCP or anyone else, will kill the casual gamer: myself included. ------------------- NFF Recruitment
http://oldforums.eveonline.com/?a=topic&threadID=465085
|

Plasticine Perfection
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 21:05:00 -
[308]
Woah woah woah, so let's see what's happening here.
CCP allow people to buy ISK via GTC's.
This goes on for a LONG time, despite repeated protestations about the dangers of turning EVE into an RMT game. Large alliances get involved and the sums changing hands, both ISK sums and real-life cash sums start to get very, VERY big.
CCP changes their minds FINALLY after over a year of double standards - saying on the one hand (and I QUOTE a senior GM) "buying your way ahead in EVE is cheating, period" while allowing, condoning and protecting GTC sales.
And there's outcry? No! Really?!!!!
FOR ****S SAKE CCP you reap what you sow.
You turned EVE into an RMT game and now you expect there to be no backlash when you suddenly turn 180 degrees?
I'm very, very glad to see the end of RMT in EVE. It cheapened the game, it made you look like fools, but the way you've handled this is appalling. You deserve to lose a lot of subscribers over this.
|

Maya Rkell
Forsaken Empire The Forsaken Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 21:59:00 -
[309]
Edited by: Maya Rkell on 05/05/2007 21:58:19 Hardly. This is pushing RMT back into a situation where players will be scammed and cheated, and also RMT will NOT profit CCP as previously. CCP's previous stance was sensible. Inflating the ebay price again ISN'T. That will be the sum total effect of this change.
They're going to lose subs, yes, the people they'll be banning for buying from ebay, where formerly they used GTC's. This change is a moral stance by CCP, which only hurts the players and their own bottom line.
CCP, don't confuse "for the good of the playerbase" for "for how we, morally, feel things should work". This is not good for anyone except Yantis. He must be laughing his head off.
//Maya |

pyschosis
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 22:01:00 -
[310]
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn The only way I can afford to PvP is to buy GTCs and sell them for in game ISK. I don't do it that often, but I still do it to pay the bills!
dont the the door hit you on the ass on the way out. Good riddance to leeches like you.
If you want something in Eve. A POS, an Outpost, a Faction ship, anything at all..
YOU EARN IT IN EVE.
not by plopping down cash to gain an 'unnatural' advantage over those who are ACTUALLY PLAYING IN GAME.
Cheers again CCP. This isn't a FPS where you simply respawn by feeding the machine another dollar bill.. you have to learn to create, maintain and manage your supply lines. This change finally reinforces long term play over the 'Counterstrike wanna be's'
Sad that griefers like this have no problem preying on those who are trying to 'earn an Eve Living'. Every hauler, miner, ratter you killed while claiming to be a 'might PvP warrior' mean absolutely nothing except you know how to charge a credit card in RL.
|

Riddick Valer
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 22:02:00 -
[311]
I'd like to see them create a GTC type market.
Game time is bought directly from CCP, and added to your account. You can place some of that time for sale on a market at a set price in Isk. Anyone can buy that time, and it is credited directly to their account. Isk, minus a 5% CCP market fee, is deposited to the seller.
No codes that can be transfered out of game = no profiting on the sales. It still allows people to trade isk for time, still allows people to sell time for isk. Resellers could still buy time and resell for higher isk, but couldn't change it to out-of-game money as easily.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 22:21:00 -
[312]
Originally by: pyschosis Sad that griefers like this have no problem preying on those who are trying to 'earn an Eve Living'. Every hauler, miner, ratter you killed while claiming to be a 'might PvP warrior' mean absolutely nothing except you know how to charge a credit card in RL.
  
Lol. You get scammed or something?
|

pyschosis
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 22:43:00 -
[313]
no i'm smarter than that.
it is that it these are two separate games entirely.
One depends on long term planning, coordination, and the establishment of mutual support systems. You actually have to build or buy (and earn using ingame mechanics) everything you use/lose in Combat. Loses actually affect your ability to continue to fight if you haven't planned a support structure to resupply continually.
The other is a 'coin' operated pwnmobile. Die as many time as you like and 'respawn' using the proverbial 'daddy's wallet' to refund your losses. It means your actual 'supply lines' are completely untouchable, all the while the majority of your prey is the relatively 'defenseless' ships playing the 'other' game.
if CCP wants to support a 'pay per loss, rebuy your pwnmobile for 200.00' it should be a separate server entirely. Where the only thing that matters is how much you are willing to spend to say you 'won'.
|

Kairi Elan
FATAL REVELATIONS
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 22:45:00 -
[314]
Edited by: Kairi Elan on 05/05/2007 22:43:10 Edited by: Kairi Elan on 05/05/2007 22:42:49 What everyone seems to be missing here is that CCP through a variety of potential changes that have been discussed in detail in the Dev Blogs (read them please people everything makes so much more sense) they are seeking to:
Cripple the macromining profession by removing all stationary asteroid belts. Read the dev blog about how every ship will have limited exploration capabilities.
REMOVE T2 BPOs ENTIRELY in favor of the invention system. Everyone should have known about this for a while now, why are people still complaining about T2 BPOs?
Encourage the small gang PvP where people actually have fun. The game is supposed to be about PvP, but crashing a node isn't player vs. player, it's player vs. server.
Make EVE resources the product of EVE effort, not Ebay effort. The account management page would gain an option similar to a new type of subscription, where you could deduct X isk from one of your characters accounts to purchase a month of gametime. The only reason they are keeping GTCs around AT ALL is to not penalize people who have already spent money on them.
There are a lot of changes planned for the future of EVE, and if they get implemented correctly the only people who get hurt will be the ones who were exploiting the game in the first place.
Revelations 2 & 3 FTW
|

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 22:54:00 -
[315]
Originally by: pyschosis
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn The only way I can afford to PvP is to buy GTCs and sell them for in game ISK. I don't do it that often, but I still do it to pay the bills!
dont the the door hit you on the ass on the way out. Good riddance to leeches like you.
If you want something in Eve. A POS, an Outpost, a Faction ship, anything at all..
YOU EARN IT IN EVE.
not by plopping down cash to gain an 'unnatural' advantage over those who are ACTUALLY PLAYING IN GAME.
Cheers again CCP. This isn't a FPS where you simply respawn by feeding the machine another dollar bill.. you have to learn to create, maintain and manage your supply lines. This change finally reinforces long term play over the 'Counterstrike wanna be's'
Sad that griefers like this have no problem preying on those who are trying to 'earn an Eve Living'. Every hauler, miner, ratter you killed while claiming to be a 'might PvP warrior' mean absolutely nothing except you know how to charge a credit card in RL.
Someone's obviously been ganked recently and lost their hard earned navy raven...
Someone else made the point better than me above, when they said some of us have jobs and real lives that take up most of our time, and when we do have the time to play EVE, we want to PvP. When you have to spend 4 hours PvEing to spend 1 hour PvPing, it makes the game no longer a game, but a chore.
I'm not saying I spent thousands on GTCs to buy the best faction ship and a POS for myself. If I did, I'd be flying better ships than the Absolution for starters.
To be frank, you're probably the kind of person that got awarded a t2 BPO like a Vagabond or something and think you've earnt it in some way for all the hard work you put in waiting for an offer from your research agent.
How am I different from those sorts of people? They got given a free advantage over everyone else (the vagabond BPO owners must be trillionnaires by now). I work hard in real life and then put a little bit of that money in to EVE to get extra ISK.
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:17:00 -
[316]
Originally by: pyschosis no i'm smarter than that.
it is that it these are two separate games entirely.
One depends on long term planning, coordination, and the establishment of mutual support systems. You actually have to build or buy (and earn using ingame mechanics) everything you use/lose in Combat. Loses actually affect your ability to continue to fight if you haven't planned a support structure to resupply continually.
The other is a 'coin' operated pwnmobile. Die as many time as you like and 'respawn' using the proverbial 'daddy's wallet' to refund your losses. It means your actual 'supply lines' are completely untouchable, all the while the majority of your prey is the relatively 'defenseless' ships playing the 'other' game.
if CCP wants to support a 'pay per loss, rebuy your pwnmobile for 200.00' it should be a separate server entirely. Where the only thing that matters is how much you are willing to spend to say you 'won'.
You're so full of sh*t.
Not everyone who sells GTCs for isk funds their entire game experience with it. That would be so expensive as to defy belief. I've sold about 500mil worth of GTCs in the year i've been playing, mostly cause I really wanted a Rattlesnake for no particular reason. Good for me, I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
No one funds their whole game through GTC sales. And not everyone whom sells GTCs is a spoiled 12 year old with a rich 'daddy'. Some people actually work for their rl money!! I'm 20, it's no f*cking business of yours where I got my money and as long as CCP allows me to, i'll reserve the right to sell GTCs. But I don't because Eve doesn't mean so much to me that I need to spend hundreds of pounds on it, the monthly sub is plenty.
Not that you care about any of this, cause you're probably some broke 25 year old who can't be bothered to get a job and hence has no money. Now who's being a presumptuous ass?
|

QwaarJet
Gallente hirr Morsus Mihi
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:18:00 -
[317]
I'm still not entirely clear here. Are you saying that I can't sell GTC's purchased from the EVE site on to other EVE players?
If that's the case, then i'm screwed. I have severe illnesses that prevent me from spending much time on EVE, and the time I do spend I enjoy because the GTC's mean I can have a comfortable (somewhat) money supply and just play the game.
If I have misunderstood Kieron, please inform me.
"Hobbes, she stepped into the Perimeter Of Wisdom.Run!" |

Xatso
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:19:00 -
[318]
Just a suggestion - I realize there will never be a proven solution to this problem...
1) Trading of GTC for ISK should be strictly controlled and done in moderation. Currently there is no limit to the amount of ISK you can buy for RLC - translating into the ISK buyer having an unfair advantage over players who have made their ISK the 'hard and originally intended way'.
2) Take away the Dollar and Euro trading value of ISK by creating a more supportive playing environment for the casual Eve player - make piracy illegal and give more players access to 0.0 mining operations to support their PVP binges through effective mining and other ISK generating endeavors.
3) Scrap the BPO system completely and make ship designs available to some sort of manufacturing skill level for everyone.
|

Flynn Walker
Caldari Caldari Provisions
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:20:00 -
[319]
Originally by: Marquis Dean I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
Waaaaaah... I'm going to have to actually play EVE now to make ISK.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:23:00 -
[320]
Originally by: Flynn Walker
Originally by: Marquis Dean I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
Waaaaaah... I'm going to have to actually play EVE now to make ISK.
Waaaaaah I can't play 23/7 cause I have a life so I guess i'm screwed then.
|

Flynn Walker
Caldari Caldari Provisions
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:24:00 -
[321]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Flynn Walker
Originally by: Marquis Dean I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
Waaaaaah... I'm going to have to actually play EVE now to make ISK.
Waaaaaah I can't play 23/7 cause I have a life so I guess i'm screwed then.
Since when you you need to play 23/7 to make ISK.
|

Gorken
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:27:00 -
[322]
Originally by: CCP kieron Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
This is the statement that has me scratching my head.
So, does this mean that their are no real plans for EVE in the future? Is this a fix for the lag issue, as its clear you will lose subs over this no? Whats the deal?
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:31:00 -
[323]
Originally by: Flynn Walker
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Flynn Walker
Originally by: Marquis Dean I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
Waaaaaah... I'm going to have to actually play EVE now to make ISK.
Waaaaaah I can't play 23/7 cause I have a life so I guess i'm screwed then.
Since when you you need to play 23/7 to make ISK.
I can play 2/5 and still make enough isk to buy the parts for and build a capital. But it's going to take me 3 months.
And I have only ever sold GTCs once, on a whim. Until recently I didn't have a problem with the PvE grind in order to afford things cause PvE was fun (sort of). But recently i've wanted to PvP, partially cause CCP have totally clusterf*cked PvE, but also because it was getting dull anyway.
So how about this: now I don't want to kill npc blobs or mine digital rocks to make money. I just want the money now so I can play the rest of the game. If CCP are going to make a 4-month PvE grind mandantory before anyone embarks on a serious project they need to make PvE not suck. But it does, and this is a way around.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:37:00 -
[324]
Edited by: Nero Scuro on 05/05/2007 23:33:52
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn To be frank, you're probably the kind of person that got awarded a t2 BPO like a Vagabond or something and think you've earnt it in some way for all the hard work you put in waiting for an offer from your research agent.
So do I have a vaga BPO too Fely? Since I was making a similar point, apparently I do, according to you. Maybe you can remind me where I left it..?
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn How am I different from those sorts of people? They got given a free advantage over everyone else (the vagabond BPO owners must be trillionnaires by now). I work hard in real life and then put a little bit of that money in to EVE to get extra ISK.
Yes, all ten of them. Using stupidly small minorities as excuses to change game balance is retarded. T2 BPOs suck, yes, everybody knows this. They have invention to compete with now though, and will probably be removed in the future. The damage is done however and nothing can be done about it, but that's not an excuse to make things even more broken.
You don't need to fly a HAC to have fun in the game. Why is a HAC any different from a cruiser? What does it do differently? Nothing. It has higher stats. An arbitrary number that only means something if your opponent has a similarly high number. If both you and your opponent are both flying HACs or both flying cruisers it's EXACTLY the same. You don't need a trillion ISK to PvP.
And while I'm here - to those people who are saying GTC>ISK didn't hurt anyone. WRONG.
1. "Sure are a lot of farmers and macroers around. Wonder why there's so many of them all of a sudden?"
Try - meeting the demand of the all those people buying ISK with cash? Macroers are not players. There's no point, the gains of their profession (ISK) will leave them banned. They're in it for the real cash - this is a job to them - and any process which legitimises and legalises the process of turning ISK into cash will increase their numbers. Sucks to be a miner or NPCer, but you got undercut by some macroer/farmer because some noob wanted to buy their way into the game.
2. "Everybody with ISK just grinded it. I have a life, better things to do than grinding, so buying ISK is justified."
No. People don't get masses of ISK by grinding. I doesn't happen. Nobody became a multi-billioner by grinding lvl4s. They got it by holding 0.0 space with good ore or complexes or by manipulating EVE's player run market, which involves planning, teamwork, dedication and skill.
0.0 alliances have the logistics, 0.0 space and infrastructure that earns them the right to fly HACs and CS around. Sitting on your ass for your entire EVE life in Jita training skills before buying ISK and flying off into 0.0 does not grant you the same right. You have put none of the ingame effort in.
3. "I don't like to PvE for hours to fly a fancy ship! Make EVE more like that game, whatsitcalled... oh yeah, counterstrike! There's no lame PvE in that!"
Guess what genius? Nobody else likes to grind either! It's there for a reason though - it stops EVE becoming some lame twitch based, point system obsessed, consequenceless piece of crap (cough).
And how do you justify blowing up somebody else's ship which THEY'VE grinded for with a ship you threw money at to get? How do you justify all the time THEY'VE grinded going down the tube because you didn't want to? So now THEY have to pay because of YOU couldn't be bothered? That makes you a selfish ****, plain and simple.
4. WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHH!!
I swear, if there weren't laws against kicking babies in the head...
|

Rhaegor Stormborn
Sturmgrenadier Inc R i s e
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:41:00 -
[325]
CCP lands a wrecking hit on Goonswarm for infinate damage.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:43:00 -
[326]
Originally by: Nero Scuro Macroers are not players. There's no point, the gains of their profession (ISK) will leave them banned.
And that's where your argument fell apart.
If CCP did something about the macros, they would have this problem. But CCP wants their sub money, so instead they devise ever-more convoluted means of trying to stop isk inflation while not actually tackling the cause of the problem. I subbed 5 different petitions about macros in my time in Eve, each and every one I followed up and nothing had been done. CCP doesn't ban macros, so cheap minerals flood the market and isk keeps getting sold.
Nothing to do with GTCs, which are fine in their current shape.
And on top of all that, I fail to see how:
Swap cash for GTC. Swap GTC for isk. Swap isk for cash.
actually makes any money.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:43:00 -
[327]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Flynn Walker
Originally by: Marquis Dean I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
Waaaaaah... I'm going to have to actually play EVE now to make ISK.
Waaaaaah I can't play 23/7 cause I have a life so I guess i'm screwed then.
You must suck tremendous amounts of ass if you can't find the ISK to PvP with just a little bit of ingame effort (hint - there are ships other than carriers and CS).
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:44:00 -
[328]
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Flynn Walker
Originally by: Marquis Dean I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
Waaaaaah... I'm going to have to actually play EVE now to make ISK.
Waaaaaah I can't play 23/7 cause I have a life so I guess i'm screwed then.
You must suck tremendous amounts of ass if you can't find the ISK to PvP with just a little bit of ingame effort (hint - there are ships other than carriers and CS).
I want isk, but I want to PvP. So where exactly does the isk come from?
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:44:00 -
[329]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Nero Scuro Macroers are not players. There's no point, the gains of their profession (ISK) will leave them banned.
And that's where your argument fell apart.
If CCP did something about the macros, they would have this problem. But CCP wants their sub money, so instead they devise ever-more convoluted means of trying to stop isk inflation while not actually tackling the cause of the problem. I subbed 5 different petitions about macros in my time in Eve, each and every one I followed up and nothing had been done. CCP doesn't ban macros, so cheap minerals flood the market and isk keeps getting sold.
Nothing to do with GTCs, which are fine in their current shape.
And on top of all that, I fail to see how:
Swap cash for GTC. Swap GTC for isk. Swap isk for cash.
actually makes any money.
Swap GTC for cash on Ebay, which is legal and very profitable if you undercut CCP's GTC prices.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:45:00 -
[330]
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Nero Scuro Macroers are not players. There's no point, the gains of their profession (ISK) will leave them banned.
And that's where your argument fell apart.
If CCP did something about the macros, they would have this problem. But CCP wants their sub money, so instead they devise ever-more convoluted means of trying to stop isk inflation while not actually tackling the cause of the problem. I subbed 5 different petitions about macros in my time in Eve, each and every one I followed up and nothing had been done. CCP doesn't ban macros, so cheap minerals flood the market and isk keeps getting sold.
Nothing to do with GTCs, which are fine in their current shape.
And on top of all that, I fail to see how:
Swap cash for GTC. Swap GTC for isk. Swap isk for cash.
actually makes any money.
Swap GTC for cash on Ebay, which is legal and very profitable if you undercut CCP's GTC prices.
Right, so I buy a GTC for $15, and sell it for less than $15.
Genius.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:48:00 -
[331]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Nero Scuro
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Flynn Walker
Originally by: Marquis Dean I spent a little rl cash (hardly any), someone got to play Eve for isk, and I got my Rattler. End of.
Waaaaaah... I'm going to have to actually play EVE now to make ISK.
Waaaaaah I can't play 23/7 cause I have a life so I guess i'm screwed then.
You must suck tremendous amounts of ass if you can't find the ISK to PvP with just a little bit of ingame effort (hint - there are ships other than carriers and CS).
I want isk, but I want to PvP. So where exactly does the isk come from?
Trade on the player market. Make deals. Interact with other players. Examine the current state of the game and use recent changes to your advantage (I've currently got two projects ongoing in this manner, both which should net me a tidy profit - took a little effort but it was more fun than grinding). Just use your brain.
If you expect to make it rich by having some NPC handing you ISK in exchange for grind you're mistaken.
|

Nero Scuro
Jejaikaro Corporation
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:50:00 -
[332]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Right, so I buy a GTC for $15, and sell it for less than $15.
Genius.
Right, so you buy a GTC for 15 dollars, macro/farm enough isk for 10 GTC (for example) and sell them each for 14 dollars, 125 dollars in total.
Genius (you are not).
|

Siege
Minmatar Siegecraft Bounty Hunting
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:51:00 -
[333]
Utterly Hysterical, this entire thread, best I've read in a LONG time.
It's so easy to spot those who have been using their wallets to gain power. They have lost their edge, and are upset. They will no longer be able to buy success, their money will no longer give them power. You won't be missed. And, apparently, neither will your money, if CCP has decided on this course.
o/
|

Amber Leonne
Gallente New Eden Technical Institutes
|
Posted - 2007.05.05 23:57:00 -
[334]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Ionia alot of somewhat unlikely stuff...
Maybe Amber Leonne should just get banned for GTC conversion. There goes your argument.
Kinda hard to ban someone for 1) Something they've never done. 2) Something that's not against the EULA.
|

Kairi Elan
FATAL REVELATIONS
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 00:12:00 -
[335]
Originally by: Xatso
2) Take away the Dollar and Euro trading value of ISK by creating a more supportive playing environment for the casual Eve player - make piracy illegal and give more players access to 0.0 mining operations to support their PVP binges through effective mining and other ISK generating endeavors.
3) Scrap the BPO system completely and make ship designs available to some sort of manufacturing skill level for everyone.
Ok wow. Someone has NOT been reading the Dev blogs. Scrap the BPO system. THEY ARE. That's what invention is all about, and if you haven't noticed, market competition has already driven the price of some items, notably Covert Ops Cloaking Device II down to 1/3rd of the pre-invention price. In one of the next Revelations installments, ALL existing T2 BPOs will become 100 run copies. The monopoly is coming to an end, so we can all stop with the 'I need to sell GTCs to afford T2 lewt' argument. If you really want it that badly, train it and build it, or find some other way besides cashing in on GTCs.
Also, Piracy IS illegal. There's this whole thing called Sec status. And making it impossible for people to be Pirates is as idiotic as making it impossible for people to run missions or mine. One of the core principles of EVE is that it is a game where you can be whatever you want to be. Removing an aspect of that would do more damage to the game than removing ISK selling ever will.
|

captain kikaz
Pitch Black Incorporated
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 00:28:00 -
[336]
so after reading all 12 pages of this i've got 2 things from it.
a headache
a sense of confusion I've not had since i saw vanilla sky
From what I can gather I will no longer be able to take my 20 quid to shattered crystal buy a 90day gtc then come onto eve and sell it to someone for 330mil isk.
If this is the case then meh so be it if ccp decide to reduce there profits thats up to them.
But they had better not come to me at a later date and say "we need to put subscription prices up because we are not getting the money we were getting from people buying codes to play the game"
and yes i do sell gtc's for in game cash i don't fund my entire game from them if i get a bonus at work then i buy A card sell it and reduce my grind for a week or 2.
If i get no bonus i grind and get very ****ed off doing it.
This will affect players i for one know a player who pays for his game with gtcs he has no credit card and pay by cash sucks.so this is gonna basically cut him off at the knees.
|

Maya Rkell
Forsaken Empire The Forsaken Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 00:29:00 -
[337]
Originally by: Siege Utterly Hysterical, this entire thread, best I've read in a LONG time.
It's so easy to spot those who have been using their wallets to gain power. They have lost their edge, and are upset. They will no longer be able to buy success, their money will no longer give them power. You won't be missed. And, apparently, neither will your money, if CCP has decided on this course.
o/
Oh it will. More ISK. Only the profit will flow to Yantis et al, not CCP. I don't need to use GTC's to suppost my character. I just happen to know a lot about MMO economies and the blatent bullheadness blindless of trying neo-prohibitionary methods on RMT which has been proven over and over not to work, and to cost you players.
GTC policy was one of the factors behind Eve being slow-burn, afaik. They're throwing away a major advantage for the sake a moral stance which will only hurt CCP and hurt the players as a while.
//Maya |
|

Rauth Kivaro
Forum Moderator Interstellar Services Department

|
Posted - 2007.05.06 00:38:00 -
[338]
Again, let's keep things civil, please. This thread has engendered some obviously hot tempers, and if you need to take a break to keep from getting yourself into trouble do it. Flaming, evading the profanity filter, and insulting other players is not cool. Debate respectfully and keep this thread from being locked or having warnings start being handed out.
Thanks in advance for your help on this. :)
Rauth Kivaro, CRC, A division of ISD |
|

Vexed Angel
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 00:41:00 -
[339]
Originally by: Siege Utterly Hysterical, this entire thread, best I've read in a LONG time.
It's so easy to spot those who have been using their wallets to gain power. They have lost their edge, and are upset. They will no longer be able to buy success, their money will no longer give them power. You won't be missed. And, apparently, neither will your money, if CCP has decided on this course.
o/
You have missed the point completely... Some simple facts you folks may think about: 1.Since the first MMO virtual currency has been marketed for real life cash. 2. Every MMO company has at some point tried to take steps to crush this practice without success. 3. As with anything in life: If demand is there a supply will eventually appear. 4.Many companies have banned thousands of "Currency Farmers" and guess what....they are still there. 5.If Nub #1 with cash wasnt getting popped in pvp every day 3 times a day your industry alt wouldn't be making as much money. 6. If Nub #2 was investing his time to create industry alts your industry alts wouldn't be making as much money. 7. If ISK wasn't so easy to make in eve the prices for ISK sales for cash would be alot higher thus decreasing the demand...but then you all would be /sniffling about not making any cash for all your hard work. 8. Inflation is a fact of life, you will never lower it decently when your player base is learning to make money faster even without ISK sales. 9. Look to any other MMO on the planet do you realy think Eve is unique? They all work on the same basic value. Once the player base as a whole evolves past the noob stages and moves into the veteran status you will see inflation regardless. 10. If you don't like having to fight against someones wallet then maybe you should have payed attention in school or applied your work ethic to RL instead of a game, because you will always be contending with someone whos made money easier and faster then you. 11.CCP starts allowing ISK for for time trades and also starts losing money AND the ISK farmers still sell ISK regardless. THEN CCP downsizes due to low sales or goes under completely and we all lose eve and /cry
You won't ever be rid of farmers so long as theres a person willing to set up a hangar of PC's and pay poverty stricken people to play video games. Sorry but thats just the way the cookies crumble.
Scarlet
|

Siege
Minmatar Siegecraft Bounty Hunting
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 01:39:00 -
[340]
Edited by: Siege on 06/05/2007 01:35:48
Originally by: Vexed Angel
Originally by: Siege Utterly Hysterical, this entire thread, best I've read in a LONG time.
It's so easy to spot those who have been using their wallets to gain power. They have lost their edge, and are upset. They will no longer be able to buy success, their money will no longer give them power. You won't be missed. And, apparently, neither will your money, if CCP has decided on this course.
o/
You have missed the point completely... Some simple facts you folks may think about: 1.Since the first MMO virtual currency has been marketed for real life cash. 2. Every MMO company has at some point tried to take steps to crush this practice without success. 3. As with anything in life: If demand is there a supply will eventually appear. 4.Many companies have banned thousands of "Currency Farmers" and guess what....they are still there. 5.If Nub #1 with cash wasnt getting popped in pvp every day 3 times a day your industry alt wouldn't be making as much money. 6. If Nub #2 was investing his time to create industry alts your industry alts wouldn't be making as much money. 7. If ISK wasn't so easy to make in eve the prices for ISK sales for cash would be alot higher thus decreasing the demand...but then you all would be /sniffling about not making any cash for all your hard work. 8. Inflation is a fact of life, you will never lower it decently when your player base is learning to make money faster even without ISK sales. 9. Look to any other MMO on the planet do you realy think Eve is unique? They all work on the same basic value. Once the player base as a whole evolves past the noob stages and moves into the veteran status you will see inflation regardless. 10. If you don't like having to fight against someones wallet then maybe you should have payed attention in school or applied your work ethic to RL instead of a game, because you will always be contending with someone whos made money easier and faster then you. 11.CCP starts allowing ISK for for time trades and also starts losing money AND the ISK farmers still sell ISK regardless. THEN CCP downsizes due to low sales or goes under completely and we all lose eve and /cry
You won't ever be rid of farmers so long as theres a person willing to set up a hangar of PC's and pay poverty stricken people to play video games. Sorry but thats just the way the cookies crumble.
Scarlet
Just because there is a demand for something, and an illicit supply chain, doesn't mean it should be endorsed by the powers at be. Yes the problem is probably always going to exist at some level, but that doesn't mean it isn't an issue.
You're just like all the burnouts I used to see back in high-school who would try to justify their addictions, claiming that there was so much demand that everything should be legalized. Or all the corrupt construction firms that pass money under the table to build things at lower cost because they are getting around the building code. Or the shoplifter who says there are no victims because it's only a cheap CD and the big corporations won't miss the money. Now you're trying to justify the money you've made off of others by claiming it's just the way things are, just like any pimp, pusher, corrupt politician, tax evader, bootlegger, or whatever.
Just because there is a lot of something happening, doesn't mean it's good.
|

alexreborn
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 02:02:00 -
[341]
Edited by: alexreborn on 06/05/2007 02:00:20 Edited by: alexreborn on 06/05/2007 02:00:12 I want to tell you guys a story, about my character alexreborn.
I first started playing this game back in August 2006. I bought a 1 month subscription and played for about 1 month straight.
The first week it was cool, so was the second, as I mined, and grinded missions to make some money to buy the next best ship. At that time the next best ship was going from a Kestrel, to a decked out merlin, to a moa, and a caracal as I learned to play the game.
However the game was getting progressively more and more boring, that and coupled with the fact taht each gate I had to jump to = me landing 15km away from it and having to fly to it, which was rediculously boring.
So I stopped play EVE. I cancelled my account.
In February of this year my buddy who had been playing ever since told me about ya this game is so sick being in a pvp corp, flying around with your mates chatting on vent and making life miserable for other plyers.
I thought to my self thats awesome, so I restarted my account.. Alexreborn was still there so I re-activated him and got back to the game, but this time I joined my friends pvp corp.
Let me tell you Ive had a blast ever since. Honestly there is only one way to play this game and its pvp. For those of you who care bear, honestly whats the fun in killing the same spawns over and over and over again?
None.
Let me get to my point here as this is dragging on. AFter spending Many many many many many hours ratting in 00 space and making cash I discoverd an easier way- Buying a GTC. The only down side was me paying 17$ canadian for in game money which sucks because I dont make that much per hour, however, if I have to spend 10 hours of eve time killing NPCs, and only have to spend 1 hour of real life time to make the same ammount of isk the trade off in spending alitlte bit of money to buy the ship and modules I want is worth it to me.
Whats the point of playing an online game, if all youre doing is blowing up npcs ON YOURE own F.F.S.?
Honestly the only reason I play this game is to get on vent shoot the **** with some real life friends, and some crazy Euro's while we blow things up. If I cant do that easily, then I will jut have to find a new MMO.
And trust me, while you guys giving easy solutions to us: "get a new mmo" There would be no EVE without ME and You. We make EVE. And when people start leaving you will notice it, as there really isn;t that many people. 30,000 people is not alot.
|

Xatso
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 02:05:00 -
[342]
Originally by: Kairi Elan
Originally by: Xatso
2) Take away the Dollar and Euro trading value of ISK by creating a more supportive playing environment for the casual Eve player - make piracy illegal and give more players access to 0.0 mining operations to support their PVP binges through effective mining and other ISK generating endeavors.
3) Scrap the BPO system completely and make ship designs available to some sort of manufacturing skill level for everyone.
Ok wow. Someone has NOT been reading the Dev blogs. Scrap the BPO system. THEY ARE. That's what invention is all about, and if you haven't noticed, market competition has already driven the price of some items, notably Covert Ops Cloaking Device II down to 1/3rd of the pre-invention price. In one of the next Revelations installments, ALL existing T2 BPOs will become 100 run copies. The monopoly is coming to an end, so we can all stop with the 'I need to sell GTCs to afford T2 lewt' argument. If you really want it that badly, train it and build it, or find some other way besides cashing in on GTCs.
Also, Piracy IS illegal. There's this whole thing called Sec status. And making it impossible for people to be Pirates is as idiotic as making it impossible for people to run missions or mine. One of the core principles of EVE is that it is a game where you can be whatever you want to be. Removing an aspect of that would do more damage to the game than removing ISK selling ever will.
Yes, I have not read the Dev blogs. CCP surely knew that the monopolization of T2 BPO's will result in several serious problems such as the indirect illegal trading of ISK - several parties are to blame for this situation and no-one can sit back and proclaim that they are innocent or that they did not contribute to the ISK trading problem.
Piracy may be illegal, but it have grown rampant and have reached disastrous levels. It is just too easy to be / become a pirate. There is no way for the casual player or small corporations to compete against them for access to 0.0 resources. The only option is then to grind in high sec, buy ISK or try to join one of the alliances in 0.0 as a drone.
Flame me if you must - I really don't care.
|

alexreborn
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 02:09:00 -
[343]
youre joking right?
piracy has ruined the game?
dude stay in high sec then and stop your bickering. ITs called low security for a reason, theer are NOT any cops TO POLICE IT.
Its like going to the deserts in Africa on your own. If you get mugged or shot NO ONE IS GOING TO SAVE YOU.
Thats the principle behind this game.
|

Riddick Valer
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 02:20:00 -
[344]
Its impossible to stop currency farming in MMOs. With EVE's trial system, it is even easier for them. But, the free trial does help improve the subscription base. However, steps can be done to combat currency selling, and CCP has a system in place (GTCs) that can be tweaked to help.
Step1: Prevent trial accounts from accepting more then 5m in player donations. Thats enough for someone to give their friend a headstart when trying out the game, and would make it hard to sell isk in game.
Step2: Run a list of all players with more then 100m in player donations in a given day. Investigate as many as possible. Ban all resellers and strip the isk from buyers. Since these people are in paying accounts (see step 1), this will cut into their own real life money.
Step3: Eliminate GTCs as actual codes. CCP sells the time directly to your account. You would purchase 90 days, and see +90 days listed in your account. No code= nothing to trade outside of the game and outside of CCPs control.
Step4: Make selling this time EASIER. Create a market where each player could list how many days off their subscription they are selling, and at what price. Entirely automated. Player 1 lists 90 days off his subscription for sale at 350m. Player 2 sees that as the low bid for 90 days, and buys it. The time is directly credited to player 2's account, and player 1 gets 350 million (-5% fee) isk in their account. Time bought from another player CANNOT be resold. Selling and buying GTCs is a very quick and painless affair.
What would this do? Without GTCs, its harder to directly profit out of game, and the currency farmers will migrate towards other easier and more profitable games. People who want to buy isk can, without supporting the currency farmers. People with isk can buy time, but only time for themselves (or for an alliance with money moving around between people). Everyone wins, and market forces keep the two balanced.
Will this fix inflation? No. But it lessens motivation for farmers, which should lessen inflation a bit. Isk sellers won't disappear. Some will still exist and try to undercut the market, but since the time sales is an actual market, other players are free to do the same within the system. Plus, CCP is still getting paid for every day of playing time player use.
People need to realize that farming won't go away, and neither will reselling, but maybe it can be managed a bit.
|

Riddick Valer
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 02:51:00 -
[345]
Edited by: Rid**** Valer on 06/05/2007 02:48:35 Not sure. I just started a second account (paid through my money, not isk sales) and sent it some isk for basic implants (I'm lazy for training times). I know they can accept isk, didn't bother trying the other direction.
Also, it should be limited both ways. Otherwise people will transfer a bil to a trial account, then pay the transfer fee to add it to someone else's account. They get the billion isk, and the price only goes up for the $20 (i think) transfer fee.
|

Argenton Sayvers
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 03:05:00 -
[346]
Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 06/05/2007 03:12:45 Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 06/05/2007 03:11:37
Originally by: Maya Rkell They're throwing away a major advantage for the sake a moral stance which will only hurt CCP and hurt the players as a while.
I actually think its pretty funny to observe reactions. Since kierons post is so confusing, everyone hears what they wanted to hear.
The only "moral" stance i can see is that they want to kill shatteredcrystal (and maybe goonswarm) and keep the cut for themselves.
Look, someone will have to pay for the "free" gaming time people are purchasing via ISK (CCP can spawn it, so it holds no value).
And this someone will either be a sponsor (think walmarkt - family values and morning prayers), or other rich eve players (status quo). Just taking a look at sell orders forum will tell you that it wont be CCP who will pay for it.
Killing the Euro / Dollar difference, thats a reasonable argument a immoral cynic like me can understand (lots of Euro players => forced to pay in Euros => more money).
But losing money due to morals? Unnerf privateers and make players with less then 3 cap ship accounts useful again while you are on a crusade of goodness.
Evebay or "premium accounts" are a lot more likely then the banning of official RMT. Because everyone knows that even if they are deluded enough to try the moral stance thing, enterprising, sometimes hungry people from all over the world will happily step in.
Originally by: Vexed Angel You won't ever be rid of farmers so long as theres a person willing to set up a hangar of PC's and pay poverty stricken people to play video games. Sorry but thats just the way the cookies crumble. Scarlet
You forgot the alliance leaders, college students, normal guys with financial troubles, normal guys without financial troubles, disgruntled veterans who quit etc. RMT doesnt exist because of the North / South divide, it exists because Grind MMOs are based on RL resources.
Quote losely based on Hippoking: Chosing between eMorals and $50k to get you through university isnt really hard.
|

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 03:26:00 -
[347]
Well said, alex, we love you too! 
The thing is, why should someone be forced to spend 10 hours playing on their own (ratting or mission running) in order to spend 1 hour playing with friends?
Nero, take my housemate for example (everyone in ENIGMA and the Sekura Family knows who I mean). With his new jobs and whatnot, he's not been able to play EVE at all recently, he's even had me logging on and changing skills for him because he doesn't have the time. When he finally gets an hour to play the game, is it fair that he should spend 54 minutes of that grinding missions and ratting, in order to spend 6 minutes on a gate camp with us, chatting on VT and having fun?
Just because you've found a couple of nice ISK-making ventures doesn't mean everyone else can! If you forced me to do so, I'd probably find the same ones as you, and instead of having 2 right now, you'd have 1. As you probably know, I used to resell faction gear in Jita, but that got stale for me as well... The only thing that hasn't got boring for me over the years and months I've played this game is the PvP and social aspect.
Hell, after thinking about this whole thing today, I took an AF out to a 0.0 system to try and get some missions and standings, to see how painful it would actually be... Turns out very! I did 2 missions and logged off to watch a film!
Don't force people to partake in one part of the game that they may not like, so that they can partake in the part they like. Then the game just turns in to a job and becomes unenjoyable.
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

Scarlet Azmodea
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 04:15:00 -
[348]
Edited by: Scarlet Azmodea on 06/05/2007 04:15:08
Originally by: Siege Edited by: Siege on 06/05/2007 01:35:48
Originally by: Scarlet
You have missed the point completely... Some simple facts you folks may think about: 1.Since the first MMO virtual currency has been marketed for real life cash. 2. Every MMO company has at some point tried to take steps to crush this practice without success. 3. As with anything in life: If demand is there a supply will eventually appear. 4.Many companies have banned thousands of "Currency Farmers" and guess what....they are still there. 5.If Nub #1 with cash wasnt getting popped in pvp every day 3 times a day your industry alt wouldn't be making as much money. 6. If Nub #2 was investing his time to create industry alts your industry alts wouldn't be making as much money. 7. If ISK wasn't so easy to make in eve the prices for ISK sales for cash would be alot higher thus decreasing the demand...but then you all would be /sniffling about not making any cash for all your hard work. 8. Inflation is a fact of life, you will never lower it decently when your player base is learning to make money faster even without ISK sales. 9. Look to any other MMO on the planet do you realy think Eve is unique? They all work on the same basic value. Once the player base as a whole evolves past the noob stages and moves into the veteran status you will see inflation regardless. 10. If you don't like having to fight against someones wallet then maybe you should have payed attention in school or applied your work ethic to RL instead of a game, because you will always be contending with someone whos made money easier and faster then you. 11.CCP starts allowing ISK for for time trades and also starts losing money AND the ISK farmers still sell ISK regardless. THEN CCP downsizes due to low sales or goes under completely and we all lose eve and /cry
You won't ever be rid of farmers so long as theres a person willing to set up a hangar of PC's and pay poverty stricken people to play video games. Sorry but thats just the way the cookies crumble.
Scarlet[/quote
Just because there is a demand for something, and an illicit supply chain, doesn't mean it should be endorsed by the powers at be. Yes the problem is probably always going to exist at some level, but that doesn't mean it isn't an issue.
You're just like all the burnouts I used to see back in high-school who would try to justify their addictions, claiming that there was so much demand that everything should be legalized. Or all the corrupt construction firms that pass money under the table to build things at lower cost because they are getting around the building code. Or the shoplifter who says there are no victims because it's only a cheap CD and the big corporations won't miss the money. Now you're trying to justify the money you've made off of others by claiming it's just the way things are, just like any pimp, pusher, corrupt politician, tax evader, bootlegger, or whatever.
Just because there is a lot of something happening, doesn't mean it's good.
"You're just like all the burnouts I used to see back in high-school who would try to justify their addictions, claiming that there was so much demand that everything should be legalized."
Since you decided to go that route. No, I have a bach. degree, firefighters certificates, real estate license, a family, a nice house a couple of apartment complexes and lots of toys. I chose to work hard and excel at my chosen crafts and its payed off wonderfully for me. If your disgruntled try going back to school or working harder. I do not recall saying that I was pro virtual cash sales or not. I simply stated the facts and the history of MMO games in general. I never once said CCP should endorse ISK sales at all. Honestly, you may as well start getting used to it because it is not leaving in your time nor in mine.
|

nickky01
The Collective Against ALL Authorities
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 04:30:00 -
[349]
Originally by: Argenton Sayvers
So if your goal is to protect people from the perils of the Devil's brewage, making it *legal *monitoring the production to ensure quality (noone wants to drink methanol) *ensuring that supply is regulated by "normal" (true production costs) forces and not artificial ones (illegal != impossible, just added risk. Every investment has risk, some more then others. Illegal business may be less risky then legally investing in copper mines in Africa) *educating people about responsible use *helping those with troubles (few are going to ask for help when he could end up in jail) will help the humans and society a lot more, even if your goal is to actually prevent something, and not freedom of choice. Should be easy to see how this applies to RMT.
Now, if you dont care about the people or society, but just want to ease of mind, make it illegal. The gangsters will love it.
legalize pot
|

matty01
Minmatar Chaos Reborn
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 04:35:00 -
[350]
Originally by: nickky01
Originally by: Argenton Sayvers
So if your goal is to protect people from the perils of the Devil's brewage, making it *legal *monitoring the production to ensure quality (noone wants to drink methanol) *ensuring that supply is regulated by "normal" (true production costs) forces and not artificial ones (illegal != impossible, just added risk. Every investment has risk, some more then others. Illegal business may be less risky then legally investing in copper mines in Africa) *educating people about responsible use *helping those with troubles (few are going to ask for help when he could end up in jail) will help the humans and society a lot more, even if your goal is to actually prevent something, and not freedom of choice. Should be easy to see how this applies to RMT.
Now, if you dont care about the people or society, but just want to ease of mind, make it illegal. The gangsters will love it.
legalize pot
this __________________________
|

Sadist
Rage and Terror Against ALL Authorities
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 04:38:00 -
[351]
Originally by: matty01
Originally by: nickky01
Originally by: Argenton Sayvers
So if your goal is to protect people from the perils of the Devil's brewage, making it *legal *monitoring the production to ensure quality (noone wants to drink methanol) *ensuring that supply is regulated by "normal" (true production costs) forces and not artificial ones (illegal != impossible, just added risk. Every investment has risk, some more then others. Illegal business may be less risky then legally investing in copper mines in Africa) *educating people about responsible use *helping those with troubles (few are going to ask for help when he could end up in jail) will help the humans and society a lot more, even if your goal is to actually prevent something, and not freedom of choice. Should be easy to see how this applies to RMT.
Now, if you dont care about the people or society, but just want to ease of mind, make it illegal. The gangsters will love it.
legalize pot
this
/signed. MJ is not a drug! òòòòòòòòòòòò
VIP member of the [23]
Quote: - Numbers alone do not win a battle - No, but I bet they help.
|

nickky01
The Collective Against ALL Authorities
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 04:39:00 -
[352]
Originally by: Sadist
Originally by: matty01
Originally by: nickky01
Originally by: Argenton Sayvers
So if your goal is to protect people from the perils of the Devil's brewage, making it *legal *monitoring the production to ensure quality (noone wants to drink methanol) *ensuring that supply is regulated by "normal" (true production costs) forces and not artificial ones (illegal != impossible, just added risk. Every investment has risk, some more then others. Illegal business may be less risky then legally investing in copper mines in Africa) *educating people about responsible use *helping those with troubles (few are going to ask for help when he could end up in jail) will help the humans and society a lot more, even if your goal is to actually prevent something, and not freedom of choice. Should be easy to see how this applies to RMT.
Now, if you dont care about the people or society, but just want to ease of mind, make it illegal. The gangsters will love it.
legalize pot
this
/signed. MJ is not a drug!
/signed
|

Scarlet Azmodea
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 04:47:00 -
[353]
I will say this, if CCP starts taking its own money as trade for game time then it will eventually implode or downsize because of it OR they will just allow ISK companies to generate even more sales.
You folks waste so much time *****ing about things like this and you don't even take the time to actually research it. Do you realize that in terms of the world economy that at EQ's peak the real money generated by the country "everquest" ranked higher in the global economy then 2/3 the rest of the world. How do you stop a machine that has allowed several multi million dollar companies to spring to life. That was years ago and now these companies deal in cash from 10+ games at any one time. I am sorry but yall might as well put away yer wine, cheese and violins cause these multi million dollar currency machines are going nowhere, and yes one such comapany sold for upwards of 12 million dollars. Sony started allowing monetary sales on certain server in EQ2...did not slow up the famrers one bit about the only thing it did was make te buyers a better offer due to farmers having to set prices far lower. This in turn just generated more sales lol. WoW tried banning thousands of people for selling gold etc. Go type: "buy wow gold" in a search engine anywhere. Yep thats right theres tons of shops selling their items. I personally don't mind the whole idea because in the end it is the same as any other hobby like painball, hunting, fishing, skiing, and yet it is still cheaper to fund even if you bought ISK to support your fun.
You may not like the way the world runs but in essence you are powerless to change the majority of it's trappings. I may be wrong but somewhere in the neighborhood of 90% of the worlds money rests in the hands of 2% of the economy; why would you ever expect it to be different in a game where the market and economy is based on real life principles.
I think you will find that 90% of the power in eve rests in the hands of a small 2% group.
|

Jenna Ashton
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 05:46:00 -
[354]
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn
Don't force people to partake in one part of the game that they may not like, so that they can partake in the part they like. Then the game just turns in to a job and becomes unenjoyable.
Well said, i partly agree with you. I would love to run missions and mine in low-no-sec without all that PVP business.
Aside from that.. screw money for score. Might as well go to Vegas.
|

Lynae
Caldari
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 06:22:00 -
[355]
The Summary Lets see... For me kierons statement is perfectly clear on the general view.
a) You can buy game time (not game time codes!) from third parties for ISK. -> Goto account management page -> Click "Extend subscription" -> Click "Buy Game Time for ISK" -> Click "<some third parties name> 30 day Game Time - 200 Mio ISK" -> Click select character & confirm = You gain 30d added to your account and 200M ISK deducted from selected character.
b) You can buy game time codes (!) for real life currency. c) You may not trade these game time codes for ISK.
It seems that "third parties" is limited to CCP, but this is not clearly stated.
My Opinion It is a interesting move. CCP will lose money if this system is implemented and the aforementioned "third parties" are limited to CCP. This is unusual for a game company, but since CCP is no EA (or any other american company) it is not completly out of the line. There will always be companies which will reduce their profit margin if it means a better product.
And thats the case here. Any impact of real life money on the game is bad.
EVE is about the simulation of a virtual universe. Economy, Strategy, Tactics, Politics, Combat and so on. We have been given a (in some cases limited) toolset and we shape our world with it.
The rules are simple. If you want to live in this world, you must live by its rules. This is true in RL and this is also true in EVE. The rules are defined by the EULA and the TOS. The EULA forbids outside influence (unless via the GTC-loophole).
Why? Because it is bad for the game. A simulation depends on its rules. By cheating around those rules, you gain an advantage. This corrupts the entire simulation and ruins every players experience.
I don't care if you are in the game for PvP or PvE only or if you enjoy both. I don't care if you have more money, less money, more time, less time, a family, no family, a life, no life outside of EVE.
These facts are true in RL and these are also true in EVE.
- You want something, you must earn it.
- If you cannot afford it, you cannot have it.
- If you cheat, you get punished.
Do whatever you want in EVE, as long as you follow the rules. If you want to PvP and cannot afford the ship, go earn some ISK. If you do not want to earn those ISK to buy your ship, go elsewhere.
Yes it is a game, and should not compete with your RL work. But this does not allow you to cheat around the rules. If EVE means work for you, it is the wrong game for you.
Yes, even if you have 10 Mio $ or own 20 companies in RL, this is not RL. This is EVE. We are equals here, building our own world. If you cannot understand this, then please leave.
No, I do not want your stuff, I have earned my own.
Conclusion This is a bug fix. Not in TQs code, but in TQs EULA. Be grateful and fly safe. ___
Originally by: Dark Shikari They're protected by shuttles carrying Templars, Amarr fighter drones used by carriers, but their tanks aren't that strong.
|

Zanarkand
Gallente Outer Heaven DARPA
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 07:03:00 -
[356]
Edited by: Zanarkand on 06/05/2007 07:00:00
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn Well said, alex, we love you too! 
The thing is, why should someone be forced to spend 10 hours playing on their own (ratting or mission running) in order to spend 1 hour playing with friends?
Nero, take my housemate for example (everyone in ENIGMA and the Sekura Family knows who I mean). With his new jobs and whatnot, he's not been able to play EVE at all recently, he's even had me logging on and changing skills for him because he doesn't have the time. When he finally gets an hour to play the game, is it fair that he should spend 54 minutes of that grinding missions and ratting, in order to spend 6 minutes on a gate camp with us, chatting on VT and having fun?
Just because you've found a couple of nice ISK-making ventures doesn't mean everyone else can! If you forced me to do so, I'd probably find the same ones as you, and instead of having 2 right now, you'd have 1. As you probably know, I used to resell faction gear in Jita, but that got stale for me as well... The only thing that hasn't got boring for me over the years and months I've played this game is the PvP and social aspect.
Hell, after thinking about this whole thing today, I took an AF out to a 0.0 system to try and get some missions and standings, to see how painful it would actually be... Turns out very! I did 2 missions and logged off to watch a film!
Don't force people to partake in one part of the game that they may not like, so that they can partake in the part they like. Then the game just turns in to a job and becomes unenjoyable.
Noone is forcing you to play EVE. Don't like eve? Play another game. Play CS, there is no risk and no "doing boring stuff" in there. Perfect for you. Or... are a slave, who is forced to play EVE?
EVE is a game, point of the game is more or less have fun... Part of EVE is making and using the money wisely. Ever wondered why ccp didn't make Tranq market same as SiSi? Because EARNING & LOSING ISK is part of the game and makes it fun for many of us. Re-read the monopoly analogy, this is exactly how silly this RL cash -> ISK is.
Ingame advice? No, you don't need a full t2 absolution to enjoy this game.
oh btw, you will be petitioned & banned. Account sharing is against EULA. Even more so if announce it on EVE-O forums... :
|

Pudgy d'Noob
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 07:37:00 -
[357]
Kieron,
First off, your inability to communicate in a semi-intelligible fashion undermines your title of community manager.
For those that are wondering how CCP can make a profit by selling GTC's for isk, the key words in his statement were "third parties." This implies, to me, that CCP will act as a broker to these third parties who choose to sell GTC's. Who are these third parties? Who knows? But in order for a transaction to be feasible, all parties must receive some form of utility. Will CCP be selling game time cards for isk directly? I doubt it. What utility would they receive from this other than increased costs for decreased revenue?
So, letÆs go back to my opening statement: your inability to communicate in a semi-intelligible fashion undermines your title of community manager.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 07:46:00 -
[358]
The monopoly analogy is completely retarded because A) theres a finite amount of money in a monopoly game, B) you get the same amount of turns as any other player, and C)its a limited timeframe game, with an actual winner and loser. Lets compare those 3 facts to eve, A) isk increases all the time, and has to whenever a new player joins the game to accomadate their market share, B) the amount of time spent on the game varies GREATLY depending on the player, and C) you can NEVER win Eve, unless CCP completely screws up the game.
Now that we've settled the fact that your analogy is ******* retarded, lets get back to the fact that different people spend different amounts of time on the game. Its been said before, but if person A can spend a lot of time in the game, enjoys PVE just as much as PVP, and got lucky with some form of the randomness of the game, be it t2 BPO, officer spawn, whatever, and person B can't, doesn't, and hasn't, but buys a GTC and sells it for ISK, what god damned mother******* difference does it make to you player C. The answer is it doesn't. Ergo all your whining and *****ing about the "Evils" of GTC trading for ISK is moot and completely retarded. I can understand GAME COMPANIES not liking RMT for profiting off their intellectual property, but you the player have ABSOLUTELY no say in the morality of such things because it affects you NOT ONE BIT. You fatuous idiotic *******s.
|

Odinegras
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 08:09:00 -
[359]
Im abit confused by what the op is saying.
And tbh i dont think what he has said has answered most of the questions
The questions i have.
Am I going to be able to buy GTC's for Cash from a reseller?
Am I going to be able to buy GTC's for ISK from someone? Anyone? Even if its just CCP?
Quote: In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK. In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. (yes) Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option. (then no)
So which is it? Id assume you mean - You can buy time cards for isk from ccp but player trades of time cards is going to be against the revised (probably) EULA
2 Simple yes/no questions without all the babble....
I agree with being able to buy ingame time for isk its a good feature and a selling point for the game...
I dont agree with people funding there ingame purchases with out of game cash...
Odin
|

Zanarkand
Gallente Outer Heaven DARPA
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 08:10:00 -
[360]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Its been said before, but if person A can spend a lot of time in the game, enjoys PVE just as much as PVP, and got lucky with some form of the randomness of the game, be it t2 BPO, officer spawn, whatever, and person B can't, doesn't, and hasn't, but buys a GTC and sells it for ISK, what *snip* difference does it make to you player C. The answer is it doesn't. Ergo *snip* the "Evils" of GTC trading for ISK is moot and completely retarded.
Okkokk, go on, flame on...
But please, go play CS if you want a risk-free-no-boring-stuff game.
I always thougth that EVE is different... ? Or at least tries to be...
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 08:33:00 -
[361]
Originally by: Zanarkand
Okkokk, go on, flame on...
But please, go play CS if you want a risk-free-no-boring-stuff game.
I always thougth that EVE is different... ? Or at least tries to be...
This is what most people fall back on if they can't come up with an actually coherent argument towards GTC > ISK. Which is quite often beause there is no such thing, and anyone who thinks different probably can't follow an IQ test from one question to the next. From the example above, how do you, Joe Public know who's "playing CS" and who isn't. Hell some guy with an empire alt who basically prints ISK is just as untouchable as the guy who buys ISK with a GTC. You don't even have to neccessarily leave the STATION to make ISK, even in empire. Thats pretty untouchable. You don't EVER know the difference, because its not your character, unless said person deems to tell you. Hell even then you have absolutely no clue if they're telling you the truth. ****, sitting in 0.0 isn't much different if you pay attention and aren't a complete moron. People do it in enemy territory all the time. The only real difference is person A can stand doing it, and person B chooses not to.
The fact of the matter is your argument doesn't have a leg to stand on, so you and the rest of the 2 bit internet lawyers out there are grasping at straws for why "its bad."
PS: The "grind" as its called ISN'T to make the game harder you gits, its to make CCP money. Guess what, GTC sales still make CCP the same amount of money. Ergo your argument is ******* worthless.
PPS: To the mod who tore up my post. I never evaded the profanity filter, if your company really had a problem with it, they would delete the word entirely not star it out.
|

Trind2222
Amarr Dark-Rising Fallen Souls
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 09:03:00 -
[362]
This is a good and a bad change the good one is that ccp will be only one selling gtc. The bad once you won't be able no longer buy isk for real money in a legal way. Many will buy isk ilgal how are ccp gona stopp them?
This queston to ccp how can you stopp people from seling time codes from ebay?
|

Zanarkand
Gallente Outer Heaven DARPA
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 09:18:00 -
[363]
Edited by: Zanarkand on 06/05/2007 09:15:23
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Originally by: Zanarkand
Okkokk, go on, flame on...
But please, go play CS if you want a risk-free-no-boring-stuff game.
I always thougth that EVE is different... ? Or at least tries to be...
This is what most people fall back on if they can't come up with an actually coherent argument towards GTC > ISK. Which is quite often beause there is no such thing, and anyone who thinks different probably can't follow an IQ test from one question to the next. From the example above, how do you, Joe Public know who's "playing CS" and who isn't. Hell some guy with an empire alt who basically prints ISK is just as untouchable as the guy who buys ISK with a GTC. You don't even have to neccessarily leave the STATION to make ISK, even in empire. Thats pretty untouchable. You don't EVER know the difference, because its not your character, unless said person deems to tell you. Hell even then you have absolutely no clue if they're telling you the truth. ****, sitting in 0.0 isn't much different if you pay attention and aren't a complete moron. People do it in enemy territory all the time. The only real difference is person A can stand doing it, and person B chooses not to.
The fact of the matter is your argument doesn't have a leg to stand on, so you and the rest of the 2 bit internet lawyers out there are grasping at straws for why "its bad."
PS: The "grind" as its called ISN'T to make the game harder you gits, its to make CCP money. Guess what, GTC sales still make CCP the same amount of money. Ergo your argument is ******* worthless.
*snip*
Please don't discuss moderator actions on the forum. -Rauth Kivaro ([email protected])
If making ISK is so eaasy, why don't you do it? Oh right, making isk takes time... Should ingame reward be decided by ingame results or RL cash?
This ruins the GAME.
H.o.w.h.a.r.d.i.s.i.t.t.o.u.n.d.e.r.s.t.a.n.d.t.h.a.t?
|

Galk
Gallente Autumn Tactics All the things she said
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 10:00:00 -
[364]
Just logged and saw the motd for the first time.
Im betting the op was written in conjunction or beforehand, to answer it.
This ain't no different to GM arkanoids blog last year folks..... you know that one where he pillarized isk buyers......"who wants to play a game where people are buying themselfs ahead" ect ect.....
Everybody knows.
True intent of that blog, much like this one is mearly to ostrisize people like me for future wrangles on whatever they decide.... you've been thown a shred, you'll (well the defenders, apologists , and obviously the trolls) will keep grasp to this thread for dear life when they announce whats realy going to happen.
Telling you, there playing you, the thread/motd.. it's all leading to something
As for what people think.....Craam Hustler, thank him... not ccp or your heroic community manager... what have they done for you lately ______
|

Thews Mortaza
Minmatar Brutor tribe
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 10:08:00 -
[365]
Originally by: Jayyne Cobb
Quote:
CCP will never get rid of every bug, so why bother fixing the current ones?
Some bugs SHOULDNT be fixed, as that can cause countless others as well as security flaws or data loss. EVE isn't immune to this.
This is the worst argument I've ever read on these boards. Words fail me. (Sig) Your momma so fat ... when I tried to scoop her to my cargo hold, she don't fit ! |

Heroldyn
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 10:21:00 -
[366]
still no answer as to why unemployed people should be allowed to have their real life conditions gain them an unfair advantage in the game. so i guess everyone agrees to a max allowed playtime of 2 hours/day ? or maybe better ccp charging per hour instead of per month/days.
if theres anything ruining eve, then its unemployed and students.
|

Lilian Long
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 10:33:00 -
[367]
Originally by: Heroldyn still no answer as to why unemployed people should be allowed to have their real life conditions gain them an unfair advantage in the game. so i guess everyone agrees to a max allowed playtime of 2 hours/day ? or maybe better ccp charging per hour instead of per month/days.
if theres anything ruining eve, then its unemployed and students.
If they like, they can make an extra server for people like you, who can only play 2 hours a day or less.
|

Valan
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 10:38:00 -
[368]
CCP have been consistent on this. They said they don't like people buying their way ahead of others. The positive affects of GTCs out weighed the negative but they promised to try and balance it.
They are now trying to make the system more secure and fairer. You knew it was coming same with nano ships, running missions in carriers and the soon to be nerfed passive tanked Drakes. So stop whining, if you're going to cheat by buying isk, buy it in the wrong way and risk a ban. I prefer it that way risk vs reward. /start sig I love old characters that post 'I've beeen playing the game three years' when I know their account has been sold on. /end sig |

Robacz
Essence Trade Essence Enterprises
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 10:54:00 -
[369]
Kieron, do you see what you have caused? Please next time either don't say anything, or say it all. Thank you. 
IMO Kieron's statement is too uncertain to make any conclusions and can be explained in many different ways. Therefore any speculations on this matter are just waste of time.
_________ Buying/Selling: Implants & Hardwirings Producing/BPCs: Mining Barges, T2 Components T2 Distribution: 8 regions covered |

Galk
Gallente Autumn Tactics All the things she said
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 11:02:00 -
[370]
Originally by: Robacz
IMO Kieron's statement is too uncertain to make any conclusions and can be explained in many different ways. Therefore any speculations on this matter are just waste of time.
Bingo.
But realy, thats the point of it ______
|

ToxicFire
Phoenix Knights Dark Nebula Galactic Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 11:11:00 -
[371]
Im just rofling at people keep trying to post as if kieron said that the system will be implement so that third parties are still going to be selling time for isk just under ccp's internal system. Alot of people obviously in denile or hopeing desperately that there still gonna be making isk the easy way.
Lets take apart that famous paragraph line by line
Originally by: CCP kieron In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK.
This is the line thats throw most people because the wordings slightly off this line is about the system that being replaced not what its been replaced with. if you change the part that says "current system" to "current system with one" changes the entire meaning of the sentence in the wrong direction but the sentence isn't as ambiguous. if you change "replacing the current system that" to "replacement for the current system which" the line clears itself up but the important part is to rember the part in bold THAT IS WHAT IS BEEN REPLACED by a system not yet specified in the paragraph by this line.
Originally by: CCP kieron In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP.
This line is fairly clear, those with isk who want to exchange time for isk will be able to, and this will be done directly with CCP no third parties. This prevents trading time for isk for players (confirmed in the next line) This I think clearly states that CCP isn't going to be implementing a system where someone buys time its allocated to their account they then can sell it via a ccp system to other players for isk. Theres no mention in the op of these mysterious third party systems that people have said ccp will invent. Most important things to note from this line are "directly from CCP" and purchasing time for isk.
Originally by: CCP kieron Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
This line is more about players worrying that they won't be able to buy GTC's with cash to use normally for their subscription, but also it confirms by saying GTC for ISK trade will be no longer approved, that they will no longer be allowing non official third parties to trade GTC's in anyform.
Alot of crap as come up in this thread with people inventing concepts to cover there ass or to deny to themselves the fact something that has unfairly tipped the economy for over a year now is finally about to get binned. Frankly I say good riddance to the system. Sig removed as it lacks EVE-related content. Mail [email protected] if you have questions. -Hango
|

Talkie Toaster
Amarr
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 11:37:00 -
[372]
Ta toxic i think you cleared that up. it wasnt the best wording in the OP which has led to a shed load of speculation and panic.
all selling GTC from player A to player B did was promote a "im rich irl and now i want to be rich in game" philosophy.
|

Denton Farrow
UK Corp FATAL Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 11:44:00 -
[373]
If they are buying for isk direct from CCP then in effect paying subscribers will subsidize people who only pay in isk.
If this is the case then why not just remove the whole GTC system as why should paying subscribers subsidize people who play for free?
|

hybridundertaker
Amarr coracao ardente Triumvirate.
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 11:48:00 -
[374]
hm it is somehow a step in right direction, cos i dont think games should be like RL where the guy with $$ can pwn any little guy anytime.
However i dont get it how CCP will get rl money from that system. Before smone had to pay so i could play with tc. Now noone will pay but ccp will end up with isk they created in first place. It is good for eve economy beyond any doubt but i fear they might fix the price very high to avoid loosing paying customers.
EvE +NLINE - T+TALHELLDEATH SUPPORTER |

Mathias Orsen
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 12:04:00 -
[375]
Really do get alot of opinions on this one. With those come some good and bad points. As for my thoughts on it..
People should always have the right to buy and sell GTCs for isk. Sure, to get the isk you should earn the isk. That has more than one side to it though. Many people in EVE spend 40+ hours a week making isk. That could even be considered "part time" compared to many EVE players.
Then there are many people in EVE that spend 40+ hours away from EVE working to pay the bills. If someone such as myself, who works fifty hours a week, wants isk for nice ship, then should I not have the right to be able to make that isk?
I do think that things should be earned. Often times that is not possible though. Someone who spends 10+ hours a day can work to earn a billion isk per week. Someone who works 10+ hours a day at thier job is never gonna have that chance. The question is, If the person that has to work most of the time sells a few GTCs, who actually works the hardest for thier isk.
The OP mentions "time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged"... but what about time and ISK-poor, but financially secure"? The only real issue I see with someone selling GTCs would be the people that buy and sell them by the dozens. If that person is buying dozens, hundreds of dollars worth of GTC, to sell them for ISK, it's his choice. -------------------------------------- ---"What's in your wallet?"--- "There are two kinds of respect, fear and admiration.... I'll take what I can get" |

Zechs Kushrenada
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 12:41:00 -
[376]
Arent' you guys (CCP) 'killing' yourselves this way. With the current situation you still get money for your game. But if you will implement this new feature you won't get any money for gametime anymore........
|

Zeonos
Amarr Fairtrade Syndicate
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 13:09:00 -
[377]
Originally by: Athena Attom Edited by: Athena Attom on 04/05/2007 22:49:59
Originally by: Del Narveux Wait...so buying GTC from sellers, or selling themself, is bad, but getting them from CCP is okay? And is this going to affect those big third party resellers that currently do most of the sales? Im a bit confuzzled, though Ive never been a big fan of getting cash for game money or vice versa so it doesnt really affect me.
Its because people are purchasing GTCS with RL money and selling them for ingame ISK effectively buying ISK from a website, except CCP get paid this way...
its an unfair advantage that some people use to fund their entire accounts ship losses etc and also certain alliances :)
well some people play isk and earn them ingame. some people dont have that time, because they have a real life work, and maybe education and home work, so they spend a little to get some isk "on GTC" so they also can have some fun..
Latest evemon |

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 13:49:00 -
[378]
Originally by: Zanarkand Edited by: Zanarkand on 06/05/2007 07:34:14
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn Some stuff...
Noone is forcing you to play EVE. Don't like eve? Play another game. Play CS, there is no risk and no "doing boring stuff" in there. Perfect for you. Or... are you forced to play EVE? Again there are gazillion mmorpgs out there.
Ah, the generic "I'm losing the argument so go play a different game" comeback. Seriously, get a new line, it's boring now...
Originally by: Zanarkand EVE is a game, point of the game is more or less have fun... Part of EVE is making and using ISK wisely. Ever wondered why ccp didn't make Tranq market same as SiSi? Because EARNING & LOSING ISK is part of the game and makes it fun for many of us. You know, those funny things like "doing anything in EVE has a meaning or things like EVE is special." CCP makes the game, not you or your ideas about gaming.
Me, you, everyone on these forums, we make EVE what it is. CCP provide the universe and we play in it. Without me or you, there would be no EVE. That's why they call it a MMOG.
Originally by: Zanarkand Re-read the monopoly analogy, this is exactly how silly this RL cash -> ISK is.
Originally by: Rachel Vend
Originally by: Felysta Sandorn I work hard in real life and then put a little bit of that money in to EVE to get extra ISK.
I work real hard, and when I play monopoly with my friends I buy extra monopoly board games and use that money to beat my friends in monopoly.
Ingame advice? No, you don't need a full t2 absolution to enjoy this game. SERIOUSLY GO PLAY ANOTHER GAME.
True, you don't need faction fitted faction BS to enjoy the game, or fully t2 Absolutions, and I don't always fly them! Sometimes I jump in my t1 cruisers and fly around for a bit of old school fun. The monopoly analogy is very flawed because of what someone said previously, that there is a winner and there is a finite amount of money.
Put simply, I'm going to be in a t2 fitted Absolution whether I spend 10 hours ratting to afford one, or whether I bypass that and buy a single GTC (about 1 hour work in real life) so that I can play this game in the way I like. Similarly, I'll also be flying t1 Arbitrators whether I have to kill 2 rats for them or use 2mil out of a GTC to fly them. Just because you don't like PvPers doesn't mean they should all go play Counterstrike... Grow a pair and find a valid argument!
Originally by: Zanarkand oh btw, you will be petitioned & banned. Account sharing is against EULA. Even more so if announce it on EVE-O forums... :
Petition me if you want, I don't account share with my housemate. He's got 2 full time jobs and doesn't have the time to play EVE at the moment, not only that, but after he recently installed VISTA, he can't actually run EVE, so I logged on the other day to change his skill. I put a 24 day skill on so I don't have to do this for another month, but hopefully by that time, he'll be playing again and can do it himself.
If you really want to petition me for that, go ahead, but it's just being overly petty and trying to get me banned because you're losing an argument on these forums that doesn't really account for anything anyway.
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

nickky01
The Collective Against ALL Authorities
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 13:56:00 -
[379]
Originally by: nickky01 *snip*
Let's keep references to RL drugs out of the forums, regardless of your stance on the issue, it's not germane to this topic. -Rauth Kivaro ([email protected])
the man - 1
nickky01 - 0
|

Monty Burns
Rampage Eternal Ka-Tet
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 14:13:00 -
[380]
Guess the answer for us who have a life, job, friends, girlfriend is to buy a shed load of GTC's now and sell em quick.
CCP. Another post in a storm of many that will probably get swamped but, remember many of us have been with you since launch and we want to play but there is no way we can afford to if you do this. Many of us don't take the p**s, we finance a few cruisers and clones (of which i need many! ). Darwin 4tw
|

Felysta Sandorn
Caldari Murder of Crows E N I G M A
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 14:23:00 -
[381]
Originally by: Monty Burns Guess the answer for us who have a life, job, friends, girlfriend is to buy a shed load of GTC's now and sell em quick.
CCP. Another post in a storm of many that will probably get swamped but, remember many of us have been with you since launch and we want to play but there is no way we can afford to if you do this. Many of us don't take the p**s, we finance a few cruisers and clones (of which i need many! ).
Well said... Quoting you so CCP might read your post twice! 
Latest Video, Click Here!
|

Lady Abaris
Shih Yang Tong
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 14:44:00 -
[382]
I cannot see buying game time direct from CCP using isk causing them huge finacial hurt. There just isnt going to be a huge jump in numbers buying as those who choose to pay in this way already do so. CCP know exactly how many GTCs are used every month and will have done their sums.
The are 2 groups who will suffer. Those who profit by reselling for rl cash and nobody who gives a damn about EVE will have any sympathy for them. The second group is those who fund their ingame activities using their rl wealth. Well this group is already able to get big advantages by the use off multiple accounts to raise isk so all is not lost for them.
CCP do seem to be raising their game in terms of fighting the Isk selling menace and this change is hopefully just part of the attack on the sellers. I can see a trend towards an eve with proportionally less isk per head in it. An example being the new Level 5,6 and 7 missions will be item rewarded rather than isk. Removing the isk sellers from the game removes a massive amount. While CCP selling game time for isk also fits the pattern although i think the numbers involved are in reality somewhat smaller than we think.
Lets be honest EVE would be a far more interesting place with out the isk sellers in any form and with less isk in the economy. The dedicated pvpers who currently use bought isk would either have to fly smaller ships, earn isk ingame like average players or shock horror cooperate with nonpvpers and gain an industrial base. Real player miners (bless em) would actually become vital again to the community and the economy.
The result? Well we could expect to see fewer capital ships and battleships blobs out there. Smaller ships like cruisers and afs would again be more common again allowing the newer players more accessability. Oh yes and miners would get more friends.
|

Kuolematon
Space Perverts and Forum Warriors United Cult of War
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 15:40:00 -
[383]
Originally by: Chribba This could potentially mean that those of us who buys GTC's off american sites (since it's cheaper vs the euro price) would get forced into buying european gtc's via cpp ending up paying a lot more again because of the european VAT system, that doesn't sounds too good in my ears.
QFT! Us europeans gettings shifted again! 
Proud member of Cult of War and Amarr 4tw Finnish people seeking PvP, contact me ingame!
|

Skyly
Generals Of Destruction Syndicate Terror In The System
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 16:29:00 -
[384]
You mean I might have to go into belts? To shoot rats? or... Rocks?!?!
Please don't do it 
|

Baliera
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 16:36:00 -
[385]
This idea sucks quote 'dis if you're down
|

Johanna Bogue
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 16:38:00 -
[386]
Originally by: Baliera This idea sucks quote 'dis if you're down
|

Trancestor
Caldari Art of War Cult of War
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 16:47:00 -
[387]
Edited by: Trancestor on 06/05/2007 16:44:10 i just have the question... what is the different between buying isk in ebay or selling gtc's for isk
1. u give rl money to get isk in ebay
2. or u give money for gtc's sell them to other player and get isk.
result is the 1st is not allowed, the second is legal.
there is no different for me, the result is always the same.. u get isk for rl money.
i dont have only 1 account but i think its better to stop selling gtc's for isk.
|

Monty Burns
Rampage Eternal Ka-Tet
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 17:19:00 -
[388]
Originally by: Kuolematon Edited by: Kuolematon on 06/05/2007 15:54:45
Originally by: Chribba This could potentially mean that those of us who buys GTC's off american sites (since it's cheaper vs the euro price) would get forced into buying european gtc's via cpp ending up paying a lot more again because of the european VAT system, that doesn't sounds too good in my ears.
QFT! Us europeans gettings shifted again!  Is only REAL problem here that certain people has figured that buying GTC's for cheap ISK and then selling them for real money in eBay is back? Didn't your "secure" trade method helped that?
I for one love ISK -> GTC ratio that currently have (320m for 90d) so I can put my accounts for good use (all 3 of them )
Just for your info, VAT does NOT explain the huge diference in prices. VAT is the excuse CCP have used in the past and simply holds no water at all - in fact as much as a bucket with a really big hole in the bottom. Darwin 4tw
|

Karitsa
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 17:28:00 -
[389]
After years of making isk lazy trading I noticed the fastest way to make isk and still handle the taxes right was to instead of changing 100 orders and find new ones for several hours a week to make few bill -> order GTC, pay the taxes and use the rl wealthy income to save time.
This always felt a little bad but I arent teenager and like my family time more than mining rocks to be able to pvp.
So this will force me back to manipulating markets, but somehow I feel its a healty change. I wont spend hours on mining, chaining, exploration, invention but put the real life skills to analyze market, use the file export and continue reimbursing mates when needed to.
With the isk/ETC thing ccp created possiblity for working men to spend more time with family and still play even they way they wanted. But at same time it created enormous source of isk and made it possible for many of us to pvp in pimped ships 24/7.
Eve is already family friend with the skillpoints system, and clever people with less time to carebear for isk, can still make fortunes with minimal time.
For me it will be bit sad to see GTC trade go, which have made me billions with few extra hours from well paid programming job. But at least wealthy people are not able to fund titan after titan to make the game silly.
So even I have to spend few more hours weekly on a game at least I get more rl isk for booze, *****es and gambling =)
So as a working man 60hours+ a week in major consulting company, who had charished ETC trade legally - I agree this move might change game to better direction even it will cut some isk from ccp as I have spend more rl money to ETC than to the game game during the years ;)
So do it and unleash the market beast.
|

Kairi Elan
FATAL REVELATIONS
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 17:29:00 -
[390]
Here's the thing, most of the people I know who buy GTCs with ISK under the current system, do it not so that they don't have to pay at all, but so that they don't have to pay $15 a month for each of their 3 alt accounts.
People who want to see the game stay around will still pay money for at least one of their accounts. Also, with the removal of the resale market on GTCs CCP will be able to decide how many ISK they are willing to accept from a player in exchange for game time. CCP may think that 100mil ISK per month is too cheap. Heck, I do.
People have been complaining that the inability to circumvent the EULA and buy ISK through GTCs will ruin their play experience because they will no longer be able to fly their fancy T2 ship and 'wtfbbqpwn teh noobzorz!!!111!!!1!' at their gate camp thus ruining their fun and enjoyment of the game. As we all know, people who work for their ISK in game LOVE having their hard earned assets blown up at a camp by people who 'insert cash here' whenever they need to replace a ship.
CCP is trying to evolve the game universe at the moment, with a lot of changes that will dramatically affect the landscape. This is an attempt to partially reign in the economy, and re-balance the playing field before they go and add anything new.
The cash for ISK economy ruins more than just the PvP side of the game, as many of the skills required for production and invention are currently grossly inflated in value by people with too much un-earned ISK on their hands.
For people who need to be able to cheat to play, go back to single player console games, buy the strategy guide, enable godmode and leave the rest of us to play EVE in peace.
|

Juwi Kotch
Gallente VIRTUAL LIFE VANGUARD Freelancer Alliance
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 17:48:00 -
[391]
I believe that CCP is not that much profit driven as other MMOG companies, but I don't think that they will just easily give up at least 20% to 30% of their total turnover.
A direct purchase from gtcs from CCP with ISK, for what price ever, will result in the loss of the income out of the RL world gtc sale for each and every one of that gtcs, as it takes place right now before any one gtc is sold for ISK in game.
So I'm really curious, how CCP will do that, without cutting a significant chunk out of their profits.
Juwi Kotch
JOIN NOW, KLICK SIG! |

Monty Burns
Rampage Eternal Ka-Tet
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 17:58:00 -
[392]
All of this would make more sense if CCP would tell us how many GTC's they sell each month.
If its as many as to upset the economy (which I very much doubt it is) then I can understand them trying to do this but, then, no wait, they wouldn't would they. If it was so many to upset the economy then it would be worth significant income to them, enough to warrant them leaving it in.
Don't tell me CCP are NOT profit driven. ALL companies are. The very fact they "merged" (there is no such thing in business, one takes over the other) proves that they ARE profit driven ... sorry "Looking to expand on options and strengthen the company" ....
Darwin 4tw
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:01:00 -
[393]
Originally by: CCP kieron The recent MotD mentioning the sale or purchase of ISK for real money generated some questions about how Game Time can be traded for ISK, Game Time that was purchased with real world cash. In some of my replies, I was unclear. This wasn't by intention, but because of the information I am authorized to release at this time.
In the future, CCP will introduce a billing solution replacing the current system that allows the purchase of game time from third parties for in-game ISK. In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP. Game Time codes will still be available for purchase, but the trade of game time codes for ISK will no longer be an approved payment option.
We still have a number of details to work out, as well as implementation and integration, but that will hopefully clear up some of the confusion created earlier.
nice thanks.
The Amazing Fire Eaters webpage
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:04:00 -
[394]
Originally by: Lady Abaris I cannot see buying game time direct from CCP using isk causing them huge finacial hurt. There just isnt going to be a huge jump in numbers buying as those who choose to pay in this way already do so. CCP know exactly how many GTCs are used every month and will have done their sums.
The are 2 groups who will suffer. Those who profit by reselling for rl cash and nobody who gives a damn about EVE will have any sympathy for them. The second group is those who fund their ingame activities using their rl wealth. Well this group is already able to get big advantages by the use off multiple accounts to raise isk so all is not lost for them.
CCP do seem to be raising their game in terms of fighting the Isk selling menace and this change is hopefully just part of the attack on the sellers. I can see a trend towards an eve with proportionally less isk per head in it. An example being the new Level 5,6 and 7 missions will be item rewarded rather than isk. Removing the isk sellers from the game removes a massive amount. While CCP selling game time for isk also fits the pattern although i think the numbers involved are in reality somewhat smaller than we think.
Lets be honest EVE would be a far more interesting place with out the isk sellers in any form and with less isk in the economy. The dedicated pvpers who currently use bought isk would either have to fly smaller ships, earn isk ingame like average players or shock horror cooperate with nonpvpers and gain an industrial base. Real player miners (bless em) would actually become vital again to the community and the economy.
The result? Well we could expect to see fewer capital ships and battleships blobs out there. Smaller ships like cruisers and afs would again be more common again allowing the newer players more accessability. Oh yes and miners would get more friends.
yes amen.
The Amazing Fire Eaters webpage
|

Monty Burns
Rampage Eternal Ka-Tet
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:17:00 -
[395]
Originally by: Earthan
Originally by: Lady Abaris ..... The are 2 groups who will suffer. Those who profit by reselling for rl cash and nobody who gives a damn about EVE will have any sympathy for them. The second group is those who fund their ingame activities using their rl wealth. Well this group is already able to get big advantages by the use off multiple accounts to raise isk so all is not lost for them....
Wrong.
a 3rd group.
Those of us who buy occasionaly to allow us to play but dont have the time in rl to dedicate any major commitment. Those of us that have maybe 2 or 3 hours a week. Those of us who love the pvp and want to be able to participate in ops. Those of us that have been playing since launch. Those of use that through change of life cannot dedicate the time to mine/mission/rat/etc like we used to.
Yeah yeah ... "get a frig" i hear you say "buy my replacement 40mil sp clones" I say to you!
People: Stop assuming us GTC sellers are all greedy bastards, we are not. We don't all own motherships. We don't all fly Tech 2 fitted stuff (yes im skilled enough to).
Darwin 4tw
|

Nymos
Celtic Anarchy Anarchy Empire
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:24:00 -
[396]
i didn't read through 14 pages, but thank you for getting rid of isk buying via GTCs. - if i understood that right. --
Every time a carebear dies an angel gets their wings (murder one)
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:29:00 -
[397]
Edited by: Earthan on 06/05/2007 19:26:19
Originally by: Monty Burns
Wrong.
a 3rd group.
Those of us who buy occasionaly to allow us to play but dont have the time in rl to dedicate any major commitment. Those of us that have maybe 2 or 3 hours a week. Those of us who love the pvp and want to be able to participate in ops. Those of us that have been playing since launch. Those of use that through change of life cannot dedicate the time to mine/mission/rat/etc like we used to.
Yeah yeah ... "get a frig" i hear you say "buy my replacement 40mil sp clones" I say to you!
People: Stop assuming us GTC sellers are all greedy bastards, we are not. We don't all own motherships. We don't all fly Tech 2 fitted stuff (yes im skilled enough to).
no mate i disagree.Mixing rl moneny to buy ingame stuff is just plain wrong.
Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
This is a game.Its a separate universe where rl money must stop giving you advantage( as much as its possible).
If you can play that little you still can make enough isk to pvp in cruisers.But i want you to earn that isk not buy it.Cause i also got little time for Eve and i do all kind of smart risky stuff to earn isk ingame faster and when i risk my hard ingame earned bs and fight i want to face somebody who also had to earn it ingame, not some guy who is just rich and bought from ebay officer stuff and will pwn me, despite he is so much "worse" in term of this game.
On side note a 51 milions sp clone costs nowadays i think 7 milions.You earn that in 30 minutes in 0.0 .
In game must rule only game rules.RL rules must stop.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:33:00 -
[398]
Originally by: Earthan Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
Yes it's exactly like that. rl analogies ftl.
Even buying isk is bad, this change is going to change nothing. It'll just drive it underground, the people who want to buy isk will find a way.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:34:00 -
[399]
Edited by: Earthan on 06/05/2007 19:32:12
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Earthan Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
Yes it's exactly like that. rl analogies ftl.
Its nice you mock my post but arguments would help.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:39:00 -
[400]
Originally by: Earthan Edited by: Earthan on 06/05/2007 19:32:12
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Originally by: Earthan Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
Yes it's exactly like that. rl analogies ftl.
Its nice you mock my post but arguments would help.
Read harder. You editing the rest of my post out of your quote doesn't erase my post.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:39:00 -
[401]
NO NO NO. Why do people perpetuate this retarded myth that it makes ANY difference WHERE people got their ISK. It doesn't. They have it however they have it and you don't. RMT matters to CCP because it means they aren't getting paid for their intellectual property, it DOESN'T matter to John Q Player, because some schmoe has more money ANYWAY, by a circumstance outside your control.
I'll say it again for the retards in the cheap seats, to think that being able to afford GTC's to fund their in-game pursuits is ANY different than being lucky enough to have the TIME to put into making that money "legit" is a complete FALLACY.
In fact is actually MORE likely that a person with excess TIME has a bigger advantage than anyone buying ISK with GTCs, because MOST people won't drop $20k, yet some guy who gets lucky with a t2 Vaga BPO sells it for that much in-game currency, or mines/rats it up because they have nothing better to do with their lives.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:41:00 -
[402]
Originally by: Marquis Dean
Read harder. You editing the rest of my post out of your quote doesn't erase my post.
The rest of your post has no arguments as to why this analogy is rubbish in your eyes.
|

BubbaZanetti
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:44:00 -
[403]
Originally by: Earthan no mate i disagree.Mixing rl moneny to buy ingame stuff is just plain wrong.
And so is mixing in real life time. Which is why we're all only going to be allowed to play for an hour a week from now on. Because it's important that real life circumstances don't impact the game world at all.
Originally by: Earthan Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
Your analogy is broken. It's the same game. I fly the same ships and my skills fly at the same rate. Your analogy is so broken I can't even fix it to indicate how it could be apt.
Originally by: Earthan This is a game.Its a separate universe where rl money must stop giving you advantage( as much as its possible).
Sure. And so must real life spare time. We're all equals here, right? I can play for an hour a week. What are you going to do with your hour per work from now on?
Originally by: Earthan If you can play that little you still can make enough isk to pvp in cruisers.But i want you to earn that isk not buy it.Cause i also got little time for Eve and i do all kind of smart risky stuff to earn isk ingame faster and when i risk my hard ingame earned bs and fight i want to face somebody who also had to earn it ingame, not some guy who is just rich and bought from ebay officer stuff and will pwn me, despite he is so much "worse" in term of this game.
Good. I'm glag you're going to be ok with only playing an hour a week from now on.
Originally by: Earthan On side note a 51 milions sp clone costs nowadays i think 7 milions.You earn that in 30 minutes in 0.0 .
Wow, man, that's gonna be half your play time for the week. Hope you don't get pod killed much.
Originally by: Earthan In game must rule only game rules.RL rules must stop.
Yep. Agree completely. Hope there's no one out there that only plays fifteen minutes a week, or we're all screwed.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:46:00 -
[404]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI NO NO NO. Why do people perpetuate this retarded myth that it makes ANY difference WHERE people got their ISK. It doesn't. They have it however they have it and you don't. RMT matters to CCP because it means they aren't getting paid for their intellectual property, it DOESN'T matter to John Q Player, because some schmoe has more money ANYWAY, by a circumstance outside your control.
I'll say it again for the retards in the cheap seats, to think that being able to afford GTC's to fund their in-game pursuits is ANY different than being lucky enough to have the TIME to put into making that money "legit" is a complete FALLACY.
In fact is actually MORE likely that a person with excess TIME has a bigger advantage than anyone buying ISK with GTCs, because MOST people won't drop $20k, yet some guy who gets lucky with a t2 Vaga BPO sells it for that much in-game currency, or mines/rats it up because they have nothing better to do with their lives.
Mate your post is so wrong on so many levels.
First if you think buying isk with rl money is great why do we bother with this game? lets just compare our rl wallets and who can spare mroe wins a fight.great fun.
The last bit "because they have nothing better to do with their lives." is weird.I mean you are in game yes? you do it for fun? and you insult poeple who play more then you.
I you think this game is rubbish and rl is so much better go and work 14h/day , earn alot of rl cash and be happy.Dont waste your time here lol.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:46:00 -
[405]
Originally by: BubbaZanetti
Originally by: Earthan Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
Your analogy is broken. It's the same game. I fly the same ships and my skills fly at the same rate. Your analogy is so broken I can't even fix it to indicate how it could be apt.
There we go.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:52:00 -
[406]
Originally by: BubbaZanetti
Originally by: Earthan no mate i disagree.Mixing rl moneny to buy ingame stuff is just plain wrong.
And so is mixing in real life time. Which is why we're all only going to be allowed to play for an hour a week from now on. Because it's important that real life circumstances don't impact the game world at all.
Originally by: Earthan Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
Your analogy is broken. It's the same game. I fly the same ships and my skills fly at the same rate. Your analogy is so broken I can't even fix it to indicate how it could be apt.
Originally by: Earthan This is a game.Its a separate universe where rl money must stop giving you advantage( as much as its possible).
Sure. And so must real life spare time. We're all equals here, right? I can play for an hour a week. What are you going to do with your hour per work from now on?
Originally by: Earthan If you can play that little you still can make enough isk to pvp in cruisers.But i want you to earn that isk not buy it.Cause i also got little time for Eve and i do all kind of smart risky stuff to earn isk ingame faster and when i risk my hard ingame earned bs and fight i want to face somebody who also had to earn it ingame, not some guy who is just rich and bought from ebay officer stuff and will pwn me, despite he is so much "worse" in term of this game.
Good. I'm glag you're going to be ok with only playing an hour a week from now on.
Originally by: Earthan On side note a 51 milions sp clone costs nowadays i think 7 milions.You earn that in 30 minutes in 0.0 .
Wow, man, that's gonna be half your play time for the week. Hope you don't get pod killed much.
Originally by: Earthan In game must rule only game rules.RL rules must stop.
Yep. Agree completely. Hope there's no one out there that only plays fifteen minutes a week, or we're all screwed.
No bubba if you buy isk with rl money its not the same game.Cause you get advantage from outside game.
Nobody had said that everybody has to play same time.
Its what my analogy was pointing at.IF you got to a tennis tournament , those that could train more will have advantage because thats what it is about,its about tennis.Not what you do outside tennis.Your tons of money wont help you ( at least not taht much in amatuer tournaments, the stuff to play doesnt matter so much at certain level).And i dont think anybody would be happy if rules changed and you could buy a 1 game set for 20 $.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 19:58:00 -
[407]
Originally by: Earthan
Mate your post is so wrong on so many levels.
First if you think buying isk with rl money is great why do we bother with this game? lets just compare our rl wallets and who can spare mroe wins a fight.great fun.
The last bit "because they have nothing better to do with their lives." is weird.I mean you are in game yes? you do it for fun? and you insult poeple who play more then you.
I you think this game is rubbish and rl is so much better go and work 14h/day , earn alot of rl cash and be happy.Dont waste your time here lol.
Way to read way too damned much into a post, I'd flame you for it but I've been warned. I'm actually one of those people who's got endless amounts of time, and basically have nothing better to do with it. I've never bought a GTC to sell for ISK, and probably never will.
It doesn't matter though because theres always going to be someone out there with more time/luck than I do, who's going to be richer. Same goes for anyone who can afford to spend A LOT of money on GTC's for ISK. Theres no difference between the two as far as I'm concerned because they both have more ISK, end of story. How they got it is of no concern to me.
News flash sparky, there are people who through entirely ingame means have a big enough wallet to NEVER work for ISK EVER again and still have enough money around to fly fully factioned ships from now until the servers close down, they're going to win the ISK war against anyone but someone with way more disposable income than is likely to waste on the game.
Besides ISK can only take you so far. I knew a guy in another MMO who used to brag about the fact that he spent more money on game currency than people spent on college, he got made fun of endlessly for sucking at the game, not for his RMT habits.
Oh and as to your last point, I play this game for the things that excite me, like PVP, or marginally VERY marginally to come across a faction spawn and get some cool loot, its like playing the lotto. I don't play this game to grind money, CCP makes it a part of the game to make themselves money, its a game mechanism to keep us playing and paying, GTC > ISK transactions still fulfill that part of the bargain, somebodies still paying for that time to CCP. But I doubt anyone arguing against GTC > ISK will have the wit to actually comprehend that statement.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:05:00 -
[408]
Edited by: Earthan on 06/05/2007 20:03:29
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Oh and as to your last point, I play this game for the things that excite me, like PVP, or marginally VERY marginally to come across a faction spawn and get some cool loot, its like playing the lotto. I don't play this game to grind money, CCP makes it a part of the game to make themselves money, its a game mechanism to keep us playing and paying, GTC > ISK transactions still fulfill that part of the bargain, somebodies still paying for that time to CCP. But I doubt anyone arguing against GTC > ISK will have the wit to actually comprehend that statement.
No actually its abit deeper, you dont understand.Its human psychology. Its about working for somethign and then living the thrill of combat.You must work for your ship to then apreciate it and feel the thrill of combat.
I dont know actually how poeple who buy with rl money Eve stuff actually have fun.I suspect most of them play a few months and leave.
And its not some theory i was in Eve beta and i was on last day when they have given everybodu enough isk to buy anything and play with it.For me it wasnt that fun.
If its all about pvping with best stuff why CCP dont give everybody free modules and let everybody endleslly fight it out?Because Eve would be dead in 1 week.It wouldnt be fun
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:09:00 -
[409]
Hurray for you, and way to miss the point. Just because you don't like the game if you don't have to grind for it doesn't mean the rest of us are brain-damaged as well. Besides, its likely to hurt more for someone who GTC'ed their ISK because thats REAL ******* MONEY they're losing, not time spent staring blankly at a computer screen watching a rock or some worthless NPC ship thats so easy its routine inside a week.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:17:00 -
[410]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Hurray for you, and way to miss the point. Just because you don't like the game if you don't have to grind for it doesn't mean the rest of us are brain-damaged as well. Besides, its likely to hurt more for someone who GTC'ed their ISK because thats REAL ******* MONEY they're losing, not time spent staring blankly at a computer screen watching a rock or some worthless NPC ship thats so easy its routine inside a week.
I repeat so follwoing your way of thiking CCP should just scrap all the prices so everybody can use any module /ship, and it would be perfect, with no grinding?then everybody can fight non stop.
Or make an offical market for items say: bs - 10 $ titan - 100 $ hac 12 $
At least it would be clear
That would hell of fun.
|

Zanarkand
Gallente Outer Heaven DARPA
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:18:00 -
[411]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Just because you don't like the game if you don't have to grind for it doesn't mean the rest of us are brain-damaged as well.
Isn't that sort of the point of RPG? You know, train your SP, train your skills, earn isk and spend it wisely... Grinding is part of RPGs and what make the game fun. I am not saying that I am playing the game to shoot rats in 0.0/run missions, but I do understand that it is a part of game and like it as it is.
CS is always good for those who can only play 1h/week. Oh, if you are really annoyed by the "play another game" then you may always do pvp on SiSi.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:22:00 -
[412]
Edited by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI on 06/05/2007 20:20:16 Way to be a complete and contradictory idiot. The way things are now allows the LARGEST majority of the game to enjoy it the way they want to. People with extra cash and no time get to play, people with no cash and extra time get to play, its a win/win situations for the whole group, except for morons who whine about the "unfairness of it all" and the "Evils and immorality" of buying ISK with GTC's. Of course the fact that such people basically have a persecution complex and need something to whine about to make themselves morally superior is disgusting and frankly THEY should be the ones who "quit if you don't like it."
Edit: Zanarkand you're completely off your rocker if you think that MMO's are designed so that the grind is part of the fun. Its a TOOL to make the game company keep your business longer, nothing more.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:26:00 -
[413]
Originally by: Zanarkand Edited by: Zanarkand on 06/05/2007 20:17:24 Edited by: Zanarkand on 06/05/2007 20:15:54
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Just because you don't like the game if you don't have to grind for it doesn't mean the rest of us are brain-damaged as well.
Isn't that sort of the point of RPG? You know, train your SP, train your skills, earn isk and spend it wisely... Grinding is part of RPGs and what make a RPG different from other type of games. I am not saying that I am playing the game to shoot rats in 0.0/run missions, but I do understand that it is a part of game and like it as it is.
CS is always good for those who can only play 1h/week. Oh, if you are really annoyed by the "play another game" then you may always do pvp on SiSi.
and, yes, the 1000$ for titan official market from CCP would make this game very good, would allow players to skip the all boring, useless, worthless part of game 
good points
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:31:00 -
[414]
Edited by: Earthan on 06/05/2007 20:31:02
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Edited by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI on 06/05/2007 20:20:16 Way to be a complete and contradictory idiot. The way things are now allows the LARGEST majority of the game to enjoy it the way they want to. People with extra cash and no time get to play, people with no cash and extra time get to play, its a win/win situations for the whole group, except for morons who whine about the "unfairness of it all" and the "Evils and immorality" of buying ISK with GTC's. Of course the fact that such people basically have a persecution complex and need something to whine about to make themselves morally superior is disgusting and frankly THEY should be the ones who "quit if you don't like it."
Edit: Zanarkand you're completely off your rocker if you think that MMO's are designed so that the grind is part of the fun. Its a TOOL to make the game company keep your business longer, nothing more.
I think you got some real problems after reading your posts...And you got a really high esteem of yourself while eveybody else is idiot.You dont even read other posts to understand what other poeple say but just to prove them wrong.
And plz call me idiot again but i dont want to go out and fight in my hard earned for 4 hours dominix some rich boys who ahve just bought it in 1 minute. Its a 1-1 perspective.
Now imagine 60 % of an alliance buy ships with isk bought for rl money.The other alliance dont have such means.They fight and ofc first rich rl alliance comes on top. Great eh?I repeat ingame should only function ingame laws, no rl money advantage as much as its possible.
|

Etien Aldragoran
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:35:00 -
[415]
Edited by: Etien Aldragoran on 06/05/2007 20:32:47 .
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:37:00 -
[416]
Your logic fails, because in-game laws as you call them aren't fair anyway. You don't take turns or anything like that to keep it even, in your example, alliance A) plays 1 hour per player a week more than alliance B) they fight, alliance A wins because they had more time to grind. Same inequity, you're just to ******* stubborn to see it.
Hell lets make it more abstract, alliance A lives in a better area of the game, so they get 10% more money per hour of grinding than alliance B. They meet in combat and alliance B still loses, because of the money disadvantage. You going to cry that all areas of the game should be completely equal, thereby reducing all territorial ambitions to worthlessness? Way to try to kill the game because you don't like a certain aspect of it.
|

Riddick Valer
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:40:00 -
[417]
How much of an advantage does buying isk really give someone? Yes, they can fly the best stuff, but do they have the skill to use it? There is a big difference between someone who spent hundreds of hours of PvE and PvP to get the money for a ship, and someone who gets in 3 weeks training and some $.
I know who I'd bet on in the fight. Plus, people who play limited in-game hours, and buy isk, are less likely to be part of a larger corp. These are the types of people that aren't as likely to socialize and form the friendships that make eve more fun and easier.
Face the fact that you won't stop them from buying isk, and try to come up with ways to control it that won't support the isk farmers that ramp up inflation.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:40:00 -
[418]
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Your logic fails, because in-game laws as you call them aren't fair anyway. You don't take turns or anything like that to keep it even, in your example, alliance A) plays 1 hour per player a week more than alliance B) they fight, alliance A wins because they had more time to grind. Same inequity, you're just to ******* stubborn to see it.
Hell lets make it more abstract, alliance A lives in a better area of the game, so they get 10% more money per hour of grinding than alliance B. They meet in combat and alliance B still loses, because of the money disadvantage. You going to cry that all areas of the game should be completely equal, thereby reducing all territorial ambitions to worthlessness? Way to try to kill the game because you don't like a certain aspect of it.
No you still dont understand my point of view.
I dont want Eve to be equal i never said that , you just assumed it.Eve is unfair and will be.I cant play more then 5 sometimes 10 hours aweek so i know i will be somwhere in the middle foodchain.Im fine with it.
Unfairness is okay as long as its ingame.I dont want outside of game advantages.As said ingame ingame laws.No matter if fair or not.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:43:00 -
[419]
Oh so its fine as long as the unfairness helps you but not the other guy. Hypocrit. You have more time/tolerance for the pain of the grind than someone else so you get all the advantages while they're supposed to slug through, or not play at all, because you want all the advantages. What a crock.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:45:00 -
[420]
Edited by: Earthan on 06/05/2007 20:44:55
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Oh so its fine as long as the unfairness helps you but not the other guy. Hypocrit. You have more time/tolerance for the pain of the grind than someone else so you get all the advantages while they're supposed to slug through, or not play at all, because you want all the advantages. What a crock.
you dont read my posts eh?i said i got 5 to 10 hours aweek eve time so i hardly get much advantages lol.I actually am not so poor and i could buy isk if i wanted.But i never did and never will do it cause its so so wrong.
You just cant grasp the idea of signing up for a sport and playing by the rules not cheating.
|

BubbaZanetti
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:49:00 -
[421]
Originally by: Earthan Unfairness is okay as long as its ingame.I dont want outside of game advantages.As said ingame ingame laws.No matter if fair or not.
How is availability of time (which exists outside the game) any different from availability of money (which exists outside the game)?
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:53:00 -
[422]
Oh so now its cheating is it. Seems like it was CCP sanctioned, and still is. Hell from the way I read the news, it still will be. They aren't changing the system because of people selling GTC's for ISK, they're changing the system because people have found a way to profit off of their intellectual property, without working for CCP. The fact that you don't understand this completely proves you're clueless to the points you're arguing.
CCP does not want other people making REAL MONEY from their game. Thats the be all and end all of their position. Its the be all and end all of any MMO producers position. And its one that I can fully support, because it makes sense. The other bull**** thats been spewed about it being cheating to GTC > ISK your way through the game DOESN'T.
They want to stop people from playing this game as a job, but you and all the other moronic tools don't get that. You just want to whine about how you're getting put upon because someone offended your delicate sensibilities.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:55:00 -
[423]
Originally by: BubbaZanetti
Originally by: Earthan Unfairness is okay as long as its ingame.I dont want outside of game advantages.As said ingame ingame laws.No matter if fair or not.
How is availability of time (which exists outside the game) any different from availability of money (which exists outside the game)?
Well good phillosphical question but imho its simple really:
With time you can play more ( as you can train more tennis for example) improving game.
Money is something outside game, so using it ingame is worng.
I repeat woudl you like to sign up to a tennis tournament, and when you will be wining cause you trained more then your opponent , your oponnent will pick up his wallet pay 20 $ and because of it he can try to serve not 2 times as usual but 4 times.And he wins in end thanks to this.Would you like it?
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 20:58:00 -
[424]
Your tennis analogy is ****. Its actually more like are you going to ***** and complain because you go to a tourney where the guy on the other side of the net from you has paid for a high priced coach to help him train better, and faster in less time than you did all on your lonesome.
|

BubbaZanetti
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:00:00 -
[425]
Originally by: Earthan I repeat woudl you like to sign up to a tennis tournament, and when you will be wining cause you trained more then your opponent , your oponnent will pick up his wallet pay 20 $ and because of it he can try to serve not 2 times as usual but 4 times.And he wins in end thanks to this.Would you like it?
If I spend $15 to "buy" 150mil isk, I'm not buying a do-over. It doesn't change my shot from a "You barely missed Earthan's Dominix" to a "You scored a wrecking hit on Earthan's Dominix."
The difference is more something like, you work at the Player's Club and slowly earn your way to being able to buy good tennis racket with your employee discount (or maybe you'll get lucky, and a player will hand you a good racket). But I just come in off the street and buy a good racket with cash I already had. Then we play. It's not affected our game at all.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:02:00 -
[426]
Edited by: Earthan on 06/05/2007 21:03:29
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Oh so now its cheating is it. Seems like it was CCP sanctioned, and still is. Hell from the way I read the news, it still will be. They aren't changing the system because of people selling GTC's for ISK, they're changing the system because people have found a way to profit off of their intellectual property, without working for CCP. The fact that you don't understand this completely proves you're clueless to the points you're arguing.
CCP does not want other people making REAL MONEY from their game. Thats the be all and end all of their position. Its the be all and end all of any MMO producers position. And its one that I can fully support, because it makes sense. The other bull**** thats been spewed about it being cheating to GTC > ISK your way through the game DOESN'T.
They want to stop people from playing this game as a job, but you and all the other moronic tools don't get that. You just want to whine about how you're getting put upon because someone offended your delicate sensibilities.
You are wrong it seems indeed they are limiting it.Not stopping but limiting.
Quote: In essence, it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player to purchase game time directly from CCP.
Notice "for a time".
I understand all other reasons that you are pointing but that might very well be but it doesnt counter anything i have said.Both aremain true.
|

Earthan
Gallente The Absolutely Amazing Fire Eaters
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:06:00 -
[427]
Originally by: BubbaZanetti
Originally by: Earthan I repeat woudl you like to sign up to a tennis tournament, and when you will be wining cause you trained more then your opponent , your oponnent will pick up his wallet pay 20 $ and because of it he can try to serve not 2 times as usual but 4 times.And he wins in end thanks to this.Would you like it?
If I spend $15 to "buy" 150mil isk, I'm not buying a do-over. It doesn't change my shot from a "You barely missed Earthan's Dominix" to a "You scored a wrecking hit on Earthan's Dominix."
The difference is more something like, you work at the Player's Club and slowly earn your way to being able to buy good tennis racket with your employee discount (or maybe you'll get lucky, and a player will hand you a good racket). But I just come in off the street and buy a good racket with cash I already had. Then we play. It's not affected our game at all.
good point to show the hole in my analogy but i insist that your example is broken because in Eve ships and modules arent just tools like boots and rackets in tennis.They are more.They are part of what you work for.
Anyway sorry got to go to sleep, speaking of work:), wont be replying anymore.
Good discussion Bubba but i still am convinced my point of view is right
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:12:00 -
[428]
Hukt on Fauniks werkt fur U! No I've never made a cent on the game, which is why I understand and AGREE with the fact that RMT is bad for a companies bottom line, and should be dealt with accordingly. GTC > ISK is completely different, and if you stopped and thought about it instead of your kneejerk reactions on "OMG ur teh cheatzors."
Also LEARN TO READ.
Here I'll break down the sentence you're trying to jam into your twisted ideals to what it really says.
Quote: In essence,
This part is pretty self explainitory.
Quote: it will be possible for a time and ISK-rich, but financially challenged player
Possible for what kind of player? A time and ISK rich one. Also a Finacially challenged one.
Not it will be possible for a time, meaning that its going to end soon.
Quote: to purchase game time directly from CCP.
This is where it gets tricky. Its really a bad line, because nobody in their right mind thinks that CCP would actually allow people to play the game without SOMEBODY paying for the time accrued...
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:30:00 -
[429]
Edited by: voogru on 06/05/2007 21:32:07
Originally by: This entire thread WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
Attention, Cheaters: cheating is not allowed!
Originally by: GM Arkanon GM Arkanon here, screaming incoherently, although somewhat muffled by an ever growing mountain of petitions.
Although we're generally so busy these days that we hardly have time to play our usual 18 holes of Jovian minigolf at lunchtime, I would like to take a moment to address the issue of online trading of ingame items, as many users seem to be unaware of our policy in these matters.
As most of you probably know all trading of ingame items using real currency is forbidden, as detailed in our EULA. This goes for buying and selling and even attempted trading, advertising or otherwise publicising this activity.
Recently, we have noticed that the trend seems to be that ISK buyers are investing even more heavily than before, sometimes up to one, or over a billion ISK at a time. Needless to say, by illegally obtaining such amounts of ISK, the offending players are not only cheating, but their actions can severely affect other players, who are put at an unfair disadvantage in many vital areas of the game, such as in PVP and in the market. We do not intend to allow people to ruin the gaming experience for other players through this most lazy and underhanded way of achieving your goals in EVE. In other words, THIS WILL NOT BE TOLERATED!
Here's a brief rundown of the horrors in store for those evildoers foolhardy enough to think they can get away with breaking our rules:
Anyone found selling items through Ebay or other similar auction sites faces an instant and permanent ban from the game. This ban will apply to all accounts traced to that user. Users supplying ISK to salesmen will also receive permanent bans.
Users who buy ISK or other items from auction sites will receive a warning or a temporary ban, depending on the severity of the offense and the user's previous record. The ISK will be confiscated, even if that means we have to put the offender's wallet into a negative state. Severe or repeated offenses will be met with instant and permanent bans.
This issue is not up for discussion. Buying your way ahead in EVE is cheating, pure and simple. There are many examples of games ruined by online merchants and their customers, and for good reason. Who wants to play a game where no one plays by the rules? Where's the fun in obtaining your goals through normal gameplay, only to have them wiped out by someone who bought his advantage on Ebay?
If you engage in such activity, do not be surprised if action is taken against you. We do not care if you bought your ISK yesterday or last month, what you did constitutes an unfair advantage against other players and we will take action regardless. You stand to lose your accounts, your Ebay investment and the ability to enjoy the best MMORPG there is (hey, we won!), all in one fell swoop.
All the best,
GM Arkanon
But noooo... The GM can't possibly be right can he?!?!?!
And if ISK buying goes underground, and you PVP and buy ISK, it'll only take one petition from someone who suspects you of ISK buying to bring you crashing down. So is it worth the risk? I think not.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:36:00 -
[430]
Oh hay, that Devblog completely proves the point I've been trying to make for something like 10 pages now. CCP doesn't give a DAMN about GTC > ISK, they care about other people making money off of their game through E-Bay and unsanctioned RMT.
|

Cassiuss
Minmatar STK Scientific Rule of Three
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:48:00 -
[431]
Personally i think in game sanctioned isk for gtc a great idea, Im concerned that the current farmers will be out of business and that a good portion if this gaming community has been making shedloads off this game forever now.
There have been people have played eve a few months and are capital ready now due to character buying from gtc isk sales, its getting out of hand and Im glad ccp is pulling in the reigns.
Looks good to me, I am looking forward to it.
Might have a market impact but im all for the price of T2 to rise :)
/cass Cassiuss, STK-S Recruitment Officer
|

Cassiuss
Minmatar STK Scientific Rule of Three
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:49:00 -
[432]
p.s. someone ban teh I|I|I|I|I spammer, we got your point. Lets hear from others ffs. Cassiuss, STK-S Recruitment Officer
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:55:00 -
[433]
Obviously people don't get the point or they wouldn't still be babbling on about this crap. Of course the fact that 90% of the people calling GTC > ISK cheating don't seem to have the mental capacities of a caterpillar makes it hard to reason with them, so you have to take a brute force approach.
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 21:56:00 -
[434]
Originally by: Cassiuss p.s. someone ban teh I|I|I|I|I spammer, we got your point. Lets hear from others ffs.
You mean the cheaters point of view. I know what it is. They want to be able to cheat still.
Truth is, what they say means diddly squat.
|

IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI
Hos B4 Bros
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 22:01:00 -
[435]
Strange that Mr. Luxury Yacht is calling me a cheater. Especially since I've never once gotten ISK for GTC's, I actually pay for my gametime the other way around. Worried that someone might blow up your stupidly expensive toy with something they bought off GTC sales and get the better deal out of the encounter? Or just an elitist ***** with too much time on his hands who wants to keep the upper hand over everyone else.
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 22:16:00 -
[436]
Edited by: voogru on 06/05/2007 22:15:19
Originally by: IlIlIlIlI IlIlIlIlI Strange that Mr. Luxury Yacht is calling me a cheater. Especially since I've never once gotten ISK for GTC's, I actually pay for my gametime the other way around. Worried that someone might blow up your stupidly expensive toy with something they bought off GTC sales and get the better deal out of the encounter? Or just an elitist ***** with too much time on his hands who wants to keep the upper hand over everyone else.
I never called you a cheater.
Quote: Or just an elitist ***** with too much time on his hands who wants to keep the upper hand over everyone else.
Yeah, I'm an elitist. None of my assets were bought with $$$.
|

Monty Burns
Rampage Eternal Ka-Tet
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 22:17:00 -
[437]
Originally by: Earthan ....
...Its exactly like if in sport drugs would be allowed and ehancements.And the one using them would say hey i got no time to train, but i got money so its fair.
This is NOT real life. Its supposed to be fun... a game.
Originally by: Earthan
This is a game.Its a separate universe where rl money must stop giving you advantage( as much as its possible).
You are NEVER going to stop this. I can create a new character or two each month and farm them off. By all accounts as I have been told a far better return per pound than gtc's. Of course though, this would be "underground" but TOTALY un-provable.
Originally by: Earthan .... other stuff ..
On side note a 51 milions sp clone costs nowadays i think 7 milions.You earn that in 30 minutes in 0.0 . ....
No wait, no I won't coz EVEN if you could earn that (which I can) ISK an hour you would expect me to PvP to put in my fair share of combat defending it. Suddenly, that 30 mins is no where near sufficient - assuming your going to do your bit but in your alliance, defensive pvp (boooring but essential), mining (Alliance minerals ... booring but essential), Ice Mining (Alliance but essential) ..... see where this is going?
I have spent years grinding roids. I am in a lucky position where I can afford to go buy a mothership for real life cash. I don't. I just want to be able to finance the odd BS and a few cruisers and more importantly, the clones I loose! 
Oh wait ....
Time to log
Darwin 4tw
|

Cassiuss
Minmatar STK Scientific Rule of Three
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 22:19:00 -
[438]
LOL, okay dude. Chill or get back to the lvl70 padadin and pwn some noobs, mmk.
Cheating comes in all forms, just because its in Eula doesnt make it any less severe than say someone shooting your corp or alliance mates through POS shields.
**** happens, let the CCP deal with it. There have been isk/currecy farmers since MMos started, its a business for some people.
If I could make s 10bn isk and I was from a under developed country in Eastern Europe/Asia and I could sell that isk in american dollars and make 5X what my current currecy is in american then that means someone has a fulltime job and I now have a full time job thats pretty damn cool.
Virtual currecy despite what anyone says has a real world value, it always will once you have 15 year olds who have control over there mommies credit card. There is always looking to buy what you have...its the means of selling uncontrolled that CCP doesnt condone.
Everyone looks for an advantage, whether that warping your titan into a POS of enemies to kerknock them out of shields so you can pwn em or buying isk to finance your next capital pilot which comes with a Moros.
Cheating is rampant in this game, I know CCP doesnt condone cheating but I am sure they are fighting the battles they can win. :)
They might have seen a general increase in GTC sales as well and realized wow I wonder how some of these guys are buying thousands of dollars in GTCs.
 Cassiuss, STK-S Recruitment Officer
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 22:21:00 -
[439]
Originally by: Cassiuss LOL, okay dude. Chill or get back to the lvl70 padadin and pwn some noobs, mmk.
Cheating comes in all forms, just because its in Eula doesnt make it any less severe than say someone shooting your corp or alliance mates through POS shields.
**** happens, let the CCP deal with it. There have been isk/currecy farmers since MMos started, its a business for some people.
If I could make s 10bn isk and I was from a under developed country in Eastern Europe/Asia and I could sell that isk in american dollars and make 5X what my current currecy is in american then that means someone has a fulltime job and I now have a full time job thats pretty damn cool.
Virtual currecy despite what anyone says has a real world value, it always will once you have 15 year olds who have control over there mommies credit card. There is always looking to buy what you have...its the means of selling uncontrolled that CCP doesnt condone.
Everyone looks for an advantage, whether that warping your titan into a POS of enemies to kerknock them out of shields so you can pwn em or buying isk to finance your next capital pilot which comes with a Moros.
Cheating is rampant in this game, I know CCP doesnt condone cheating but I am sure they are fighting the battles they can win. :)
They might have seen a general increase in GTC sales as well and realized wow I wonder how some of these guys are buying thousands of dollars in GTCs.

Then why not go play a game that allows RMT? They do exist.
|

Cassiuss
Minmatar STK Scientific Rule of Three
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 22:26:00 -
[440]
Cause those games suck, Eve is the greatest mmo. I abide by the rules, some people chose not to.
Meh. Its a game.
Those who are so vehamently opposed are people who probably have a vested interest.
Cassiuss, STK-S Recruitment Officer
|

MacGardner
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 22:29:00 -
[441]
Why isn't this scenario feasable?
1. There will be no GTC with no real known numbers, only abstract GTC notion.
2. Person A says on his char page he wants to trade a 90 days GTC to person X for 340 mils isk.
3 CCP announces person X that A wants to sell him a 90 days GTC for 340 mils.
4. X enters on his page, as it is done now, and when he accepts the deal, the CCP makes the transaction: charges person A for real money, and transfers from X 340 mils isk into A's account, and if all of them have the money for the transactions A will get his 340 mils isk, CCP gets the RL $ and X gets another 90 days of playing.
And the good thing about it is that there is not a single known code that can be sold by a third party. CCP controls everything; and everybody, except macro-miners and scammers, are happy with the deal. Also the beatiful thing is that there will be a player's price regulation due to offer and requests.
I dunno the amount of coding to put this in motion but this would be a solution, that would allow me to keep my 2 accounts.
I really do hope CCP will find a solution that will please everyone that plays for the game and not to make $ on e-bay. I really do.
|

Procurement Alt
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 23:02:00 -
[442]
I think we all know many people buy isk for real money and the value of these sales are massive. CCP is a company, the heart beat that keeps all companies in business is sales.
Everything revolves around sales.
I believe CCP sell isk for real money via a 3rd party(s), this is huge income for them, this is very smart on their part, they will eliminate their competition and what they loose in subscriptions they will make up in isk sales for real money via their 3rd party(s).
This is a video game, you are a customer. You'll get your good service and they'll get their profits, like all companies you just don't have to let your customers know how.
|

Argenton Sayvers
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 23:16:00 -
[443]
Edited by: Argenton Sayvers on 06/05/2007 23:24:12 Maybe there are fiscal reasons to massively increase revenue during the next weeks?
People will panic and try to convert Real money into ISK before the curtain falls (if only in their minds).
As for the (in my opinion off-topic) discussion on the morals of RMT: The discussion is not about RMT or NO RMT. Its about wether RMT happens on Eve forums or on GOLD4Ca$$.com.
|

Marquis Dean
Energy.
|
Posted - 2007.05.06 23:39:00 -
[444]
Originally by: Cassiuss LOL, okay dude. Chill or get back to the lvl70 padadin and pwn some noobs, mmk.
This single statement discredited your entire post.
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 03:20:00 -
[445]
Edited by: voogru on 07/05/2007 03:17:42
Originally by: Procurement Alt I think we all know many people buy isk for real money and the value of these sales are massive. CCP is a company, the heart beat that keeps all companies in business is sales.
Everything revolves around sales.
I believe CCP sell isk for real money via a 3rd party(s), this is huge income for them, this is very smart on their part, they will eliminate their competition and what they loose in subscriptions they will make up in isk sales for real money via their 3rd party(s).
This is a video game, you are a customer. You'll get your good service and they'll get their profits, like all companies you just don't have to let your customers know how.
If you really believe that, I got some really good Kool-Aid you should try.
|

Creepin
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 04:05:00 -
[446]
Originally by: voogru Edited by: voogru on 07/05/2007 03:17:42
Originally by: Procurement Alt I think we all know many people buy isk for real money and the value of these sales are massive. CCP is a company, the heart beat that keeps all companies in business is sales.
Everything revolves around sales.
I believe CCP sell isk for real money via a 3rd party(s), this is huge income for them, this is very smart on their part, they will eliminate their competition and what they loose in subscriptions they will make up in isk sales for real money via their 3rd party(s).
This is a video game, you are a customer. You'll get your good service and they'll get their profits, like all companies you just don't have to let your customers know how.
If you really believe that, I got some really good Kool-Aid you should try.
Why not? I personally find this idea disturbingly probable.
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 04:41:00 -
[447]
Originally by: Creepin
Originally by: voogru Edited by: voogru on 07/05/2007 03:17:42
Originally by: Procurement Alt I think we all know many people buy isk for real money and the value of these sales are massive. CCP is a company, the heart beat that keeps all companies in business is sales.
Everything revolves around sales.
I believe CCP sell isk for real money via a 3rd party(s), this is huge income for them, this is very smart on their part, they will eliminate their competition and what they loose in subscriptions they will make up in isk sales for real money via their 3rd party(s).
This is a video game, you are a customer. You'll get your good service and they'll get their profits, like all companies you just don't have to let your customers know how.
If you really believe that, I got some really good Kool-Aid you should try.
Why not? I personally find this idea disturbingly probable.
Yes, CCP sells ISK to players then takes it away for first time buyer, and then bans the buyer after a second offense.
Way to keep the active player counts up. 
|

J Valkor
NayTech Inc
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 04:41:00 -
[448]
I haven't payed for EvE since I first re-activated my account last September. I probably would pay for it if I had to... but it's soo much easier to just make the money in my free time. 330 mil for 90 days? Easy.
|

Garia666
Amarr T.H.U.G L.I.F.E
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 05:04:00 -
[449]
Edited by: Garia666 on 07/05/2007 05:03:04 I havent read the reply`s but what i can say is this.
Everyone does what he or she likes in eve. I like to PvP pvping is a costly hobby especialy as you die as much as i do ;) Anyway as i have a very social live.
I don`t have time to mine..(no skillz :) ) Dont have an lvl 4 agent.. i dont` own a tech II bpo. So I get my isk from GTC.
So every once in a while i buy a gtc and sell them for isk. . I die a couple of time`s and do it all over.
If that possibility is to disapear i most likely will aswell.
And that would be a very sad thing over all these years..
->My Vids<- |

Tonkin
D00M. Triumvirate.
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 05:07:00 -
[450]
why?
i dont use time cards
your still making money of the system when people buy time cards.
so why stop it?
you dont make sense did the general manager bang his head or summet in ccp toliets?
|

voogru
Gallente Massive Damage
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 05:15:00 -
[451]
Originally by: Tonkin why?
i dont use time cards
your still making money of the system when people buy time cards.
so why stop it?
you dont make sense did the general manager bang his head or summet in ccp toliets?
Oh I don't know, maybe they care about the integrity of their game?
Just a hunch.
|

Procurement Alt
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 06:32:00 -
[452]
Yes, CCP sells ISK to players then takes it away for first time buyer, and then bans the buyer after a second offense.
Way to keep the active player counts up. 
I believe they only ban the players who don't buy from their sources (their competition) who they plan to remove via this method, wake and smell the coffee they don't love and adore you, this is business.
|

Mortania
Minmatar Carbide Industries Apocalyptica.
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 07:24:00 -
[453]
Edited by: Mortania on 07/05/2007 07:21:46 Dear people who don't get why accepting the inevitable can be better in the long run:
Accepting cash for items "ruins" the fun of the game. Yeah, I agree, I'm peeved about it as well. But, the reality is "gold farmers" are here to stay and people who want to use gold farmers are the reason for it. As much as we might want to hold our breath until we turn blue it won't make that reality go away. Ignoring it will only exacerbate the problem and CCP will lose out on a potential cash infusion which would allow them more opportunity to create more content or the like.
Analogy time: Alcohol is undeniably bad, in the US alone one person is killed every 25 minutes from drinking and driving (that's a bit more than 20,000 people a year, or 80,000 people since eve started) . This doesn't include alcohol related murders, killings, self-eliminations not associated with driving.
Once upon a time, people thought the best thing to do in the US was to drive this evil from the land. Prohibition was born. And what happened? Alcohol consumption went down a tiny bit (some argue it went up, but tracking usage became impossible), but organized crime sprung up around it to supply the insatiable demand for alcohol. After the crime and black markets had a good laugh at the expense of the good people of the land, the lawmakers came to their senses and repealed the obviously flawed law.
Bringing it back around: ISK sellers WILL happen. You cannot stop it. Rather, let's let CCP profit from it and have the cash that is generated from people who want to buy ISK go to the people who can use it to make our game better rather than someone else.
Thank you, Mort ---
|

Mnengli Noiliffe
|
Posted - 2007.05.07 09:59:00 -
[454]
so does ccp move to f2p model? hmm unlikely, it's rather an illusion of f2p. lots of paying accounts (alts of else) will be canceled. less server stress. ccp sells some unneeded hardware to cut on expenses and fire some no longer wanted staff. so remaining fans pay enough to cover remaining expenses. less lag and everyone is happy. and finally bob conquers whole of eve. eve history ends in honour. servers shut down. ccp moves on to their next mmo project.
|
|

Rauth Kivaro
Forum Moderator Interstellar Services Department

|
Posted - 2007.05.07 10:45:00 -
[455]
This thread has run its course and is turning into a flamefest, and so it gets the *click*.
*click*
forum rules | [email protected] | Our Website
|
|
| |
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 .. 16 :: [one page] |